Pointon Partners

A DISCLAIMER SAVES THE DAY

A recent Queensland Court of Appeal decision shows the continuing utility of disclaimers on products despite legislative reforms narrowing the scope of their effectiveness.

In Mallonland Pty Ltd & Anor v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd[1]  a class action was brought on behalf of commercial farmers against the manufacturer of sorghum seed. The farmers had bought the seed from distributors and had no contractual relationship with the manufacturer. The seeds were contaminated by shattercane seeds resulting in economic loss to the farmers. The farmers used the sorghum as animal feed or biofuel. The shattercane weed competed with the sorghum and the effects were felt over many seasons as the mature weed contains a head that shatters, releasing further seeds that grow vigorously. The only way to prevent it from disrupting the sorghum growing business was to stop growing sorghum and remediate the fields.

The issue of interest in the appeal was whether a manufacturer of a product owed a duty of care for pure economic loss, where that loss was caused by negligence in the manufacture of the product, and the loss was sustained by an end user who purchased the product from intermediaries but was not in a direct contractual relationship with the manufacture.

It is worth noting at the outset that this was not a case where the farmers purchased as consumers under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). Generally speaking, goods are purchased by individuals or businesses as consumers if:

except if the goods are purchased:

In this case the farmers were not ‘consumers’ under the ACL because the goods were purchased for use in production. Accordingly the consumer guarantees arising under the ACL did not apply and the case was run as a negligence claim for pure economic loss.

If the farmers were able to establish a duty of care then they would have succeeded in the proceeding as the trial judge found in their favour regarding negligence, causation and loss.

In the development of the law of negligence the Courts have been cautious about permitting a remedy for cases of ‘pure economic loss’, as distinct from personal injury or property damage. In a competitive commercial environment firms seeking to maximise their own profit will inevitably cause economic loss to other firms, both as competitors or suppliers or acquirers. If the law permitted a general remedy for persons suffering economic loss from commercial activity then commerce would grind to a halt. Accordingly the cases have established limits to recovery for this kind of loss, sometimes by finding no duty of care and sometimes by finding that loss was not sufficiently proximate.

A remedy for pure economic loss was first allowed in Australia by the High Court in Caltex Oil (Aust) Pty Ltd v The Dredge Willemstad[2]. That case involved damage to a pipeline carrying oil which the plaintiff had a contractual right to use but did not own. The plaintiff was able to recover for the cost of arranging an alternative supply of oil while the pipeline was out of service.

Perhaps the ‘high water mark’ for economic loss in the High Court was Perre v Apand Pty Ltd[3]. In that case diseased potatoes were imported and infected land in the vicinity of the plaintiff’s farm but not the farm itself. Because of such infection the plaintiff was unable to export potatoes to Western Australia. A majority in the High Court held that the plaintiff/appellant could recover for pure economic loss due to the reasonable foreseeability of damage and because the appellant fell into an ascertainable class of person vulnerable to the respondent’s actions.

In Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v Owners Corporation Strata Plan 61288[4] the High Court refused recovery for the costs of repair of latent defects in the common property incurred by an Owner’s Corporation due to negligent design and construction. Brookfield was the builder of the apartment complex and did not have a contractual relationship with the Owner’s Corporation. Although there was provision in the building contract for purchasers of apartments to have rights against Brookfield those provisions did not extend to the Owner’s Corporation. The High Court found that Brookfield did not owe a duty of care to the Owner’s Corporation.

In the Mallonland case the Court of Appeal (per Morrison JA)[5] emphasised the following passage from the judgment of French CJ in Brookfield [6]:

“Abstracting the reference to proximity in Bryan v Maloney[7], the decision adverted to factors adverse to the recognition of a duty of care for pure economic loss other than in special cases. The special cases would commonly, but not necessarily, involve an identified element of known reliance or dependence on the part of the plaintiff, or the assumption of responsibility by the defendant, or a combination of the two.”

In Mallonland the Court found that a disclaimer negated an assumption of responsibility by the manufacturer and a duty of care did not arise. Assumption of responsibility has been a salient feature in findings that a duty of care existed since Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [8]. Because of the disclaimer the seed was not sold as free of any weeds, but was sold only on the basis of a minimum purity.

The Court of Appeal noted (per Morrison JA) the following features of the disclaimer:

“[129]   The wording of the conditions was not phrased in an archaic or overly legalistic way; rather, it used relatively plain words to convey several clear propositions. Those stated clearly were:

(a)          the bag must only be opened if the buyer had read and agreed with the conditions;

(b)         return the bag if the conditions are not acceptable;

(c)          if the product in the bag did not comply with its description, within recognised tolerances, Pacific Seed’s liability would be limited to the cost of replacement of the product; and

(d)         Pacific Seeds would not be liable for loss and damage caused by the use of the product, including by its negligence.

[130]     The reference to ‘tolerances’ would have been readily understood by buyers. The evidence from buyers, as outlined in paragraphs [75] to [88] above, showed that they concentrated on the germination data which was contained on its own label. But that data also contained three statements as to the contents of the bag:

(i) the ‘Minimum Purity’ was 99%;

(ii) the ‘Maximum Other Seeds’ was 0.1%; and

(iii) the ‘Maximum Inert Matter’ was 0.5%.

[131]     All of those paragraphs referred to simple concepts and were delivered in plain words without any complicated syntax or legalistic terms. All were, in my view, easy for a lay person to understand. All of them stated plainly that the risk of using the product lay with the buyer and that Pacific Seeds was not accepting any responsibility for loss and damage caused by negligence on its part.

[132]     These paragraphs do not fall to be tested as though they were part of a contract between the buyer and Pacific Seeds. As the learned trial judge recognised, it was no part of the case advanced by Advanta that ‘by a plaintiff or group member opening the bag and using the seed, a contract was made between the plaintiff or group member and the defendant under which the plaintiff or group member agreed to those terms’…

[133]     Rather, they are to be examined for whether they reveal a clear disclaimer of an assumption of responsibility. In my view, they do so.”

Conversely both the trial judge and the Court of Appeal found that the farmers were vulnerable to the manufacturer. Vulnerability in this sense is concerned with whether the farmers were able to protect themselves from economic loss or damage caused by the manufacturer’s failure to take care.

“[209]   His Honour said that it may be unrealistic to expect a consumer in the appellants’ position to extract a warranty from the seller against a defect in the quality of the goods purchased that would protect against economic loss. Factors such as the consumer’s limited bargaining position, the retailer’s inability to obtain a similar warranty from its supplier, and the fact that the goods may not be examinable before purchase, were relevant to that conclusion.”

This case demonstrates how Courts of Appeal are likely to approach claims for pure economic loss post Brookfield and the continuing usefulness of product disclaimers.

Pointon Partners can assist in drafting or advising about product disclaimers. Please contact Michael Bishop, David Mazzeo or Andrew Cox.

[1] [2023] QCA 24

[2] [1976] HCA 65

[3] [1999] HCA 36

[4] [2014] HCA 36

[5] [2023] QCA 24 at [225]

[6] [2014] HCA 36 at [22]

[7] [1995] HCA 17

[8] [1964] AC 465

Buying or Selling a Business – Here are the top 5 things you should consider

https://pointonpartners.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/PP-Video-Final.mp4

Buying or selling a business is a major decision for both the seller and the buyer and can be a daunting and exciting process. Regardless of whether you are a seller or buyer, it is important you take into account a number of considerations and steps when preparing for the sale or purchase of a business, during the negotiation of the sale or purchase of the business and prior to signing a contract of sale.

Although the sale and purchase of each business will be different depending on the circumstances specific to that business and sale, the following list sets out a brief outline of what can be considered the top 5 things that a seller and buyer should consider when selling or buying a business:

  1. What are you selling? What are you buying?

Buying or selling a business is the process of transferring some or all of the assets of the business from the seller to the buyer. Accordingly, it is important for the seller to work out what they are selling and for the buyer to know exactly what is up for sale and what they are buying.

A seller will need to consider:

For a buyer, it is essential that you know what you are paying for.

  1. Preparing for a sale and purchase

Prior to purchasing a business, a prospective buyer should commence a due diligence investigation. A buyer will usually request certain documents to review such as financial accounts, copies of material contracts with customers and suppliers, corporate registers and intellectual property registrations. From a buyer’s perspective, this process is critical to ensure there are no legal or financial factors which may impact the value of the business and their purchase of the business and to identify any issues that may need to be addressed prior to the sale of the business.

Consequently, once a decision is made to sell a business it is important for a seller to conduct a ‘health check’ to determine any legal ‘gaps’ to be addressed to satisfy a buyer’s due diligence investigations. ‘Gaps’ can include: ‘undocumented’ material customer agreements, supplier contracts or leasing agreements; inadequate intellectual property assets protections, including intellectual property licences; deficient employment agreements; or licences and permits not being up to date. Good preparation early will make the negotiation process with prospective buyers a lot easier.

During the due diligence investigation or discussions the seller has with potential buyers, confidential information about the business may be exchanged. It is therefore important that Non-Disclosure Agreements be entered into in order to prevent any ‘walk away’ potential buyers from using the sellers and the businesses confidential information for their own benefit.

  1. Employees

A seller will need to ensure that all employment arrangements are in order as during the due diligence investigation, a buyer will be looking to see if employees have been paid the correct amounts and checking which award and classifications within the award apply to the employees.

As a result of a sale of business, an employee will either transfer across to the buyer (the new employer) or their employment will be terminated due to the sale of the business. Either way, a seller will need to give notice to an employee terminating their employment with the seller and comply with employment laws, such as notice and entitlements. Therefore, a seller may want to put together a plan to communicate the sale of the business to employees so as to avoid ‘office gossip’.

If the employees are transferring to the buyer, the buyer should seek advice on employee entitlements, including those that they must recognise and others that they do not have to recognise.

  1. Intellectual Property

When considering what assets a business has and if these assets will be transferred, a buyer will need to identify if any intellectual property is being transferred and included as part of the sale. Intellectual property of a business can include trade marks and logos, websites, domain names and email addresses, trade secrets, know-how, designs and copyright.

Intellectual property rights may be valuable and offer a commercial advantage. Therefore, as a buyer you want to see how these intellectual property assets are owned, if it be assigned to you or whether the seller has the right to licence or assign a licence of the intellectual property to you. To assist with this sellers will want to look to register any trade marks and ensure that licence agreements are in place and can be assigned to the buyer.

  1. The Contract of Sale

Each sale of a business will have certain terms specific to the sale and accordingly it is important to get a lawyer to draft the contract of sale if you are the seller or review the contract of sale prior to signing if you are the buyer.

A contract of sale can include essential terms that, for example, can restrict a seller from trading in the same or similar business after the sale of a business, provide that certain conditions must be met before a the sale of the business can be completed or provide for personal guarantees from the directors of the seller or buyer guaranteeing that the seller or buyer will comply with the contract.

It is also important to remember that each state or territory may have special requirements that you need to follow as a buyer or seller and therefore, you should seek independent advice from a lawyer prior to entering into the contract of sale.

For example, in Victoria, when selling a small business at a price up to $450,000, the seller or their accountant will need to prepare a Section 52 Statement setting out the financial performance of the business over the last 2 years and provide this to the buyer before the contract of sale is signed.

Above all, seek advice

Selling or buying a business can be stressful. However, if the rights steps are taken during the preparation, negotiation, drafting of the contract of sale and the settlement of the business, both the seller and buyer can mitigate any risk and walk away with a successful outcome.

Professionals, such as brokers, lawyers and accountants, can help you navigate through a sale or purchase of a business, including helping you understand any risks, preparing and providing advice on the sale, drafting the contract of sale and providing advice on any legal and government requirements for the sale or purchase of the business. There are many potential issues with the selling or buying of a business and therefore you should seek advice prior to making an offer if you are the seller or signing a contract of sale if you are the buyer.

The Commercial Team at Pointon Partners have extensive experience in commercial and corporate law matters across a wide variety of areas, including sale of businesses.

If you would like to discuss a sale or purchase of a business, please do not hesitate to contact our Commercial Team.

Director Identification Numbers – Now in Force

Australian company directors are now required by law to apply for a director identification number (“director ID”).

A director ID is a unique identifier given to an eligible officer who has verified their identified their identity with the Australian Business Registry Services (“ABRS”). The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) defines an “eligible officer” to include “a director of a company, or of a body corporate that is a registered Australian body or registered foreign company, who:

A person will only ever have one director ID and directors will need to keep their director ID even if they cease to be a director, become a director of a different company, change their name or more interstate or overseas.

The timeframe of when you have to apply for your director ID is dependent upon when you first became a director and applies as follows:

Date you first become a director Date you must apply
On or before 31 October 2021 By 30 November 2022
Between 1 November 2021 and 4 April 2022 Within 28 days of appointment
From 5 April 2022 Before appointment

The ABRS estimates that the total director population in Australia is more than 2.5 million and approximately 700,000 directors have still not applied for their director IDs.[1]

If you became a director of a company on or before 31 October 2021 and have not already applied for your director ID, the time to act is now. A 14 day grace period has been announced by the ABRS for directors who were required to apply for their director IDs by 30 November 2022 and these directors must apply before 14 December 2022 to avoid penalties.

If you are becoming a director for the first time, you will now need to apply for your director ID prior to being appointed as a director of a company.

Applications for a director ID can be made online, over the phone or by paper application if you live outside Australia and cannot apply online. For further details in relation to applying for a director ID please refer to the ABRS website. https://www.abrs.gov.au/director-identification-number/apply-director-identification-number?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIk-Gv3oXp-wIVDBwrCh1cbwWFEAAYASACEgLz5vD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

If you have any queries about director IDs or would like further information, then please feel free to contact our Commercial Team.

[1] https://www.ato.gov.au/Media-centre/Media-releases/Statement-from-ABRS-Registrar-Chris-Jordan-on-the-director-ID-deadline/

Employee Share Schemes – Eligible Start Up Concessions

In today’s tight labour market we continue to see interest from employer clients in establishing employee share schemes in order to retain, attract and incentivise talent.

Perhaps the most straightforward of the schemes to create, administer and explain to staff is one relying upon the “eligible start up concessions” in the Tax Act.  It also provides the most favourable tax result for the employees as there are no income tax consequences for them and enables them to acquire the shares on capital account.  Therefore, the employee will be in a positon to rely upon the 50% CGT concession when the shares are ultimately disposed of.

In terms of the type of equity which can be offered and the extent of it, they have to be ordinary shares and no more than 10% of the company’s capital can be made available to employees using the eligible start up concessions.

There are safe harbour rules which apply which enable the shares to be issued at up to a discount of 15% to their market value.  We discuss further below how market value is determined.

The trick with the eligible start up concessions relates to whether the employer is eligible to offer a scheme relying upon these concessions and, further, is able to rely upon special valuation rules which enable the company to be valued on a net tangible asset basis.  Ie ignoring goodwill.  .

For the eligible start up concessions to apply at all the employer is required to have been incorporated for less than ten years and have less than $50m in turnover.

The special valuation rules enabling valuation on a net tangible asset basis are available if the following additional criteria are satisfied:

If those special valuation rules can be relied upon then there would generally be no need to obtain an independent valuation of the company.  Instead, the issue price of the shares could be determined by reference to the net tangible assets of the company as per its current balance sheet.

If the special valuation rules are not available but the employer company does meet the aforementioned definition of an “eligible start up” then there may be a need for an independent valuation and the issue price of the shares would need to take account of the goodwill component.

The eligible start up concessions can also be used in relation to the grant of options as can the special valuation rules.  The only essential difference is that with options the exercise price has to be at least equal to the current market price (i.e. based on net tangible assets if the special valuation rules are available) and the “15% discount safe harbour” isn’t available.

If you are interested in established an employee share scheme using the eligible start up concessions or have any queries about employee share schemes generally then please feel free to contact Michael Bishop.

Landmark High Court Google Defamation Ruling

The High Court last week handed down a landmark defamation ruling concerning whether Google was regarded as having been the publisher, for defamation law purposes, of the results of Google searches

Five members of the Court (with two judges dissenting) held that Google was not the publisher of material derived from searches using the Google search engine.

The plaintiff in the case was the Melbourne criminal law solicitor George Defteros.  In 2004 during the height of the Melbourne gangland wars he was charged with conspiracy to murder and incitement to murder Carl Williams and was committed to stand trial.  Before the matter came to trial the DPP withdrew the charges against him.  However prior to that occurring The Age newspaper published an article entitled “Underworld loses valued friend at court” which Defteros considered defamed him.  Defteros did not commence defamation proceedings against The Age but in 2016 Defteros caused to be sent to Google  a “removal request form” requesting that The Age article be removed from the results of Google searches.  When Google failed to comply he commenced defamation proceedings in the Victorian Supreme Court against Google asserting that it had been involved in publishing the article which defamed him.  The trial judge held that the article was defamatory of Defteros.  The primary issue before the High Court was whether Google was actually involved in publication of the article.

The Court considered the way in which the Google search engine operates, by way of trawling the web for relevant webpages and creating hyperlinks which the user can click on to take them to the website in question.

The majority of the Court (by way of three separate judgments) took the view that the hyperlinks created by way of google searches were merely tools to enable the user to navigate to another webpage.  And further that the creation of those hyperlinks by Google did not amount to “enticement” on the part of Google for the user to click on the hyperlink. In those circumstances, Google was not to be regarded as the publisher of the article in question.

In terms of the approach taken by the dissenting judges, Keane J stated that:

“Google’s search engine operates, as intended in accordance with its design, to respond to a user’s search query by facilitating near-instantaneous access by hyperlink to publications on topics relevant to the user’s query.  For the purposes of the law of defamation in Australia, that is sufficient communication of the content of the work of the primary publisher to the user of Google’s search engine.”

whilst the other dissenting judge Gordon stated that:

“Where, as here, the creator and operator of a search engine system  has the intention that third parties will access and read news articles that are hyperlinked in the search engine results generated by that system, it is the publisher of the news articles under the strict publication rule.”

Conclusion

The contrasting approaches taken by the majority and the dissenting members of the Court are quite fascinating.  Obviously this decision will make it much more difficult for Australian plaintiffs to sue Google for defamation in the future, unless the defamatory content is for instance embedded in and on display in the hyperlink generated by the result of the Google search. However in terms of more practical implications it is possible that going forward Google may be more resistant to requests for  defamatory webpages to be removed from the results of google search results, knowing that Google has near blanket immunity in Australia in respect of its search engine and the results generated by it.

If you have any queries concerning any of the above please feel free to contact Michael Bishop   

Pointon Partners Commercial Law Seminar – 14 July 2022

Join us for an in person presentation by Andrew Cassin of Cassin Advisory for advice on the process of preparing your business for sale.

Andrew is the author of “On Your Terms – 101 Ways to Prepare a Business for Sale or Succession.”

Our partners Michael Bishop & Felicity Cara-Carson will also be presenting on the key commercial, employment and IP arrangements you should have in place before embarking on the business sale process.

Date: Thursday, 14 July 2022
Time: 4:00pm – 5:00pm followed by refreshments
Location: Pointon Partners Boardroom, 14/565 Bourke Street,
Melbourne VIC 3000.

Please RSVP by clicking on Register Now.

ACCC v Airbnb: Airbnb allegedly misled Australians about accommodation prices

Australia’s consumer watchdog has commenced proceedings against Airbnb for false or misleading representations about their services. The ACCC argues that Airbnb had made it unclear that the dollar sign ($) they were displaying on their website was in American dollars (‘USD’) instead of Australian dollars (‘AUD’). This has reportedly affected thousands of Australian Consumers between January 2018 to August 2021.

Harm to Consumers

Customers who booked their accommodation either through the Airbnb website or app were charged more than they were expecting. Due to the Australian Dollar averaging a price of 0.72 USD, a customer who thought that they were paying $500 AUD was instead paying approximately $700 USD for their accommodation (price difference cost). Additionally, some consumers also had to pay additional transaction charges to their banks which would not have been levied if the representation was in AUD (Transaction Fee Costs). In cases where consumers were using the .au website for Airbnb, there were no references that the currency that they were paying in was USD. In other cases, there were references to the currency being in USD but this was often in a smaller font which was obscure to many consumers using the Airbnb website.

Aside from paying more than they thought, consumers were deprived of the chance to make an informed choice about how much they were willing to spend on their accommodation. There were commercial benefits to Airbnb in making this misrepresentation to customers as many would not have booked their accommodation if they realised the currency was in USD. The travel lodge giant has benefitted through misrepresenting their prices to consumers as a whole. Moreover, the ACCC also alleges that in instances where consumers were misled about the $ amount, Airbnb did not compensate customers.

“Airbnb did not compensate many consumers who complained about this conduct, and so we will be arguing that the court should order Airbnb to compensate people who were misled about the price of their accommodation[1]”

Legal Proceedings

The ACCC has claimed that Airbnb has broken section 29(i) of the ACL which outlines that a person must not, in trade or commerce in connection with the supply of goods or services make a false or misleading representation with respect to the price of goods or services. Additionally, they seek to claim[2]:

  1. A declaration under section 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth);
  2. An injunction under section 232 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), contained in Schedule 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth);
  3. Pecuniary penalties under section 224 of the ACL;
  4. Orders for redress for non-party consumers under section 239 of the ACL;
  5. Publication and compliance orders under section 246 of the ACL; and
  6. Costs under section 43(1) of the FCA Act.

What Implication does this Decision hold?

While this case does not introduce anything new as it is the responsibility of businesses to ensure the accuracy of the information of their products, by taking this actions against Airbnb, the ACCC is making it clear to businesses who conduct business on digital platforms to warrant that the information and the way they display it is as clear as possible for consumers.

“By taking this action, we are stating very clearly that digital platforms like Airbnb need to ensure the accuracy of all statements that may affect consumers’ purchasing decisions[3]”

Companies who primarily conduct business through digital platforms should ensure the accuracy of all the information they provide.

If there are any further enquiries, please do not hesitate to contact David Mazzeo or Stefano Mazzeo at our office.

[1] “Airbnb allegedly misled Australians about accommodation prices”, Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (Media Release, 8 June 2022) https://www.accc.gov.au/media-release/airbnb-allegedly-misled-australians-about-accommodation-prices#:~:text=The%20ACCC%20alleges%20that%2C%20between,those%20prices%20were%20in%20US

[2]“ACCC v Airbnb Ireland UC and Airbnb, Inc. Filing for Notice”, (Concise Statement, 8 June 2022)

[3] Ibid

Pointon Partners Employment Law Webinar: Key issues for the new financial year

Please join us as our employment lawyers Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman and Ben Drysdale discuss the key employment issues likely to impact your business in the new financial year, including:

Please also feel free to send in any questions or topics you would like to see covered.

Date: Thursday, 23 June 2022
Time: 12:30pm – 1:30pm
Location: via Zoom – link will be provided to attendees prior to webinar

Please RSVP by clicking on Register Now.

Collective Bargaining With Suppliers – ACCC Relief

If you are a small business, it may be beneficial for you to join with competitors to engage in collective bargaining with a substantial or dominant supplier in your industry. However, this may breach the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 through the cartel and competition provisions of the act.

Despite this, the ACCC recognises that collective bargaining by small businesses can sometimes result in better or fairer outcomes. As a consequence, the ACCC has provided three forms of relief which we discuss further below.

What is Collective Bargaining?

Collective Bargaining occurs when two or more competitors form a group to negotiate with a supplier about terms, conditions and/or prices. For example, if your business does not have the capital to buy enough products to qualify for a discount, joining up with other businesses to collectively bargain with a supplier of those goods may qualify the group for a bulk discount.

Other benefits include:

While collective bargaining may be quite beneficial to businesses as a whole, they still risk breaching the cartel and competition provisions of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010.

How do I work around them – forms of relief?

Notification

A notification is the simplest way in which small businesses may qualify to collectively bargain. To limit this to strictly small businesses, the expenditure on the part of the small business with the targeted supplier must be less than $3 million in a 12 month period. Higher thresholds apply to other industries:

Lodging a valid notification involves filling out the form from the ACCC website. A $1000 fee applies per notification. Once the notification is lodged and there are no objections raised by the ACCC, protection commences 14 days after it was lodged. Protection remains for three years beginning on the day the notification was lodged.

Class Exemption

As of the 3rd June 2021, a class exemption to engage in collective bargaining may be sought. This allows a business with a turnover of less than $10 million in the financial year prior to them forming a collective bargaining group with competitors to negotiate with against suppliers. Franchisees and fuel retailers may also apply for a class exemption regardless of their turnover.

Small businesses must complete a notice form and lodge it with the ACCC. Once lodged, legal protection automatically commences and lasts until 30 June 2030.

Authorisation

Unlike a notification, there is no monetary threshold required, anyone may apply for an authorisation.

Lodging an authorisation is a lengthy process. Collective Bargaining groups must download and fill out the form on the ACCC website. A fee of $7500 applies to the authorisation. Once the form is sent, the ACCC will consult with the target business and then issue a draft of determination setting out the reasons for the ACCC’s proposed decision as to whether the authorisation is granted or rejected. The ACCC will then invite written or oral submissions in response to the draft and a final determination will be sent out. The ACCC will only grant an authorisation if it considers that there is a net public benefit in doing so.

The ACCC specifies when legal protection starts in the final determination. This must not be earlier than 21 days after the final determination is issued. There is no strict deadline of when the authorisation expires as each authorisation is examined on a case by case basis. In most cases, authorisations last for 5 years.

If you have any queries, feel free to contact Michael Bishop at our office.

Labour Hire Agreements

In the current environment, it is not unusual for businesses to enter into an arrangement with another party for the provision of workers, whether for a specific task or type of work, or for the ongoing performance of services.

Labour hire agreements can be drafted to reflect the terms and conditions of such an arrangement, that is, between one party who provides the workers (“Provider”), and the other party who “hires” the workers (“Client”).  The agreement will usually set out the rights and obligations of each party, and may vary depending on the workers being provided, the work being performed and the industry of work.

Some of the matters which may be covered in a labour hire agreement include the following:

It is also important to review your labour hire agreements regularly, to ensure that the terms accurately reflect your current arrangement, and any changed circumstances.

A separate written agreement can also be entered into between the Provider and the actual worker setting out the terms and conditions of their arrangement and their respective rights and responsibilities.

If you have any queries or require any further information in relation to the above, then please do not hesitate to contact Felicity Cara-Carson or Michael Bishop of Pointon Partners on (03) 9614 7707.