Pointon Partners

Banking Royal Commission Final Report – Implications for the Financial Planning Industry

The Final Report of the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry was handed down on 4 February 2019. The Commissioner, the Honourable Kenneth Madison Hayne AC QC, outlined a number of key recommendations to address the issues identified by the Commission. These are likely to have a significant implication for participants in the financial planning sector.

Summary of the key recommendations

Ongoing fees:

In response to fees being charged where no services were provided the Commissioner recommends that the law be amended to:

Conflicts of interest and conflicted remuneration:

To address conflicting interests and duties of financial advisers the Commissioner recommends:

Misconduct/ Disciplinary action:

To better address misconduct the Commissioner recommends a new disciplinary system be established. Under such a system AFSL holders would be required to:

Detailed background

Fees for no service:

Fees for no service concern the charging of ongoing fees to client accounts for services that were not provided. The Commissioner recommends that the law be amended to provide that ongoing fee arrangements be required to be renewed annually, record the services the client will be entitled to receive and only permit fees being taken from the client’s account on express written authority from the client.

The Commissioner in his report identifies certain conduct engaged in by financial advice entities that he considers relevant to the offence for dishonest conduct in s1041G of the Corporations Act.

Two scenarios are identified in the report in which the charging of fees for no service are considered relevant to a contravention of section 1041G.

These include where an ongoing fee was charged and:

  1. There was no adviser linked to the client; or
  2. The client had died and the entity had been notified of the death.

It is stated in the report that ASIC has been investigating the conduct of one entity in relation to this offence, and that the Commissioner has provided to ASIC information in relation to a further two entities that may be relevant to contravention of s1041G.

Conflicts of Interest:

The report examines the conflicting duty of financial advisers to act in the best interests of their clients and the personal interests of advisers in circumstances where they are set to benefit financially from the advice provided.

Financial advisers are required to act in the best interests of their client under s961B(2) of the Corporations Act. This section requires that advisers:

The Commissioner indicates that the law has not seen client’s interests preferred over the interests of advisers. He refers to ASIC’s January 2018 report which indicates that on average two thirds of client investments of advisers licensed with the largest five banking institutions where made in in house products. He notes the incompatibility between the financial benefits to advisers in using in house products and adviser’s best interest’s duty. This is reflected in ASIC’s report which concluded that 75% of advice files that ASIC reviewed did not demonstrate compliance with s961B.

Better disclosure of adviser interests is recommended to better manage conflicts of duty and interest. There is currently no requirement for financial advisers to disclose any information about their approved product lists used. The Commissioner considers that disclosure should be required where an adviser will only consider products issued by their firm or entities having close links with the firm. He recommends that where advisers are not independent or impartial in this way that they be required to provide a statement disclosing that they are not independent or impartial.

Conflicted remuneration:

Conflicted remuneration concerns monetary and non-monetary benefits given to licensees or their representatives who provide financial product advice in circumstances where that advice could be expected to influence the choice of financial product recommended or the advice given to clients.[8]

The Commissioner notes that whilst the Corporations Act provisions in relation to conflicted remuneration appear comprehensive there a number of exceptions that exist to their application.

Grandfathered Commissions:

Grandfathered Commissions are a form of conflicted remuneration that has been permitted to continue by ‘grandfathering’ provisions made by Subdivision 5 of Division 4 of Part 7.7A of the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth). This was permitted by the FoFA reforms which allowed arrangements entered into prior to the reforms coming into effect in July 2013 to continue.

The report indicates that these benefits account on average for a third of licensees’ total income. The Commissioner recommends that such provisions be repealed as soon as reasonably practicable.

Life Risk Insurance:

Until 1 January 2018, commission paid in respect of life risk insurance products were exempt from the ban on conflicted remuneration. The report indicates $6.1 billion was paid by life insurers to financial advisers in the last 5 years in respect of such products.

Since 1 January 2018, conflicted remuneration has included volume-based benefits given to a licensee or a representative in relation to a life risk insurance product. A monetary benefit will not be conflicted remuneration however if it is a level commission with the applicable cap and provides a ‘clawback’ arrangement if the policy is cancelled, not continued or the policy cost is reduced in the first two years of the policy.[9]

ASIC will conduct a post-implementation review in 2021 to assess the effect of the reforms. The Commissioner indicates that few submissions in response to the Interim Report supported making further changes and recommended that ASIC consider reduce the cap when it conducts its review.

General Insurance, Consumer Credit Insurance and Non-Monetary Benefits:

The Commissioner recommends that the justification of these exemptions be reviewed.

Professional Discipline:

The Commissioner cites the fragmented disciplinary arrangements for financial advisers as leading to advisers who have engaged in poor or unlawful conduct not facing appropriate consequences for their actions. He examines how the primary responsibility is on AFSL holders in relation to their employees and authorised representatives, an obligation imposed by the Corporations Act.

The report notes that more needs to be done to ensure ‘best practice’ in the design of audit and consequence management systems. Poor auditing and communication between licensees in relation to misconduct by advisors is cited as limiting proper discipline.

The formalisation of reporting of ‘serious compliance concerns’ by AFSL holders to ASIC is recommended to allow ASIC greater capacity to take action.

Summary:

Pointon Partners does have significant experience in acting for financial planning practices and other bodies within the financial planning sector. If you have any queries regarding the Report or require any advice concerning its possible effects on you then please feel free to call Michael Bishop on 9614 7707.


[1] Recommendation 2.1

[2] 2.2

[3] 2.4

[4] 2.5

[5] 2.7

[6] 2.8

[7] 2.9

[8] S963A Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

[9] ASIC Corporations (Life Insurance Commissions) Instrument 2017/510, 3 May 2017 (Cth) s6

Acquisition of part interests in Pharmacies

Pointon Partners has handled the sale and purchase of dozens of pharmacies over the last fifteen years. We have considerable experience in acting for vendors of pharmacies as well as purchasers of pharmacies whether they be first time owners or pharmacists who operate already several pharmacy businesses.

We also cater to the day to day legal needs of our pharmacist clients whether it be employment law advice, leasing advice, review of franchise agreements & supplier contracts together with other advice and representation as required.

An emerging trend in recent years has been the sale and acquisition of part interests or minority interests in pharmacies generally involving employee pharmacists buying into the pharmacy they are currently working in.

Succession planning is often the motivating factor for the existing proprietor in these situations. The exact form of the transaction will depend upon the legal structure currently utilised by the pharmacy business.

If the pharmacy business is conducted:

  1. through a company, then a Share Sale Agreement will be prepared;
  2. through a unit trust, then a Unit Sale Agreement will be prepared; or
  3. By the existing proprietor in their own name, then a Sale of Assets Agreement will be prepared transferring a part interest in the business to the incoming owner.

It is also advisable to put in place a document regulating the ongoing relationship between the owners. This would be a Partnership Agreement, Shareholders Agreement or Unitholders Agreement as applicable.

We can prepare these on behalf of the existing owner or review and negotiate these on behalf of the incoming owner. On occasion the existing owner will have a service trust or company which is providing services (e.g. staff, premises or equipment) to the pharmacy business. The transaction will also need to involve the incoming owner acquiring an interest in this service trust or company.

The consent of any landlord to the new ownership arrangements is also something which needs to be addressed.

On a final note, the incoming owner will need to consider what legal structure they use to acquire their interest in the pharmacy business. The alternatives are buying the pharmacy interest in their own name, through a company or through a trust. Disclosure of these arrangements must be made to the Victorian Pharmacy Authority (VPA). We have experience in submitting documents to the VPA and preparing or amending trust deeds in order to meet the requirements of the VPA.

If you have any queries regarding pharmacy issues or transactions, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Felicity Cara-Carson for advice.

Are your contracts unfair? Don’t get caught out by the unfair terms legislation now applying to business to business contracts

Background

The doctrine of freedom of contract is a fairly standard one in Australian law, as well as in most Western legal traditions. The doctrine recognises that individuals should have the freedom to strike whatever bargain they choose.

However, as it turns, the situation between contracting parties in Australia is actually not that clear-cut. In fact, the freedom of contract doctrine is fettered under Australian law, and never has this been so true until now, with the recent expansion of the unfair contract terms legislation to capture business to business (B2B) contracts.

An overview of the legislation, which commenced on 12 November 2016, can be found in our earlier article here. Needless to say, it extends the unfair contract terms regime, which hitherto applied only to “consumer contracts” – contracts entered into by individuals for personal, domestic or household goods or services – to standard form “small business contracts” where at least one party to the contract is a small business (a business that employs fewer than 20 people), and the upfront price payable does not exceed $300,000 (for contracts of 12 months duration or less) or $1,000,000 (for contracts of more than 12 months duration).

Our article above discussed the first case to test the new legislation, Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1224. In that case, the ACCC took JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd, a waste-management company, to court over eight terms in its service agreements that were ultimately found to be void for unfairness. Since then, the ACCC has continued its hunt for companies that include “unfair terms” in their standard form small business contracts, and the next company to be caught in the firing line is Servcorp Limited, in the Federal Court of Australia (FCA) case of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Servcorp Limited [2018] FCA 1044.

Are your standard form contracts at risk?

In Servcorp, the company and its related entities entered into agreements with a number of small businesses for the supply of serviced office spaces and virtual office services such as office suites, secretarial services, IT and communications, in 24 locations around Australia.

The contracts considered by the FCA were entered into prior to 12 November 2016, when the unfair contract terms regime as applicable to small business contracts commenced. The regime nevertheless applied to each of the impugned contracts as they had been renewed after that date.

The contracts were prepared prior to any discussions between the parties and the parties were presented with the contracts without being invited to negotiate their terms (apart from the main subject matter of the contracts). This meant they satisfied the statutory definition of a “standard form contract”.

The terms declared by the Court to be unfair had the effect of:

The effect of the FCA’s declaration was that all of the impugned terms were void.

Servcorp was also required to implement a compliance program to ensure it did not contravene the legislation in future, and pay the ACCC’s costs in the proceeding, fixed at $150,000.

Key takeaways

The two Federal Court decisions and the earlier ACCC report, “Unfair terms in small business contracts: A review of selected industries”, show that the ACCC is on the prowl for companies that use standard form B2B contracts with terms that may be considered unfair.

The ACCC expects companies to take action by removing unfair terms from these contracts. Companies who fail to do so may face enforcement action in the Federal Court. JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd and Servcorp Limited are just the first two companies to get caught in the ACCC’s sights.

To ensure that your business does not fall foul of the unfair contract terms legislation, you should check your standard form contracts for any terms that may be slanted too far in favour of your business or that may unreasonably prejudice the rights of another party (whether they may be small businesses or consumers).

Alternatively, if you have entered into a standard form contract that has onerous terms that unfairly favour another party, then you may be entitled to relief from complying with such terms.

Pointon Partners can assist with the review and/or amendment of both consumer and small business contracts.

Do you need to comply with Europe’s General Data Protection Regulation?

On 25 May 2018 the new European Union General Protection Regulation (the GDPR) came into force.  The GDPR regulates the handling of personal data by “controllers” and “processors”, irrespective of whether the controller or processor was established in the EU.

Australian businesses, individuals, public authorities, agencies or other bodies may be bound by the GDPR and will be required to comply with these new data protection requirements as well as Australian privacy laws.

Does the GDPR apply to you?

The GDPR applies to the processing of personal data activities of “controllers” or “processors” with an establishment in the EU.[1] Generally, a “controller” determines the purposes and means of the processing of personal data and a “processor” processes personal data on behalf of the controller.[2]

The GDPR also applies to the processing of personal data activities of controllers or processors not established in the EU, where the processing activities are related to:

  1. the offering of good or services to individuals who are in the EU, irrespective of whether a payment is required; or
  1. the monitoring of the behaviour of individuals in the EU.[3]

Therefore, an Australia business may be covered by the GDPR including in circumstances where the business has an office in the EU, the website enables an individual to order good and services in a European language (other than English) or enables payment in currency (such as euros).[4]

Personal data and the GDPR

The GDPR defines ‘personal data’ as:  “any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person”.

An “identifiable natural person” is “one who can be identified, directly or indirectly, in particular by reference to an identifier such as a name, an identification number, location data, an online identifier or to one or more factors specific to the physical, physiological, genetic, mental, economic, cultural or social identity of that natural person.”[5]

In comparison, the definition of ‘personal data’ is similar to the definition of ‘personal information’ in Australia’s Privacy Act 1988 (Cth), which is defined as ‘information or an opinion about an identified individual, or an individual who is reasonably identifiable’.[6]

Obligations and requirements of the GDPR

The GDPR imposes numerous obligations and requirements on data controllers and processors. Some of these include:

  1. Consent: where the processing of personal data is based on consent, the controller must be able to show that the individual has consented to the processing of his or her personal data.[7] Where a controller uses a pre-formulated request for consent it must be presented in a manner which is ‘clearly distinguishable from other matters, in an intelligible and easily accessible form, using clear and plain language’.[8] Furthermore, an individual has a right to withdraw consent at any time.[9]
  1. Accountability: a controller is responsible for, and must be able to demonstrate compliance with the principles relating to processing of personal data in Article 7, including for example, that personal data is “collected for specified, explicit and legitimate purposes and not further processed in a manner that is not incompatible with those purposes”.[10]
  1. Right to erasure (‘right to be forgotten’): an individual has the right to obtain from the controller the erasure of personal data concerning him or her without undue delay.[11] The controller has the obligation to erase personal data where a ground in Article 17 of the GDPR applies.
  1. Right to data portability: where the processing of personal data is carried out by automated means an individual who has provided their personal data to a controller has the right to receive that personal data in a structured, commonly used and machine-readable format.[12] However, this right to transmit or receive personal data ‘should not create an obligation for controllers to adopt and maintain processing systems which are technically compatible’.[13]
  1. Right to object: an individual has the right to object to the processing of their personal data even when that processing is ‘necessary for the performance of a task carried out in the public interest’ or ‘for the purposes of the legitimate interests of the controller or by a third party’’.[14] It is the obligation of the data controller to show that its ‘compelling legitimate interest overrides the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms’ of the individual.[15]
  1. Responsibility of the controller: a controller must implement ‘appropriate technical and organisational measures to ensure and be able to demonstrate’ compliance with the GDPR.[16] This may include the implementation of data protection policies.
  1. Representatives: a controller or processor who is not established in the EU must designate in writing a representative in the EU unless an exception under Article 27(2) of the GDPR applies, such as being a public authority or body.[17]
  1. Notification of a personal data breach: a controller must without undue delay, notify the “supervisory authority” of a data breach within 72 hours of becoming aware of a breach that is likely to result in a risk to the rights and freedoms of individuals.[18] A processor also has an obligation to notify the controller of a personal data breach without undue delay.[19] These requirement are similar to the mandatory data breach notification regime now required by Australian privacy laws.

We note that there are many other requirements that data controllers and processors need to comply with under the GDPR and this article is only intended to provide a snapshot of the requirements of the GDPR.

Risk of non-compliance

The GDPR gives each “supervisory authority”, being an independent public body established by a Member State pursuant to the GDPR,[20] the power to impose administration fines in accordance with the GDPR. The maximum administrative fine can be up to 20 million euro or 4% of the total worldwide annual turnover of the proceeding financial year (whichever is higher) for contraventions, including:

As seen above the consequences of not complying with the GDPR can be significant. Therefore, if this is relevant to you and your business, it is crucial that you ensure that you comply with the requirements of the GDPR.

If you wish to discuss the matters raised in this article, do not hesitate to contact Felicity Cara-Carson or Jess Tomlinson of our office.


[1] Article 3(1) of the GDPR.

[2] Article 4(7) and 4(8).

[3] Article 3.

[4] Recital 23 of the GDPR.

[5] Article 4(1).

[6] Privacy Ac 1988 (Cth) s 6(1); OAIC, Australian businesses and the EU General Data Protection Regulation (March 2018), 4.

[7] Article 7(1).

[8] Recital 42.

[9] Article 7 and Recital 42.

[10] Article 5.

[11] Article 17.

[12] Article 20.

[13] Recital 68.

[14] Article 21 and 6(1)(e)-(f).

[15] Article 69.

[16] Article 24.

[17] Article 27.

[18] Article 33(1).

[19] Article 3.

[20] Article 4(21).

[21] Article 83(5).

Suppliers and lenders take note – Ensure that personal guarantees have been drafted and executed properly before advancing credit to customers

The recent case of FJ & SM Monaghan Pty Ltd v Slade [2018] NSWCA 79 has reiterated the importance of suppliers and lenders obtaining personal guarantees that have been carefully drafted in order to enforce them.

The importance of properly drafted guarantees

Although judgement was eventually awarded against the guarantors, it took nearly five years and several arduous court proceedings for the supplier to achieve this result. Had the guarantee been worded even slightly differently, the supplier may have been unsuccessful.

This case highlights the importance of guarantees that are clearly and thoroughly articulated and that, from a creditor’s perspective, expressly state that they cover all past, present and future debts owed, in the form of a continuing guarantee.

Pointon Partners has extensive experience in drafting credit terms and conditions for suppliers and general finance documents.

Contact us to have a comprehensive guarantee drawn up before advancing substantial credit or loans to customers.

Background

Between 2001 and 2013, FJ & SM Monaghan Pty Ltd (Monaghan), operated a petrol station and provided fuel on a running account to “Slade Refrigerated Transport” (Slade), a company of which a husband and wife were the sole director and sole shareholder, respectively.

From 1 July 2006, Slade’s overdue account with Monaghan incurred interest at a compound rate of 2.5% per month (around 34.5% per annum).

When arrears continued to increase into 2008, Monaghan instructed a solicitor to prepare a document under which the Stephen and Wendy Slade would personally guarantee the monies owing by Slade. Monaghan threatened to cease supply of fuel if the guarantee was not provided.

On 29 July 2008, the Slades opted instead to personally guarantee the debt by providing a one page letter that read as follows:

This letter is to explain that we Stephen Slade and Wendy Slade are Directors of S & W Slade Pty Ltd trading as Slade Refrigerated Transport.

We personally guarantee the debt with F & S Monaghan for fuel supplied to Slade Refrigerated Transport.

Yours sincerely

STEPHEN SLADE                  WENDY SLADE

The primary decision

In 2013, Monaghan brought a proceeding in the District Court of NSW against Slade and the guarantors for the outstanding balance on the running account, plus interest.

The key issue in that proceeding was whether the guarantee covered an amount outstanding on the date of the guarantee, or thereafter from time to time.

As payments had been made by Slade in partial discharge of its underlying liability to Monaghan, the guarantors would only be liable if the guarantee covered the amount outstanding from time to time, including interest.

The primary judge held that the guarantee only covered the balance outstanding on 29 July 2008, albeit including interest, and dismissed the claim. Monaghan appealed against that judgment.

Including interest in the personal guarantee

The Court of Appeal confirmed the trial judge’s finding that interest was properly construed as being included in the guaranteed amount.

In reaching their decision, the Court of Appeal noted that the only amount which could plausibly be described as the singular “debt with F & S Monaghan for fuel supplied to Slade Refrigerated Transport” was the running balance outstanding, which included interest to that date.

Whether the personal guarantee covered amounts outstanding from time to time

At trial, the primary judge had held that the reference to ‘the debt’ for ‘fuel supplied’ referred only to past indebtedness. On appeal, the Court found that the primary judge had erred in relying on this textual consideration.

When constructing the guarantee, the Court of Appeal looked to the surrounding circumstances to determine that the guarantee was a ‘continuing guarantee’ for the balance due from Slade to Monaghan from time to time.

In particular, the statements of account issued to Slade at the end of each month did not treat debits for fuel or interest at particular times or in particular periods as separate debts. Nor did they explicitly apportion any payments made by Slade, other than in reduction of the running account.

Nothing in the evidence suggested to the Court of Appeal that the debt between Monaghan and Slade would cease to be a single, but fluctuating, balance on the account.

Further, the guarantee was given in response to Monaghan’s ultimatum to cease supplying fuel unless a guarantee was provided. The commercial purpose was therefore to secure the continued supply of fuel and credit on the terms of the existing running account.

The Appeal was allowed and judgement was entered in favour of Monaghan against the guarantors in the amount of $750,000, being the jurisdictional limit of the original District Court.

If you would like to discuss the information above further, please contact Ben Drysdale of our office on (03) 9614 7707.

6 New Year’s resolutions for your business – Legal tips for development and success

The start of the calendar year is a great time for businesses to take stock of their current practices, policies and documentation in order to identify potential risks and opportunities for improvement.  We have compiled a brief checklist of critical (but often overlooked) items, to assist in your reflection on your business’ current practices.

If any of the following strike a chord with you, it may be time to consult with your legal advisor to address any barriers to the continued growth and success of your business in 2018.

  1. Review your current employment contracts

The National Employment Standards apply to all employment contracts and many employees will also be covered by a relevant Modern Award.  Employers need to be aware of the minimum employee entitlements contained within these instruments, and all standard employment contracts should be regularly reviewed to ensure that they are compliant.

Some businesses may also wish to include more complex terms in contracts with their senior employees, such as non-solicitation or restraint of trade clauses and ‘garden leave’ provisions.  It is imperative that these provisions are drafted by lawyers with experience in employment law, as inexpertly drafted restraint clauses have often been held to be invalid by the Courts

  1. Review any contractor arrangements

The office of the Fair Work Ombudsman has indicated that it will maintain a heightened focus on sham contracting arrangements in 2018.  Businesses must accurately classify employees and contractors, and be aware of the key differences between them.  Pointon Partners have previously prepared an employee/contractor checklist to assist in this classification.

Your business may also benefit from legal advice concerning the obligation (in certain circumstances) to pay superannuation and/or payroll tax in relation to independent contractors and whether any exceptions may apply

  1. Implement or update your business’ policies

Employee policies are an important resource for both employees and management, as they describe how all team members are expected to conduct themselves.  Some policies which your business may require are those concerning:

If your business collects any personal information from customers, you must also have a privacy policy in place. The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner recommends that privacy policies be reviewed and updated every 12 months.

  1. Update your trading terms and conditions

If your business has trading terms and conditions, they should be periodically reviewed by legal advisors to consider the impact of legislative changes.  For example, all standard form agreements should have been examined after 12 November 2016, when the unfair contract terms protections contained in the Australian Consumer Law were extended to small business contracts.

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has already successfully enforced the new regime against JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd, in a high-profile case concerning what the ACCC considered to be unfair terms

  1. Reassess any material arrangements between the business and any directors or associates

Where there are arrangements in place between your business and any associate, such as the provision of loans or services, the terms of such arrangements should be reduced to writing. If there are loans from the business to any shareholders or their associates, there may also be implications arising in relation to Division 7A of the Income Tax Assessments Act 1936 (Cth) which will need to be considered

  1. Consider asset protection for directors and key personnel

Directors and key individuals within a business should be made aware of their potential personal liability as a result of the business’ activities. By way of example, directors can be made liable under the insolvent trading provisions of the Corporations Act 2001, whilst human resources managers and payroll officers have recently come under fire through the accessorial liability provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 for underpayments by employers.

Particularly where directors and/or key individuals own significant assets in their own names, they may wish to discuss restructuring their personal affairs with a legal advisor.

Pointon Partners have significant experience in advising small to medium businesses.  If you wish to discuss any of the above issues, or your business activities generally, please contact Michael Bishop or Ben Drysdale on (03) 9614 7707.

Management of Kindergartens – Navigating a legal minefield

Kindergartens in Victoria have to comply with a myriad of legislative obligations which can seem a minefield for the unsuspecting parent volunteer who finds themselves on a Committee of Management.

Pointon Partners works with Kindergartens, Early Years Managers (formerly known as cluster managers) and education professionals and can guide understanding of and compliance with legislative obligations.

The National Quality Framework (‘NQF’) introduced a new quality standard in 2012 across Australia to improve education and care across long day care, family day care, preschool/kindergarten and outside school hours care services.

The NQF aims to raise quality in children’s education and care services through:

For community kindergartens who are reliant on parent volunteers who manage the administration of the kindergarten including the finances, policies and procedures, the enrolment processes and are the employers of the staff there is a lot of regulation to be aware of and comply with. In addition, these regulations and standards are often changing as occurred with the NQF in October 2017.

Pointon Partners is able to assist the Committees of kindergartens on all aspects of the administration of a kindergarten including specific advice on the NQF and ensuring compliance with the NQF (as amended from time to time).

The Committee of Management is also responsible to ensure all staff have a safe workplace, are being employed in accordance with the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and are being remunerated correctly in accordance with the Victorian Early Childhood Teachers and Educators Agreement (VECTEA).

Pointon Partners specialises in employment law and is able to provide advice on all aspects of employment law including contracts for the employment of kindergarten staff, performance management of staff and applying the VECTA. In addition, employees of Pointon Partners have experience on being on the Committee of Management at kindergartens and are able to advise on specific employment law issues as they relate to kindergartens and staff.

Another important function of the Committee of Management is managing complaints in accordance with policies of the kindergarten and to ensure that appropriate mandatory reporting obligations are fulfilled. For example, section 174(2)(b) of the Education and Care Services National Law Act 2010 (‘the Act’) provides that complaints alleging that:

A failure to comply with this provision carries a penalty of $4,000 in the case of an individual and $20,000 in any other case. Potentially the Committee of Management which usually has an Executive Committee comprising a President, Vice President, Secretary and Treasurer are all liable for financial penalties for breaches of the Act. As such it is prudent for volunteers who are on Committees of Management to seek legal advice when they are unsure of their responsibilities or reporting obligations under the Act.

For an increasing number of kindergartens filling committees with volunteers is increasingly difficult as many families have both parents working and as such cannot commit to spend the time required by these roles including attendance at Committee meetings. In addition, parents may not feel like they have sufficient experience to volunteer for a role on the Committee of Management especially the Executive Committee roles and for these and other reasons many kindergartens are considering and moving into arrangements with Early Years Managers (formerly known as cluster managers) whereby they leave the administration of the kindergarten to the Manager. Parent volunteer committees can then focus on fundraising and other similar initiatives.

Pointon Partners has experience in transitioning Kindergartens through this process so they retain some autonomy and protect their financial position. It is extremely important to have good documentation in place to protect the Kindergarten and ensure that the parent Committee of Management and the Early Years Manager understand their respective roles.

Pointon Partners is able to assist Committees of Management, Early Years Managers and Kindergartens looking to transition to a management arrangement. For more information, please contact Amelita Hensman.

Consumer watchdog on the hunt for unfair terms in B2B contracts

The recent decision by the Federal Court of Australia (FCA) in ACCC v JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd[1] is expected to empower small businesses to negotiate terms of standard form contracts.  It also serves as a timely reminder for large businesses to review their standard form contracts and practices.

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) succeeded in its contention that eight terms in service agreements used by JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd (JJ Richards) were unfair and therefore void.

What is the relevant law?

The Australian Consumer Law (ACL) provides that an unfair contractual term of a standard form contract will be void.  The contract may continue to bind the parties, to the extent that the contract can continue without the void term.

What are “unfair contract terms”?

A contractual term is “unfair” under the ACL if it satisfies the following three conditions:

The unfair contract term regime previously applied only to standard form “consumer contracts”, that is, contracts entered into by individuals for personal, domestic or household goods or services.    As of 12 November 2016 the regime was extended to cover standard form “small business contracts”.  A “small business contract” is a contract for the supply of goods or services or sale or grant of an interest in land in which:

The provisions regarding unfair terms apply to standard form contracts only.  The ACL sets out various considerations in determining whether a contract is “standard form”.  These include the relative bargaining power of the parties, who prepared the contract and whether there were opportunities given to negotiate.   It is important to note that once a party to a proceeding alleges that a contract is standard form, the onus is on the other party to prove that it is not.

JJ Richards’ service agreement was considered a standard form contract because it was offered on a take it or leave it basis and could not be negotiated by the customer.

What went down in Court

JJ Richards provides waste-management services to tens of thousands of Australian consumers and businesses, subject to the terms of its service agreements. Amongst other things, the service agreements that came under the microscope in the FCA gave JJ Richards the following rights:

By way of consent orders, the FCA declared all 8 of the above terms to be unfair and therefore unenforceable. The orders provide that JJ Richards is prevented from relying on these terms in future, has to publish a corrective notice on its website, notify all small businesses that were party to its service agreement and implement a program for compliance with the ACL for a period of 3 years.

Significance of the case

This was the ACCC’s test case for enforcing the newly expanded unfair contract terms regime. It has made an example of JJ Richards and serves as a general deterrent to the use of unfair terms in standard form contracts with consumers and small businesses.  In public statements made after the FCA handed down its decision, the ACCC was not shy to admit that it is actively investigating other large businesses for similar contraventions of the ACL.

In the wake of this case, large businesses will need to review their standard form contracts in order to ensure compliance with the ACL and to understand which terms are at risk of being declared unfair.

Small business owners can take comfort in the outcome of this case, and should take the time to understand their rights under the ACL, should the need arise to dispute the terms of a standard form contract in future.

Pointon Partners have a wealth of experience in the areas of contract law and consumer law. If you require legal advice or have any queries in relation to this article, please do not hesitate to contact our office on (03) 9614 7707.

Potential liability of franchisors and holding companies for breach of workplace laws – Vulnerable workers legislation commences

Extended liability for franchisors and holding companies

Recently, the Fair Work Act has undergone a number of amendments as a result of the Fair Work Amendment (Protecting Vulnerable Workers) Bill 2017.

Importantly, the amendment introduced new accessorial liability provisions that will apply from the 27 October 2017.[1] The new provisions are designed to make it easier for the courts to hold franchisors and holding companies responsible for certain workplace contraventions made by franchisee or subsidiary employers. This is in response to the highly publicised cases of worker exploitation, such as those made by 7-Eleven franchisees.

Interestingly, the provisions will not just apply to large scale franchisors like 7-Eleven. Franchisors and even holding companies of small to medium businesses are also at risk.

Here at Pointon Partners, we have provided a general outline of the new provisions to help small to medium businesses understand their legal position, and the best course of action to lessen their risk of accessorial liability.

Accessorial Liability Provisions

Franchisors or holding companies may be deemed to be accessorily liable for contraventions made by the franchisee/subsidiary employer of:

The main condition is that a franchisor, holding company or an officer knew or could reasonably be expected to have known that the contravention by the subsidiary would occur, or a contravention of the same character was likely to occur.[2] For instance, holding companies that have shared directors and/or staff are at greater risk of having actual or expected knowledge. It is unclear whether holding companies that are more ‘hands off’ in relation to their subsidiaries would also be reasonably expected to have known that a contravention would occur. It will be interesting to see how these new provisions are applied by the courts, and what amount of evidence is needed.

However, there is more guidance on the factors that may prevent a finding of accessorial liability. When examining an accessorial liability claim, the courts may not hold franchisors liable if they took reasonable steps to prevent a contravention by a franchisee employer. The court will take into account a range of factors, including examining:

Although the reasonable steps provision provides some clarity, there is still some uncertainty on what is the best practice for franchisors and holding companies. There is a conflict between franchisors employing an appropriate level of risk management and oversight of franchisees in order to have a reasonable defence, and not being too controlling of the franchisees’ affairs to risk direct legal liability.

There is also the practical constraint on small to medium businesses not having the resources to monitor the actions of their franchisee/subsidiary employers. This is partially recognised as a defence, but it will be interesting to see how lenient the courts are willing to be.

Despite these uncertainties, businesses can minimize their risk of accessorial liability by implementing at least some of the reasonable steps outlined above. It is also important to ensure that any complaint process or similar arrangements will need to be bona fide and handled carefully to be complaint with the Fair Work Act.

At Pointon Partners Lawyers, we can assist assessing your business’s risk of secondary liability and the adequacy of your monitoring and complaint systems. For more information, please contact Michael Bishop (director) on (03) 9614 7707.


[1] Fair Work Act (Cth) 2009, Schedule 1 (Application, saving and transitional provisions relating to amendments to this Act), Part 4, Clause 19.  (ie. six weeks from the commencement date of the amendments, being 15 September 2017).

[2] Fair Work Act (Cth) 2009, s 558B.

Crowd-sourced funding for proprietary companies: Differences between exposure draft and bill

The Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017 (Bill) has now been introduced into Parliament.

The Bill “sets out amendments to the Corporations Act 2001 (Corporations Act) to enable proprietary companies in Australia to access crowd-sourced equity funding”.[1]

Prior to the introduction of the Bill into Parliament, the Government released draft legislation for public consultation (Exposure Draft).

For more information on the Exposure Draft please access our article here that discusses what crowd-sourced funding (CSF) is, the current limitation and the proposed extension to include proprietary companies as eligible CSF companies.

The consultation occurred between 9 May and 6 June 2017 and received submissions that were generally supportive of the extension of the CSF framework to proprietary companies.[2]

There are numerous changes to the draft legislation as the Treasury further redefined the legislation through targeted consultation.[3] The changes include:

  1. the removal of the “appropriate CSF exit arrangements” that provided a trigger for a person to offer to buy out other shareholders if their voting power in the company was 40% or more;
  1. an increase to the CSF audit threshold from $1 million to $3 million, unless the amount is changed by regulations; and
  1. the inclusion of new provisions that propose to make changes to existing legislation relating to eligible public companies that access the CSF regime, including:

a.     an amendment to the meaning of an eligible CSF company to clarify that the “company cannot be listed on a financial market overseas in addition to not being listed on a financial market in Australia”;[4]

b.     a reduction in the cooling-off period from one month to 14 days;[5] and

c.     an increase to the audit threshold for public companies eligible for corporate governance concessions that now provides that they will only be required to have their financial statements audited and appoint an auditor after raising $3 million or more from CSF.[6] The current threshold is $1 million.

The House of Representatives moved the second reading of the Bill on 14 September 2017.

Restructuring

Small businesses wishing to access crowd-sourced funding may need to restructure prior to participating in any equity raisings. For example, a business operated via a family trust would need to be restructured into a proprietary company, which would raise a variety of commercial and tax law issues.

Pointon Partners are able to assist with restructuring as well as crowd-sourced funding.

If you have any queries or wish to seek advice in relation to restructuring or crowd-sourced funding, please contact Jess Tomlinson on (03) 9614 7707.


[1] Commonwealth, Parliamentary Debates, House of Representatives, 14 September 2017, 1 (Scott Morrison).

[2] Explanatory Memorandum, Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017 2.63.

[3] Ibid 2.65.

[4] Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017 sch 1 pt 2 item 52.

[5] Ibid sch 1 pt 2 item 51; Explanatory Memorandum, Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017 1.67.

[6] Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017 sch 1 pt 2 items 47, 48, 49; Explanatory Memorandum, Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017 1.69.