Pointon Partners

New ways of working during the latest Victorian lockdown

As Victoria enters a new period of stage 4 restrictions, employers must consider the impact on their workplace. Pointon Partners are able to assist employers with relevant issues including stand down, COVID-specific OH&S requirements and the availability of work permits for certain industries.

Reliance on JobKeeper powers

For those employers receiving JobKeeper payments, now may be the time to rely on the extraordinary powers granted to employers, allowing them to:

Standing down employees that can’t be usefully employed

If a non-JobKeeper employer must shut down part or all of its operations during lockdown and its employees cannot be usefully employed, the employer may be able to rely on the ‘stand down’ provisions contained in the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

Section 524 of the Act provides that an employer may stand down an employee without pay when:

It is a requirement that there actually be a stoppage of work within the employer’s business outside the employer’s control and not merely just a slowdown in patronage of the business.

OH&S considerations during the pandemic

WorkSafe Victoria introduced the temporary Occupational Health and Safety (COVID-19 Incident Notification) Regulations 2020 which commenced on Tuesday 28 July 2020.

Previously, employers were not required to notify WorkSafe of an infectious disease in the workplace, unless immediate inpatient treatment was required or the disease is the cause (or suspected cause) of a death.

The current state of disaster means that timely notification of potential workplace transmission is critical for the effective management of COVID-related health and safety risks.

The Regulations require that WorkSafe be notified if:

Those found to have breached the Regulations could be lumped with a fine of up to $39,652 for an individual or $198,264 for a company.

Worker permits for certain industries

As of midnight on 5 August 2020, Victorian workers from permitted industries will be allowed to travel to or from work, even during the 8:00pm to 5:00am curfew.

Employees will be required to carry a worker permit, signed by them and their employer, when they travel to their workplace. By signing the permit, each party will be making certain declarations, as set out below:

By signing the permit, the Employer:

By signing the permit, the Employee:

Please contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Ben Drysdale to discuss any issues arising in your workplace.

Spamming and the Spam Act

Many of us, have from time to time, received unsolicited emails or other messages from unknown sources, or businesses keen to advertise an event or product through content marketing. This would seem to have become even more rife during the COVID-19 period, as businesses have sought to expand their offerings and clientele in challenging circumstances.

It is important to note however that in Australia, legislation known as the Spam Act 2003 (Cth) (“the Act”) sets out rules relating to spam messages, including information relevant to senders as well as receivers of such messages.

The Act provides that, subject to certain exceptions, an unsolicited commercial electronic message (“CEM”) (which is broadly defined and can include emails and SMS messages), must not be sent without the consent of the relevant electronic account holder of the email address, instant messaging service, telephone number or other account holder (section 16 of the Act).[1]

Consent under the Act is taken to constitute both express consent or consent that can be reasonably inferred from the conduct and the business and other relationships of the individuals or organisations concerned, and may not be inferred from the mere fact that a relevant electronic address has been published.[2]

There are however two exceptions relevant to section 16 of the Act, namely a “conspicuous publication” and a “designated message”.

(a) Conspicuous publication[3]

Generally speaking, if the particular electronic address has been:

(b) Designated commercial message[4]

One of the types of designated commercial messages is a message that consists of no more than factual information and other additional information specified in the Act, and which complies with other specified conditions.

There are also other designated commercial messages defined in the Act such as messages authorised by government bodies, political parties, charities and educational institutions.

The Act also requires that CEM’s include accurate sender information and an avenue for the recipient of the message to unsubscribe.[5]

It is important to note that the Act also prohibits acquiring or supplying address-harvesting software and harvested-address lists for the purpose of sending commercial electronic messages.[6]

Failure to comply with the requirements in the Act can lead to the imposition of penalties, such as pecuniary penalties, compensation, recovery of financial benefits or an injunction.[7]

These pecuniary penalties can be severe, with the Australian Communications and Media Authority (“ACMA”) website listing that repeat corporate offenders may face penalties of up to $2.1 million a day.

Recent matters published on the ACMA website illustrate some of the penalties which have been imposed as follows:

If you wish to discuss this article, or any other matter relating to this article, please feel free to contact Felicity Cara-Carson on (03) 9614 7707.

[1] SPAM Act 2003 (Cth), Section 16.

[2] SPAM Act 2003 (Cth), Schedule 2.

[3] SPAM Act 2003 (Cth), Schedule 2, cl 4.

[4] SPAM Act 2003 (Cth), Schedule 1.

[5] SPAM Act 2003 (Cth), Section 17.

[6] SPAM Act 2003 (Cth), Part 3.

[7] SPAM Act 2003 (Cth), Parts 4, 5, 6 and 7.

[8] https://www.acma.gov.au/articles/2019-11/oneflare-pays-75600-infringement-notice-spamming

[9] https://www.acma.gov.au/articles/2020-01/optus-pays-504000-spamming-australians

Revisiting Early Commercial decisions in COVID-19 and the Law

Commercial decisions caused by COVID-19 have led to many early decisions being driven by real or perceived income and cash flow concerns without a clear consideration of the applicable laws.

If this has happened it is recommended that the law is now looked at in respect of these past decisions as the future ramifications can be unfortunate.

Common issues include:

Leases

The preferred position is always to reach a written variation agreement with the lessor. This normally begins with a notification notice to the landlord’s agent / landlord that trading conditions have changed.

If you as a Lessee have been affected and you have not done this yet you should do it now. This notification should be in writing via a short email or letter, and should clearly explain how your turnover and / or income is being impacted by COVID-19. Recently the Victorian Government have released new regulations that specify how the notification and negotiations should be made, which we go into further detail in our recent article available here.

Lessors and their agents should also try to negotiate an arrangement or compromise in good faith during this period. Negotiations can generate certainty and a better relationship with the Lessee going forward. Otherwise, the prospects of recovering rent in arrears after the pandemic is over may be low if negotiations are not attempted. These negotiations should be carefully considered and any agreement should be reduced to writing if possible.

Many Lessors will look to enforce their rights after this period of pandemic is over.

Retail especially was hit hard commercially early in this pandemic and many stopped paying rent completely or made unilateral reductions. Although understandable commercially, the fact is it is highly unlikely to be in accordance with the lease or the law.

In a lease of property it is very unusual that there is a force majeure clause. Such a clause allows for suspension of the contract in various circumstances outside the control of the parties which are identified in the clause. Even if there was such a clause it is unlikely to apply under its terms as pandemics are rarely included as a defined event.

Under common law if the doctrine of frustration applies it leads to the termination of a lease. The doctrine of frustration requires there to be changed circumstances that mean that the contract cannot be performed objectively and it is a very difficult test to achieve on the basis of decisions by the Courts in this area. Note that the only relief that can be given is termination and not rent relief.

There is likely to be a right to quiet enjoyment terms in commercial property leases. If the landlord has locked you out rights can arise the circumstances from this pandemic have led to decisions being by Government or by the lessee rather than the lessor where a vacation of premises has occurred.

The legal basis for a change of lease are set out in principle in the National Code of Conduct released on 7 April 2020 by the Australian Government and then legally effected by each State which may also amend the federal principles. Recently, the Victorian Government has released regulations that include some variations and exceptions to the code. For further detail, please refer to our article here.

Even if the provisions do not apply due to technicalities there are still commercial reasons why the landlord and lessee should still use them as a basis to lead discussions.

The National Code allows for a reduction in rent of at least 50% of the turnover reduction of the Lessees’ business. This reduction is then 50% forgiven and 50% deferred for repayment over two years.

It is important to note that the lessee will need to provide information of their business turnover (BAS statements are a good start or appropriate other financial reports) to negotiate.

It is more important to note that the Code sets out a minimum reduction and a larger reduction or larger forgiveness may be more appropriate.

Note landlords do want to retain good tenants and will not want to eventually terminate into what could be a difficult leasing environment for them after the pandemic. Leases cannot currently be terminated for non-payment of rent but may be terminated for other breaches of the terms of the lease, depending on the circumstances.

Employment Changes

Some employers in panic stood down permanent staff or cut their permanent employees hours without due process.

The JobSeeker amendments introduced on 7 April 2020 have introduced amendments to the Fair Work Act that have allowed unilateral decisions by qualifying employers to enforce reduced hours for their employees. A process must however be followed.

If the employer is not a qualifying employer then the existing Fair Work provisions apply which include the ability to reduce employees to 75% of current hours if 75% of employees vote for in favour. Also there is the power to enforce annual leave where the employee has over two weeks owing.

Working from home Legal Issues.

Many legal issues arise from the working remote environment we are currently in and many employers have not fully considered these.

As a starting point it is worth reviewing the privacy implications and a useful starting point are the guidelines set out by the Office of Australian Information Commissioner.

Dealing with Suppliers 

Many supply requirements will have changed markedly under the current trading positions and unilateral decisions to amend should be reviewed for their legality. The availability of force majeure clauses and the common law doctrine of frustration described above need to be considered.

Amendments to the contracts often relate to reduced volumes or suspension which can be as of right or by agreement. These legal requirements are generally contractual in nature.

For issues in relation to the transport and retention of suspended goods, parties should also be aware of their rights and obligations under contract as well as the tort of negligence and the doctrine of bailment.

We are happy to advise and assist in any review process.

Victorian Regulations Affecting Commercial Leases During COVID-19 Finally Released (4 May 2020)

New Victorian Regulations designed to mitigate the effect of the COVID-19 (coronavirus) pandemic on “eligible leases” in Victoria have finally been released. They shall apply retrospectively from 29 March 2020.

A Mandatory Code was announced by the Federal Cabinet in April 2020, but this contained high level “leasing principles” only and did not represent the law in Victoria.

The new Regulations provide much needed legislative clarity on the specific rights and obligations of commercial tenants and landlords in Victoria during the COVID-19 pandemic. The Regulations broadly follow the scheme of the Mandatory Code, but with a number of important exceptions.

These exceptions include that the amount of rent relief offered by landlords to tenants does not need to be directly proportional to the reduction in the tenant’s turnover – arguably a win for landlords. Also, a formal rent relief offer process must be followed in order for the tenant to avoid being evicted, sued for non-payment of rent or the security deposit being used.  An influx of compulsory mediations is expected to follow.

KEY POINTS:

Rent relief period

  1. The Regulations operate retrospectively from 29 March 2020 until 29 September 2020.

Eligible leases

  1. The Regulations (and relevant rent relief entitlements) only apply to “eligible leases”. An eligible lease is a lease under which the tenant:

Agricultural leases (or leases permitting the tenant to carry out farming activities) are not eligible leases. This is surprising and not previously foreshadowed in the Mandatory Code.

The Tenant under an eligible lease is not automatically protected under the Regulations

  1. The tenant does not get any protection under the Regulations, and the provisions of the lease continue to apply (including provisions giving the landlord the right to evict a tenant, use the security deposit to make good its loss and sue for unpaid rent) unless:

The landlord must make the tenant a written rent relief offer

  1. Upon receiving a request under (3)(a) above, the landlord has 14 days (or a different timeframe by agreement) to make an offer for rent relief. The offer must, among other things:

VCAT or a Court may ultimately need to determine if the landlord’s offer complies with the above, if the parties cannot come to agreement (see below).

Issues arising from terms of the offer the landlord must make

  1. There are some interesting issues that arise from the above offer requirements. The requirement that the landlord’s offer:

Consequently, if the landlord is a retiree with no income except the income from the lease, this may be taken into account in the landlord’s offer. Similarly, if the landlord is highly leveraged and its lenders have provided only limited extensions on its loans, then this, too, is a consideration.

The Small Business Commission has foreshadowed a guideline on the financial information to be provided.  However, whatever that guideline ends up saying, given the discretion in the terms of the offer given to the landlord, we think it would be prudent for a tenant to provide at least some trading figures to their landlords because it is difficult for the landlord to take into account the tenant’s ability to pay the reduced rent without at least some financial information.

If a deferral is offered, the deferred rent is not repayable until after the earlier of the expiry of the lease and 29 September 2020 (unless otherwise agreed). The landlord must also offer an extension to the lease (on the same terms at the end of the lease) if required to ensure the tenant has at least 24 months to repay the deferred rent.

How to document a rent relief agreement

  1. Agreements for rent relief must by confirmed by an amendment to the lease or a side agreement.  However, as is always the case when dealing with land, it is still important to record the agreement in a formal document to ensure it complies with the rapidly changing legal landscape and there is a clear record of the agreed terms.

What if the parties cannot come to an agreement

  1. If the parties cannot agree on the terms of the rent relief, either party can refer the matter to mediation at the Small Business Commissioner and have a lawyer present to represent them. Failing resolution through mediation, parties can choose to go to either VCAT or Court to have disputes under the Regulations determined.  If parties go to VCAT, the ‘no cost’ rule in s 92 of the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) applies (i.e. each party bears its own costs).

Outgoings

  1. If outgoings are reduced (eg land tax for non-retail leases or Council rates), then the landlord must reduce the amount payable by the tenant and reimburse them for overpayments since 29 March 2020.

Interest or fees

  1. No fees, interest or charges can be levied for late payment of rent or deferred rent.

Trading hours

  1. Leases cannot be terminated for closures or a reduction in trading hours.

Confidential information

  1. Landlords and tenants must not divulge or communicate personal, business process or financial information obtained under or in connection with the Regulations, save in specified circumstances.

GET LEGAL ADVICE

Landlords and tenants should obtain legal advice from an expert in commercial leasing and have any agreement carefully documented to ensure it complies with the rapidly changing legal landscape.

Pointon Partners have developed a comprehensive COVID-19 Lease Variation Document which can be adapted to each circumstance and each lease situation. It is important that agreements are documented carefully to take into consideration the present but also the future including future changes to the landlord and tenant’s interests (such as a sale of the land or a transfer of the tenant’s business). Don’t rely on email correspondence for any agreement. Document it properly. A poorly drafted document or agreement will have a longer lasting impact than COVID-19.

Pointon Partners also has significant experience negotiating COVID-19 related amendments to leases on behalf of both landlord and tenants.

Whether you are a tenant or a landlord, if you are seeking assistance as to how to best proceed in this uncertain environment please contact us on (03) 9614 7707.

Property Team

PM Announces Details of Mandatory Code of Conduct for Commercial Leases: COVID-19 UPDATE (8 April 2020)

The Prime Minister announced yesterday the introduction of The Mandatory Code of Conduct (the Code). The Code sets out a series of guidelines for negotiated solutions to financial distress caused by the COVID-19 crisis in the commercial leasing context.

It addresses, among other things, tenant relief eligibility requirements, mandatory rent waivers/deferrals and how these are calculated, non-termination rights and compulsory mediations.

The Code is to be implemented by way of state-by-state legislation or regulations, as appropriate. It will come into effect on a date after 3 April 2020.

DOES THE CODE APPLY TO YOUR LEASE?

The purpose of the Code is to impose a set of good faith leasing principles for application to commercial tenancies (including retail, office and industrial) between landlords and tenants, in circumstances where the tenant is:

Tenants will be eligible for the JobKeeper subsidy if, at the time of applying:

For tenants that are not eligible for the JobKeeper Program or have a turnover of more than $50 million, the Code will not apply.

MANDATORY LEASING PRINCIPLES

While the Code has not yet become legislation in Victoria, the following leasing principles as prescribed by the Code should be applied as soon as reasonably practicable and in the most appropriate manner in light of the specific leasing arrangement:

  1. Landlords must not terminate leases due to non-payment of rent during the COVID-19 pandemic period (or reasonable subsequent recovery period).
  1. Tenants must comply with their obligations under the lease, subject to any amendments to payment of rent as negotiated under the Code. It is important to note that a material failure to abide by substantive terms of a lease will forfeit any protections provided to the tenant under this Code.
  1. Landlords must offer tenants proportionate reductions in rent payable in the form of waivers and deferrals based on the reduction in the tenant’s trade during the COVID-19 pandemic period and a subsequent reasonable recovery period.

a. Rental Waivers: A waiver of rent means that rent is not payable for that period and it cannot be recovered by the landlord at a later date. Under the Code, rent waivers must constitute no less than 50% of the total reduction in rent payable during the COVID-19 pandemic period. It is stated that this amount should be increased where it affects the tenant’s capacity to fulfil its other obligations under the lease however, regard must also be had to landlord’s financial ability to provide such additional waivers. Tenants can agree to waive the 50% minimum by agreement.

b. Rent Deferral: A deferral of rent suspends the obligation to pay rent to a later date at which point it is equally applied over the balance of the term or at least over the next 24 months (whichever is greater). The parties can come to another agreement.

Example 1

Where the tenant’s revenue has fallen by 100%, then at least 50% of the rent for the COVID-19 period is waived and the balance is applied as a rent deferral.

 Example 2

Where the tenant’s revenue has fallen by 30%, the rent payable will be reduced by 30%. At least half of the amount of that reduction will be waived, and the balance will be deferred.

  1. Where rent is deferred or waived, the landlord should not claim fees, interest or other charges from the tenant.
  1. Where the agreements negotiated in light of the Code require repayment of a sum at a later date, such repayment should occur over an extended period of time, as mentioned above under point 3(b), and should not commence until the earlier of the COVID-19 pandemic period ending or the existing lease expiring.
  1. The tenant should be provided with an opportunity to extend its lease for an equivalent period of the rent waiver and/or deferral period to allow it additional time to trade.
  1. Landlords must not draw on a tenant’s security for non-payment of rent during the COVID-19 pandemic period and /or a reasonable subsequent recovery period.
  1. Rent increases (except for retail leases based on turnover) are frozen for the COVID-19 pandemic period and a reasonable subsequent recovery period. The parties may nonetheless mutually agree that rent will increase under the terms of the lease.
  1. Any reductions in statutory charges (for example land tax, council rates etc) or insurance will be proportionally passed onto the tenant.
  1. Landlords should seek to share any benefit due to a deferral of loan payments with the tenant in a proportionate manner.
  1. Landlords, where appropriate, should seek to waive recovery for any other expenses or outgoings during the period the tenant is not able to trade.
  1. Landlords may not apply any restrictions, levies or penalties if the tenant reduces its opening hours or ceases to trade during the COVID-19 pandemic.

MEDIATION

Where parties cannot reach an agreement, the matter should be referred to the relevant State or Territory Small Business Commission or Ombudsmen for binding mediation of the arrangement. We will need to see what further information the legislation gives regarding this mediation process.

ACCESS TO AND PROVISION OF INFORMATION

Landlords and tenants are to act in an open, honest and transparent manner, and will each provide sufficient and accurate information within the context of negotiations to achieve outcomes consistent with the Code.

This means if you are a landlord, you are within your rights to request information generated from an accounting system, and information provided to and/or received from a financial institution, that demonstrate the level of financial stress experienced by the tenant as a direct result of the COVID-19 event and the tenant’s reduction in revenue.

If you are tenant, you need to be prepared to substantiate that the rent reduction/waiver being sought is proportionate to your decrease in revenue over recent months as a direct result of the COVID-19 pandemic (including government-mandated trading restrictions).

GET LEGAL ADVICE

Landlords and tenants should obtain legal advice from an expert and have any agreement documented carefully to ensure it complies with the rapidly changing legal landscape.

Pointon Partners has developed a comprehensive COVID-19 Lease Variation Document which can be adapted to each circumstance and each lease situation. It is important that agreements are documented carefully to take into consideration the present but also the future including future changes to the landlord and tenant’s interests (such as a sale of the land or a transfer of the tenant’s business). Don’t rely on email correspondence for any agreement. Document it properly. A poorly drafted document or agreement will have a longer lasting impact that COVID-19.

Whether you are a tenant or a landlord, if you are seeking assistance as to how to best proceed in this uncertain environment please contact us on (03) 9614 7707.

Property Team

Commercial Lease COVID-19 Update (30 March 2020): PM announces 6 month moratorium on termination of commercial leases, urges landlords and tenants to renegotiate lease terms

Following our previous update on the escalating COVID-19 situation in the commercial lease context, the Prime Minister has just announced a 6 month moratorium on termination of commercial and residential tenancies for non-payment of rent.

There have also been additional reports today that Banks will allow commercial landlords with loans of up to $10 million to delay their loan repayments by up to six months, on the condition tenants are not evicted due to the coronavirus crisis.

Mr Morrison says:

  1. States and Territories will be implementing a six-month ban on evictions of people as a “result of financial distress if they are unable to meet their commitments”; and
  1. He wants landlords and tenants to work with each other and banks while the policy is worked on. “We want people to sit down and work this out … There is no rule book for this,” he says.

The term “commercial”, presumably, also includes retail leases.

It is not clear at this stage when the moratorium will start, but 1 April 2020 is a logical start date.

It is also not clear how ‘financial distress’ or a tenant’s ability to ‘meet their commitments’ will be defined or assessed. This will no doubt be fleshed out in the wording of the new legislation.

Whilst a 6 month ban on any evictions offers a critical life line to tenants, the new measures do not relieve tenants of their obligation to pay rent and outgoings in full during the entire term of the lease, including during the moratorium period.

As a result, if the lease terms are not renegotiated and properly documented by the end of the moratorium period, the new measures will serve to only delay the inevitable (and potentially exacerbate the tenant’s cash flow problems at that time) if it does not pay all unpaid rent in one hit at the end of the moratorium period.

Landlords and banks are effectively being asked to carry the burden of the crisis during the moratorium period.

In light of the above announcement, here are our top tips for both commercial and retail landlord and tenants as well as matters to consider:

Tenants

  1. Seek to renegotiate the terms of your existing lease to include a rent abatement or reduction clause for an agreed period of time, but be careful about what you ask for.

You should ensure you carefully consider what sort of relief you’re asking for as there can be a material difference between a rental abatement, meaning the rent is not payable for a period, and a rental deferral, meaning the rent for a period remains payable, but at a later date. You should also ensure any agreement is properly documented and sets out what happens at the end of any rent abatement or reduction period, or at the end of the statutory moratorium period. A properly drafted lease variation agreement avoids ambiguity and disputes in the future and may be required to be produced to financiers and future assignees of the lease.

  1. Check if your lease has a “force majeure” clause.

A “force majeure” clause operates to exclude liability where a party’s failure to perform its obligations under the contract is caused by unforeseen circumstances. Generally speaking, “force majeure” clauses are not common in lease but if your lease has one, this may be the easiest way to avoid your ongoing obligations under your lease, if doings so is commercially your only option.

  1. No “force majeure” clause – look to the doctrine of frustration.

In the absence of a “force majeure” clause, the common law doctrine of frustration may in limited circumstances be able to be relied upon as basis for terminating the lease. There is an extensive body of law that relates to the doctrine of frustration and the consensus is that it can be difficult to establish.

In the case of COVID-19, however, the orders imposed by the government may prohibit the conduct of the permitted use which may be cause for the lease to be frustrated.

The specific circumstances of each case should be considered and parties should seek advice in relation to whether the lease is frustrated and whether or not termination of the lease is desirable.

Landlords

  1. Carefully consider the impact of any rent abatement or reduction request prior to agreeing to any variation to the lease and consider its impact on your mortgage.

You should ensure any lease variation agreement is properly documented and sets out in clear terms what happens during, and at the end of, any rent abatement or reduction period, or at the end of the statutory moratorium period. Importantly, you should obtain legal advice to ensure you avoid inadvertently waiving your rights under the lease to receive rent and outgoings at the end of the moratorium period on account of any decision you make now (on compassionate or commercial grounds) to not exercise your rights when the tenant is in breach of the lease.

You should also consider the impact of any agreement reached with the tenant has on your mortgage over the premises as any variation to the lease, including a significant rent reduction, may technically trigger a default under your loan if the variation is not consented to by the mortgagee. Although in the current environment financiers are likely to be more flexible around these issues, it is important to remember that the COVID-19 crisis is only temporary and, at some point, lease variations that limit the landlord’s rights or its income entitlements will need to be brought into account, including for valuation purposes.

A properly drafted lease variation agreement avoids ambiguity and disputes in the future and may be required to be produced to financiers and future purchasers of the premises.

  1. Security deposits and further security.

Consider what your leases says about the security deposit and how this can be accessed. Further, if you are considering agreeing to a rent abatement or reduction, think about asking for further security in exchange for grating that relief to protect your right to receive rental after the rental abatement period ends. This could be particularly important if the tenant is placed under any form of external administration in the future. For example, requesting a GSA over the assets of the tenant or a charge over property of the tenant or a guarantor of the tenant. You should obtain legal advice in relation to such security and your rights under it.

  1. Do you want a vacant premises in the face of this epidemic?

Although you may choose to be compassionate towards your tenant’s position and their requests for a rent reduction or abatement in this current environment, you may also be concerned about your personal situation and if you can afford to not have your usual rental income.

Despite the above, it is worth considering whether having a vacant premises in these times, as well as entering into negotiations in an unfavourable market, both now and following the COVID-19 crisis, is wise.

Whether you are a tenant or a landlord, if you are seeking assistance as to how to best proceed in this uncertain environment please contact us on (03) 9614 7707.

Property Team

Commercial & Retail Leases in the COVID-19 Environment – Tips for Tenants & Landlords

Just like many other sectors, retail and commercial tenants and landlords are currently under pressure and desperate to know what their options are in the current COVID-19 crisis.

There have been reports that the Victorian Government will shortly announce the introduction of new legislation relating to rent relief for tenants dealing with the Coronavirus. Unfortunately, nothing has been announced as yet and it is uncertain whether such relief measures will extend to commercial tenants as well as retail and residential tenants, or what those measures will entail.  We will publish another update as soon as we have clarity on any new proposed legislation.

It is important to know that despite any legislative measures that are implemented in the coming days / weeks, both landlords and tenants need to understand the issues emerging in this area.

Here are our top tips for both commercial and retail landlord and tenants as well as matters to consider:

Tenants

  1. Ask your landlord for a rent abatement or reduction, but be careful about what you ask for.

If you don’t ask, you won’t know what your landlord is prepared to offer. You should ensure you carefully consider what you’re asking for as there can be a material difference between a rental abatement, meaning the rent is not payable for a period, and a rental deferral, meaning the rent for a period remains payable, but at a later date. You should ensure any agreement is properly documented and reflects your understanding of what is agreed.

  1. Check if your lease has a “force majeure” clause.
  1. No “force majeure” clause – look to the doctrine of frustration.

In the case of COVID-19, however, the orders imposed by the government may prohibit the conduct of the permitted use which may be cause for the lease to be frustrated.

The specific circumstances of each case should be considered and parties should seek advice in relation to whether the lease is frustrated and whether or not termination of the lease is desirable.

  1. Check your insurance cover.

Landlords

  1. Carefully consider any request for a rent abatement or reduction, but be careful with what you agree to.
  1. Security deposits and further security.
  1. Check your insurance.
  1. Do you want a vacant premises in the face of this epidemic?

Despite the above, it is worth considering whether having a vacant premises in these times as well as entering into negotiations in an unfavourable market both now and following the COVID-19 crisis is wise.

Whether you are a tenant or a landlord, if you are seeking assistance as to how to best proceed in this uncertain environment please contact us on (03) 9614 7707.

Property Team

COVID-19 Newsletter Update

From a legal perspective, the COVID-19 virus has raised substantial questions in relation to a range of issues across multiple sectors of industry.

Some of those issues relate to insurance and the impact on contractual obligations under leases, building contracts, property transactions and supply contracts, cyber-security, employer-employee relations, the privacy of health information and insolvency.

Insurance

In any instance of a commercial problem arising from COVID-19, businesses should be encouraged to check their insurance policies.  The first port of call will be to determine whether the event in question is a matter to which the policy responds, and to then ascertain the extent of cover under that policy.

Some policies offer Business Interruption Insurance, which can cover an insured for reductions in profits and the payment of ongoing costs and expenses for the duration of the interruption. This type of cover can exist either as a standalone policy, or as part of a more general business or office insurance package.

Businesses in the entertainment or promotional industries may have Event Cancellation, Abandonment or Non-appearance Cover as part of a Public Liability and Contingency Package. It’s important to remember that when considering the cancellation of an event, it is vital to communicate with insurer prior to cancellation and obtain prior confirmation that the cancellation is occurring within the terms of the policy.

Any cancellation fees which become payable may be subject to the doctrine of penalties, that is, they may be illegal if they are out of proportion to the loss actually suffered by the relevant party, although this will depend on an assessment of each case at the time that the contract was formed.

Businesses who are dependent on “just in time” supply of goods may have Supply Chain Insurance.

Where logistics are disrupted by closure of ports or air cargo, then Transit Insurance policies will need to be considered to see if the relevant risk is covered and the relevant provisions of any goods contracts to see who bears risk.

Many insurers have since the SARS virus (2004) written in exclusions in insurance policies for pandemics and epidemics related costs.  The rationale behind doing so was in essence the difficulty of assess the extent of the risks going forward. Having said that, the actual wording of each policy should be reviewed.

Section 54 of the Contracts Review Act 1984 (Cth) may also be relevant in this context. The effect of this provision is that some exclusions in insurance policies may not be able to be relied upon by the insurer.

Contracts

The first place to look in relation to the contractual consequences of disruption is the contract itself, and in particular, any force majeure clause.

Force majeure (which literally means superior force) refers to unforeseeable circumstances which prevent someone from fulfilling a contract. Such clauses seek to remove or alleviate risk and liability arising out of natural and unavoidable events which interrupt or make impossible contractual performance.

Even in the absence of any force majeure clause, a contract will be subject to common law doctrines of frustration and impossibility and the statutory amelioration of those doctrines. The basic rule is that unforeseen contingencies which occur after formation of a contract may discharge the parties from further obligations on the grounds that the contract has been frustrated.

Issues that may arise when considering frustration include:

Where a frustrating event is found to have occurred, then it operates to terminate future performance of the contract without requirement of notice.

Previously, at common law, past performance was not affected by a frustrating event, and a party could not recover payments made or goods delivered. That position has been ameliorated by legislation in Victoria, NSW and South Australia (in Victoria, Part 3.2 of the Australian Consumer Law and Fair Trading Act 2012 (Vic)), the general effect of which is that money paid under a frustrated contract may be recoverable and partial performance may be compensable.

Insolvency

The recent extension of the directors penalty regime to GST (commencing 1 April 2020) will be even more reason for directors to be conscious of the financial viability of the business of a company, along with the continuing duty to avoid trading whilst insolvent. The lodgement of GST returns is most important to protect against immediate directors’ personal liability, but even then potential insolvency issues will still remain.

Some companies may be forced to go straight into liquidation as a result of commercial disruption. Others may appoint Administrators with a view to entering into a Deed of Company Arrangement that may provide a better return to creditors than liquidation.

It may be open to certain businesses to seek the protection of the “Safe Harbour” amendments to the Corporations Act (s.588 GA). In essence, Safe Harbour operates as a defence to directors for trading whilst insolvent.  It is not possible for directors to insure against their liability for trading while insolvent, and even if it was, the company could not pay the premiums associated with such insurance. It is, however, very possible for a company to pay the costs of a Safe Harbour program, which can effectively operate as risk management for trading whilst insolvent. This should be of interest to any professional executive directors who are tasked with risk taking to protect shareholder assets.

Over the coming months many businesses will want to negotiate with landlords, creditors and customers about adapting to current business conditions. Safe Harbour can permit directors to be frank about their business without being concerned that they are creating evidence of trading while insolvent that may be used against them

The Safe Harbour regime may come at some expense, and may not be suited to small operators. However, directors of medium sized travel or entertainment based businesses in particular should be looking into entry into such programs now as part of the management of their businesses in such uncertain times.

Conclusion

The COVID-19 virus will pose many issues and challenges in the months ahead. Forward planning and taking appropriate steps to alleviate risk where possible is in our view essential to minimising the impact from a cost and client-retention perspective.

If you have any questions or would like more information about these issues, please don’t hesitate to contact us on (03) 9614 7707.

Corona-virus and the Implications for the Workplace

As coronavirus (COVID-19) continues to spread across the globe, employers are grappling with how best to protect and manage their employees in these very unusual circumstances.

Pointon Partners has the expertise to assist your business as you deal with these difficult  issues against a backdrop of uncertainty.

Listed below are key issues as we see them:

Meeting your Health and Safety Obligations

Your OHS duty as an employer, to protect your employees and actively reduce or eliminate risks to their health and safety should you guide your decision making in relation to the corona-virus outbreak. Regardless of whether or not the government issues orders for people to work from home, by law you are required to assess the potential risk to your employees and act accordingly.

Employers need to conduct a thorough risk assessment now – looking at your workforce activities, the likelihood and consequence of exposure and the steps that can be taken to mitigate or minimise the risks. Employers in high risk industries will need to go further in assessing their policies and the use of protective equipment.

Employers also need to make sure you are stay up to date and informed of the facts relating to the coronavirus. This will require employers to keep abreast of the latest health information provided by the relevant health departments. We recommend checking the following websites daily:

Employees like most people will be concerned about the repercussions of the coronavirus outbreak and we recommend employers keep their staff informed and provide:

Policies on Leave and Flexible Working Conditions

Employers should already have policies in place dealing with leave and how requests for flexible working conditions under the Fair Work Act 2009 (FWA) will be handled. If you don’t have such policies in place please contact Pointon Partners so we can assist you in drafting these policies.

Employers should consider personal leave in the context of the coronavirus outbreak and may wish to amend their existing policies or develop new policies to address whether employees who are required to be isolated or quarantined are entitled to special consideration. Currently the FWA does not have specific rules addressing isolation or quarantine so employers and employees need to come to their own arrangements which may include:

What if an employee wants to stay home as a precaution?

If an employee wants to stay home as a precaution against being exposed to coronavirus they need to make a request in writing to work from home (if possible) or take some form of paid or unpaid leave. Such requests are subject to the normal leave application process in the workplace and will turn on whether the employee has a legitimate concern for his/her safety.

There are a number of circumstances that could make an employee’s concerns legitimate such as the person is most at risk of serious infection as identified by the health department, the employee is following advice issued by the government or a health authority or the employee has raised reasonable concerns which the employer has failed to address.

Subject to any award or agreement that may apply if the employer’s directive to attend work is lawful and reasonable and attending work would not expose the employee to risk, the employer is not required to pay an employee who refuses to attend. The employer also has the option of treating it as a disciplinary matter, again subject to any provisions affecting the employee’s employment. In extreme cases an employee who refuses to attend work could be dismissed but the circumstances of such a situation would need to be carefully reviewed and we would recommend you contact Pointon Partners to discuss before proceeding to terminate employment for this reason.

What if an employer wants their staff to stay at home?

If an employee is at risk of infection from coronavirus for example because the employee has recently travelled to a higher risk or moderate risk country as classified by the Australian government, the employer should request the employee seek medical clearance from a doctor and to work from home (if possible) or not work during the risk period which is currently 14 days.

Where an employer directs a full-time or part-time employee not to work, generally the employee would be entitled to be paid whilst subject to the direction of the employer. Employers also need to consider their obligations under any applicable enterprise agreement, award, contract of employment and workplace policy. Pointon Partners is able to provide guidance and advice in relation to these issues.

What if your employee tests positive to coronavirus and other staff who worked in close proximity need to go into isolation? What if the Federal Government directs all non-essential businesses to close?

Under the FWA an employee can be stood down without pay if they are unable to do useful work because of equipment break down, industrial action or stoppage of work for which the employer cannot be held responsible. Enterprise agreements and employment contracts may include additional regulations about when an employer can stand down an employee without pay. If you are considering utilising the FWA stand down provisions we recommend you contact Pointon Partners to discuss before advising employees.

Conclusion

Employers need to act quickly and proactively to minimise risks to safety as far as is practicable. Employers must keep up to date with fast changing information and provide updates to their employees in a timely manner.  In a highly anxious environment, prudent employers will need to consider how they can support the well-being or their employees. Employers will also need to be mindful to ensure there are no breaches of anti-discrimination laws when putting plans into effect. Employers need to understand that conduct may be unlawful even if it arises from a genuinely held fear by the employer or the employee about the coronavirus outbreak.

Pointon Partners is able to advise and provide guidance on these complex issues. Please contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Ben Drysdale on (03) 9614 7707 with any queries.

AMP Changes to BOLR Policy

We are very aware that the changes to the BOLR Policy announced by AMP on 8 August 2019 have created considerable uncertainty for AMP financial planners.  Those changes consist of reducing the 4x multiple of recurring revenue to 2.5x and also reducing and ultimately phasing out the multiple applicable to grandfathered commissions.

The members of the AMP Financial Planners Association are investigating the prospect of a class action against AMP arising out of the changes to the BOLR Policy.

Our firm is available to provide advice and representation to members of the AMP Financial Planners Association regarding their individual rights against AMP.  This can include instigating mediation with AMP pursuant to the Master Terms and representing the member in such mediation.

In recent weeks we have been in dialogue with the AMP Financial Planners Association concerning the legal position of AMP planners who served their BOLR applications prior to 8 August 2019 but where completion of the purchase of their client registers is still to occur.  We have a view on legal steps that such planners can potentially take to complete the sale of their register rights whilst seeking to preserve their rights to participate in any class action which may be commenced against AMP.  It is not proposed that our firm would itself be involved in the class action.

We are also aware that AMP has been serving notices of termination upon a number of smaller AMP planners as part of its consolidation of the AMP adviser network.  We are available to provide advice to such planners, including assistance in handling the sale of client registers either to another AMP planning firm or a financial planning firm outside the AMP network.

By way of background, we are a commercial law firm with offices in Melbourne and Sydney but are available to provide advice to AMP planners wherever they may be located within Australia.  We have extensive experience over the last ten years in acting for AMP planners.  This has included acting for AMP planners in sale or purchase of client registers and also in BOLR transactions with AMP. We have also acted directly for the AMP Financial Planners Association from time to time over the last five years.

If any members of the Association do need any advice or assistance please feel free to contact Michael Bishop or Andrew Cox of Pointon Partners for a confidential discussion.