Pointon Partners

Blind Siding Amendment – Significant Property Developer Stamp Duty Amendment in Victoria

Almost all Victorian development agreements could soon create a stamp duty liability.

Any sharing of profit by a landowner with a property developer who does not own the land in proportion to the profit entitlement could be assessable to stamp duty.

In what may be described as a blind siding amendment to the current stamp duty law applying to what are quite standard property development agreements in Victoria, the Victorian Government has introduced a major amendment to the Victorian Duties Act 2000 in the State Taxation Amendment Bill 2019.

This amendment was not announced by the Treasurer nor highlighted in the recent Victorian budget and yet it is arguably the most significant amendment to the Duties Act.

The law currently allows for a property developer to be entitled to up to 50% of the profit above costs of a property development without having to pay stamp duty where the property development structure does not involve the transfer of the property to the developer but to remain with the original joint venture land owner.

This is the standard property development arrangement in Victoria – the original land owner is quite normally entitled to 50% or more of the profit and the remaining share would be with the experienced property developer.

The Bill introduced into Parliament will assess any party receiving an entitlement to profit who is not a landowner or receives more profit than their ownership proportion of the land.

If you wish to discuss the ramifications of this amendment or have any other State Revenue query, please contact Tony Pointon or one of our experienced State Revenue team.

Unexpected Trap when borrowing from an overseas lender for Second Hand Property

Be Wary if you are borrowing money from an overseas entity to purchase an investment property which is not in the usual business of lending money.

If you are an Australian citizen and resident of Australia for tax purposes and you are purchasing an investment property (which is not a new dwelling), and are borrowing a substantial proportion of the purchase price from a foreign entity or foreign source which is not ADI (i.e. authorised deposit‑taking institution) or a subsidiary of an ADI, you may have issues with the Foreign Investment Review Board (FIRB).

You would be purchasing what is referred to as “second-hand property” and not a new dwelling and in order for the overseas entity lending the money to obtain FIRB approval for a mortgage securing the loan, one of the following options needs to apply:

  1. The Purchaser will use the Property as their principal place of residence;
  2. The Purchaser will re-develop the Property;
  3. The Purchaser will use the Property for staff accommodation.

The FIRB will not give approval if you are buying second-hand property which you intend to use as an investment property.

The situation would be different if you were buying a new dwelling.

If you are intending to buy the second hand property with overseas funding you would need to obtain FIRB approval and you would ideally include a clause in your purchase contract, your proposed purchase would need to have a conditional clause so that your obligation to purchase the Property would be subject to obtaining the FIRB approval.

Lenders taking security over residential land

There are specific additional tests for a foreign lender which is not a foreign government investor nor an ADI (i.e. authorised deposit‑taking institution) (or a subsidiary of an ADI) when taking security over residential land. If a non-ADI foreign lender, which is not a foreign government investor, wishes to take a security interest (i.e. mortgage) over residential land the moneylending exemption will only apply if the lender (or its holding entity) is otherwise licensed as a financial institution (whether or not in Australia) and either has at least 100 holders of its securities or is listed on a stock exchange (whether or not in Australia). The exemption is meant to apply to a moneylender which is in effectively in the business of lending money.

Use of Other Persons To Purchase Residential Real Estate

Under Australia’s foreign investment framework, Australian citizens, permanent residents, exempt foreign persons, and foreign persons who are eligible for approval may be subject to strict penalties if purchasing a dwelling on behalf of, or for the benefit of, a foreign person (including family members) who has either:

The foreign person on behalf of who an interest is acquired may also have breached the rules and be subject to penalties. An interest in residential real estate is defined broadly to include any legal or equitable interest in the land, including when a person has any right to have the interest transferred to himself or herself, and despite the manner in which the interest arose.

If a proposed Mortgagee for a purchase is a foreign person for the purposes of the Foreign Acquisitions and Takeovers Act 1975 (Cth) and as there is a security interest under real property mortgage to the foreign person, you are required to obtain FIRB approval notwithstanding that you, as an Australian citizen, are requiring the legal and equitable interest in the property.

Strict penalties (including civil and criminal penalties) may apply for breaches of Australia’s foreign investment framework.

Cases of non-compliance with Australia’s foreign investment framework may also be brought to the attention of law enforcement agencies and other Commonwealth departments such as the Department of Immigration and Border Protection.

Per: Simon Della Marta
Pointon Partners Sydney

The sun is setting on delay tactics adopted by property developers in off the plan sales

Property developers engineering development delays and relying on developer friendly “sunset clauses” in off the plan contracts of sale contracts (OTP Contracts) to terminate those contracts and re-sell for higher prices are being targeted by the Andrews Labor Government through proposed new legislation.

The Sale of Land Amendment Bill 2018 provides that OTP Contracts will no longer be able to be terminated by a vendor under an OTP Contract unless the purchaser consents or ordered by the Supreme Court of Victoria. Interestingly, the amending legislation, if passed, will apply retrospectively from 23 August 2018 and will affect all OTP Contracts on foot on that day.

Sunset clauses in OTP Contracts generally allow the vendor to terminate an OTP Contract after the sunset date, being a specified date by which the development must be completed. This is usually up to 5 years after the contract is signed.

Whilst any such termination entitles the purchaser to the return of their deposit, the purchaser may have lost the opportunity to buy elsewhere during the contract period, and the vendor is then entitled to re-sell that property for a higher price if it has increased in value since the original  contract date.

Under the proposed legislation, the vendor will now be required to provide at least 28 days’ written notice to the purchaser and obtain the purchaser’s consent, before the OTP Contract can be terminated in accordance with a sunset clause.

It is proposed that the notice provided by vendor developers will need to include, for example:

  1. the reason why the vendor developer proposes to end the OTP Contract;
  2. the reason for the delay by the vendor developer in registering the POS;
  3. that the purchaser is not obliged to provide its consent.

If the vendor cannot obtain the purchaser’s consent to terminate the contract, it will require an order from the Supreme Court to do so. The Supreme Court must grant the order only if it decides that it is just and equitable in the circumstances.

We will continue to follow the passage of the Bill and keep you updated as things unfold.

Please contact us if you wish to discuss further.

Assignment of lease of commercial premises: To consent or not to consent … That is the question, if you’re a landlord

A recent VCAT decision narrows the circumstances in which a landlord can withhold consent to an assignment of lease.

This case, AVC Operations Pty Ltd v Teley Pty Ltd (Building and Property) [2018] VCAT 931, concerned a landlord’s decision to withhold consent to an assignment of lease under s 60 of the Retail Leases Act 2003, based on the financial circumstances of the proposed assignee, for licenced premises located in Toorak.

Background

The tenant wanted to sell the business and assign the lease for a pub known as the Bush Inn Hotel.

Guarantees from each director and a company (Wheatland Hotels Pty Ltd) associated with the proposed assignee were offered to the landlord, together with a security deposit representing nine months’ rent.

The lease was covered by the Retail Leases Act 2003, which governs certain types of commercial leases. Section 60 of that Act allows a landlord to withhold consent to an assignment of lease in certain circumstances, including on the basis of the financial position or business experience of a proposed assignee.

Despite numerous requests from the tenant to the landlord, consent to the assignment was not granted.

Consequently, the tenant applied to VCAT for an order that the landlord was not entitled to withhold consent.

The submissions

The landlord contended that it had not been provided with sufficient information to be reasonably satisfied that the assignee had the financial resources to meet the obligations under the lease.

Indeed, no financial documentation could be provided to the landlord for the assignee entity (Wheatland Hotels Toorak Pty Ltd), as it had been established for the specific purpose of acquiring the inn and, as such, had no trading history.

Financial information was instead provided in relation to Wheatland Hotels Pty Ltd, a pub in Armadale owned by that other company, and the assignee’s directors.

This information did not satisfy the landlord, however, having formed the view that the value of Wheatland Hotels Pty Ltd was not significant, and because the directors had no personal assets. Further, the assignee required $500,000 in funding to develop the pub in accordance with its business plan.

Against the landlord’s arguments, the tenant claimed that there was “abundant” information provided to the landlord that indicated the assignee had the financial resources or backing to meet its obligations under the lease, including a spreadsheet and a business plan purporting to show an anticipated increase in net profit of the inn following its acquisition by the assignee.

VCAT: Tenant could assign the lease

According to VCAT, it was not reasonable for the landlord to withhold consent to the assignment.

It reaching its decision, the Tribunal considered it relevant that the individuals behind the assignee entity were experienced and capable publicans. This was apparently demonstrated by the fact that other company they controlled had improved its gross profit in the previous year. This was said to lend credence to the projected revenue set out in their business plan for the Toorak inn.

The Tribunal also placed weight on the security deposit that was offered to the landlord, which was particularly relevant in light of the fact the current lease term was to end in three and a half years, as well as on the guarantees provided to the landlord. Curiously, in making this finding, it stated that it could not overlook the personal guarantees offered by the directors merely because they had no personal assets.

Takeaway

The case shows that landlords have a high hurdle to overcome to be able to refuse consent to an assignment of a lease. In particular, the financial backing and business experience of the people or entities behind an assignee, irrespective of the current value of the assets of those entities or individuals, must also be considered by a landlord when deciding whether to allow an assignment of lease.

Victoria’s real estate industry thrown into chaos after Court denies estate agent’s right to receive commission – Floodgates open for claims by vendors/developers seeking to recover commission paid

A recent decision of the Victorian Court of Appeal in Advisory Services Pty Ltd (trading as Ray White St. Albans) v Augustin & Anor [2018] VSCA 95 (Advisory Services) is sure to strike fear in the heart of estate agents, particularly those acting for developers.

The decision of Victoria’s highest court has confirmed that strict compliance with the requirements of the Estate Agents Act 1980 (the Act) is necessary for an agent to be entitled to sue for, recover or retain commission.

Facts

The facts in Advisory Services were relatively simple and may be summarised as follows:

  1. The applicants ran a Ray White franchise and were engaged by the respondent land owners to sell property in Keysborough.
  2. The agents found a buyer, but that buyer failed to settle. The agent then found a second buyer who completed the sale. The agents then sought to recover two commissions from the land owners.
  3. The landowners refused to pay the commissions on the basis that the agent’s sale authority did not contain the necessary rebate statement as required by the various sections set out in Part IV of the Act, notwithstanding that the authority clearly stated that the agent was not entitled to any rebate and was an industry standard authority.
  4. Specifically, the authority did not contain the exact words required by section 49A(4)(c) of the Act.
  5. At first instance, the County Court found for the landowners, holding that by virtue of the non-compliance with the strict provisions of the Act, the estate agent was not entitled to be paid its commission.
  6. The decision was upheld on appeal, who found that it was the clear intent of parliament that a correctly worded rebate statement must be included in every sales authority, before an agent is entitled to sue for, recover, and most importantly for developers, retain commission.

What does it mean?

While the decision is potentially harsh on estate agents, it is a boon for developers who in many cases will have paid significant commissions to agents over many years.

It means that not only can developers, or anyone else for that matter, avoid paying commission to agents where the agent’s sales authority is defective, it means that commission previously paid under a defective authority can be actively recovered from an agent.

How can Pointon Partners help?

Pointon Partners can review existing authorities and advise whether commission is:

Once we form the view that commission is recoverable, we can take efficient and cost effective action to obtain orders requiring such commissions be repaid.

Pointon Partners have significant experience in similar claims, and are aware of other matters which may entitle a party to either refuse to pay or recover commission, including:

We cannot emphasise enough how important this decision is for the real estate industry and expect that many estate agents who have been using non-compliant authorities, or are otherwise in breach of the Act will seek to restructure their businesses to wind down the entities exposed to claims for recovery of commissions.

Industry groups have also called on parliament to amend the legislation to prevent the recovery of such commissions.

A licensed estate agent is required, pursuant to section 98(3) of the Act, to retain the authority for a period of 7 years.

Any claim to recover commission will be statute barred after 6 years.

We can also act for you in defending any claim brought by your agent for the recovery of commissions that are not properly payable.

Estate Agents

Pointon Partners can assist estate agents or their stakeholders by reviewing the form of authorities or agency agreements they use to ensure they are compliant with the Act. Given recently identified deficiencies in certain REIV authorities, Pointon Partners can also assist with preparing new authorities or agency agreements that comply with the Act and protect estate agents’ interests. We can also advise on restructuring options that may be available.

Please contact Carl Millington with any query.

Don’t get caught out – Be aware of what constitutes a “terms contract” when selling an interest in land

When parties negotiate settlement terms of a contract of sale of real estate, particularly when it is a long term settlement, they can inadvertently structure the terms of the transaction in a way where the contract is deemed to be a ‘terms contract’ under the Sale of Land Act 1962 (the Act).

This can have adverse consequences, including giving a purchaser a right to avoid the contract prior to settlement or giving the purchaser a right to require the vendor to transfer the title to the purchaser at any time prior to settlement in exchange for a mortgage back to the vendor for the remaining outstanding funds.

What is a ‘terms contract’ 

A ‘terms contract’ arises where a purchaser is either:

Implications if a contract is deemed to be a ‘terms contract’

There are serious implications for both vendors and purchasers under a ‘terms contract’. Such implications include the following:

How to prevent unintentionally entering into a ‘terms contract’

To avoid inadvertently entering into a ‘terms contract’, it is crucial that parties are familiar with the limitations imposed on them by the Act in terms of how many payment instalments are permitted before the contract is deemed a ‘terms contract’, and any deal is structured accordingly.

We also find that special conditions which provide a purchaser with access rights to the property prior to settlement, if not worded properly, can constitute the purchaser taking possession or having occupation of the property in a way which renders the contract  a ‘terms contract’. Access rights for a purchaser during a long settlement is common and often an essential aspect of the deal.

If a terms contract cannot be avoided, then care should be taken with the drafting of the contract to ensure it complies with the Act so that the contract does not become voidable.

Finally, legal advice from a firm with experience in dealing with terms contracts should be sought prior to the signing of any contract.

If you have any queries or question relating to the above, do not hesitate to contact our property team.

What is “Protection Work” under the Building Act 1993 (Vic)?

For the uninitiated, being served with a Form 3 “Protection Work Notice” can be confusing. We have endeavoured to provide a short explanation of what “Protection work” actually is, and the process involved.

Building Permit

If a building permit is required, then before it is granted, one of the things that the Relevant Building Surveyor (RBS) must consider is whether the work could adversely impact adjoining owners.

If the RBS considers that it will, they must require that the owner of the development site (the developer) protect the adjoining owner’s property in some way. This work is “protection work”.

The Process

The process involves:

If there is disagreement, the RBS then makes a decision as to what is appropriate. If either party is unhappy with the decision, they can appeal to the Building Appeals Board (BAB).

Once the “protection work” is either agreed upon, or finally determined (whether by the RBS or BAB), the work must be undertaken before the developer can proceed with the building work (unless the developer decides it is too expensive, in which case he can start the whole process again, as explained by Digby J in Colonial Range v CES-Queen [2017] VSC 317). However, for the adjoining owner, they are bound by the decision and must allow the “protection work” to be done, and for example, it is an offence to refuse access (section 96 Building Act).

If damage, inconvenience, or loss occurs to their property either during, or in connection with the protection work, they are entitled to compensation (sections 98 and 159 Building Act).

So, what’s the problem?

The problem is that the concept of “protection work” is not necessarily intuitive, and very much depends on the individual circumstances of the build. The VBA practice note is helpful, though at 21 pages, isn’t quite to the point.

It is our opinion that any work that:

is protection work.

Thus, protection work can include excavation and work that would otherwise be considered “building work” if it is done in a way so as to protect the adjoining property. A good example of this is “hit and miss” excavation. There might be no underpinning of the adjoining property’s footings, and no barriers or propping required, but in light of the work method employed, the excavation itself is “protection work”.

The takeaway is that clear communication between the adjoining owner, developer and building surveyor is key to identifying what is actually occurring and why.

If you would like to discuss the information above further, please contact Matthew Francke or Carl Millington of our office on (03) 9614 7707.

Neighbourhood Tree Disputes

Written submissions to the VLRC inquiry into neighbourhood tree disputes closed on 28 February 2018. Practitioners in this area will await the outcome of the inquiry with bated breath.

In the interim, the consultation paper prepared by the Commission contains an impressive recap of the present law, although it will be unsatisfying for the average punter looking for a short summary (the paper is 156 pages).

In the Commission’s own words:

3.227 In Victoria, neighbours involved in a tree dispute must rely on disparate information sources published by government and community organisations to navigate the fragmented resolution process for themselves.

3.228 Neighbours unwilling or unable to reach agreement informally have little structure or support to assist them, and conflicts may escalate quickly.

3.229 If formal mediation is sought, neighbours will be provided with more information, but their rights and responsibilities may still not be clear, as the current law in Victoria, based on the common law, is difficult to understand and not clearly articulated in a single, accessible location or document. Further, agreements made in DSCV-led mediation are not necessarily binding, and may not finally resolve a dispute.

3.230 Only when a common law action is brought in the courts are neighbours then subject to binding orders. The outcomes may still not be what either party had expected or hoped for, and the remedies are limited.

The full list of submissions made to the Commission can viewed here.

New GST Rules Affecting Property Transactions – ATO cracking down on developers who avoid paying GST

How these new obligations will affect both developers and purchasers

Treasury has released draft legislation which proposes a new process for the remittance of GST to the ATO for property transactions that relate to the supply of “new residential premises”.

Why the Changes

The purpose of these new rules is to shift the obligation to remit GST from developers onto purchasers to alleviate the ATO’s concerns with developers liquidating their companies prior to remitting their GST on sales.

Summary of Withholding Obligations for Purchasers

Summary of Notification Obligations for Developers

Refund Mechanism and Tax Credits for Developers

When the New Regime Takes Effect

If the legislation is passed, these new withholding obligations will likely apply to contracts settling on or after 1 July 2018.

A transitional period is likely to be implemented.

Our firm will continue to keep our clients updated with any further developments.

In the meantime, for further information on how the above may affect you or your business, please contact us.

The widening definition of “Retail Premises”: Is your commercial lease affected?

The Supreme Court of Victoria’s recent decision in IMCC Group (Australia) Pty Ltd v CB Cold Storage [2017] VSCA 178 has confirmed that a wide interpretation of ‘retail premises’ should be used for the purposes of the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) (Act).  This included a finding that ‘the ultimate consumer test can be satisfied by either commercial or non-commercial consumers’[1] – i.e. in relation to business to business services, as well as business to private customer.

This decision could have major implications for both landlords and tenants under existing and future leases, by bringing such leases within the regulation and scope of the Act.

The facts

Cold Storage (the tenant) operated a cool storage business using freezer warehouses and related facilities which were built on the premises.[2]

The customers of Cold Storage paid fees to store their dairy products, seafood, small goods and the like.[3] In addition, Cold Storage provided ancillary services such as loading and unloading of pallets into the warehouses and arranging the transportation of products to and from the warehouses.[4]

The usual customers of Cold Storage were companies involved in the food industry.[5]

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal and found that the premises were retail premises for the purpose of the Act.[6] The Supreme Court applied the ‘ultimate consumer’ test and determined that the ‘ultimate consumer’ does not necessarily to have to be a person, but can be a business which uses services for a business purpose.[7]

What does this mean?

If your premises are deemed to be retail premises for the purposes of the Act, the Act will deem that certain potentially onerous provisions apply in relation to the lease of that premises, despite any term in the lease to the contrary, including that:

These provisions demonstrate the risk for landlords who do not correctly identify retail premises leases, and set terms accordingly.

Let’s revisit the definition of retail premises

A retail premises as defined by section 4(1)(a) of the Act is a ‘premises, not including any area intended for use as a residence, that under the terms of the lease relating to the premises are used, or are to be used, wholly or predominantly for the sale or hire of goods by retail or the retail provisions of services’.[12]

Under the Act the time to determine if the premises are retail premises is at the time the lease is entered into or renewed.[13]

How to determine if the premises are retail

The Act does not prescribe a checklist of premises that are considered to be retail. In some circumstances it will be easy to classify your premises as a retail premises for the purpose of the Act, with some obvious examples being premises used as a clothes shop, a hairdresser or a café.

However, it can often be difficult for parties to determine if the premises is a retail premises where the tenant provides services, including if services are provided on a business to business basis.  Prudence must be exercised in such circumstances, in particular by landlords.

Reasons for findings in the Cold Storage Case

The Supreme Court concluded that the premises was a retail premises as:

It was noted by the Supreme Court that in isolation none of the above features would ‘suffice to constitute the premises as retail premises’ but the ‘absence of one or more of them, would not necessarily result in a finding that the premises were not retail premises’.[15]

The Supreme Court of Victoria stated that ‘the phrase ‘retail provision of services’ has long been interpreted by reference (at least in part) to an ultimate consumer test; that is, are the services used by the person to whom they are sold or are the services passed on by the purchaser in an unaltered state to some third person?’.[16]

Therefore, it is clear that the ultimate consumer test can be satisfied by either commercial or private consumers as ‘no distinction has been drawn between commercial and non-commercial users of the service’.[17]

Lesson

  1. When determining whether a premises are a retail, special consideration to the ultimate consumer test needs to be given; and
  2. Landlords in particular should err on the side of caution, and consider setting commercial terms which are consistent with the Act, to minimise the risk exposure should a lease be found to be retail and
  3. Proper legal advice should be sought during the negotiations of the terms of the lease and in relation to the management or prevention of claims arising during or after the life of the lease.

If you have any queries relating to retail premises or leases generally, please contact Jess Tomlinson on (03) 9614 7707.

[1] IMCC Group (Australia) Pty Ltd v CB Cold Storage [2017] VSCA 178, 44.

[2] Ibid, 1.

[3] Ibid.

[4] Ibid.

[5] Ibid.

[6] Ibid, 50-1.

[7] Ibid 44.

[8] Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) s 50.

[9] Richmond Football Club Limited v Verraty Pty Ltd [2011] VCAT 2104.

[10] Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) s 21(1).

[11] Ibid s 51.

[12] Ibid s 4(1)(a).

[13] Ibid s 11(2).

[14] IMCC Group (Australia) Pty Ltd v CB Cold Storage Pty Ltd [2017] VSCA 178, 50/

[15] Ibid.

[16] Ibid 3.

[17] Ibid 3, 44.