Misleading and Deceptive Conduct and Misrepresentations Induced Investments into Failed Companies: Investors Recover from Former Directors
In an application before the Federal Court, investors in a failed group of companies have recovered their lost money from the group’s former directors directly. The Court held that the directors’ misleading and deceptive conduct induced the investments and awarded damages in respect of the misrepresentations made.
Background
The two personal respondents in RRG Nominees Pty Ltd v Visible Temporary Fencing Australia Pty Ltd (No 4) [2019] FCA 686 (‘RRG’) were the directors of a business which was established to on-hire temporary fencing of the kind commonly found at construction sites, entertainment venues and the like.
The father and daughter duo had no previous experience in hiring out fencing panels, but over the course of several years established separate companies in every state and territory of Australia barring the ACT.
The respondents enticed a group of investors to finance their operations through a series of predominantly oral representations about the future prospects of the business, including statements that fencing supply contracts had been entered into with Rio Tinto, the organisers of the Melbourne Grand Prix and VicRoads.
Misleading and deceptive conduct
The applicants claimed that the respondents had breached section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law (‘ACL’) and section 1041H of the Corporations Act.
Section 18 of the ACL provides:
A person must not, in trade or commerce, engage in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive.
The applicants alleged that the representations concerned future matters and relied on section 4 of the ACL, which provides that such representations are taken to be misleading unless the person making the representation can demonstrate there are reasonable grounds for making it.
Section 1041H of the Corporations Act provides:
A person must not, in this jurisdiction, engage in conduct, in relation to a financial product or a financial service, that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive.
The term ‘financial product’ is defined in s 763A to include the shares in a company. The applicants alleged that 10 of the 15 representations pursued at trial were made in relation to shares.
The misrepresentations and loss of investments
In simple terms, the applicants in RRG needed to prove:
- the alleged misleading or deceptive conduct had actually occurred;
- they had suffered loss; and
- the misleading or deceptive conduct had caused the investment and therefore the loss.
The Court was satisfied that most of the misrepresentations pleaded had actually occurred and that they were made in the course of trade or commerce. The contemporaneous file notes made by one of the applicants of his meetings and discussions with the respondents were crucial in this regard.
As the companies’ businesses had failed and were effectively worthless, the applicants were taken to have wholly lost the sum of their investments, barring a small amount that liquidators anticipated paying out as a dividend.
The Court found that the applicants had relied on the misleading or deceptive conduct and that there was a sufficient causal connection between the loss claimed and the applicants’ reliance on the misleading conduct.
Misrepresentations made to experienced investors
The respondents argued that the applicants were experienced in business and were aware that an investment into a start-up company was highly speculative and risky. Although the Court accepted this premise, the argument failed for several reasons:
- even experienced business people can be misled by misrepresentations, especially in the context of a niche market where the representor claims specialist knowledge; and
- there is no requirement that an applicant’s reliance upon misleading or deceptive conduct be reasonable.
In finding for the applicants, the Court noted that the case would also have succeeded under the tort of deceit, had this been necessary.
Lessons for investors and directors
Prospective investors should carefully assess and record any representations made to them when considering investment proposals. Although the investors in RRG succeeded at trial, thorough due diligence may have prevented the loss altogether.
Company directors seeking to raise capital must be aware that they may be personally liable for claims of misleading and deceptive conduct if a person invests into their company based on material omissions, inaccuracies or errors in information that they provide.
Pointon Partners can assist with misleading and deceptive conduct claims and related litigation.
Please contact Nick McCarthy , Carl Millington or Ben Drysdale to discuss.
Telco’s go head to head in advertising tussle: Telstra Corporation Ltd v Singtel Optus Ltd [2018] VSC 247
Pointon Partners are regularly asked to advise clients as to their prospects of obtaining an urgent interlocutory injunction.
Common examples include:
- preventing a competitor from publishing misleading advertising material;
- preventing former employees or contractors from disclosing sensitive confidential information to competitors or to the market at large; and
- preventing disgruntled contractors from attending business premises and removing items supplied by them.
A recent judgment of the Supreme Court of Victoria helpfully summarises the applicable principles which must be considered by the Court in exercising its discretion to grant such an injunction.
The facts
A recent report published by a global telecommunications consultancy stated that after exhaustive testing, Optus had achieved the highest score of all mobile networks in Australia.
The consultancy scored each provider out of 1000, and Optus’ score was 3 points higher than Telstra’s.
Optus subsequently published an advertisement which depicted a phone box, bearing a close resemblance to the previously common Telstra boxes, abandoned in the desert with the copy:
‘Empires End: That’s what they do’
The Optus network has been ranked best overall in voice and data.
By P3 Mobile Benchmark, Dec 2017”
Telstra formed the view that the advertising was misleading and deceptive in that it represented to the observer that:
- there had been a significant and permanent change in the relationship between the Telstra and Optus mobile networks; and
- Optus is now the undisputedly operating a better mobile network than Telstra.
After requests to Optus to pull the advertising were refused, Telstra sought an urgent interlocutory injunction requiring Optus to cease using the advertising or other similar advertisements.
The relevant test
The Court held that in order to obtain the injunction it sought, Telstra had to show:
- that there was a serious question to be tried;
- that it would suffer irreparable injury, for which an award of damages would not be adequate compensation, if the injunction were not granted; and
- that the ‘balance of convenience’ favours the granting of an injunction until the dispute is finally determined.
Element 1 – Serious question to be tried
To determine whether this element was satisfied the Court considered two preliminary questions:
- Would it be open for the Court to find, on the evidence, that the representation alleged by Telstra is conveyed in the advertisement; and
- If yes, is it arguable that representation misleading or deceptive?
In this case, the Court answered both questions in the affirmative, placing significant reliance on the fact that the report cited by Optus described the competing providers as in a ‘neck-and-neck’ race, which was inconsistent with the messaging in the relevant advertisement.
Element 2 – Irreparable Injury for which damages not appropriate
Telstra led evidence that the advertisement was having a significant impact on its customers, and that it was difficult to forecast how many of its customers had switched to Optus, or away from Telstra, as a result of the advertisement.
The Court found that the difficulty in establishing how many customers had left or would leave Telstra meant that damages would be difficult to quantify which, in turn, supporting a conclusion that Telstra would suffer irreparable injury not capable of remedy by damages.
Element 3 – The Balance of Convenience
The Court noted that if the injunction was granted, and Optus ordered to remove the advertising, then Optus will have suffered the expense and inconvenience associated with taking down the advertisement. Optus would also have been deprived of the positive effect of the advertising in the period between the injunction being granted and the dispute being finally determined. Telstra on the other hand faced the prospect of potentially losing customers to Optus.
In weighing up the parties’ respective positions, the Court noted the importance of what is known as an ‘undertaking as to damages’ which is a promise by the party applying for the injunction to pay compensation if they are unsuccessful at final hearing.
The Court found that while there was difficulty in quantifying any damages payable to Optus, the balance of convenience favoured the granting of the interlocutory injunction.
PS: At final hearing Optus was successful, with the Court ultimate finding that the advertising did not convey the representations pleaded by Telstra and was permitted to continue using the impugned advertising. A copy of the relevant final judgment is available for reading here.
If you require any further information regarding interlocutory of final injunctions, please contact Carl Millington of our office on 9614 7707.
An update from our Mediators – 5 reasons why Mediation is good for business
Did you know that Pointon Partners offers mediation as a cost effective dispute resolution service to enable your clients to get back to business?
Mediation can be organised at any time – you don’t need to be involved in Court proceedings, you just need to agree with the other party to the dispute to try the process, and engage a mediator.
Pointon Partners offer the services of two qualified mediators – Brigid O’Dwyer and Andrew Cox.
Why Mediate?
As much as most people would prefer to maintain harmonious business relationships, and operate on a purely good faith basis, it is inevitable that disputes crop up from time to time in many commercial dealings. How these disputes are dealt with can make a huge difference to their impact and outcome.
Litigation is a notoriously expensive process. Even more detrimental, in particular for a small business, can be the hidden cost of director and staff time. Being involved in a Court case can take up significant time and money which could otherwise be spent profitably. And that’s if you win! A worst case scenario of losing a case and being ordered to pay the other party’s claim, as well as interest and costs, could be disastrous.
One way to keep disputes to a minimum is to invest in and adhere to clear procedural documentation, including terms of engagement, credit management and quality control. Another is to act early when things go wrong, and not wait for a dispute to escalate.
One of the most popular and widely used forms of alternative dispute resolution is mediation.
What is Mediation?
Mediation is a process whereby settlement negotiations are facilitated by a neutral and impartial third party. A mediator is not a judge, and does not make any decision about the merits of each party’s claim. The mediator’s job is to assist the parties in highlighting areas of agreement, clarifying the issues in dispute, sticking to a process and staying focussed, exploring various options for settling a dispute, and working towards a resolution that everyone can live with.
Mediation is a confidential process –things said at mediation can’t be used against a party in Court, which can encourage people to be frank and honest with each other when looking for possible solutions.
It is also a flexible process. Mediations can be attended just by the people involved in the dispute, or with the assistance of lawyers. It can occur as part of the litigation process, or can be instigated by the parties prior to any litigation. The parties choose where and when to mediate. If an agreement is reached, the parties usually sign up to terms of settlement on the day recording their deal. Terms of settlement are legally binding as a contract, except in exceptional circumstances, so it can pay to have your lawyer attend mediation with you to give you advice along the way, and before you sign.
Mediators don’t give you legal advice – their job is to oversee the process, not dictate the outcome.
Mediation vs Litigation:
Some of the reasons it is a good idea to mediate rather than litigate are:
- To keep ownership of the outcome: One reason people choose to run their own business is to avoid being told what to do. Mediation helps keep this alive – the alternative, if a dispute is litigated, is to ultimately have to comply with an order handed down by a Magistrate, Judge or VCAT Member, who will generally have to make a decision which goes against one party. A mediated outcome gives you a level of control, and certainty at an early stage, avoiding the stress and risk inherent in litigation.
- To find a solution which works for you and your business: Third party adjudicators, such as Magistrates, naturally won’t have the same knowledge about the business, and the industry, as the parties to the dispute. A good mediator can help the parties use this knowledge to come up with solutions ‘outside the box’ that are sustainable and mutually beneficial in the long term.
- To maintain an ongoing commercial relationship: Statistics and common sense show that an ongoing commercial relationship is more likely to be preserved if parties are able to settle disputes by agreement, rather than fight their battles out in Court. Utilising the mediation process to resolve disputes, particularly at an early stage, can keep valuable relationships on foot, to the benefit of everyone involved. This is particularly the case for business disputes involving families.
- To save precious time and tens of thousands of dollars: Mediation is usually a very quick process to organise, especially in contrast to the delays which are notorious in Court proceedings. And although mediator fees are comparable to lawyer’s fees (many mediators are lawyers), the expenses of mediation, including the costs of your own lawyer, will in almost every case be dwarfed if compared to the ongoing cost of briefing lawyers, and spending time away from your business, throughout months, if not years, of litigation.
- Because you have to: At some point in time in almost every jurisdiction in Australia, mediation is a mandatory step before a matter can proceed to trial. By that point, both parties will usually have spent thousands of dollars in legal costs, if not tens of thousands, even in relatively minor disputes. This obviously has an impact on the bottom line for settlement negotiations, and reduces the chances of salvaging any commercial relationship. So why not mediate early?
The benefits of early mediation have been recognised in legislation – in certain disputes the law now requires that mediation must be attempted before proceedings can even be commenced. For example, in most retail landlord/tenant disputes in Victoria, a certificate from the Office of the Victorian Small Business Commissioner (OVSBC) stating that mediation has failed must be obtained before proceedings can be issued.
Both Brigid and Andrew have completed extensive mediator training, in addition to their many years of experience as commercial litigation lawyers (more than five decades between them!).
Brigid holds national accreditation under the National Mediation Accreditation System, and is a member of the panel of mediators at the OVSBC.
Although the requirement for impartiality would preclude Brigid or Andrew from acting as mediator in any disputes to which Pointon Partners’ clients are parties, we welcome referrals and enquiries in respect of any new matters, and would be pleased to answer queries you or your clients may have regarding the mediation process.
If you would like to discuss this article further, please contact Andrew Cox on (03) 9614 7707.
Does your business use owner-drivers? If so, make sure your business is complying
Do you engage owner-drivers in your business? If so, you should be aware of the Victorian Government’s owner-driver legislative scheme, which comprises:
- Owner Drivers and Forestry Contractors Act 2005 (the Act)
- Owner Drivers and Forestry Regulations 2006 (Regulations)
- Owner Drivers and Forestry Contractors Code of Practice (Code of Practice)
Why?
The Act was enacted in an effort to better protect small businesses, usually owner drivers, which are prominent in the road-transport industry. Evidence was put before the Victorian Parliament that owner drivers were working longer hours for less money, which was linked to long hours of work, increased fatigue, increased propensity to speed and breaches of other road rules.
The Act seeks to arm owner-drivers with useful information to assist them in their business. It imposes minimum requirements on person’s engaging owner-drivers, alternative dispute resolution pathways, including the use of the Small Business Commissioner and the conferral of jurisdiction on the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal) to deal with disputes.
Who is an owner-driver?
Generally, an owner-driver can be a person, company or partnership who provides services in transporting goods in a vehicle (up to 3) owned by them.
If you contract with an owner-driver to transport your goods, this is generally considered to be a ‘regulated contract’ under the Act. You should be aware that a contract is not always in writing. It can be partly oral, partly in writing or a combination of both. Generally, the engagement of an owner-driver to provide transport services for payment, and their acceptance of that offer, constitutes a contract. Regulated contracts are required to be in writing and therefore any oral agreement should be reduced to writing.
What to do before entering into a ‘regulated contract’
If you intend to engage an owner-driver for a period of more than 30 days, at least 3 business days before you engage that person, you are required to give the owner-driver:
- an information booklet a copy of the most recently published rates and costs schedule applicable to the owner-driver and the class of vehicle: Note: you are also required to give the owner-driver a copy of the revised schedule if it changes throughout their engagement.
- As a matter of best practice, you should also provide the owner-driver with a copy of the proposed contract. Given that this would be a ‘regulated contract’ under the Act, you should ensure that it complies with the following:
- Is in writing
- States the guaranteed minimum number of hours of work or income level that the owner-drive will receive
- Sets out the rates to be paid to the owner-driver
- Sets out the minimum period of notice of termination or payment in lieu of notice, which is regulated by the Act
Negotiating an owner-driver contract
In conducting any negotiations with an owner-driver, you should be aware of the Code of Practice. A failure to comply with the Code, particularly in negotiations with a contractor in bargaining the terms and conditions of the contract, can be tantamount to unconscionable conduct.
Unconscionable conduct is prohibited under the Act and if found by the Tribunal to be in contravention of that provision, damages may be awarded in favour of the owner-driver.
The Code of Practice identifies best practice techniques to ensure that negotiations for a contract are conduct fairly and that both parties to the contract fully understand its terms and conditions.
Other matters to be aware of
If you are hiring an owner-driver or if you already engage owner-drivers you should also be aware of the following:
- A hirer cannot require the owner-driver or deduct from the owner-driver’s pay:
- insurance amounts, unless a contract of insurance is in force and you have provided a copy of the relevant insurance policy to the owner-driver
- any other amounts (e.g. for fuel and toll charges) unless those amounts are specified in the contract, they are a direct and proper reflection of the actual cost and if practicable, you have given the owner-driver an opportunity to obtain the service/equipment elsewhere.
- There are minimum notice requirements for termination depending upon the classification of the vehicle or if a person is a forestry contractor. Unless you have obtained a certificate from the Small Business Commissioner (SBC) or the owner-driver has ‘materially’ breached the contract or if the period of engagement of the owner-driver is less than 3 months.
- If you are using a broker to engage owner-drivers or a tender process, there are additional requirements.
Resolving a dispute
Generally, parties are required to attend the SBC for alternative dispute resolution before they are able to issue proceedings at the Tribunal. Alternative dispute resolution in this case usually means mediation, where an independent mediator is present and both parties can speak openly about the dispute in an effort to seek a resolution before matters proceed to a litigious stage. The costs for mediation are not burdensome and the parties can choose to have legal representation present.
If the dispute cannot be resolved at mediation, it can then proceed to the Tribunal upon application. It is important to note that there are time limitations to bring an application to the Tribunal.
The legislative scheme for using owner-drivers is complex and quite onerous on hirers. This article does not intend to be a comprehensive outline of the owner-drivers legislation. If you use owner-drivers we recommend that an audit of your compliance with the Act Regulations & Code of Practice be undertaken so as to avoid costly disputes and disruption to your business.
In relation to compliance or general advice concerning the Act or any matters raised in this article, please contact Nicholas Brand or Michael Bishop.
A Swing and a Near Miss: Member challenges merger of Kingswood Golf Club and Peninsula Country Club
On 3 September 2014 the Victorian Supreme Court handed down judgment in the matter of William Falkingham v Peninsula Kingswood Golf Club [2014] VSC 47, a proceeding brought by a member of the Peninsula Kingswood Country Golf Club Ltd who was attempting to undo a merger of Kingswood Golf Club Ltd (Kingswood) and Peninsula Country Golf Club (Peninsula).
BACKGROUND
On 26 March 2013 Kingswood and Peninsula signed a heads of agreement in relation to a potential merger of the clubs. The key feature of the proposed merger was the sale of Kingswood’s golf course at Dingley. It was intended that the merged club’s members would play their golf at the Peninsula’s two golf courses, with Kingswood’s golf course at Dingley being sold to ensure the ongoing financial viability of the merged club.
In September 2013, 63 percent of Kingswood members and 98 percent of Peninsula members voted in favour of the proposed merger. On 2 October 2013, the merger was effected when over 1000 members of Peninsula were made members of Kingswood.
THE PROCEEDING
The plaintiff, a Kingswood member who opposed the merger, sought a declaration that the admission of the Peninsula members was void and an order preventing the sale of the Dingley land on the grounds that the board had, in contravention of section 232 of the Corporations Act 2001, acted oppressively towards the plaintiff and other members who opposed the merger.
The main instance of alleged oppression examined by the Court was that when the board accepted the admission of the Peninsula members, they used their power to accept new members for a purpose other than that for which the power was conferred.
OPPRESSION FOUND
His Honour Justice Robson found that the substantial object of the decision to admit new members was to give effect to the merger agreement and that this was a purpose other than that for which the power to admit new members was granted under the constitution of Kingswood. His Honour held that but for the intention of the board to achieve the merger the power to admit the members would not have been exercised.
His Honour considered the general resolution of the members of Kingswood in support of the merger but found that it was ineffective to authorise the admission of the Peninsula members, noting:
“Constitutions protect the rights of the minority, not only those of the majority. The fact that the members in the general meeting approved the merger does not alter the constitutional obligation to the board to only exercise their powers for the purposes for which they were given.”
His Honour further found that the board’s admission of the members without constitutional authority was unfairly oppressive to the plaintiff as it deprived him of the use of the golf club he had been a member of for many years.
REMEDY AND COSTS
Having established that the conduct of the company was oppressive to the plaintiff, it was open to the Court to make orders under section 233 of the Corporations Act 2001, or in equity, voiding the admission of the Peninsula members and effectively undoing the merger.
The defendant pleaded an equitable defence of laches, acquiescence and delay arguing that the plaintiff’s delay in taking the action had meant that it would be unjust or unreasonable to grant the remedy sought. The defendant noted that the plaintiff was aware of the merger by December 2013 yet did not institute the proceeding until 24 August 2014 in circumstances where he knew the substantial expenses that were being incurred by the defendant and potential buyers of the Dingley land.
His Honour accepted the defendant’s defence finding that:
“The plaintiff has by his inaction and standing by, placed the defendant and third parties in a situation in which it would be inequitable and unreasonable to place them if the remedy of setting aside the merger would afterwards be asserted”
His Honour also took into account the fact that the majority of members had voted in favour of the merger when concluding that the relief sought by the plaintiff was unwarranted.
Typically, the unsuccessful party in a case pays the successful party’s costs but in this case each party was ordered to bear their own costs. His Honour found that although the plaintiff’s case was dismissed, he should not have to pay the defendant’s costs as he was successful on the oppression argument which was the issue that took up most of the time at the hearing.
REQUEST FOR INJUNCTIVE RELIEF PENDING APPEAL
The plaintiff has appealed. The plaintiff sought an injunction restraining the club from selling the Dingley land pending the hearing of the appeal. The injunction was not granted as the plaintiff could not establish that the granting of the order sought carried with it a lower risk of injustice if it should later be shown that the order should not have been made. The Court again referred to the substantial costs that would be incurred by the defendant and third parties if the merger or sale was halted.
CONCLUSION
The case highlights the importance of directors abiding by their company’s constitution even in circumstances where there is broad board and member approval to a course of action. The case also emphasises the need for oppressed parties to act swiftly when seeking to rely on the oppression remedy to challenge the actions of a company, particularly in situations where their delay in acting will cause the company or third parties to suffer loss or put themselves in a position of potential disadvantage.
If you do need any advice or assistance regarding the above, then please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Nicholas McCarthy .
A Swing and a Near Miss: Member challenges merger of Kingswood Golf Club and Peninsula Country Club
On 3 September 2014 the Victorian Supreme Court handed down judgment in the matter of William Falkingham v Peninsula Kingswood Golf Club [2014] VSC 47, a proceeding brought by a member of the Peninsula Kingswood Country Golf Club Ltd who was attempting to undo a merger of Kingswood Golf Club Ltd (Kingswood) and Peninsula Country Golf Club (Peninsula).
BACKGROUND
On 26 March 2013 Kingswood and Peninsula signed a heads of agreement in relation to a potential merger of the clubs. The key feature of the proposed merger was the sale of Kingswood’s golf course at Dingley. It was intended that the merged club’s members would play their golf at the Peninsula’s two golf courses, with Kingswood’s golf course at Dingley being sold to ensure the ongoing financial viability of the merged club.
In September 2013, 63 percent of Kingswood members and 98 percent of Peninsula members voted in favour of the proposed merger. On 2 October 2013, the merger was effected when over 1000 members of Peninsula were made members of Kingswood.
THE PROCEEDING
The plaintiff, a Kingswood member who opposed the merger, sought a declaration that the admission of the Peninsula members was void and an order preventing the sale of the Dingley land on the grounds that the board had, in contravention of section 232 of the Corporations Act 2001, acted oppressively towards the plaintiff and other members who opposed the merger.
The main instance of alleged oppression examined by the Court was that when the board accepted the admission of the Peninsula members, they used their power to accept new members for a purpose other than that for which the power was conferred.
OPPRESSION FOUND
His Honour Justice Robson found that the substantial object of the decision to admit new members was to give effect to the merger agreement and that this was a purpose other than that for which the power to admit new members was granted under the constitution of Kingswood. His Honour held that but for the intention of the board to achieve the merger the power to admit the members would not have been exercised.
His Honour considered the general resolution of the members of Kingswood in support of the merger but found that it was ineffective to authorise the admission of the Peninsula members, noting:
“Constitutions protect the rights of the minority, not only those of the majority. The fact that the members in the general meeting approved the merger does not alter the constitutional obligation to the board to only exercise their powers for the purposes for which they were given.”
His Honour further found that the board’s admission of the members without constitutional authority was unfairly oppressive to the plaintiff as it deprived him of the use of the golf club he had been a member of for many years.
REMEDY AND COSTS
Having established that the conduct of the company was oppressive to the plaintiff, it was open to the Court to make orders under section 233 of the Corporations Act 2001, or in equity, voiding the admission of the Peninsula members and effectively undoing the merger.
The defendant pleaded an equitable defence of laches, acquiescence and delay arguing that the plaintiff’s delay in taking the action had meant that it would be unjust or unreasonable to grant the remedy sought. The defendant noted that the plaintiff was aware of the merger by December 2013 yet did not institute the proceeding until 24 August 2014 in circumstances where he knew the substantial expenses that were being incurred by the defendant and potential buyers of the Dingley land.
His Honour accepted the defendant’s defence finding that:
“The plaintiff has by his inaction and standing by, placed the defendant and third parties in a situation in which it would be inequitable and unreasonable to place them if the remedy of setting aside the merger would afterwards be asserted”
His Honour also took into account the fact that the majority of members had voted in favour of the merger when concluding that the relief sought by the plaintiff was unwarranted.
Typically, the unsuccessful party in a case pays the successful party’s costs but in this case each party was ordered to bear their own costs. His Honour found that although the plaintiff’s case was dismissed, he should not have to pay the defendant’s costs as he was successful on the oppression argument which was the issue that took up most of the time at the hearing.
REQUEST FOR INJUNCTIVE RELIEF PENDING APPEAL
The plaintiff has appealed. The plaintiff sought an injunction restraining the club from selling the Dingley land pending the hearing of the appeal. The injunction was not granted as the plaintiff could not establish that the granting of the order sought carried with it a lower risk of injustice if it should later be shown that the order should not have been made. The Court again referred to the substantial costs that would be incurred by the defendant and third parties if the merger or sale was halted.
CONCLUSION
The case highlights the importance of directors abiding by their company’s constitution even in circumstances where there is broad board and member approval to a course of action. The case also emphasises the need for oppressed parties to act swiftly when seeking to rely on the oppression remedy to challenge the actions of a company, particularly in situations where their delay in acting will cause the company or third parties to suffer loss or put themselves in a position of potential disadvantage.
If you do need any advice or assistance regarding the above, then please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Nicholas McCarthy .
Creditors Statutory Demands
A creditor’s statutory demand is an effective and compelling method to recover debts owed by a company. Most compelling is the presumption by the Courts of the insolvency of a company if it fails to comply with a statutory demand. This presumption extends for 3 months following the failure by a company to comply with the statutory demand.
The Law
As a statutory demand is a creature of legislation, there are some crucial elements that must be complied with. The Courts have found that there should be no defects in the demand that give rise to substantial injustice.
In summary, the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) provides that:
- The debt must be over $2000.00
- The demand must be in the prescribed form
- If the debt is not a judgment debt, the demand must be accompanied by an affidavit in support which must verify that the debt is due and payable
- There must be no genuine dispute about the debt
Defects
Common defects in statutory demands include the failure to properly serve the demand and any accompanying affidavit on the debtor company. The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) provides for the service on a company at its registered office by ordinary mail. If the matter proceeds to Court, sometimes the simplest of errors (e.g. incorrect spelling of the debtor’s name and address) may defeat the validity of the statutory demand which could result in the Court application being dismissed with costs payable by the creditor.
Timeline for statutory demands
The swiftness and timely effect of a statutory demand is evident in the following timeline:
- Debt arises and any terms are not complied with (no genuine dispute about the debt)
- Statutory demand and any affidavit is served on the debtor company
- The debtor company is given 21 days from service to either:
- Pay the debt or reach agreement to pay the debt on terms; or
- Make application to the Supreme Court or the Federal Court to set aside the statutory demand
- 21 days pass and there is no payment or agreement to pay and no application is made to the Court à the debtor company is presumed insolvent for the next 3 months
- Within the 3 month period the creditor can make application to the Court to wind up the debtor company on the basis that it is presumed insolvent
Likely outcomes
Within the 21 day period –
- The debtor pays the debt or enters into an arrangement with the creditor to make payment of the debt
- The debtor disputes the debt and requests that the creditor withdraw the statutory demand failing which it makes application to the Court to have the demand set aside:
Setting aside statutory demands
Should the debtor put before the Court sufficient evidence that there is a genuine dispute about the debt, the demand can be set aside by the Court and the creditor may be liable to pay the debtor’s legal costs for having to make application to the Court.
The Courts have held that a genuine dispute need not mean that the debtor prove that it might have a successful defence, only that it can point to facts or circumstances that might give rise to a defence.
This is a low threshold and a genuine dispute can include an off-setting claim by the debtor in respect of monies the creditor may owe it.
After the 21 day period –
- The creditor issues Court proceedings to have the debtor company wound up and a liquidator is appointed
Winding up a debtor company
The creditor has the ability to apply to the Court to wind up the debtor company and get a Court appointed liquidator to distribute any of the debtor’s assets. Usually, the costs of this will be a priority in the distribution of the debtor company’s assets.
- Noting – the creditor is not required to act on the non-compliance with the statutory demand and issue costly Court proceedings, it can simply do nothing
Involvement of the Courts
The Courts can become easily involved in the use of statutory demands and therefore the use of them should not be taken lightly. Statutory demands are given effect pursuant to Commonwealth Legislation and therefore only the superior Courts have jurisdiction to hear any application in respect of them. As such, barristers are often required to be briefed should you wish to set aside a statutory demand or wind up a company for failure to comply with one.
Conclusion
In conclusion, a statutory demand is an effective tool that can be used for the timely collection of undisputed debts. Essentially, debtors are required to respond to the demand within 21 days of service, failing which a presumption of insolvency will be applied by the Courts to that debtor company for the next 3 months. Whilst the Courts can become easily involved and the costs of such involvement can increase costs, if used properly, statutory demands are a highly persuasive mechanism to force payment of debts.
For further information, or if you have any queries relating to Creditor Statuary Demands, please contact Nicholas Brand, Andrew Cox, Amelita Hensman, Brigid O’Dwyer of our office on 03 9614 7707.
Participating in a Mediation
Anyone involved in a family business these days will sooner or later find themselves attending mediation. Nearly all disputes nowadays will go through a mediation process of one sort or another, including the following:
- Consumer complaints;
- Landlord/tenant disputes;
- Franchisor/franchisee disputes;
- Disputes with suppliers;
- Disputes with financiers;
- Planning objections;
- Building disputes;
- Disputes between co-owners of a business;
- Disputes between family members over a will or trust.
A mediation may occur before proceedings are issued in a Court or Tribunal, either under the terms of a contract, as part of the procedures of a regulator handling a complaint or by agreement between the parties after a dispute has arisen.
Where proceedings have been issued most Courts or Tribunals will require that the parties engage in a mediation prior to the Court or Tribunal hearing the dispute.
Characteristics of mediation
However they arise, mediations are said to have three defining characteristics. Mediations are:
- Voluntary;
- Conducted by an independent third party; and
- Confidential.
Each of these characteristics, however, has some qualifications and exceptions.
Although a mediation is said to be voluntary, you can be required to attend one in various ways. A Court, Tribunal or regulator may require that a mediation occur. A contract you have signed may require that disputes be referred to mediation. In those cases you may find it necessary to attend a mediation.
It seems a nonsense to say that something is ‘voluntary’ if you have to do it. Why then are mediations said to be voluntary?
Firstly, because the compulsion usually ends with attendance. Unless you have agreed otherwise you can be required to attend a mediation, but be under no obligation to do or say anything further. You are not obliged to make statements, answer questions or make or respond to offers. There have been mediations where a party turns up, obtains confirmation that they have attended and then turns around and walks out. This is not usually a good idea but it illustrates the voluntary nature of a mediation.
Apart from losing what may be the best opportunity of settling a dispute turning around and walking out can create problems if:
- you have previously agreed to mediate the dispute ‘in good faith’;
- the mediation is conducted by a regulator or Court officers rather than an independent third party; or
- the mediator has reporting obligations beyond whether the mediation was held and whether it has finished.
Because mediation is voluntary you can generally end it at any time. The mediator may ask that you not terminate the mediation without first discussing it with her, but whether the mediation continues or not is your decision.
The second way in which mediation is voluntary is that any resolution of a dispute at mediation is subject to your agreement. The mediator can’t impose an outcome upon you. Your advisers cannot make or accept an offer without your instructions. You are the one who decides.
The person conducting the mediation (the mediator) will often be an independent third party who is registered under the National Mediator Accreditation Standards. Sometimes the staff of a regulator or officers of a Court or Tribunal may conduct a mediation.
Whoever conducts the mediation should be independent of the parties and not have an interest in the outcome of the dispute. If you believe that there is some relationship between the mediator and another party then you or your advisers should raise that concern at the earliest opportunity.
Mediators should disclose prior relationships or interests to parties. You might find, for example, that a Court official discloses that his superannuation fund has shares in a Bank which is a party to a proceeding. If that were the fund’s only investment and the dispute was likely to have a substantial impact upon the share price then you might decide to ask for another mediator. If the shares were a minor component of the fund and the dispute would have no effect on the share price then you might decide to continue with that mediator.
The mediator controls the process of the mediation, the parties control the content. The mediator may ask the parties to comply with ‘ground rules’ such as not interrupting, politeness and not leaving without discussing your intention to do so with the mediator.
Mediations are confidential. You cannot discuss the offers or arguments made at mediation with anyone outside the mediation. If a friend or family member accompanies you to the mediation then they will usually be asked to sign a confidentiality agreement to the same effect.
If you believe that another party is breaching the confidentiality of a mediation then you should seek legal advice. The mediator does not have any power to control parties after the mediation.
If the mediation is unsuccessful and a judge or tribunal member has to resolve the dispute then they will not be told anything that occurred at the mediation. This encourages the parties to make concessions or offers for the purpose of the mediation, without affecting the arguments or positions they might adopt in a final hearing.
Within the mediation you will usually have a private discussion with the mediator. In those discussions you may tell the mediator things which you do not want the other party to know. The mediator is under an obligation not to disclose such confidential matters to the other party. Likewise the mediator may have been told matters by the other party which they cannot reveal to you.
The obligations of confidentiality in a mediation are subject to exceptions. A mediator may be required to report admissions of child abuse. A mediator may be obliged to advise other participants of a bomb threat made by a party. These exceptions are, hopefully, unlikely to arise in relation to commercial disputes.
Preparing for mediation
If you have lawyers acting for you then they will prepare your case for mediation. That includes providing relevant documents to the mediator and preparing arguments to be made within the mediation.
Part of a lawyer’s preparation for mediation should include advising you of the costs you have incurred up to mediation and estimating future costs should the matter not settle.
If you do not have lawyers acting for you then you should look at any letters or notices from the mediator or regulator as to steps you should take to prepare for mediation. That will usually include bringing copies of the documents you want to show to the mediator or the other side.
It can be of assistance prior to mediation to write down what you understand the other party’s argument or position to be. That will assist you in identifying the issues in dispute. It may be that at the mediation the other party’s position turns out to be different from what you had understood.
At the mediation you may be asked what you regard as the important issues. It can assist to have thought about that before the mediation and even to make notes of the matters that you think should be discussed.
The role of the mediator
Mediators are not acting as judges; they will not decide your dispute or impose a resolution on the parties. They may, however, recommend an outcome to you or make a comment about the strength or merit of your position.
Mediators are not acting as lawyers; they will not give you legal advice. They may, however, ask your lawyers questions or challenge their assumptions in order to test your position.
Mediators are not investigators. They may ask questions or read documents to understand the dispute, but they are not tasked with finding out the real facts of a dispute or reporting to the parties what they believe actually occurred.
Mediators are listeners and facilitators. They will listen to your side of the story and will try to understand your position. They will assist you to understand the other side’s position. They will discuss various ways to resolve the dispute both in private with you and jointly with the other parties.
Recording a settlement
Often one of the ground rules of a mediation is that nothing is to be regarded as binding on any party until a written agreement is signed. Up until that point either party can withdraw any offers or terminate the mediation without further obligation.
If you have lawyers acting for you then the lawyer will either prepare or check any written settlement agreement.
If neither party has lawyers then the mediator will usually assist the parties in preparing a written document setting out any agreement they have reached.
A settlement agreement usually sets out the things that each party has agreed to do and may include provision for confidentiality, non-disparagement and an agreed public statement about the dispute. It will often contain releases meaning that neither party can sue the other for anything arising out of the dispute.
Regretted settlements
Sometimes a person signs Terms of Settlement but subsequently regrets doing so. They may try to set aside the settlement or sue the mediator or their advisers.
It is very rare for any settlement reached at a mediation to be set aside. One of the few grounds on which that might occur is if the settlement is procured by fraud. The evidentiary requirements to establish fraud are usually not met.
If a settlement is set aside then the dispute is not automatically resolved. A Court or Tribunal may still have to determine the dispute.
A mediator appointed by a Court or Tribunal will usually have an immunity from suit. If so, they cannot be sued in the same way that a judge or magistrate cannot be sued.
A privately appointed mediator usually makes it a condition of their acting as mediator that the parties agree not to sue the mediator. Sometimes such a condition may not be enforceable, particularly if the mediator is a lawyer and their services as a mediator are legal services.
Sometimes people complain that improper pressure was put upon them to settle by their own advisers or the mediator. Clients of lawyers can complain to the Legal Services Commissioner if they believe that to be the case. A lawyer can, however, give robust advice to a client regarding their position and still be acting in the best interests of the client.
There has been only one decided case in Australia about mediator’s liability. In that case the mediator sought to strike out the claim against him before a final hearing and the Court said that the case should go to a final hearing. The matter settled before such final hearing but the Court was not willing to say that the claim against the mediator could never have succeeded: Tapoohi v Lewenberg [2003] VSC 410.
Because it is so difficult to set aside any settlement agreement at mediation it is important to consider all the ramifications before signing one. If there is some element of the agreement on which the parties require further advice, such as tax implications, they can agree to make final agreement subject to their obtaining such specialist advice.
Mediation does not usually result in outcomes that are celebrated by either party. It is designed to find and encourage outcomes with which people are content or can live with. Outcomes imposed by a Court or Tribunal may not have either of those qualities, usually for one party, sometimes for both.
For further information on how Pointon Partners can assist you with mediation matters, please contact Andrew Cox or Brigid O’Dwyer of our office on 03 9614 7707.
PPSR Alert – New Zealand Case Creates Possible Defence for Guarantor if Supplier Failed to Register its Retention of Title Arrangement on PPSR
PPSR Alert – New Zealand case creates possible defence for guarantor if supplier failed to register its retention of title arrangement on PPSR
Facts:
In Haar v Eastland Tyres Ltd [2013] NZHC 692 an appeal was brought by a former director-shareholder (‘the Director’) of Gisborne Haulage in the New Zealand High Court, following winding up of that company.
Gisborne had entered a credit agreement with a supplier (‘the Supplier’) under which the Director agreed to guarantee Gisborne’s debts. The credit agreement included an acknowledgment that Gisborne was granting a registrable charge under the Personal Property and Securities Act 1999 (NZ) (NZ PPSA) over its property, in the form of a retention of title arrangement in favour of the supplier.
When Gisborne subsequently went into liquidation the Supplier sued the Director under the personal guarantee.
The Director sought to argue that it was discharged from the obligation to pay the Supplier on the grounds that the Supplier had failed to register its interest against Gisborne, prejudicing the Director’s right of subrogation against Gisborne.
Judgment:
The NZ PPSA Argument
The Director’s argument was that the Supplier had a duty to register its charge – in failing to do so, and subsequently exercising its claim against the Director for the whole of Gisborne’s debt the Supplier had injured the Director’s right of subrogation against Gisborne.
Right of Subrogation Explained
The right of subrogation can be explained briefly as follows:
- The Supplier suffered a loss caused by Gisborne (failure to repay the debt);
- When Gisborne did not repay its debt, the Supplier had a secondary right to claim the debt from Gisborne’s guarantor (the Director), which it did;
- After paying the Supplier the Director is entitled to ‘stand in the shoes’ of the Supplier (i.e. Gisborne would then owe the debt to the Director). The Director is then entitled to the benefit of any security held by the Supplier for the debt.
The reason that Courts grant a right of subrogation is founded in the law of unjust enrichment – if the Director did not have a right against Gisborne to be repaid then Gisborne would have enjoyed:
- the benefit of the credit agreement, and
- the benefit of not having to repay the amount owing under the credit agreement.
Courts would see the avoidance of repaying the debt as a valuable benefit in the hands of Gisborne (a cost saving) at the expense of the Director – a form of ‘additional’ benefit that Gisborne cannot be permitted to retain. Therefore the Courts will act to ensure that Gisborne does not retain that benefit by permitting the Director to recover the amount paid.
Supplier’s Failure to Register – Injury to Subrogation Rights Argument
In summary, based on the principles explained above, the Director argued that the Supplier had damaged the Director’s ability to recover the debt from Gisborne (in subrogation) by failing to secure the property that was subject to the charge in the credit agreement, on the basis that:
- failing to take proper steps to secure Gisborne’s debt so that it could recover at least some of the debt directly created a greater liability for the Director to repay the entire amount; and
- failing to claim assets that could then be released to the Director when they paid the full balance of the debt to the Supplier also created a greater liability for the Director.
Finding
The Court found that the argument made by the Appellant had merit. However, whilst the Supplier did have a duty to register the charge the Director was unsuccessful in avoiding its obligation to pay the Supplier because the Court was unable to determine the amount of damage suffered.
Being unable to determine how much the secured property would have been worth the Court was unwilling to compromise the Supplier’s entire right to repayment and opted to allow full recovery by the Supplier.
Implications for Suppliers
The Australian Personal Properties Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (PPSA) is modelled on the NZ PPSA and the law of subrogation in Australia closely parallels that in New Zealand.
Haar v Eastland Tyres Ltd is likely to be significant in any Australian case where a secured party fails to register its security and subsequently seeks to recover a debt from a guarantor. The case highlights the significant impact of the PPSA on the obligations of a secured party to take steps to protect its interests.
Parties suing on personal guarantees should be mindful that the law of subrogation creates rights in 3rd party guarantors that may inadvertently impact their ability to recover against that guarantor if a security interest such as a retention of title arrangement had not been perfected by registration on the PPSR.
A well drawn guarantee can minimise the risk associated with any failure to register. We recommend that all suppliers review their guarantees to ensure that, so far as possible, such failures do not affect recovery against guarantors. Pointon Partners would be pleased to assist with such review.
If you would like to find out how the PPSA may apply to your business, either as a guarantor or secured party please feel free to contact Laszlo Konya, Anthony Pointon or Michael Bishop of our office on 03 9614 7707.
Lodging Caveats Over Property Without a Proper Basis
LODGING CAVEATS OVER PROPERTY WITHOUT A PROPER BASIS
Review of Sovereign MF Ltd (in liq.) v EOS Janus Holdings Pty Ltd [2013] VSC 347
Caveats may only be lodged over another person’s property if you have a legal or equitable interest in the property. The effect of the caveat is to give notice to the world of the interest claimed by the caveator.
In a recent decision of a single judge of the Supreme Court, Justice James Elliot awarded the plaintiff indemnity costs on the basis that the defendant had lodged a caveat over the plaintiff’s property without a proper basis.
The award of indemnity costs is an adverse measure taken by Courts and unlike party-party costs its purpose is to ensure that the other party is not out of pocket (Spencer v Dowling & KL Dowling & Co (a firm) [1997] 2 VR 127). This means that all costs incurred by the other party will be allowed, save for any unreasonably incurred amounts.
The decision of His Honour reinforces that the Courts will order a party to be responsible to pay all the landowner’s legal costs and disbursements as a consequence for lodging caveats without any proper basis.
Facts
In this case, the defendant lodged a caveat in respect of a property located in Tarneit (first caveat). The defendant’s grounds to support the first caveat were “pursuant to a constructive trust”.
The first caveat lapsed on 25 June 2013 and on 1 July 2013 the defendant lodged a subsequent caveat, with the grounds being “pursuant to rights under an underwriting agreement” (further caveat).
The plaintiff and defendant had entered into an underwriting agreement on 25 February 2010 in respect of sale of lots of the Property. The defendant claimed that it had monies outstanding to it by the plaintiff and on that basis lodged caveats over the Property.
Importantly, there were no terms in the agreement that gave rise to any legal or equitable interest in the Property to provide grounds and proper bases for the defendant to lodge a caveat in respect of the Property.
Accordingly, by summons on originating motion to the Supreme Court, the plaintiff sought orders that the defendant remove the caveat from the register. Between the issuing of the summons and its return date for hearing, the defendant lodged a withdrawal of caveat from the register. As a result, the matter was referred to the Court on the question of costs alone.
Decision
In determining whether to order the defendant to pay indemnity costs, Justice Elliott referred to and upheld the factors considered by Justice Forrest in Love v Kempton [2010] VSC 254, which are as follows:
- The nominated basis for lodging the caveat was without a proper basis.
- The other party had put the defendant on notice that if it failed to withdraw the caveat and the plaintiff was required to make an application to the court, it would apply for indemnity costs.
- A caveat is not a bargaining chip.
- Lodging caveats is a serious business as it has the potential to affect commercial transactions and the lives and financial interests of others.
His Honour considered that in light of the “high-handed conduct” of the defendant in not only lodging the first caveat, but lodging the further caveat together with the satisfaction of the above factors in Love v Kempton, costs should be awarded to the plaintiff in respect of the summons on an indemnity basis.
Key Points to remember
- Is there a proper basis for lodging the caveat, that is do you have an equitable or legal interest in the property in which you propose to lodge the caveat over?a) Does any legal instrument, for example a written agreement, make provision for you to lodge a caveat in respect of the other party’s property on satisfaction of particular circumstance?
a) Do you have any equitable interest in the property or has the registered proprietor granted you an interest in the property (e.g. an equitable charge to secure debt)?
- After proceedings have been instituted by the other party for the withdrawal of the caveat and it is withdrawn, if there were no grounds to support that caveat there still may be costs awarded against you despite the withdrawal;
- Costs are likely to be awarded on an indemnity basis if there is no proper basis to lodging the caveat.
In consideration of the above, it is prudent to seek legal advice prior to lodging any caveat.
Please contact Nicholas Brand of our office on 03 9614 7707 for further information.