Pointon Partners

Trade Mark Owners Take Note: First to File v First to Use

With the prevalence of the internet and social media, growing your brand and your business and connecting with markets overseas has never been easier.  In navigating this era of globalisation, it is important that business owners trading under valuable brand names or using other types of trade marks in the operation of their businesses, understand that there are different rules which may apply to determine trade mark ownership and rights in different countries.

In trade mark law in Australia, the “use” of a trade mark by a trader in relation to their goods or services on a commercial level is important and can assist in determining matters such as: the ownership of a trade mark, the distinctiveness of a trade mark, whether a trade mark registration should be removed from the Australian trade marks register for non-use and whether a registered trade mark has been infringed (amongst others).

Australia is therefore considered to be a “first to use” country – that is, a country which gives priority to those who are the “first to use” a particular trade mark in Australia “as a trade mark” in relation to goods or services, and can demonstrate evidence of that use, even if another party has applied to register that mark as a trade mark in Australia first.  Other countries which are also known as “first to use” countries include the United States and New Zealand.

Some countries however follow a “first to file” trade mark system instead.  This approach gives rights to the party who first filed a trade mark application in that country for such mark, even if another party has used that trade mark in that country prior to the filed application. Countries which follow a “first to file” system include China, Japan and Thailand.

In “first-to-file” countries however, the failure of a trade mark owner to register a trade mark application in such countries, can leave their business vulnerable to “trade mark squatting”.  This situation occurs where a trade mark is registered by a third party in such a country, without the authorisation of the legitimate owner.  This may be done, for instance, by a competitor or other party, with a view to obtaining a financial gain from the legitimate owner for the transfer or by a supplier or manufacturer with whom the legitimate owner has a supply or manufacturing arrangement with (as well as other circumstances).   Many businesses have fallen subject to this in recent years.  For instance, it was reported in July 2012, that Apple paid US$60 million to Proview Technology (Shenzhen) to end a dispute in relation to the iPad trade mark name in China,[1]  following a Chinese court’s ruling that Proview Technology, who had registered trade marks for the IPAD and iPad names in a number of countries including China, was the rightful owner of the iPad trade mark in China.[2]

Whilst it is important to seek trade mark registration in the markets in which you are operating to protect your trade mark, whether in Australia or overseas, trade mark owners should be particularly mindful when supplying to, trading in, manufacturing in or operating in “first to file” countries.  Lodging your trade mark application as early as possible will assist in increasing your chances of obtaining trade mark protection in such countries.

If you have any queries about trade mark registration internationally, please contact Felicity Cara-Carson and other members of our intellectual property team.


[1] Lee, M and S Shen, 2012, “Apple settles China iPad dispute for $60 million”, The Sydney Morning Herald, 2 July 2012;  “Apple loses China iPad trademark case”.

[2] IP Australia, 31 July 2017, <https://www.ipaustralia.gov.au/tools-resources/case-studies/apples-trade-mark-problems-china>

Advertisers Beware – Social Media Influencers paid to promote products must disclose the commercial nature of their posts

The rise and prevalence of advertising via influencers on social media sites has experienced rapid growth.  In recent times however, the lack of disclosure by certain influencers of their commercial relationship with the brand owners of the brands which they advertise to followers has been brought to the forefront and received negative publicity. In the last 12 months, a number of key celebrities have been joined personally to various litigation proceedings for not having disclosed that they had entered into a commercial arrangement with the brands they were advertising for and received a benefit. Many of these cases have predominately been issued in the United States, however, given the Australian Association of National Advertisers’ (‘AANA’) approach (see original article below), it may not be long before such an action is commenced in Australia.   The implications of this are likely to affect the advertising industry and the relationship between influencers and brand owners.

It is therefore important that arrangements between the influencer and the brand owner are made clear at the commencement of the relationship in order to clarify the terms of the arrangement and ensure compliance with the law and transparency in relation to social media promotion.  This can be reflected in a written agreement between the parties. Pointon Partners have been involved in drafting and reviewing of influencer, sponsorship and ambassador agreements on behalf of brand owners as well as on behalf of influencers.  If you or your organisation are using social media influencers to promote your products, or if you are a social media influencer, feel free to get in touch with us to discuss this article, or any queries you may have in relation to these developments.


Article Dated: May 9th, 2017

On 1 March 2017, a new provision was introduced into the Australian Association of National Advertisers’ (AANA) Code of Ethics (Code). The new provision stipulates that ‘Advertising or Marketing Communications must be clearly distinguishable as such to the relevant audience’. This is set to have a considerable effect on celebrities and other social media “influencers”, many of whom are paid significant amounts to advertise products on Instagram and various other social media platforms. These influencers and the advertisers that pay them will now need to ensure that such posts are identified as advertising, rather than being “camouflaged” as independent reviews, user-generated content or private blogs.

What does the provision target and when will it apply?

Like all provisions of the Code, the new provision applies whenever material “draws the attention of the public in a manner calculated to promote” a product or service, and the advertiser has “a reasonable degree of control” over the material.

There is no absolute requirement that advertising or marketing communication must have a label. If it is clear to the relevant audience that the content is commercial in nature, then no further disclosure or distinguishing element is needed.

Accordingly, the provision would not apply when an advertiser collaborates with an influencer to create editorial content that is distributed by the brand via its own social media presence, as the commercial nature of the communication is evident by the nature of the communication.

Similarly, if an advertiser were to send the influencer merchandise with no conditions attached, and the influencer subsequently made a post about the merchandise, then the new provision of the Code would not apply due to lack of content control. However, if the advertiser were to arrange with the influencer to post content on social media where the advertiser retains control over the content, this likely would be considered a marketing communication which must be clearly distinguishable as such to the relevant audience – this applies equally whether the influencer is paid in cash or is given free samples.

What is the complaints process if the Code is breached and what are the ramifications of a breach?

A complaint for a breach of the Code can be made to the independent Advertising Standards Bureau (Bureau). If a dispute is lodged with the Bureau, the Bureau’s Complaints Board (Board) must decide whether any of the advertising claims disputed are not substantiated, and it then must provide the case decision to the advertiser with an invitation to produce an Advertiser Statement stating whether the claims will be modified or discontinued.

Immediately after receiving such an Advertiser Statement, or if a response is not received from the advertiser within a nominated period, the Board must issue a final case report to the parties, identifying the advertiser, the product, the subject matter involved and the final decision.

Where an advertiser does not agree to modify or discontinue an advertisement found in contravention of the Code, the Board can also refer the case report to an appropriate government agency and/or forward it to media proprietors. For example, in some instances there could be potential liability under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) for misleading or deceptive conduct, in which case the case report might be referred to the ACCC.

What will be the effect on social media influencers?

As a result of the new provision, it is evident that transparency is the key determining factor. The new provision could have a significant effect on the ways in which brands, companies and advertisers engage social media influencers to promote their products, goods and services. In the AANA’s best practice guideline notes recommend that brands require influencers to use the hashtags ‘# #ad’ within their social media posts in order to ensure compliance with the new provision, and several influencers have begun using these hashtags in their posts.

If you would like to discuss this article, please contact David Mazzeo, Felicity Cara-Carson or Stefano Mazzeo  on (03) 9614 7707.

™ And ® – The Art of Using a Trade Mark Symbol

A trade mark is a way of branding and identifying a product or service, and distinguishing those products or services from competitors.  Over time, the concept of what is considered to be a trade mark has expanded and can include a logo, word, colour, sound, smell, phrase, shape, picture, movement, number, letter, aspect of packaging, or a combination of any of these elements.  In addition to this, trade marks being used in Australia in the marketplace may be regarded as an “unregistered” trade mark, pursuant to which rights are developed via use and reputation, or a trade mark which has been “registered” in relation to nominated goods or services, under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (“the Act”).   The status of a trade mark however can be identified through the correct use of different symbols, which are also an important element of brand protection.

What are the trade mark symbols?

The two symbols primarily being referred to are the ™ symbol and the ® symbol.  In Australia, these are commonly placed in a prominent position, typically to the right at the end of a trade mark and used by traders in the marketplace, however their respective meanings may not be widely understood and they are sometimes applied incorrectly.

“TM” symbol

The ™ symbol can be used to indicate to competitors and consumers that you intend for your brand to operate as a “trade mark”. The use of this symbol however does not mean that your trade mark is registered, nor does it indicate that you have any rights pertaining to registered trade marks under the Act.

“R” symbol

The ® symbol on the other hand, indicates that a trade mark has been registered under the Act and should only be used once the trade mark has been registered as a trade mark under the Act.   It therefore demonstrates to consumers and competitors alike that the owner of it has been granted certain exclusive rights of use as well as protection mechanisms which are only available to and enforceable by registered trade mark holders under the Act  This may also assist in acting as a deterrent to potential infringers from copying your brand logo or name.

It is also important to note that in Australia, the use of the ® symbol in relation to a trade mark which has not been registered under the Act, is an offence under the Act and penalties apply.  For instance, if you are found to have incorrectly used the ® symbol, you may be liable for a fine.

Conclusion

Using the correct symbol is important to both avoid penalties under legislation, as well as to enhance your brand protection strategy.

Pointon Partners are able to assist you with queries you may have in relation to brand protection, trade mark registration and registered and unregistered trade mark rights.

If you have any queries, or wish to discuss this article further, please contact Felicity Cara-Carson or Stefano Mazzeo .

Colour Trade Marks

A trade mark is considered to be a way for consumers to identify a particular good or service, typically known as a “brand”.  Whilst most consumers are likely to readily identify a trade mark which is in the form of a logo, it is important to note that a trade mark can also take other forms, such as a letter, number, word, phrase, sound, smell, shape, movement, aspect of packaging, or even a colour.   A colour can function “as a trade mark” where the public has come to identify the colour with a business’ goods or services.

Colour trade mark application

A colour trade mark application in Australia can be made over a specific colour, or a combination of colours. If an applicant does wish to obtain a colour trade mark registration, they must be able to provide evidence that:

  1. the public has come to identify the colour the applicant is applying to register as a trade mark as synonymous with a particular good or service;
  2. the colour alone is capable of distinguishing the goods or services of the applicant; and
  3. the colour the applicant is applying to register as a trade mark is actually a “trade mark” and not just part of the goods or their packaging.

An Australian colour trade mark registration, if obtained, provides the applicant with the right to use that particular shade of colour or colour combination applied for, exclusively in Australia, but only in relation to particular nominated goods and/or services.

IP Australia (‘Trade Marks Office’) indicates that the following, however, cannot be protected by a colour trade mark registration:

‘A functional colour, or combination of colours, cannot be trade marked. In other words, if a company sells turf, they couldn’t register the colour green because green is the colour of grass and is therefore functional. Similarly, you’re unable to register colours that convey a generally accepted meaning, for example, it would be difficult to trade mark a combination of red and orange because those colours are synonymous with safety signs and hazard warnings.’

The application process to obtain a colour trade mark registration is therefore complex, and for an application to be successful, usually requires the applicant to be able to demonstrate sufficient (and usually of a significant amount) evidence of use of the particular shade of colour or combination of colours that they are claiming distinguish their goods and/or services.

Thus, single colour trademarks may be more difficult to obtain on the basis that it is considered easier for consumers to distinguish colour trade marks which consist of two or more colours. In addition, the Trade Marks office is inherently reluctant to provide registrations over single colour trade marks as the market for those colours is more finite than those of multiple colours, and the monopoly to be gained is significantly greater.

It is also worth noting that a colour trade mark registration is restricted in certain aspects of the protection it grants to the owner. A colour trade mark registration only provides the owner with the rights to use that specific colour and/or colours in in relation to the goods and services claimed. Accordingly, a third party could seek to apply for a colour trade mark registration of the exact same colour, or a similar shade of colour, for goods or services that are considered to be sufficiently different from those that the registration relates to, and if they are able to show the requisite amount of distinguishability and use, they could be successful in obtaining a colour trade mark registration.

Examples of Colour Trade Marks:

Some examples of colour trade mark registrations which have been obtained in Australia are as follows:

Whilst colour trade marks are a valuable tool, and lots of brands utilise a certain colour or colours to convey their branding to consumers, obtaining a colour trade mark registration may be difficult unless evidence of use can demonstrate to the Trade Marks Office that the goods and services relating to the trade mark are synonymous with the colour being applied for and that the colour is able and is being used to distinguish the goods and services of the applicant.

If, however, the applicant is unable to obtain a colour trade mark registration, there may be other causes of action available for the applicant if copying occurs, such as the common law tort of passing off and/or misleading and deceptive conduct or making other false representations under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth).

If you wish to discuss the matters raised in this article, do not hesitate to contact David Mazzeo, Felicity Cara-Carson or Stefano Mazzeo of our office.

Protection of your Trade Mark internationally under the Madrid Protocol

One of the ways in which trade mark owners in Australia may apply for registration of their trade mark internationally is via a treaty known as the Madrid Protocol. A person who has registered or applied for a trade mark in a country party to the Madrid Protocol (such as Australia), can lodge a single application, under the Madrid Protocol, designating the countries which are members of the Madrid Protocol convention in which it wishes to seek trade mark registration.

What is the Madrid Protocol?

The Madrid Protocol allows for international registration of trade marks in countries which are members of the Madrid Protocol treaty, and is administered by the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO).

Member Countries

At present, there are 99 member countries of the Madrid Protocol treaty. These include the United States of America, China, the European Union, the United Kingdom and Australia.

Not all countries however are members of the Madrid Protocol.  For instance, Canada, Indonesia, Brazil and South Africa are yet to join the Madrid Protocol. Thailand will officially become a member on November 7th this year.

The Application Process

In one trade mark application filed with WIPO via the Madrid Protocol, applicants can nominate multiple member countries in which they seek trade mark protection.  The requests are then examined by the relevant intellectual property office of each nominated member country in accordance with their national trade mark laws.

As the application process involves lodgement of one application, it can save both time and costs that would otherwise be expended when making multiple applications internationally.

Base Trade Mark Application or Registration

It is important to note that for the first 5 years, an international registration obtained under the Madrid Protocol is dependent on the base Australian trade mark registration or application.  This means that restrictions to the IP rights of the base trade mark registration or application during this five year period will also impact on the international registration.

Term of Registration

Once registered, an international trade mark registration is protected for a period of 10 years from the date of application, and can be renewed every 10 years upon payment of the relevant fees.

International Application direct to a Country’s IP Office

Another method of applying for an international trade mark registration involves filing a trade mark application directly with the intellectual property office of the country in which registration is sought. Direct applications are lodged with the relevant intellectual property office in each country and may require the assistance of a local agent in order to comply with the registration requirements of those countries.

Determining whether to lodge a trade mark application internationally under the Madrid Protocol or directly with another country’s intellectual property office will involve a consideration of various matters, including, amongst others, whether that country is a party to the Madrid Protocol.

Pointon Partners can assist you with your trade mark applications within Australia and internationally.  If you have any queries in relation to this article or trade mark law generally, please contact David Mazzeo or Felicity Cara-Carson on (03) 9614 7707.

Protecting your Brand at the Border

As an intellectual property rights owner of, it is important that you are vigilant about protecting your intellectual property from infringement and maintaining the reputation and value of your brand and/or products.  Counterfeit products which are imported in Australia can impact on and undermine the growth of a brand and its presence. The Australian Department of Immigration and Border Protection however does provide some comfort to brand owners against counterfeit importation by giving them the option of lodging a Notice of Objection to stop the flow of counterfeit products at the border.

What is a Notice of Objection (“Notice”)?

A Notice is a document that allows the Australian Border Force to seize imported goods that are suspected of infringing trademark and/or copyright rights that are the subject of the Notice. A Notice is lodged by Intellectual Property owners (or in some cases authorised users) who are concerned about the potential damage to trade, reputation and profits that may result from the importation of goods that infringe their intellectual property.  Intellectual Property rights owners with a Notice in place are commonly referred to as ‘objectors’.

What can the Australian Border Force (‘ABF’) do when infringing goods are imported?

With a valid Notice in place, the ABF are able to seize goods that:

  1. are subject to customs control;
  2. are covered by a valid Notice;
  3. appear to infringe on an Intellectual Property owners rights; and
  4. are intended for commercial purposes.

How is a Notice Filed?

In order to file a Notice, the following must be submitted to the Department of Immigration and Border Protection:

  1. a completed Notice Form which includes details of the objector and their intellectual property rights;
  2. evidence of intellectual property ownership such as a registered trade mark or copyright materials; and
  3. a completed Deed of Undertaking (‘Deed’). The Deed is a formal undertaking from the objector that they agree to pay any costs incurred by Department of Immigration and Border Protection outside their normal business duties while enforcing the Notice (for example, transportation, storage and destruction costs).

How long is the Notice valid for?

A Notice under the Trade Marks Act 1995 and/or Copyright Act 1968 is valid for four years. A Notice can be re-lodged to ensure ongoing protection, or withdrawn at any time if no longer required.

What happens when goods are seized?

When goods are seized, the importer and the objector will be notified in writing by the seizing officer of the Department of Immigration and Border Protection.

If the importer wishes to make a claim for the release of seized goods, they must do so within ten working days of notification.

If a claim for release is made by the importer, the objector will be notified and will have ten working days to:

  1. commence legal action; or
  2. consent to the release of the goods to the importer.

The importer can voluntarily forfeit the goods at any time before legal action has commenced.

If the objector does not commence legal action and the goods have not been forfeited by the importer, the ABF will release the goods to the importer subject to all other legislative requirements being met. The ABF does not however make the final decision on whether goods are infringing Intellectual Property.  This will be determined by the Courts, if an action is commenced by either party, and orders will be made by the Court accordingly.  This may include:

  1. releasing the goods to the importer; or
  2. forfeiting them to the Commonwealth.

If the goods are ordered to be forfeited, the ABF will dispose of them as directed by the relevant delegate, usually by destruction.

What are the costs to obtain a Notice?

There are no fees involved in the actual lodgement of a Notice.

In the event that counterfeit goods are seized however, costs will be incurred, and these will depend on factors such as quantity, type of goods and storage.

Notably, if the objector takes the matter before the Court, the objector may be able to recoup some of its costs from the importer as part of the settlement process.

If you wish to seek advice in relation to these matters, please contact David Mazzeo, Felicity Cara-Carson or Stefano Mazzeo on (03) 9614 7707.

Advertisers Beware – Social Media Influencers paid to promote products must disclose the commercial nature of their posts

On 1 March 2017, a new provision was introduced into the Australian Association of National Advertisers’ (AANA) Code of Ethics (Code). The new provision stipulates that ‘Advertising or Marketing Communications must be clearly distinguishable as such to the relevant audience’. This is set to have a considerable effect on celebrities and other social media “influencers”, many of whom are paid significant amounts to advertise products on Instagram and various other social media platforms. These influencers and the advertisers that pay them will now need to ensure that such posts are identified as advertising, rather than being “camouflaged” as independent reviews, user-generated content or private blogs.

What does the provision target and when will it apply?

Like all provisions of the Code, the new provision applies whenever material “draws the attention of the public in a manner calculated to promote” a product or service, and the advertiser has “a reasonable degree of control” over the material.

There is no absolute requirement that advertising or marketing communication must have a label. If it is clear to the relevant audience that the content is commercial in nature, then no further disclosure or distinguishing element is needed.

Accordingly, the provision would not apply when an advertiser collaborates with an influencer to create editorial content that is distributed by the brand via its own social media presence, as the commercial nature of the communication is evident by the nature of the communication.

Similarly, if an advertiser were to send the influencer merchandise with no conditions attached, and the influencer subsequently made a post about the merchandise, then the new provision of the Code would not apply due to lack of content control. However, if the advertiser were to arrange with the influencer to post content on social media where the advertiser retains control over the content, this likely would be considered a marketing communication which must be clearly distinguishable as such to the relevant audience – this applies equally whether the influencer is paid in cash or is given free samples.

What is the complaints process if the Code is breached and what are the ramifications of a breach?

A complaint for a breach of the Code can be made to the independent Advertising Standards Bureau (Bureau). If a dispute is lodged with the Bureau, the Bureau’s Complaints Board (Board) must decide whether any of the advertising claims disputed are not substantiated, and it then must provide the case decision to the advertiser with an invitation to produce an Advertiser Statement stating whether the claims will be modified or discontinued.

Immediately after receiving such an Advertiser Statement, or if a response is not received from the advertiser within a nominated period, the Board must issue a final case report to the parties, identifying the advertiser, the product, the subject matter involved and the final decision.

Where an advertiser does not agree to modify or discontinue an advertisement found in contravention of the Code, the Board can also refer the case report to an appropriate government agency and/or forward it to media proprietors. For example, in some instances there could be potential liability under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) for misleading or deceptive conduct, in which case the case report might be referred to the ACCC.

What will be the effect on social media influencers?

As a result of the new provision, it is evident that transparency is the key determining factor. The new provision could have a significant effect on the ways in which brands, companies and advertisers engage social media influencers to promote their products, goods and services. In the AANA’s best practice guideline notes recommend that brands require influencers to use the hashtags ‘# #ad’ within their social media posts in order to ensure compliance with the new provision, and several influencers have begun using these hashtags in their posts.

If you would like to discuss this article, please contact David Mazzeo or Stefano Mazzeo on (03) 9614 7707.

When is unauthorised use of a trade mark not an infringement of the trade mark owner’s rights?

The owner of a registered trade mark has an exclusive right to use that trademark. But what happens when you use a trade mark without the permission of the trade mark owner? The Trade Marks Act provides protection to users of a trade mark in limited circumstances where their use does not infringe the trade mark owner’s rights.

Trade mark infringement

Under s 120 of the Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) (the Act)[1] the registered proprietor of a trade mark is granted the exclusive right to:

You will infringe a trade mark owners’ rights if you use as a trade mark a sign which is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, the registered trade mark,  in relation to the specified goods and services of the trade mark.[2]

Section 122 of the Act allows some limited, specified exceptions to this rule by permitting third party use in certain circumstances.

When is a trade mark not infringed?

Use of own name

Section 122(1)(a) allows you to use your own name or the name of your business (or the name of your predecessor in business) in good faith.

Good faith requires an “honest belief that no confusion would arise by reference to the earlier trade mark’s reputation, and the absence of an intention to take advantage of the reputation acquired by another trader”.[3] Whether or not you are acting in good faith is determined objectively.

In 2013, the Federal Court of Australia restrained Bob Jane (via his associated entities)[4] from using his own name to sell tyres, wheels, batteries, accessories for auto motive vehicle parts and services relating to their installation.[5]

Following an acrimonious departure from Bob Jane Corporation Pty Ltd (a major component of the business being Bob Jane T-Mart), Bob Jane commenced trading using marks such Bob Jane Global Type Corporation Limited and Bob Jane Southern Motors.

As Bob Jane was using his own name, the court considered a possible defence under section 122(1)(a). As he had previously allowed his name to become part of the Bob Jane Corporation Pty Ltd trade marks, and was aware of their continuing use, it was found that the respondents commenced use of similar names with the intention that consumers would associate them with Bob Jane Corporation Pt Ltd. Further, Bob Jane and the respondents communicated with the suppliers of Bob Jane Corporation Pty Ltd which misled at least one to believe that they were dealing with Bob Jane Corporation Pty Ltd.[6] Accordingly, the ‘own name’ defence was held not to be available based upon the evidence before the court.

In Flexopack S.A. Plastics Industry v Flexopack Australia Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 235 Justice Beach noted that:

  1. it may aid in the defence if you have adopted honest business practices in relation to your commercial or industrial matters;[7] and
  2. it may be evidence of good faith if you have acted diligently in ensuring your chosen name does not conflict with a registered trade mark.[8]

Accordingly, when selecting a company name, it is important that you research the existence of prior registrations, including trade mark registrations. This will help to avoid selecting a name that infringes a registered trade mark, and may assist in establishing that you have acted in good faith if your use of the name is later challenged.

Descriptive use

Section 122(1)(b) allows you to use another person’s registered trade mark in good faith to indicate the kind, quality, intended purpose, value, geographical origin or some other characteristic of goods or services.[9]

In Wellness Pty Ltd v Pro Bio Living Waters Pty Ltd (with Corrigendum dated 23 April 2004) [2004] FCA 438, it was held that the use of the words  ‘Living Water’ on bottled water by the respondents, including Pro Bio Living Waters Pty Ltd (Pro Bio) went beyond descriptive, and constituted use as a trade mark.[10]  The Court noted that the words were “not used as descriptive of the goods and that their use is not reasonably necessary for the adequate description of the goods”.[11]  Accordingly, Pro Bio’s use of this term was found to infringe the trade mark ‘LIVING WATER’ which was owned by Wellness Pty Ltd.[12]

Intended purpose

Section 122(1)(c) allows use another person’s trade mark in good faith to indicate the intended purpose of your goods or services – the classic example being production or supply of compatible spare parts and accessories.

This defence enables parties to “make a fair reference to the registered trade mark in circumstances which do not create a mistaken or misleading impression”.[13]

Frequently the producers of the primary goods in question, such as cars or phones, are very well resourced and take a dim view of unauthorised third parties seeking to benefit from spare parts/after market accessory manufacture and supply.  Accordingly, anyone seeking to operate in this sphere should be vigilant in ensuring that all of their branding, marketing and other promotional material strictly adheres to the parameters of this section of the Act.

For example, in 2003, it was alleged by Nokia Corporations that a Mr Mai had, without its licence or authority, “manufactured or caused to be manufactured, imported or caused to be imported, advertised, offered for sale, distributed, supplied and sold goods bearing one or more of Nokia’s trade marks”.[14]

Mr Mai was in the business of selling Nokia mobile phone cases, neck straps and batteries. Evidence produced demonstrated that the products sold by Mr Mai contained the Nokia trade mark without Nokia’s authority, knowledge or consent.[15]

The Federal Court of Australia held that the use of the Nokia trade mark by Mr Mai was use as a trade mark in breach of section 120. It gave a misleading impression that “the mark ‘Nokia’ was a badge of origin of the goods indicating a connection in the course of trade between the goods and the person who applie it to the goods”.[16]

By contrast, in 1997, the Gillette Company and Gillette Australia Pty Ltd (Gillette) sought an interlocutory injunction against Pharma-goods Australia Pty Ltd and Franklins Limited (Pharma), claiming, among other things, that Pharma’s  use of  Gillette’s trade mark “SENSOR” was an impermissible use of Gillette’s trade mark.[17] Pharma’s packaging stated that their No Frills Moving Blades would fit Gillette’s Sensor handles, and included a statement that SENSOR was “a registered trade mark of Gillette”. Justice Burchett, hearing an injunction application, did not consider that a sufficient case had been made out by Gillette.  His Honour noted that section 122 permits use “in good faith to indicate the… intended purpose… of goods”, and found that Pharma’s use of Gillette’s trade mark was within those limits.[18]

If using a trade mark to indicate the intended purpose of goods or services it is important that you show a clear indication, through the use of specific language, that the manufactured or supplied goods are not the registered proprietor’s goods.  For example, the words “suitable for use with” or “suitable in” should be used.[19]  The greater the use and prominence of such terms, and other clear indicators that your product, while compatible with, is not made or endorsed by the original manufacturer, the more you are likely to be able to attract the section 122(1)(c) protection.

Good faith requirement

Each of sections 122(1)(a), (1)(b) and (1)(c) all require that use of a trade mark be in ‘good faith’.

The courts have determined that this requires the person or business using the trade mark to act “honestly and with no ulterior motive”.[20] Whether an act has been done with ulterior motive is something to be decided by the “subject matter in any given context”.[21]

As ‘good faith’ is a threshold requirement under both the Act and the relevant case law, it is important that you act honestly when using a registered trade mark without authorisation from the trade mark owner, whether it be use of  your own name, descriptive use or to show an intended purpose.

If you have any queries relating to trade mark infringement or intellectual property generally, please contact David Mazzeo or Felicity Cara-Carson on (03) 9614 7707.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________

[1] Section numbers in the body of the article refer to the Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) unless otherwise specified.

[2] Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth), s 120.

[3] Insight Radiology Pty Ltd v Insight Clinical Imaging Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 1406, 97.

[4] Bob Jane was (at various stages) the director, company secretary and the sole shareholder of ACN 149 801 141, Bob Jane Southern Motors Pty Ltd, Calder Park Promotions Pty Ltd (In Liq) (ACN 138 012 021) and ACN 154 904 604 Pty Ltd. He has been the director of Bob Jane Global Tyre Corporation (Hong Kong) Limited. (Bob Jane Corporation Pty Ltd v ACN 149 801 141 Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 1255, 7-8).

[5] Bob Jane Corporation Pty Ltd v ACN 149 801 141 Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 1255, 1.

[6] Bob Jane Corporation Pty Ltd v ACN 149 801 141 Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 1255, 127.

[7] Flexopack S.A. Plastics Industry v Flexopack Australia Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 235, 113

[8] Flexopack S.A. Plastics Industry v Flexopack Australia Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 235, 116

[9] Australia Postal Corporation v Digital Post Australia [2013] FCAFC 153, 89.

[10] Wellness Pty Ltd v Pro Bio Living Water Pty Ltd (with Corrigendum dated 23 April 2004) [2004] FCA 438, 51.

[11] Wellness Pty Ltd v Pro Bio Living Water Pty Ltd (with Corrigendum dated 23 April 2004) [2004] FCA 438, 51.

[12] Wellness Pty Ltd v Pro Bio Living Water Pty Ltd (with Corrigendum dated 23 April 2004) [2004] FCA 438, 63.

[13] Nokia Corporation v Mai [2003] FA 924, 46.

[14] Nokia Corporation v Mai [2003] FA 924, 5.

[15] Nokia Corporation v Mai [2003] FA 924, 11.

[16] Nokia Corporation v Mai [2003] FA 924, 52.

[17] Gillette Co & Anor v Pharma-Goods Australia Pty Ltd [1997] FCA 629.

[18] Gillette Co & Anor v Pharma-Goods Australia Pty Ltd [1997] FCA 629.

[19] Nokia Corporation v Mai [2003] FCA 924, 47.

[20] Re Johnson and Johnson Australia Pty Ltd v Sterling Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd [1991] FCA 310, 45.

[21] Re Johnson and Johnson Australia Pty Ltd v Sterling Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd [1991] FCA 310, 45.

Copyright Held to be ‘Precious’

Copyright owners will welcome the recent decision of the Federal Court in Tolkien Estate Limited v Saltalamacchia [2016] FCA 944, where the estate of famous author J. R. R. Tolkien was awarded a smorgasbord of remedies for infringement of its copyright.

Copyright generally

Copyright is a statutory right under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) (‘the Act’) that protects certain forms of creative output, including the expression of ideas or information. Unlike patents or trade marks, copyright arises automatically; there is no requirement for any formal registration.

The bundle of rights that you receive under the Act depends on the type of copyright material that you own, whether that be art, literature, music, film, broadcasts, computer programs and the like.

Background to the case

In 1937 J. R. R. Tolkien released his fantasy novel named The Lord of the Rings. Set in a fictional world named “Middle-earth”, the novel is centred on the “One Ring”, a weapon that could be used to conquer and rule all of Middle-earth. As depicted below, the One Ring is inscribed with a language that was created by JRR Tolkien and known as “Black Speech”.

ONERING(‘the One Ring Inscription’)

Until the Federal Court handed down its judgment in August this year, the Respondent had been using several online platforms to sell gold rings bearing the One Ring Inscription.

Accordingly, Tolkien Estate Limited (‘the Estate’), the successor in title to J. R. R. Tolkien, brought an action against Alexander Saltalamacchia (‘the Respondent’) for infringing its copyright in One Ring Inscription.

The proceeding

In February and March this year the Estate issued several letters to the Respondent demanding that he stop selling the rings. After receiving no response to the letters, the Estate commenced proceedings.

At trial the Estate sought summary judgement on the basis that the Respondent had no reasonable prospect of successfully defending the proceeding. Justice Beach agreed with the Estate and found that the evidence (as summarised above) clearly demonstrated that the Respondent had infringed the Estate’s copyright.

It was undisputed that the Book is a literary or artistic work for the purposes of the Act, so the Court only had to consider the extent of the infringing conduct and the remedies that should be awarded to the Estate.

The Respondent argued that the inscription on his rings were not an exact replica of the One Ring Inscription because of a gap in the lettering. Justice Beach rejected this, noting that the law only requires the plaintiff to prove that the Respondent has reproduced a substantial part of its copyright.

Orders made

Justice Beach held that the Respondent infringed the Estate’s copyright by:

  1. Reproducing a substantial part of the One Ring Inscription;
  2. Selling rings bearing a reproduction of a substantial part of the One Ring Inscription;
  3. Offering for sale rings bearing a reproduction of a substantial part of the One Ring Inscription;
  4. Communicating a substantial part of the One Ring Inscription to the public; and
  5. Exhibiting by way of trade rings bearing a reproduction of a substantial part of the One Ring Inscription on www.ebay.com.au , www.ebay.co.uk, www.ebay.com and www.australianjewellerysales.com.

 
Accordingly, the Respondent was ordered to:

  1. Be permanently restrained from infringing the Estate’s copyright;
  2. Deliver up all material in his possession that infringed the Estate’s copyright;
  3. Pay damages or an account of profits to the Estate in an amount to be determined;
  4. Disclose all essential details relating to the sale of the infringing rings; and
  5. Pay the Estate’s costs in the proceeding.

 
Importance of the case

This case serves as a cautionary tale: the Respondent did not obtain from the Estate the consent or licence to use the One Ring Inscription, nor did he respond to infringement notices issued by the Estate.

Significant amounts of time and effort are invested in the creation of copyright material and it represents a valuable commodity to individuals and businesses. Accordingly, copyright owners can and will go to great lengths to enforce their intellectual property rights and seek a broad range of remedies where there is evidence of infringement.

Pointon Partners has extensive experience in copyright law and can assist with the protection, assignment, sale and licensing of copyright.

If you have any queries regarding copyright law or intellectual property more generally then please contact David Mazzeo or Lachlan Chisholm of our office on (03) 9614 7707.

Chemist Warehouse’s Claim For Misleading and Deceptive Conduct Dismissed

The recent decision in Verrocchi v Direct Chemist Outlet Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 104 by the Full Bench of the Federal Court of Australia (‘the FCA’) has clarified the protection afforded to the reputation of goods and services in circumstances where misleading or deceptive conduct is claimed to have arisen.

Background

Chemist Warehouse is a discount retail pharmacy chain that operates across Australia. The Chemist Warehouse chain was founded by Mario Verrocchi (‘Verrocchi’) who owns a significant number of the stores. Discount Chemist Outlet (‘DCO’) is another discount retail chemist chain which has been in direct competition with Chemist Warehouse for over eight years.

At first glance the two chains have a very similar get-up consisting of a bright yellow, blue and red colour palette, use of the words “discount chemist” and various slogans (see below).
CW

The proceedings

This case was an Appeal from the decision of Justice Middleton in the Federal Court of Australia (FCA), who had held that DCO was not liable for misleading and deceptive conduct pursuant to the Australian Consumer Law. At trial, Verrocchi had argued that:

  1. DCO had adopted a “substantially identical or deceptively similar” store get-up, causing consumers to believe that the two pharmacy chains were associated;
  1. DCO had failed to adequately distinguish itself from Chemist Warehouse and had intentionally copied various attributes of Chemist Warehouse; and
  1. As a result, consumers were likely to be misled or deceived.

 
The FCA Full Court upheld Justice Middleton’s decision, which rejected Verrocchi’s submissions in favour of DCO. In his Honour’s view:

  1. there was “insufficient uniformity in the visual branding devices” of Chemist Warehouse;
  1. there was “no sufficient common identity in the design and layout” between the two pharmacy chains; and
  1. DCO had sufficiently distinguished itself from Chemist Warehouse through, amongst other things, use of its own logo and lifestyle photos on its shopfront.

 
Principles of misleading and deceptive conduct

Whether conduct is misleading and deceptive is a matter of fact, considered in light of all the relevant circumstances. This means that when a Court looks at a product or service, the plaintiff cannot use one particular aspect of that product/service to establish that it is misleading or deceptive – it is a broad inquiry.

The question to be answered is whether the consumer will be, or is likely to be, misled or deceived, not merely whether it will cause them to wonder whether two products or services derive from the same trader. Where this inquiry concerns the use of a particular get-up, the Court arrives at the answer by assessing whether the goods or services have become distinctive of and associated with a particular trader by reason of their get-up.

Consistency & distinctiveness

The primary judge applied the above principles and considered all aspects of each pharmacy chain’s get-up to determine whether there was misleading or deceptive conduct. As such, it was said that each get-up consisted of three primary colours in combination with a red logo and various discount slogans.

Chemist Warehouse’s logo “Chemist Warehouse” was its main distinctive and consistently used branding element, but Verrocchi did not plead the logo as part of Chemist Warehouse’s get-up. So how else could Verrocchi establish that Chemist Warehouse had obtained a distinctive reputation by way of its get-up? He submitted that the Chemist Warehouse colour palette was a distinctive and consistently used branding element.

The FCA held that the Chemist Warehouse get-up lacked consistency of appearance across its range of more than 250 stores. It was said that, besides the logo, the only consistent aspect of the Chemist Warehouse get-up was the colour palette.

The colour palette in Chemist Warehouse’s get-up was used for visibility and to demonstrate discount quality. It was held that the functions of the primary colour palette could apply to any type of discount goods, not just pharmacy goods because various other industries use the primary colour palette to seek the attention of the public or to communicate that their products or services are at low prices. In other words, the Chemist Warehouse colour palette, specifically the use of the colour yellow, could not denote trade origin.

DCO distinguished from Chemist Warehouse

The FCA found that the distinguishable features of DCO’s get-up were its lifestyle photos that appear on each shopfront, the words “Discount Chemist”, relatively less signage clutter and the DCO logo (the words “Direct Chemist Outlet”). Further, it was difficult to find a high degree of similarity in get-up between the two chains because of the inconsistency of appearance in Chemist Warehouse stores.  Accordingly, it was said that DCO had sufficiently distinguished itself from Chemist Warehouse.

Deliberate copying

At trial the evidence showed that DCO had deliberately (but not fraudulently) copied Chemist Warehouse’s get-up. The Full Court of the FCA reiterated that evidence of deliberate copying will not necessarily constitute misleading and deceptive conduct: DCO had evinced an intention to copy, not an intention to mislead.

Significance of the case

When the Court was considering whether DCO had distinguished itself from Chemist Warehouse, consistency of appearance was a significant factor in the comparison of each get-up. Businesses that operate multiple stores must ensure that their get-up is sufficiently consistent across all stores if they wish to protect the appearance from adoption by a competitor.

In the pleadings, Verrocchi failed to include the words “Chemist Warehouse” as part of the get-up, and his later attempt to rectify the defect in his pleadings was rejected by the Full Court of the FCA. This omission could have been avoided by way of a more careful and considered approach to drafting the pleadings at trial.

We note that deliberate copying is not necessarily misleading and deceptive, since public policy deems certain aspects of a get-up (like the colour yellow) to be non-distinctive in the sense that it does not denote trade origin. The view of the Court was therefore that DCO’s adoption of the Chemist Warehouse colour scheme did not confuse consumers.

If you have any queries relating to misleading and deceptive conduct and trade mark law generally, please contact David Mazzeo or Lachlan Chisholm of our office on (03) 9614 7707.