Pointon Partners

Australian Trade Mark Register to Undergo International Harmonisation in 2024

On March 2024, Australia is set to replace its existing Goods and Services pick list with the Madrid Goods and Services list (“MGS list”). Our current pick list is a searchable list of over 60,000 descriptions of goods and services used to describe what goods and services a trade mark is used for. The MGS list is used by numerous international trade mark offices as well as the World Intellectual Property Organisation which is the system used for filing marks in other member countries, notably, the United States Patent and Trademark Office and the European Union Intellectual Property Office. As it stands, the MGS contains claims with significant specificity when compared to IP Australia’s Goods and Services list, which often results in irregularity issues when clients are seeking to file their mark internationally using their base Australia application/registration.

What is the MGS List?

The MGS list is a database of terms like the Australian pick list which is used to classify goods and services for international trade mark applications. As of July 2023, over 40 countries have adopted the list. The MGS list ensures that when applying for a mark in another country which also uses the list, you can check whether the country will accept your list of goods and services.

Benefits

This change offers several benefits to prospective Trade Mark owners in Australia and owners who intend to register their marks overseas. This includes:

Enhanced Compatibility of your Mark Globally

By using international standards of trade mark classification, the adoption of the MGS list will simplify global trade mark registration and assist clients with protection and enforcement of their marks in other jurisdictions.

Currently, clients may apply for trade mark registration either through WIPO or applying directly to a country’s trade mark office. If an application is done through WIPO, once the mark is registered in WIPO’s International Register, the mark will be examined in the designated country for protection which would take 12 to 18 months. Given the significant time frame that may be expected from registering through WIPO, especially when an applicant is applying for registration in various countries, any discrepancy in the application, such as through errors in the description of the mark due to differing classification standards, may result in an irregularity notice being sent and the application process being delayed.

Given numerous countries as well as WIPO employ the MGS list, this ensures that little to no errors arising from discrepancies between the description of the mark between Australia and the designated country will appear. Hence, clients may expect a more expedient process for international registration and faster enforcement of their mark in other jurisdictions.

Wider Array of Descriptions

The adoption of the MGS list is also useful for clients with descriptive marks following IP Australia’s October 2023 specificity requirements. As a reminder, descriptive marks are marks which describe the goods and services provided by the mark’s owner. For example, a soap selling business that uses the mark “SOAP” has a descriptive mark and under s41 of the Trade Marks Act 1995, that mark is not to any extent inherently adapted to distinguish. What prospective mark owners should take this to mean is that the mark is significantly harder to register. In its October 2023 publication, IP Australia requires where the mark is descriptive, there must be capacity to distinguish for particular goods/services.

“Applications proceeding despite being not to any extent inherently adapted to distinguish require a demonstrated capacity to distinguish for particular goods/services.  Therefore, the specification should be restricted to accord with the actual evidence of use.  A wider specification is not acceptable (Our Emphasis)”

Interestingly, the MGS list offers a wider array of goods and service description which are far more specific than the Australian Pick list. If an applicant engages in selling goods online, under the Australian Pick list, they would likely choose to register under online retail services. For the MGS list, the applicant would have to specify what their online retail services relate to. E.g. “online retail services in relation to ”.

As a result, according more specific descriptions will lead to an easier application process for applicants with descriptive marks given this will comply with IP Australia’s specificity requirements for marks not inherently adapted to distinguish.

Semantic Search Feature

Given a wider array of descriptions are offered in the MGS list, potential applicants may be worried that the application process will be more difficult given that there are more descriptions and it would be tougher to identify the correct description for their desired mark.

However, IP Australia will introduce a semantic search function to assist applicants to find terms on the new list which have a similar meaning to the term that they are looking for. This is in stark contrast to the current application process where applicants manually search for the correct descriptions in the pick list. As a result, this feature will simplify the application process and ensures that the correct description will be accorded to your mark.

Shortcomings?

It should be noted that there are shortcomings to the Nice Classification system which the MGS list uses. Critics have often cited its inability to accommodate emerging industries with their new types of goods and services. This will often lead to applicants finding it difficult to classify some of their goods or services as. While the Nice system is regularly updated every 5 years with the most recent edition coming out in 1 January 2023, the manner in which emerging industries have been classified has remained relatively stagnant resulting in some classes of goods/services encompassing a broad range of goods/services.

For example, class 9 of the Nice system includes apparatus for scientific purposes as well as audio-visual and information technology equipment and safety and life-saving equipment. Unusually, goods like diving equipment will be under the same classification as scientific apparatuses. Hence, it may be appropriate for the Nice system to be reformed such that its framework may better reflect new and emerging industries through the addition of new classes or some classes such as class 9 being split up. However, this issue was also present in Australia Goods and Service list which also uses the Nice Classification System as a framework for its structure.

Takeaway

Despite this, the transition seems to promise a more efficient, accurate and better recognised system to register marks. Further, this change will help businesses which are seeking to expand their operations overseas through simplifying the process in which marks may be applied for overseas. We believe that this is a step in the right direction as our system becomes more harmonised with international standards and welcome these changes.

If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact David Mazzeo or Stefano Mazzeo of our Intellectual Property Law Team.

A MOTHER-load of Oppositions: Energy Beverages Successfully Opposes Application for KANGAROO MOTHER

A recent Federal Court decision between the owners of the MOTHER Mark and Kangaroo Mother Australia provides guidance for prospective trade mark owners on what to consider before applying for a trade mark.

Background

Energy Beverages (EB) is a supplier of energy drinks for the Australian market, its MOTHER energy drink was launched by Coca-Cola in 2007 and subsequently acquired by EB in June 2015. The marks of concern for this case are 1230388 (388 Mark) and 1320799 (799 Mark) collectively known as the MOTHER Marks.

Kangaroo Mother Australia (KMA) is an Australian company incorporated in 2019. It has never traded. Erbaviva Natural Care (Erbaviva) assigned its application for registration of the KANGAROO MOTHER Mark to KMA on 10 March 2020.

EB opposed the registration of the KANGAROO MOTHER Mark by KMA before the Registrar’s delegate. However the delegate found that EB failed to establish any of its grounds of opposition. EB sought an appeal of the delegate’s decision on the following grounds:

Decision

Section 44 – Substantially Identical or Deceptively Similar

To establish this grounds, EB had to show that the KANGAROO MOTHER Mark was substantially identical with or deceptively similar to the MOTHER Marks in relation to similar goods or closely related services.

KMA had conceded that its registration of KANGAROO MOTHER in class 32 and 5 were of similar goods to the 388 and 799 Marks.

His Honour found that the MOTHER and KANGAROO MOTHER Mark were deceptively similar. In his reasoning, O’Callaghan J outlined that the test for deceptive similarity was whether there was a real risk that KMA’s use of the KANGAROO MOTHER Mark will cause a significant number of ordinary persons to wonder whether the products with the MOTHER and KANGAROO MOTHER marks come from the same source.

His Honour found that the MOTHER Mark was highly distinctive in the context of its registered goods, being non-alcoholic beverages. Hence, the addition of the word KANGAROO did not give the KANGAROO MOTHER Mark the ability to distinguish itself from the 388 and 799 Marks. The Court found that it is likely that consumers would confuse that products shown with the respective marks had come from the same source.

Section 59 – No intent to use

Section 59 provides a ground of opposition provided that the applicant had no intent to use the mark in relation to the goods specified in the application. It should be noted that given the subjective nature of intention, this ground is notoriously difficult to establish. This is further exacerbated by the Aston presumption which puts the onus of finding a lack of intention on EB.

However the evidence (or lack thereof) and arguments submitted by KMA and EB provided overwhelming reason to find that there was no intent to use by KMA. The following reasons provided by O’Callaghan J were decisive in finding there was no intent to use the KANGAROO MOTHER Mark:

Section 60 – Use likely to Deceive or Cause Confusion due to Reputation

Section 60 notes that the registration of a mark may be opposed on the basis that the use of the applicant’s mark would be apt to deceive or cause confusion. O’Callaghan J inferred that the MOTHER marks had a significant reputation in Australia due to its high volume of sales and significant market share in the Australian energy drink market. This was conceded by KMA.

His Honour also found that due to the reputation of the MOTHER Mark, it is likely that the KANGAROO MOTHER Mark would be apt to mislead due to its purported registration for breakfast cereal and other cereal descriptions. O’Callaghan J found that “a lot of people” would “interchange breakfast with an energy drink”. Further, the trade channels in which the MOTHER energy drinks would be distributed overlapped potentially with the KANGAROO MOTHER products which included supermarkets, retail chains, and convenience stores and petrol stations. Due to this, the court found that consumers would be given reason to wonder whether the products with the marks in question come from the same source.

Section 197 – Amendment Application by KMA

On the penultimate day of the hearing, KMA attempted to amend the class of goods in what they outlined was to narrow the issues in dispute and to inform the Court that they did not intend to press the specifications indicated in strikethrough as a matter of efficiency.

O’Callaghan J likened the power to amend an application under section 197 of the Trade Marks Act to section 105 of the Patents Act. As such the discretions in s 105 applied to 197. This required the court to assess:

Here, the evidence submitted by EB enabled the court to infer that the amendment application in respect of some of the classes of goods was to avoid the consequence of the principle that a failure in one of the classes of goods would mean the whole application failed as a whole. The application under s 197 was rejected.

Takeaways

It would be useful for owners to assess the market and trade channel in which their marks are going to be used in and whether their use would be apt to mislead or cause confusion to consumers.

If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact David Mazzeo or Stefano Mazzeo of our Intellectual Property Law Team.

“Artificial Intelligence – An Inventor quashed”

This is an update to the article below: “Artificial Intelligence: An Inventor?” in relation to the Federal Court of Australia (“FCA”) decision of Thaler v Commissioner of Patents on 30 July 2021, in which it was found that an artificial intelligence system called “DABUS” could be named as an inventor on a patent application for the purpose of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) (“Act”):

https://pointonpartners.com.au/artificial-intelligence-an-inventor/

The Commissioner of Patents appealed this decision, and on 13 April 2022, the Full Court of the Federal Court unanimously overturned the FCA’s decision and found that an artificial intelligence system could not be considered an “inventor” for the purposes of the Act and the Patent Regulations 1991 (Cth) (“Regulations”). 

Taking into account the statutory language of the Act and the Regulations, the structure and history of the Act, and policy objectives underlying the legislative scheme, the Full Court found that only a natural person could be an “inventor” for the purposes of the Act and the Regulations[1].

The appeal judgement also opened important policy debates as to the role of artificial intelligence in Australian patent law. A question raised by the Full Court was whether, as a matter of policy, a person who is an inventor should be redefined to include an artificial intelligence system. [2]

Dr Thaler subsequently applied for special leave to appeal to the Australian High Court. The application was dismissed on 11 November 2022 and it was held that “this is not the appropriate vehicle to consider the questions of principle sought to be agitated” by Dr Thaler.[3]

[1] [2022] FCAFC 62, [113][117].

[2] [2022] FCAFC 62, [119].

[3] [2022] HCATrans 199.

Businesses should think twice before using a shape mark

A recent Federal Court case illustrates why businesses should ensure that they are using their trademarks correctly when they are taking action against a third-party for trademark infringement.

In this case, the defendant was successful in their counterclaim alleging that the plaintiff had failed to use their shape mark properly.

Background

The Plaintiff, RB, owned two trademarks in Australia that are associated with the dishwashing brand, FINISH. These products prominently feature a red power ball in the centre. Please see below for your reference.

Finish Powder Capsule Finish Gelcap

The defendant, Henkel, is part of the global Henkel Group that sells a range of products including dishwashing goods. In or about April 2011, Henkel launched a new product line called the SE Gelcaps in Europe. Henkel sought to launch their new product line in Australia in August 2021, however RB obtained an interlocutory injunction stopping Henkel from selling the SE Gelcaps in Australia.

RB commenced proceedings against Henkel alleging trademark infringement, passing off and misleading and deceptive conduct. Henkel filed a counterclaimed that RB had not properly used the 914 mark and it should be removed from the Trademark Register.

914 Mark

Judgement

Rofe J found that RB had not properly used the 914 mark because its use on the Finish packaging did not designate the trade origin of the product. The use of the 914 mark was used to show what the product inside of the packaging looked like and not to show that it was a product of the Finish Brand. This role was given to the prominent use of the Finish Logo featured on all Finish products. The purpose of the 914 mark was to highlight the particular technical attributes of the tablets.

Finish Dishwashing Packaging Finish Logo

Rofe J referred to Kitto J’s decision in Shell Company of Australia Ltd v Esso Standard Oil (Australia) Ltd (1963) 109 CLR 407 of whether there has been use of a trademark. In that case, the test used was whether the use of the mark showed a connection between the product and the owner.

In applying this test, it became increasingly clear that the main image that was used to link the Finish product and RB (The Owner) was the use of the Finish logo prominently seen on top of all Finish products. The 914 mark merely played a secondary role in illustrating what the product looked like. It failed the test.

Takeaway

Businesses should take note of the following:

  1. Carefully consider whether you can rely on a shape mark to protect against infringement of your IP;
  2. If you are considering using a shape mark, ensure that the mark would be able to identify you as the owner rather than functioning as a way for customers to identify what the product looks like; and
  3. When alleging trademark infringement, consider whether you have used your trademark properly as noted in the Shell test above.

Meghan Markle & the Trade Mark ‘Archetypes’

As part of her contract with Spotify, Meghan Markle’s (Mrs. Markle) upcoming podcast has been highly anticipated. In preparation for its release, Mrs. Markle’s podcast company, Archewell Audio LLC, has filed an application in the United States to trade mark the title, ‘ARCHETYPES’.

If this application is successfully registered, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (‘USPTO’) indicates that there would be a legal presumption that the registrant owns the trade mark and has the right to use it in the U.S, in relation to the goods and services they have sought registration over[1]. In this instance, it would appear that this is in relation to media such as podcasts, audio recordings, television programs and entertainment services, ‘in the fields of cultural treatment of women and stereotypes facing women’[2].

Trade marking your brand name is common practice and is very beneficial. A registered trade mark not only protects your business by giving you the exclusive right to the use of the mark in the context of nominated goods or services but can also be a valuable marketing tool.

Having previously attempted to trade mark the words ‘Sussex Royal’ in the United Kingdom and ‘Archewell’ in the U.S., this is not uncharted territory for Mrs. Markle. However, this current U.S application may face challenges from existing applicants who have applied for or registered trademarks in the U.S containing this word. According to the USPTO trademark electronic search system, there are currently many active trade marks that include the word ‘Archetype’.

As the application was only filed in the U.S. on the 26th of March 2022, we are yet to see the outcome of this application and for now, we watch this space.

The team at Pointon Partners are well equipped and have extensive experience in assisting brands and individuals with obtaining trade mark registration as well as other intellectual property protections. If you need intellectual property advice, please do not hesitate to reach out to David Mazzeo, Felicity Cara-Carson or Stefano Mazzeo of our Intellectual Property Team on (03) 9614 7707.

[1] United States Patent and Trademark Office, Why register your trademark? (Web Page) https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/basics/why-register-your-trademark/.

[2] United States Patent and Trademark Office, US Trade Mark Application Number 97332048.

New ‘.AU’ domain name – Australian companies need to secure their online real-estate before 20 September 2022

The Priority Allocation Period (‘PAP’) commenced on 24 March and ends on 24 September 2022. As such, all Australian companies should be looking to secure their ‘.au’ domain name, by taking advantage of the six-month PAP for existing owners of domain names ending with ‘.com.au’, ’.net.au’ or ‘.org.au’.

At the conclusion of the PAP, the ‘.au’ will be released to the general public to purchase on a ‘first come, first serve’ basis, and unlike existing rules to obtain Australian domain names, the ‘.au’ does not require the registrant to have registered a company name, trust name, business trading name or trade mark which corresponds to the domain name. Registration prior to the conclusion of the PAP will also allow companies to avoid the opportunity for disputes to arise, however, should a dispute occur, the governing body, ‘.au Domain Administration’ (auDA)*, does have a dispute resolution policy for complainants in this regard.

It is important to note that current domains names ‘.com.au’, ‘.net.au’ and ‘.org.au’ will not be affected by any of changes with the introduction of the ‘.au’.

What is the new ‘.au’ domain, and how is it different?

As an example, an Australian florist business, ‘Wild Petal Florist’ currently own the following domain names:

With the introduction of the ‘.au’ domain, Wild Petal Florist is able to also secure ‘wildpetal.au’ and ‘wildpetalflorist.au’ during the PAP as it owns the ‘.com.au’ and ‘.net.au’ domain names.

However, if Wild Petal Florist does not register its interest in the ‘.au’ name during the PAP via an approved domain name provider, then its entitlement to the ‘.au’ domain name may be at risk, as anyone will be able to purchase it after the PAP ends on 24 September,2022.

What happens if two or more parties are interested in purchasing the same ‘.au’ domain name?

In this circumstance, let us assume the following:

  1. com.au is owned by Greenyarra Apples and was registered prior to 4 February 2018 (‘a’);
  2. net.au is owned by Greenyarra Butcher and was registered after 4 February 2018 (‘b’); and
  3. org.au is owned by Greenyarra Carwash and was registered after 4 February 2018 (‘c’).

If a, b and c all wish to apply for the same ‘.au’ domain, it will become a contested domain. When there is a contested domain, the following priority rules apply for which company will be given the .AU domain name:

The creation date of the domain name on which the application is based determines the priority category:

As a result, in this scenario, Greenyarra Apples would be given the opportunity to secure and purchase the ‘Greenyarra.au’ domain name

However, what happens if there are two Priority Category 1 applicants?:

  1. com.au is owned by Greenyarra Apples (Priority Category 1);
  2. net.au is owned by Greenyarra Butcher (Priority Category 1); and
  3. org.au is owned by Greenyarra Carwash (Priority Category 2).

In this scenario, Greenyarra Carwash will not be given an opportunity to own the domain name.

As such, Greenyarra Apples and Greenyarra Butcher will be left to negotiate an agreement between each other as to which party is to own the contested ‘.au’ domain name. If the parties cannot come to an agreement, then each party is required to pay an annual ‘priority hold’ fee to keep its application for the contested ‘.au’ domain interest alive, until there is only one applicant left.

As a result of this scenario, the contested ‘.au’ domain name will not be offered to either party to purchase until the matter is resolved.

What happens if all three parties are Priority Category 1 applicants?:

  1. com.au is owned by Greenyarra Apples (Priority Category 1);
  2. net.au is owned by Greenyarra Butcher (Priority Category 1); and
  3. org.au is owned by Greenyarra Carwash (Priority Category 1).

This scenario requires all three parties to negotiate who should own the contested ‘.au’ domain. If no agreement is reached between all parties involved, then the ‘.au’ domain will not be available for any party to own until there is only one party left still paying the annual ‘priority hold’ fee for the contested ‘.au’ domain name.

How can you see if the ‘.au’ domain you want has a priority hold?

On the auDA website, anyone can find out if a priority hold of a domain name has been applied for. In order to access this, one must simply go to https://www.auda.org.au/tools/priority-status-tool and type in the current domain name. This will then generate a report on the availability of the ‘.au’ domain, or state the name of the party that has requested a ‘priority hold.

Other take away points?

Even though it is important for a business to secure its ‘.au’ domain name, it is arguable that it is far more important for a business to also ensure that it owns a registered trade mark for its brand.

Whilst domain names are critical to own, as they are an inexpensive method of owning online real-estate, they do not provide the registrant with any legal brand protection. Trade mark registration, however, provides the registered trade mark owner with legal rights under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) and provides the trade mark owner with valuable monopoly rights over the brand name and/or image.

For more information regarding the new ‘.au’ domain names or any trade mark enquiries, please feel free to contact the team at Pointon Partners.

References:

*.au Domain Administration Limited (auDA) is a not for profit organisation that works with a range of stakeholders including industry, government and the Australian and international community to develop and administer the rules for domains in the .au country code Top Level Domain (ccTLD).

WHAT MAKES A CERTIFICATION TRADE MARK AND WHY IS IT DIFFERENT TO A STANDARD TRADE MARK? What

One of the most important aspects of a consumer buying a product or engaging a service is knowing that it meets a certain standard. One way that can assist brands to communicate that their products or services are of a high standard is potentially by the use of a certification mark.

In Australia, a certification mark is a guarantee that a product or service meets a set of standards that are enforceable upon the owner of the mark. As such, it’s an effective way of building customer trust and guaranteeing quality in a product or service. A certification mark is obtained by way of an application made to IP Australia (the body that administers intellectual property rights for patents, trade marks, registered designs and plant breeder’s rights in Australia) however, unlike a standard trade mark, the Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (ACCC) is also part of the application process. As a result, there are additional rules and guidelines involved in a certification mark, and therefore it may be seen to be more trusted in the eyes of consumers.

The main differences between a standard trade mark and a certification trade mark are as follows:

  1. A standard trade mark must be distinctive and not descriptive, whereas, a certification mark can be descriptive so long as there is not an existing registered mark that is the same or similar to the certification mark;
  2. The owner of a standard trade mark must use their mark in relation to the goods and/or services they have sought registration for. If the standard trade mark owner does not use their mark, they may be subject to a non-use proceeding being filed against them, which can result in their mark being revoked. Conversely, the owner of a certification mark may not have to show that they have used their certification mark, and instead are able to rely on 3rd party use; and
  3. As mentioned previously, a standard trade mark is examined by IP Australia’s examiners, whereas, a certification mark will also be examined by the ACCC to ensure the certification rules are fair and that there is an audit process to make sure that the certification rules are adhered to.

Well-known certification mark in Australia

The “Australian Made” logo is one of the most recognised and trusted certification trade marks for manufacturers and producers of Australian made goods. The logo was created by the Australian Government in 1986 to promote Australian made products and export markets. As a result of its certification status, the logo communicates to consumers in Australia and overseas that goods showing this logo have met particular requirements to described as specifically a product can be described as ‘Australian made’ or ‘made in Australia’ if it underwent its last substantial transformation in Australia.

Other trusted certification mark examples include:

Certification mark standards must be upheld

As previously stated, a standard trade mark must be consistently used in marketing and business activities in order to maintain active protection by the owner. Common advice regarding a trademark is that you must use it, or risk losing it.

A certification mark functions in the opposite way. The owner of a certification mark grants permission for others to use it, provided they meet the rules and standards laid out.

For this reason, a certification mark must be earned, and is not handed out to anyone who applies as it could lead to the loss of reputation of the mark.

One example of this is the National Heart Foundation’s “Approved Tick” of approval.

This logo was provided to food products that met the Foundation’s criteria for healthy food choices—with an emphasis on low trans-fats and salt content. At the time of filing, this trade mark was owned by the National Heart Foundation of Australia (the Foundation). At the time, the Foundation aimed to promote the development and sale of foods consistent with healthier eating and as a result, achieve improvements in public health.

Introduced in 1989, this logo became known across Australia as a way of determining the nutritional value food items, the campaign ran for 26 years until controversy arose between 2007 and 2011, when fast-food chain McDonald’s was given approval to use this mark. As a result, the public’s perception of this certification mark as promoting healthy food seemed to waiver, as the view was taken that McDonald’s were using this mark to promote the idea that fast food was aligned with healthier eating, and the argument was made that this was not the case by consumers. Despite this, however, it turned out to be the case that the fast-foods that were granted the certification mark status did meet the standards laid out by the certification mark, however McDonalds also paid $300,000 to the organisation for the privilege. The justification for this, at the time, was that McDonalds had introduced healthier oils within its Fillet-o-Fish and the McChicken burgers so as to enable it to comply with the certification mark requirements.

However, it despite the above, it has been suggested that the Heart Foundation certification mark lost its credibility as a result of this conduct, and was ultimately retired in 2015 and replaced by the government operated health star rating system.

The process of applying for a certification mark is highly detailed and, as a result, it is advisable to seek the assistance of a registered Trade Marks Attorney or Legal Practitioner.

The team at Pointon Partners are experienced with all intellectual property matters, including certification trade marks.

If you need intellectual property advice or are interested in understanding whether a certification mark is right for you or your business, please do not hesitate to reach out to Binh Rey, David Mazzeo or the Intellectual Property Team on (03) 9614 7707.

Resources:

Handbook: Certification Trade Marks -The role of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC)

http://docreader.readspeaker.com/docreader/?jsmode=1&cid=btass&lang=en_au&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.accc.gov.au%2Fsystem%2Ffiles%2FCertification%2520Trade%2520Marks_0.pdf&v=Google%20Inc

NFT’s and your Intellectual Property Rights

NFT’s are all the rage right now. These three letters are virtually inescapable and the monetary value being attached to some are eye watering, to say the least. However, with the rise of this new wave token also comes the need to consider the issues that may arise with it, in particular, in respect of intellectual property rights.

The concept of ‘digital art’ is not a novel concept, it is, in fact, an area which sees continual growth and expansion every time there are significant developments in technology. For example, one of Australia’s highest selling digital artworks is Shaun Gladwell’s “Storm Sequence” which sold as a DVD for $84,000.00 at Sotheby’s in 2007 (see an example of this work in the video below). Comparatively, with NFT’s being the newest iteration of ‘digital art’ the fees they are attracting are soaring to new heights, and it has certainly caught the world’s attention.

What is an NFT?

As opposed to digital assets, which are considered as ‘fungible’ (such as crypto currencies like Bitcoin), non-fungible tokens (NFT’s for short) are assets which are deemed to be ‘non-fungible’, such that, unlike a Bitcoin which can be exchanged for another identical Bitcoin, a NFT is not able to be exchanged for an exact copy.

Accordingly, NFT’s can comprise of anything which is digital, but for the most part, this tech is primarily used for the purchase and sale of digital art. As such, an NFT’s authenticity is certified via block chain, and majority of NFT’s are legered using the Ethereum block chain.

NFT’s vs Intellectual Property Rights

NFT’s operate independently of intellectual property rights (‘IP Rights’), and as such, their relationship to IP Rights owners seems to be a topic of confusion, as the interplay between IP Rights and NFT’s is somewhat unclear. It must be noted that an NFT of a work (whatever that may be) does not mean that its creator, or any subsequent owner of the NFT of the work, will actually own any underlying IP Rights in the work that is the subject of the NFT. As such, the NFT owner does not own the copyright which is the subject of the NFT, nor does it own anything physical in relation to the subject of the NFT, it simply owns the NFT itself.

Accordingly, in order for the owner of an NFT to actually own the underlying IP Rights of the NFT in question, they would need to obtain an assignment or licence from the creator or owner of the work itself, which is the subject of the NFT. Should such rights be sought, the owner could seek to impose limitations and/or constraints on the rights being given in this regard, just as would be the case under any typical assignment or licence agreement. Accordingly, a purchaser of an NFT should be aware that the owner or creator of the underlying work still owns all IP Rights in the work, and is still able to assign and licence those rights, whilst also being able to impose limitations on the NFT purchaser.

An example of the above is provided by the NBA, who have made various NFT’s which can be purchased and sold on its ‘TOP-SHOT’ marketplace. Should you wish to purchase one of these NFT’s, in addition to various other constraints, you are not permitted any rights to alter the footage or sell merchandise, without first obtaining the NBA’s prior written consent. Should these terms be breached, the NBA reserves the right to remove your NFT from its app without giving any notice to the NFT owner.

However, despite the above, whilst the NFT market can be constrained by the IP Rights owner, this could also see the rise of NFT’s being sold together with unlimited IP rights from the IP Rights owner, which could, in turn, see these types of NFT’s take on even higher prices.

An example of this has been somewhat realised by artist Damien Hirst, who announced his foray into NFT’s with his initiative titled “The Currency” in association with HENI. The Currency by Damien Hirst involved the sale of 10,000 unique hand-painted dot paintings, each one corresponding to a NFT – however – the purchase of these works came with the stipulation that purchasers would have one year to decide whether they would keep the NFT or the physical artwork. If the purchaser so decided to retain the NFT, the physical artwork would be destroyed, if the purchaser decided to retain the physical artwork, they would therefore relinquish all rights to the blockchain-based artwork. To date, reports state that The Currency has made in excess of 26 million USD in respect of NFT sales.

Where to from here?

It would seem that the more mainstream NFT’s become, the more they need to be considered in all aspects of IP Rights. Accordingly, it is something that all IP Rights owners should now be considering in their agreements, when creating new works, and assigning or licensing rights.

Pointon Partners is very experienced in advising IP Rights creators and can assist all IP Rights holders in this regard. Should you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact David Mazzeo or Stefano Mazzeo .

Artificial Intelligence – An Inventor?

In a sign of the times, the Federal Court of Australia (“FCA”) has recently considered whether an artificial intelligence machine is capable of being an “inventor” for the purposes of  the Australian Patents Act 1990 (Cth) (“Act”) and corresponding Regulations.

On 30 July 2021 in the decision of Thaler v Commissioner of Patents[1], the FCA overturned a finding by the Deputy Commissioner of Patents of the Australian Patents Office (IP Australia) that the inventor on a patent application must be human and that the artificial intelligence system referred to could not be an inventor[2].

Instead, the FCA held that an artificial intelligence system called “DABUS” which was developed by Dr Stephen Thaler, and was described as being a “….device for the autonomous bootstrapping of unified sentience” could be named as an inventor on a patent application for the purposes of the Act.

The Court noted that Dr Thaler was the owner of the copyright in DABUS’s source code, and was also the owner, was responsible for and was the operator of the computer on which DABUS operated.  The alleged inventor however referred to in the actual patent application was “DABUS” which also specified that “the invention was autonomously generated by an artificial intelligence”.

The Court found that the term “inventor” in the Act is not limited to human inventors, and can be “an artificial intelligence system or device”, however the Court did note that “such a non-human inventor can neither be an applicant for a patent nor a grantee of a patent”.

It is important to note that the Commissioner of Patents has however decided to appeal the Federal Court’s decision, and so for now we watch this space.

If you wish to discuss matters relating to this article or in relation to protecting your intellectual property rights, then please feel free to contact Felicity Cara-Carson or David Mazzeo on (03) 9614 7707.

[1] Thaler v Commissioner of Patents [2021] FCA 879

[2] Stephen L. Thaler [2021] APO 5 (9 February 2021)

Kim Kardashian-West in Trade Mark Dispute over “SKKN”

The ‘KK’ moniker is one that is very well known, especially with the rise of social media. Mrs. Kim Kardashian-West (‘Mrs. Kardashian-West’) has dominated the world over, and it would seem that everything Mrs. Kardashian-West touches, turns to gold – whether that be tech, cosmetics, or shapewear. Nevertheless, it would now appear that her newest foray is seeing her expansion into skincare.

There have been a number of recent global trade mark filings by Mrs. Kardashian-West’s IP Holding entity for the word marks, “SKKN” and “SKKN BY KIM” which claim a number of classes. This coincides with her recent announcement to pull back from KKW Beauty and to relaunch this in due course.

However, it would seem that not all is smooth sailing, as recent news articles report that these “SKKN” filings have become the subject of cease and desist letters from Beauty Concepts LLC (‘Beauty Concepts’), who claim that they used the trade mark “SKKN+” in the USA prior to Mrs. Kardashian-West and as early as 2018. Furthermore, it also appears that Beauty Concepts claim to have applied to register their trademark for “SKKN+” only a few days prior to Mrs. Kardashian-West’s filing dates.

The news articles outline that the parties are in discussions to mediate this matter, and further developments are yet to come to light. However, with that being said, a review of the Australian Trade Marks Register also shows that the application for “SKKN BY KIM” has received its first filing report.

The team at Pointon Partners are well versed in dealing with all types of trade mark disputes, and assisting clients in overcoming citations and filing reports from the Trade Marks Office. If you need intellectual property advice, please do not hesitate to reach out to David Mazzeo, Felicity Cara-Carson or Stefano Mazzeo of our Intellectual Property Team on (03) 9614 7707.