Employment Law Information Webinar – Employment Law 2021
Our Employment Team hosted a webinar on Thursday 2 Sepetember 2021 which covered the following topics:
– Employee Mandatory Vaccination Policies – The Issues.
– Casual Employment in light of the High Court decision in Workpac v Rossato.
The webinar was recorded, should you want to watch please click on the link below:
https://us06web.zoom.us/rec/share/JPo-22-0W-jEj9p3zrdxDwWhYuJFEy9r8UbVIwuv1emg8Qvts-rMB5GUV0FzWAQ.goMxbCorhyinZgiD
Password: XEr$H4I9 (please manually type in password)
The High Court to determine whether truck drivers were employees or independent contractors
The decision handed down in Jamsek v ZG Operations Australia Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 119 (Jamsek) is set to be heard by the High Court, as the next in a recent slew of employment matters being decided at the highest level.
Pointon Partners wrote about the original decision of the Full Federal Court, which involved two truck drivers who were found to be employees despite being engaged pursuant to independent contractor agreements for nearly 40 years.
The Jamsek appeal is slated to begin on 31 August 2021 and the High Court’s decision is likely to have a significant impact on the way in which businesses engage contractors. This is the first time that the High Court has been asked to determine an employee v contractor dispute since Hollis v Vabu Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 21 (Hollis v Vabu).
Importantly, the High Court also recently handed down a decision in WorkPac v Rossato & Ors [2021] HCA 23 (WorkPac v Rossato), which gave employers greater certainty in the realm of casual employment, by confirming that the characterisation of an employee as a casual is to be determined with reference to the employment contract.
Up until WorkPac v Rossato, the Courts have traditionally looked at the substance (rather than the contractual form) of the working relationship when determining whether an individual is a casual or permanent employee.
Significantly for the parties in Jamsek, this is consistent with the approach generally adopted by the Courts since Hollis v Vabu when asked to assess whether a person is an employee or an independent contractor at law. The Courts would examine the “totality of the relationship” between the parties, with the contract being relevant consideration, but not determinative in its own right.
It remains to be seen whether the High Court will reconsider Hollis v Vabu in light of the approach in WorkPac v Rossato. Although this seems undesirable from a policy perspective, Jamsek is likely to be the final word in employee v contractor considerations and may require businesses to review their existing contractor agreements and arrangements to mitigate the risk of suits or claims.
Pointon Partners will provide an update following the decision being handed down and have a wealth of knowledge and experience across employment and independent contracting matters.
Please don’t hesitate to contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Ben Drysdale of our Employment Law team to discuss.
Can you direct your employees to get vaccinated?
The landscape around mandatory vaccines has shifted since March 2021 when we discussed this topic in our Employment Law webinar. As numerous States and Territories battle outbreaks of the Delta variant of COVID-19 and Australia’s vaccination program is being rolled out the Fair Work Ombudsman has issued new advice for employers considering making the Covid vaccine mandatory for their employees.
The updated advice from the Ombudsman released last week replaced previous advice that most employers would not be able to require their employees to get the Covid vaccine.
The Ombudsman has set out a four-tier system to determine when it would be reasonable for an employer to compel their employees to get the Covid vaccine.
As we discussed at our webinar in March employers can direct their employees to be vaccinated if the direction is lawful and reasonable. Whether a direction is lawful and reasonable will be assessed on the individual facts on a case-by-case basis. For a direction to be lawful, it needs to comply with any employment contract, award or agreement, and any Commonwealth, state or territory law that applies (for example, an anti-discrimination law).
Factors that influence the reasonableness of a direction include: the nature of the workplace, community transmission, the effectiveness of vaccines, work health and safety obligations, employees’ circumstances, employees’ reasons for refusing vaccination and vaccine availability.
The Ombudsman has divided work into four broad tiers:
- Tier 1 work, where employees are required as part of their duties to interact with people with an increased risk of being infected with coronavirus (for example, employees working in hotel quarantine or border control);
- Tier 2 work, where employees are required to have close contact with people who are particularly vulnerable to the health impacts of coronavirus (for example, employees working in health care or aged care);
- Tier 3 work, where there is interaction or likely interaction between employees and other people such as customers, other employees or the public in the normal course of employment (for example, stores providing essential goods and services); and
- Tier 4 work, where employees have minimal face-to-face interaction as part of their normal employment duties (for example, where they are working from home).
The Ombudsman has noted that the coronavirus pandemic doesn’t automatically make it reasonable for employers to direct employees to be vaccinated against the virus. A workplace may have a mix of employees, with different employees performing work in different tiers, all of which could change over time.
The Ombudsman has declared that it is more likely to be reasonable to require vaccination for tier one work, where employees are in contact with people at risk from coronavirus such as airline crew, or in tier two, where they work with vulnerable people, such as aged care. For tier three work that involves interaction with the public, employers may be able to require vaccination but this is more likely to be reasonable if there is community transmission. Finally for tier four work with minimal face-to-face interaction an employer’s direction to its employees to get the vaccine is unlikely to be reasonable given the limited risk of transmission.
It is important for employers to be cognisant of the fact that regardless of the tier/s that may apply to the work performed by its employees, the reasonableness of a direction will always be fact dependent and must be assessed on a case-by-case basis. This will require careful analysis of all relevant factors applicable to that individual workplace, the employees and the type of work performed. The Ombudsman has urged employers to get their own legal advice if they are considering making vaccinations mandatory for their employees. Pointon Partners is able to provide such advice.
The Ombudsman has also announced that if an employer has provided a lawful and reasonable direction to be vaccinated for coronavirus and an employee complies, the employer can also ask the employee to provide evidence of their vaccination.
An employer may ask to view evidence of an employee’s vaccination status without raising privacy obligations provided they do not collect (i.e. make a record or keep a copy of) this information. An employer should not collect vaccination status information from an employee unless the employee consents and the collection is reasonably necessary for the employer’s functions and activities.
If you have any queries regarding any issues relating to mandating vaccinations please don’t hesitate to contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Ben Drysdale of our Employment Law team.
Casual Employment – High Court upholds Workpac Appeal
Last week in the case of Workpac v Rossato the High Court unanimously upheld the appeal of the employer Workpac and ruled that the employee in question was a casual employee.
In several related decisions delivered by the Federal Court since 2018 it had been held that:
- the employee working in the mining industry on shift arrangements determined well in advance was a permanent employee and entitled to the type of entitlements enjoyed by permanent employees such as annual leave; and
- the employer was not entitled to offset the casual loadings it had paid the employee against the annual leave and other entitlements.
The High Court took the view that the fact that shifts may have been set well in advance was not of itself determinative of whether the relationship was that of permanent employment. Nor was the fact that the employment had become relatively systematic and continuous. Indeed the High Court regarded each of the shifts as separate assignments and not an advance commitment of ongoing work. Further, the High Court considered that the Federal Court had placed too little weight on the fact that the parties had contractually agreed that the relationship was that of casual employment.
In March of this year in response to the Federal Court decision the Commonwealth Government had amended the Fair Work Act to create a new statutory and retrospective definition of casual employment and which is similar in many respects to the view of casual employment expressed by the High Court. Under the legislation an employee will be classified as a casual if an offer of employment gives no firm advance commitment to regular work. And in determining whether the offer of employment makes no firm advance commitment of regular work the matters to take into account are as follows:
- whether the employee can elect to accept or reject work;
- whether the employee will work as required according to the needs of the employer;
- whether the employment is described as casual employment; and
- whether the employee will receive a casual loading.
The legislation stipulates that the question of whether or not an employee is a casual employee is assessed on the basis of the offer of employment not on the basis of any subsequent conduct of either party.
The legislation also introduced an obligation on employers (other than small businesses with less than fifteen staff) to offer permanent employment to casuals with at least 12 months employment if they had been working a regular pattern of hours. A six month transitional period was provided for but which expires on 27 September 2021. Employers will need to comply with their obligation to offer permanent employment by this date unless they have “reasonable business grounds” not to do so.
Take away points for employers
- review your casual employment contracts to ensure they meet the tests stipulated in the legislation.
- ensure compliance with any obligations under the legislation to offer permanent employment to casuals by the looming deadline of 27 September 2021.
If you have any queries regarding any issues relating to casual employment please don’t hesitate to contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Ben Drysdale of our Employment Law team.
Changes to Unfair Dismissal Regime – Sexual harassment now specifically amounts to “serious misconduct”
As from 10 July 2021, amendments to the Fair Work Regulations have had the effect of explicitly categorising sexual harassment as “serious misconduct” for the purposes of the unfair dismissal laws. Other defined pre-existing grounds included theft, fraud or assault.
This amendment was in response to The Respect @ Work Report and associated recommendations by Sex Discrimination Commissioner Kate Jenkins. The amendment is designed to reflect and signal that sexual harassment is a serious matter and assist employers in being able to quickly remove perpetrators of sexual harassment from the workplace. A number of employer groups had publicly agitated for this amendment on the basis that previously there may have a degree of uncertainty on the part of employers regarding whether sexual harassment fell within the general concept of serious misconduct. The amendment should therefore provide greater clarity for employers as well as enhancing workplace safety.
Employers should be aware though that they will still need to comply with the rules of procedural fairness when undertaking the termination of an employee who is said to have engaged in sexual harassment. This includes:
- undertaking a thorough investigation;
- putting the allegations in writing to the employee;
- giving the employee adequate time and opportunity to consider the allegations;
- allowing the employee to respond to the allegations in a meeting with the employer;
- allowing the employee to have a support person present at such meeting.
If you have any queries regarding the above please don’t hesitate to contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Ben Drysdale of our Employment Law team.
Unfair Dismissal – Increase in High Income Threshold
Given that we have now ticked over into a new financial year, we thought it worthwhile making you aware of the new high income threshold for unfair dismissal purposes. It has increased from $153,600 to $158,500 in respect of dismissals taking place on or after 1 July 2021. Employees earning above this amount are ineligible to bring an unfair dismissal claim unless they can show that a modern award or enterprise agreement applies to them (which is not that common in respect of employees on that level of remuneration).
In terms of what is taken into account in assessing whether an employee is earning above the high income threshold of $158,500 the following are not included:
- Compulsory superannuation contributions.
- Commissions
- Bonuses; and
- Other incentives that cannot be determined in advance.
If you have any queries regarding the unfair dismissal regime or termination of employment generally feel free to contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Ben Drysdale of our Employment Law team.
Employment Law Information Webinar – Employment Law 2021
Our Employment Team hosted a webinar on Wendesday 9 June 2021 which covered the following topics:
– Working from home: The changing landscape and the importance of policies
– Protecting your business from former employees: A refresher on restraint of trade and confidentiality obligations.
The webinar was recorded, should you want to watch please click on the link below:
https://pointonpartnerspoc.sharefile.com/d-s24ef02fa2d36439591fa11ccb2b28bb1
Employment Law Information Webinar – Casual Employment Law Changes- What does it mean to you?
Our Employment Team presented a Webinar on 15 April 2021 on Casual Employment Law Changes – What does it mean for you?
It covered the following topics:
– New Legislative definition of Casual Employee
– New rules to prevent double dipping of entitlements
– Obligations on Employers to offer certain casuals permanent employment.
The webinar was recorded, should you want to watch please click on the link below and enter the passcode:
Topic: Casual Employment Law Changes – What does it mean for you?
Start Time : Apr 15, 2021 12:21 PM
Meeting Recording:
https://us06web.zoom.us/rec/share/UIuFzT8HdbPJBlp3tBTqTARjUcQTfwLNlgeJTJCEOhBooUDfw4gLD5Jry71dwNEn.gp9aFdBa2oIyPYC3
Please note that if accessing the above link on a computer, please manually type the passcode rather then copy and paste.
Employment Law Information Webinar – Employment Law 2021 – The Challenges
Our Employment Team presented a Webinar on 11 March 2021 on Employment Law 2021 – The Challenges. It covered the following topics:
– COVID Vaccinations and the Workplace – Can you direct your employees to get vaccinated?
– JobKeeper Subsidy Scheme & JobKeeper Directions End 28 March 2021 – What to do next?
The webinar was recorded, should you want to watch please click on the link below and enter the passcode:
Topic: Webinar – Employment Law 2021 – The Challenges
Date: Mar 11, 2021 12:13 PM Canberra, Melbourne, Sydney
https://pointonpartners.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/GMT20210311-013028_Webinar-_640x360.mp4
Meeting Recording:
https://us06web.zoom.us/rec/share/0IflszskEOUOL6X18dSTzOcv2fgVLvhooY_o4F2FhwQ17_hAOu-jJoC0XRwAjBPK.Zj5YIIF3r1lp6JhQ
Access Passcode: cnu64@p*
Please note that if accessing the above link on a computer, please manually type the passcode rather then copy and paste.
Sexual Harassment & the Workplace
Amid recent growing debate over what many have described as a toxic culture for women working in Parliament House, questions are being raised about how other Australian workplaces are handling reports of sexual harassment and assault.
A national survey by the Australian Human Rights Commission in 2018 found 33 per cent of respondents reported experiencing workplace sexual harassment.
Disturbingly, however, the majority did not formally report their experience or seek support or advice, “with many victims believing a formal complaint would be viewed as an overreaction or that it was easier to stay quiet”.
Almost two in five women (39 per cent) and one in four men (26 per cent) reported experiencing sexual harassment in the workplace in the five years prior.
What is sexual harassment?
As outlined in Section 92(1) of the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (the Act), a person sexually harasses another person if he or she:
- makes an unwelcome sexual advance, or an unwelcome request for sexual favours, to the other person, or
- engages in any other unwelcome conduct of a sexual nature in relation to the other person in circumstances in which a reasonable person, having regard to all the circumstances, would have anticipated that the other person would be offended, humiliated or intimidated.
Work-related sexual harassment
Work-related sexual harassment is sexual harassment (as described above) directed at a person, that can happen at work, work related events, or between people sharing the same workplace. Work-related sexual harassment isn’t always obvious, repeated or continuous and can be physical, verbal or written.
It can be a one-off incident and can involve unwanted or unwelcome touching, staring or leering, suggestive comments or jokes, sexually explicit pictures or posters, repeated invitations to go out on dates, requests for sex, intrusive questions about a person’s private life or body, unnecessary contact such as deliberately brushing up against a person, insults or taunts based on sex or gender, sexually explicit physical contact and sexually explicit emails, text messages or social media activity.
Work-related gendered violence and the law
Employers, employees and others have specific duties relating to work-related gendered violence (including work-related sexual harassment) under the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (OHS Act) and the Act.
Work-related gendered violence is any behaviour, directed at any person, or that affects a person, because of their sex, gender or sexual orientation, or because they do not adhere to socially prescribed gender roles, that creates a risk to health and safety.
Work-related gendered violence can also be experienced indirectly. A person may experience gendered violence not targeted specifically at them (such as overhearing a conversation that affects them) or witness violence directed at someone else.
Types of work-related gendered violence can range in severity from comments and gestures, through to sexual assault and rape. It can include stalking, intimidation or threats, verbal abuse, ostracism or exclusion, sexually explicit gestures, offensive language and imagery, put downs, innuendo and insinuations, being undermined in your role or position, sexual harassment (as noted above) or sexual assault or rape.
Acts such as indecent exposure, stalking, sexual assault and obscene or threatening communications (for example phone calls, letters, emails, text messages and posts on social networking sites) may also be offences under criminal law and victims may choose to report criminal offences to the police.
Employer Duties
Under the OHS Act, employers must provide and maintain a work environment that is safe and without risk to the health of their employees (including independent contractors), so far as is reasonably practicable.
Employers must eliminate risks to health and safety so far as is reasonably practicable. If it is not reasonably practicable to eliminate the risks they must be reduced so far as is reasonably practicable.
Employers must provide and maintain safe systems of work, and give employees the necessary information, instruction, training or supervision to do their job safely and without risks to health.
Where there is a risk of work-related sexual harassment causing physical or mental injury, employers have an obligation under the OHS Act to control that risk. This obligation is in addition to the obligation of employers under the Act.
Work-related gendered violence may constitute sexual harassment, unlawful discrimination or victimisation (treating someone adversely because they have made, or may make, a complaint) under the Act.
Under the Act employers have a duty not to engage in discrimination or sexual harassment and to take reasonable steps to eliminate these behaviours.
An individual who discriminates against or sexually harasses another person in the workplace can be held responsible, and therefore legally liable, for their behaviour.
Employers can also be held legally responsible for acts of discrimination or sexual harassment by their employees or agents if they occur in the workplace, or in connection with a person’s employment. This is known as vicarious liability.
Preventing sexual harassment and work-related gendered violence
Prevention involves:
- identifying the hazards and assessing the risks;
- implementing measures to eliminate or control the risks; and
- reviewing the effectiveness of control measures to ensure they are working, and improving them where needed.
At the very least every business should ensure that they have policies for staff and a complaints procedure in place.
In addition it is the responsibility of the employer to ensure that staff have adequate training on sexual harassment and understand the policies and procedures.
Any complaints made by an employee should be treated seriously and handled in accordance with the complaints procedure in a timely manner. Employers should also review existing policies and procedures periodically to make sure they are up to date and accessible.
An employer that complies with all of the above is more likely to be able to demonstrate they have fulfilled their positive duty under the Act to provide a safe workplace and to take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment at work. Employers that are not proactive also risk serious financial consequences and reputational risk to their business.
Please contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman on (03) 9614 7707 to discuss.