Employers bear the onus to prevent sexual harassment under new legislation
In June 2018, the Sex Discrimination Commissioner, Kate Jenkins, and then Minister for Women, the Hon Kelly O’Dwyer, announced a National Inquiry into Sexual Harassment in Australian Workplaces to examine the prevalence, nature, drivers and reporting of sexual harassment, current legal and regulatory framework, and the impact of sexual harassment on individuals and business, as well as ways to improve prevention and response.
In March 2020, the Australian Human Rights Commission released the Respect @Work: Sexual Harassment National Inquiry Report (Report). The Report made 55 recommendations directed to all levels of government and the private sector for policy and legislative reforms to prevent and address workplace sexual harassment. The release of the Report in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic did not result in the immediate widespread coverage of the proposed reforms.
So far, Victoria is the only jurisdiction to have a positive duty for employers to prevent sexual harassment under the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic). Last month, the Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission revealed the results of its first compliance investigation, targeting bakery chain Bakers Delight chosen not in response to an incident of sexual harassment but because of the recognition that bakeries, like many other retail environments, can be a high-risk workplace for sexual harassment, particularly for women and casual workers.
The Federal Government has expressed its commitment to imposing a nationwide positive duty on employers to specifically prevent sexual harassment in the workplace and on 27 September 2022 it introduced the Anti-Discrimination and Human Rights Legislation Amendment (Respect at Work) Bill 2022 (Bill) which seeks to give effect to seven outstanding recommendations from the Report by amending the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) (SDA).
The Bill will:
- Place a positive duty on employers to take all reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate sex discrimination, sexual harassment and victimisation, as far as possible.
The meaning of ‘all reasonable and proportionate measures’ will vary depending on the size and circumstances of a business. Businesses will have 12 months to understand their new obligations and implement any necessary changes before compliance and enforcement will commence.
In anticipation of these changes, employers should move towards a preventative model, and prepare to operate as though they have a positive duty to ensure that their workplace is free of all forms of discrimination, harassment and victimisation. Employers should look to review their internal practices by:
- ensuring all staff including managers and human resources understand what constitutes discrimination, harassment and victimisation;
- developing and implementing updated policies and procedures that include a prevention plan;
- conducting training and education which communicate updated policies and procedures including awareness around the new inclusion of not subjecting someone to a hostile work environment (see further at point 3 below);
- conducting regular risk assessments to identify the likelihood of discrimination and harassment occurring and taking necessary steps to eliminate or control any risk factors;
- developing a complaints procedure that ensures complaints are dealt with promptly and efficiently; and
- frequently reviewing the workplace culture, policies and procedures and making proactive changes where required.
- Strengthen the Australian Human Rights Commission (Commission) with new functions to monitor, assess and enforce compliance with the new positive duty.
This includes the capacity to give compliance notices to employers who are not meeting their obligations, the power to conduct inquiries and enter enforceable undertakings with business.
The Commission will also have the power to commence an action against an employer to address unlawful discrimination even without an individual making a complaint. The Commission’s new powers come into effect 12 months after the legislation has passed.
- Prohibit conduct that results in a hostile workplace environment on the basis of sex.
A new offence of ‘subjecting a person to a hostile workplace environment on the grounds of sex’ is expressly created following the Report’s findings that sexual harassment may occur where a workplace environment is sexually charged or hostile, even if the specific conduct is not directed at any particular person or employee. For example a workplace that has offensive posters or where sexual jokes are customary can result in people feeling unwelcome or offended by the general environment. Employers will need to ensure that they do not have workplaces with a hostile work environment and that they conduct training in relation to this new offence as noted earlier.
- Implement cost protections in court proceedings.
Parties in unlawful discrimination cases, including sexual harassment, would be required to only bear their own costs in court proceedings rather than also bearing the costs of the other party should they be unsuccessful in their case. The Courts would however retain discretion to make orders as to costs where they consider it just to do so, for example where one party has been wholly unsuccessful in a proceeding.
- Introduce new right for unions to bring claims in the Federal Courts
Unions and other representative bodies would now be able to make applications on behalf of people alleging unlawful discrimination including sexual harassment in the Federal Courts rather than the current position which only allows the initiation of complaints on behalf of workers in the Commission.
- Introduce systematic inquiries
The Commission will be given the ability to investigate suspected systematic unlawful behaviour including systematic sexual harassment including powers to require employers to provide information and documents.
- Streamline complaint dismissal period
Complaints will only be able to be terminated by the Commission if the complaint relates to conduct that occurred more than 24 months before the making of the complaint. This change would align the Age, Disability and Racial Discrimination Acts with changes already made to the SDA in 2021.
Pointon Partners will keep you informed once the Bill has passed the Parliament. If you have any queries in relation to this update please contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law team.
Employee Litigation Following Termination on Account of Vaccination Status
In 2021 a significant proportion of employers implemented vaccination policies, either because they were required due to Public Health Orders or on account of the employer implementing their own policy in the absence of a Public Health Order. Since then there have been cases filtering through the Fair Work Commission (FWC) where such employers enforced their vaccination policy. According to the FWC, common vaccination related cases included unfair dismissal applications, general protections applications, disputes regarding workplace vaccination policies and an employee’s entitlement to be paid while they were stood down or on leave.[1] This update aims to summarise the current standing by answering the following questions.
WERE EMPLOYERS ENTITLED TO IMPLEMENT A VACCINATION POLICY?
It is now widely accepted that employer vaccination policies can constitute a lawful and reasonable direction even in the absence of a Public Health order underpinning the vaccination policy. The FWC in Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union and Ors v BHP Coal Pty Ltd t/a BHP Billiton Mitsubishi Alliance/BMA and Ors [2022] FWC 81 held that requiring evidence of an employee’s vaccination for access into a workplace was not coercion or economic duress. The FWC also addressed a common argument and found that asking for an employee’s vaccination status does not breach the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth).
In the recent decision of Adam Kachwalla v ARA Security Services Pty Ltd [2022] FWC 1459, the employer attempted to implement a vaccination policy even though New South Wales had not mandated vaccinated in the security sector. The FWC found that the employer’s policy was reasonable even though they hadn’t been the subject of government mandates.
The cases have however demonstrated that it was important for an employer to follow the necessary procedural requirements. In Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union and Anor v Mt Arthur Coal Pty Ltd t/a Mt Arthur Coal [2021] FWCFB 6059, the FWC found that the employer’s vaccination policy was unreasonable because the employer had failed to consult its employees. Pursuant to s 47-49 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Cth), an employer must consult with their employees regarding matters that relate to their work health or safety.
WERE EMPLOYERS ABLE TO ENFORCE A VACCINATION POLICY BY TERMINATING EMPLOYEES WHO DIDN’T COMPLY?
There have been a number of unfair dismissals and general protection claims relating to vaccination policies. These have typically occurred in situations where an employee was dismissed for failing to provide proof of vaccination status or failing to obtain the vaccine. Though there have been many cases, it has been established that dismissals pursuant to a failure to meet requirements of Public Health Orders constitutes a valid reason for dismissal.
In Hillenaar v RTL Mining and Earthworks Pty Ltd [2022] FWC 484, due to restrictions introduced by the Victorian Government, employees could not enter mining sites unless they were vaccinated against COVID-19 or held a valid medical exemption. The FWC found that dismissal of an employee because they could not lawfully enter the worksite was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable.
This decision has also been extended to include failure to comply with workplace vaccination policies where no Public Health Order underpinned the vaccination policy. In Damevski v Westpac Banking Corporation [2022] FWC 1553, the employer dismissed Mr Damevski for failing to provide his vaccination status. The FWC found that due to the seriousness of the COVID-19 pandemic, the employer’s policy was not only reasonable but that the employee’s dismissal for failure to comply was not unfair.
While it is generally reasonable to dismiss an employee for failure comply with a vaccination policy, in Marriott v Baptcare Limited [2022] FWC 300, the FWC found that a premature dismissal constituted unfair dismissal. Mr. Mariott was dismissed for failure to provide evidence of his vaccination status. The FWC found that even though Marriott failed to provide his vaccination status, the dismissal was premature as pursuant to the employer’s policy, Marriott could have worked from home for more than three months after his dismissal without being vaccinated.
WERE EMPLOYEES ENTITLED TO PAY IF STOOD DOWN OR ON LEAVE PURSUANT TO A VACCINATION POLICY?
In Wilkinson v Eastern Health [2022] FWC 260, the FWC found that in cases where a Public Health Order prohibited unvaccinated employees from working onsite, they were not entitled to paid personal leave. This was decided on the basis that paid personal leave is paid according to the number of hours the employee would have worked. If an employee is unvaccinated, they are not entitled to any hours and therefore are not entitled to paid personal leave. A similar outcome occurred in Nidai v Autonexus Pty Ltd [2022] FWC 841, where an employee was stood down for failure to provide evidence of being vaccinated or medically exempt. The employee returned to work after the vaccination mandate was lifted and attempted to claim pay for the period he was stood down. The FWC refused to grant this on the basis that the employee refused to provide his status and was effectively unable to perform the inherent requirements of his role during this leave period.
The team at Pointon Partners is well versed in dealing with all types of employment disputes. If you wish to discuss vaccination related matters or any other matters pertaining to employment, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop of our Employment Law team.
[1] https://www.fwc.gov.au/benchbook/vaccination-related-matters
Misuse of trade secrets by former employees – steps an employer should take to prevent this
Protection of confidential information for employers
Departing employees can pose a risk to the future goodwill of a business, as they have had the opportunity to form relationships with its customers and suppliers.
Employees will often be given unfettered access to commercially sensitive documents and information, and will have received training and have experience in terms of how best to exploit them.
The loss of customers to departing employees is an all too common situation faced by employers. A customer’s choice to follow an employee can be completely unilateral, but more frequently it is the result of the former employee enticing the customer away.
Employers should therefore take steps to protect their confidential information and, by extension, their customers, suppliers and goodwill from former employees.
How can employers protect their confidential information?
Restrictions on employees’ use of information obtained during the course of their employment stem from a number of sources, including:
- express and implied obligations owed as part of their contract of employment;
- fiduciary duties to act in their employer’s best interests and not to misuse their employer’s confidential information;
- confidentiality obligations owed under sections 182 and 183 of the Corporations Act; and
- the equitable duty of confidence.
The advantage of expressly providing for confidentiality obligations in an employment contract is that it allows an employer to clearly set out the rights claimed. Employees who might otherwise be unsure as to what constitutes confidential information are made aware of their obligations from the outset.
Confidential information can also be defined in the contract to include customer and supplier lists, contact details and technical information that might otherwise be considered “know-how” that a former employee would be free to exploit.
What constitutes a trade secret rather than know-how?
Former employees are free to use certain confidential information obtained during their employment, unless the information in question is a “trade secret”, rather than “know-how” developed by the employee during the course of their employment.
A trade secret is secret information that is confidential to the employer. The simplest way to think about trade secrets is as information which, if disclosed to a competitor, would be liable to cause real (or significant) harm to the business. This could include customer lists, pricing information and profit margins.
An employee cannot use such information during the course of their employment for purposes other than those that enhance the interests of their employer. However, after an employee has left their employment, the law will also act to prevent the employee using such information, whether or not there is a contractual agreement between the former employee and the former employer restricting such use.
“Know-how” is information that is confidential, but which once learned necessarily remains in the employee’s head and becomes part of his or her own skill and knowledge, to be applied in the operation of the employer’s business.
What can a business do to protect its confidential information?
The best way to prevent a former employee from misusing confidential information is to take practical steps within the business in order to prevent employees from accessing or taking such information with them when they leave.
If a particular document is confidential, it should be marked as such. Confidential information should only be shared as appropriate, with disclosure limited to those who need to know.
It is also important to put in place systems to restrict access to confidential information (such as by using password protection or user access controls for electronic data) and to monitor access and use.
Employers should have standard procedures in place for dealing with departing employees. Among other things, those procedures need to deal with the issue of confidential information.
If you have any concerns, seek legal advice and issue a letter that clearly communicates to the employee:
- Their ongoing confidentiality obligations, as well as any contractual post-employment restraints (if applicable);
- A list of company property that is to be returned, including a reminder that property includes documents and information; and
- When and where they are required to return all company property.
If you wish to discuss protecting your confidential information, please contact Michael Bishop or Ben Drysdale.
Significant General Protections Damages Award
The Federal Court of Australia has recently ordered an account of damages to be paid to a senior-employee of Hawkesbury Race Club, Mrs Leggett, due to the bullying and harassment resulting from her employment. This case highlights consequences that result from overbearing and harassing management of staff and how injured workers may bring substantial damages claims pursuant to the general protections provisions of the Fair Work Act.
Background
Mrs Leggett started working at Hawkesbury Race Club on January 1991. Her “tenacious nature” as her colleagues described had garnered her full employment at the Club as well as a generous means of remuneration where she was entitled to an annual rate of $25,000 as well as a 10% commission. By the time that a new CEO, Mr Rudolph commenced in that role on the 6th May 2016, Mrs Leggett was a well-respected and senior employee.
Following the commencement of Mr Rudolph’s employment, Mrs Leggett’s psychological health was found to have been substantially affected as a result of Mr Rudolph’s overbearing micromanagement style. On the 9th October 2016, following an incident, Mrs Leggett emailed Mr Rudolph stating that she was “very upset” and felt that Mr Rudolph was “rude” in his demand through the tone elicited to her. When outlining that she wanted him to inform the Board of their strained relationship, Mr Rudolph asked in an email to meet him in the office the following day to “discuss your work performance” and that she could “bring a support person” if she so wished.
When Mrs Leggett had received the email on the 10th October 2016, she claimed that she felt even more “distressed, emotionally drained and began vomiting”. When informed of this, Mr Rudolph was recorded to gloatingly remark that his employees were “dropping like flies” and that Mrs Leggett was pulling the “stress leave” to avoid working. The Club withheld payments which she was entitled and used this as “bargaining chips” to negotiate with the Complainant.
The Club’s response to these claims was found by the Court to be lacking. They had delegated authority to Mr Rudolph, the source of Mrs Leggett’s stress, to handle her complaint to resign and the Board had explicitly confirmed that they would not “get involved in those negotiations, delegating” that authority to Mr Rudolph. The Club had shown a transparently apathetic approach to the plight of Mrs Leggett, who had expressed her frustration and stress to many of the directors.
Repudiation
The Court found that there was a repudiation of the employment contract. The Club had withheld her commissions between the 10 October 2016 to 7 February 2017 and the 25 January 2017 to 21 February 2017 commissions with the latter being paid on the 8th November 2019. In addition with the fact that Mr Rudolph told the applicant that the commission would not be paid when due but would be sorted out in due course indicated that the Club had repudiated the contract. They had evinced an intention to not be bound by the terms of the employment and therefore, Mrs Leggett was entitled to substantial damages for the Club’s breach of contract.
Fair Work Act Claims
Mrs Leggett had made two claims in relation to the general protection provisions of the Fair Work Act.
Firstly, she had argued that the Club had taken adverse action against her when they had replied to her 9th October email convening a meeting to discuss her work performance. Counsel for Mrs Leggett claimed that this was used to injure or threaten her in her employment in contravention of the general protection provisions because she had exercised her workplace right to make a complaint in regard to Mr Rudolph’s conduct.
The Fair Work Act created a presumption that Mr Rudolph had taken adverse action by emailing the complainant to have a meeting to have a discussion about her performance. The critical issue here would be Mr Rudolph’s conscious mental process for taking this action. The Court rejected the argument that Mr Rudolph was concerned as to how the complainant was feeling. This is because of the comments that he made in regard to her email stating that she was pulling the “stress leave” card. A reasonable person the Court said would infer that Mr Rudolph’s actions are indicative of bullying, rudeness as well as harshness. The Club could not displace the presumption established under the Fair Work Act that adverse action was taken against Mrs Leggett through seeking to convene a meeting to discuss her work performance following her complaint.
The second claim was that Mr Rudolph deliberately withheld payment to Mrs Leggett of her commissions because she had taken sick leave and made a complaint on the 9th October email. She said that her payment was being withheld because of the complaint that she made on the 9th October and that this commission would be used as a bargaining chip for the discussion of her performance. This “drove the nail home” in addition to the Club’s response to Mrs Leggett’s claim as it showed that the Club showed a total disregard to her exercising her rights as an employee through the 9th October email.
Additionally, many of the payments that Mrs Leggett was entitled to were withheld for many months and up to years. This had clearly breached the Fair Work Act which requires payments of amounts payable to an employee in relation to the performance of work in full at least monthly. Here, the employer had withheld her entitlements for years in some cases and breached this provision of the Fair Work Act.
Consequences
The Court took into account that the conduct by Mr Rudolph had “caused a very serious psychiatric illness that may never be cured, ameliorated to any significant” in assessing the damages. As a result, the Club was ordered to pay $200,000 in compensation under the Fair Work Act for the Club’s contravention.
Takeaway for Employers
There are two main takeaways from this case. Employers should ensure that they respect the rights of their employees to make claims and to be cordial when responding to these claims. A failure to do so could be taken as an adverse action which would contravene the general protection provisions of the Fair Work Act and the employer may be liable to pay compensation.
Employers should also take note the precedent set by this case in regard to damages awarded for psychological damage pursuant to the general protection provisions. When assessing damages claims in the general protection context, traditionally the Court has tended to award general damages of $5,000 to $10,000 for harm or suffering caused to employees. As a result of this decision, we anticipate seeing more significant damages being sought by employees in some general protection matters and an increased focus on psychological damage suffered by employees for psychological distress. This may change the dynamics in the conciliation process and with the compensation being sought by the employee or their representative being materially higher than may have been in the case in the past, making it potentially more difficult for employers to settle claims for an amount they consider reasonable. Hence there is a greater need or incentive for employers to avoid these claims in the first instance.
If you have any queries regarding the above please feel free to contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Ben Drysdale of our Employment Law team.
Sources
Leggett v Hawkesbury Race Club Limited (no 3) [2021] FCA 1658
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)
Potential Legislative Reforms for Non-Disclosure Agreements
The Victorian Government is taking steps to prohibit the use of Non-Disclosure Agreements, sometimes called “gag orders”, to silence employees. This landmark decision comes as the State’s Ministerial Taskforce on Workplace Sexual Harassment released 26 recommendations for the Government to implement in response to growing demand for reform in regard to sexual harassment in workplaces. The taskforce had released 26 points for the Victorian Government to take account of, 21 of which were accepted fully, in part or in principle.
One of these recommendations outlined the need for legislative amendments to restrict the use of NDAs in relation to workplace sexual harassment cases in Victoria. The Government accepted this in principle conceding that moving forward, significant work is required before any amendments can be made to regulate the use of NDAs in workplaces. Noting the uses that NDAs may have for the employer and employee, the Victorian Government needs to be careful to balance the interests of both parties in regard to the reforms in the future.
The Report
In addition to this, the report addressed the need to treat gendered violence and workplace sexual harassment as an occupational health and safety issue. This means that harassment in the workplace will be covered by the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 in the future and afford greater protection for employees. The OHS regulator, WorkSafe, has also been given greater funding to prevent and respond to gendered violence and sexual harassment.
What can we see in the future for NDAs?
As part of the recommendation, the taskforce recommended introducing legislative measures from overseas such as the Irish Employment Equality (Amendment) (Non-Disclosure Agreements) Bill 2021 and lessons from other jurisdictions as the model for reform. Following from this, we can see how the Victorian Government may amend the use of NDAs through legislation from abroad.
Employers and Employees can expect to see the scope of NDAs greatly reduced with the opportunity for employees to waive their own duty of confidentiality in the future and because NDAs may only be able to last for a set and limited duration past an employee’s period of employment. Greater transparency and choice will be accorded to employees as the Irish Amendment Bill addressed how before entering into an NDA, the employer must offer full independent legal advice at their own expense and must not unduly influence the relevant employee in respect of the decision to include a confidentiality clause.
Overall, employees and employers should see less protections afforded by NDAs in the near future if the Victorian Government proceeds with legislative change in this area.
If you have any queries, please feel free to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.
Terminating an Employee for Excessive Phone Usage during Work Hours
As employees start to return to the office, they may find it increasingly difficult to leave their personal lives at home. Employees may be tempted to handle private affairs such as a side business or non-work related calls during working hours. While employers may be lenient to a certain extent, what happens when this compromises the quality of the employee’s work? As an employer are you entitled to dismiss an employee simply because they were using their phone?
Such a scenario played out in Lynda Murphy v Clear Day Pty Ltd [2022] FWC 373 (‘Lynda Murphy v Clear Day’). In Lynda Murphy v Clear Day, Ms Murphy was dismissed by Clear Day Pty Ltd (the Employer) for, amongst other reasons, taking excessive phone calls relating to her private business instead of performing her work duties.
A week prior to her dismissal, the Employer had a meeting with Ms Murphy where was warned that her conduct was not acceptable and was in breach of her contract. Ms Murphy’s behaviour improved for approximately a week before returning to her old habits. As a result, Ms Murphy’s employment was terminated with notice paid in lieu.
Pursuant to s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), Ms Murphy applied to the Fair Work Commission (‘the Commission’) for an order granting a remedy, arguing that she was unfairly dismissed. Ms Murphy’s contention being that she was not provided with a written warning.
Unfair dismissal is defined by the legislation as dismissal that was harsh, unjust or unreasonable.[1] In determining whether the dismissal was harsh, unfair or unreasonable, the Commission, assessed the various criteria set out in s 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).
When assessing this criteria, the Commission found that over a 29 day period, Ms Murphy had sent 1260 text messages related to non-work matters during working hours, indicating a failure on Ms Murphy’s behalf to dedicate her full time and attention to her work responsibilities. The Commission found that this constituted valid reason for the Employer to dismiss Ms Murphy. The Employer was also found to have served valid notice of these reasons upon termination and provided sufficient warning of unsatisfactory performance prior to dismissal. However, in assessing the criteria found in s 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), the Commission found that certain procedural issues existed. This included the Employer’s failure to provide a written warning as well as an opportunity for Ms Murphy to respond to the reasons for her dismissal.
Ultimately, the Commission stated that when considering the failures of the Employer, the seriousness of the reason for termination should also be taken into account. Having seen the volume of texts sent by Ms Murphy, the Commission believed that it would be impossible to believe that Ms Murphy did any work at all. As a result, the Commission found that the dismissal was not unjust.
Lynda Murphy v Clear Day is an important decision that demonstrates that when an employee uses work time to tend to personal matters, it can give rise to a right to dismiss the employee. However, employers should communicate very clear policies about what is allowed in the workplace and ensure that all procedures are correctly followed when dismissing an employee. That will ensure that an employer is best placed to defend any subsequent unfair dismissal claim.
If you have any queries regarding unfair dismissals or anything relating to employment law please feel free to contact Michael Bishop or Ben Drysdale of our Employment Law team.
[1] Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 385(b).
Employment Law Information Webinar – Independant Contractors – The Recent High Court Decisions
On 24 February, our emploment lawyers Michael Bishop and Ben Drysdale discussed the recent High Court Decisions regarding Indpendant Contractors and how this can affect your business as well as steps your business should be taking.
If you would like to view the recording of the webinar, please click on the below link…
https://pointonpartnerspoc.sharefile.com/d-sd34d0d43809847fdadad8320c3045705
Issuing of Formal Directions re Mandatory Vaccination of Authorised Workers
Late last week the Victorian Government released the formal Directions underpinning its announcement the prior week that those Victorian workers who had been classified as “authorised workers” during the pandemic would be required to be vaccinated in order to continue working.
These Directions are framed in a similar way to the Directions issued by the Victorian Government in specific sectors such as aged care, construction, healthcare and education in that they don’t impose an explicit obligation on employees to be vaccinated. Rather, under the Directions applying to those specific sectors the obligation is on the employer not to allow unvaccinated workers to attend the premises operated by those employers.
In the case of “authorised workers”, the obligation is on the employer not to allow a worker to work anywhere other than their usual place of residence unless the worker has provided the employer with evidence that the employee has had the required first and second vaccinations by the required dates. The timelines are as follows (and which were extended out one week relative to the Govt’s initial announcement):
- as from Friday 15 October the worker needs to have received their first vaccination or be booked in to receive their first vaccination within the following week;
- as from Friday 22 October the worker needs to have received their first vaccination; and
- as from Friday 26 November the worker needs to have received their second vaccination.
In terms of the evidence of vaccination that an employee can provide, it can be an immunisation certificate (eg from the MyGov register) or a letter from the employee’s medical practitioner.
Employers with turnover exceeding three million dollars will need to comply with their obligations under the Privacy Act in obtaining vaccination information from their employees. For further information about compliance with the Privacy Act see our Employment Update of 28 September 2021 (https://pointonpartners.com.au/return-to-work-office-for-fully-vaccinated-workers-requesting-evidence-of-an-employees-vaccination-status/)
The Directions do not apply in the case of workers who have provided their employer with an immunisation exemption certificate issued by their medical practitioner. The grounds for obtaining such a certificate are extremely limited (e.g. an allergy to the particular Covid vaccines).
It is important for employers to note that the Directions will apply to workers employed by essential businesses who have been largely working from home during the pandemic but in respect of whom the employer may have issued work permits for ad hoc purposes. Eg take the example of a business development manager employed by a logistics company who may have been issued a work permit by the employer once a week to enable the manager to visit clients but who was otherwise working from home. Going forward the employer would not be able to issue a work permit to such a manager unless the manager had been vaccinated by the required deadlines (or had provided an immunisation exemption certificate). This is because the Directions target any work done away from home and not just attendance at the workplace.
If you have any queries regarding mandatory vaccination please feel free to contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Ben Drysdale of our Employment Law team.
Employment Law Information Webinar – Employee Share Schemes
On 14 October, our partner Michael Bishop discussed the different types of employee share & option schemes and whether they may be suited to your business.
If you would like to view the recording of the webinar, please click on the below link…
https://pointonpartnerspoc.sharefile.com/d-sd34d0d43809847fdadad8320c3045705
Return to work/office for fully vaccinated workers – requesting evidence of an employee’s vaccination status
We note that as part of the Victorian Government’s Roadmap for the easing of restrictions released several weeks ago it announced that once 80% of the community is fully vaccinated (anticipated to be around 5 November) then staff who have been working from home will be able to return to their offices if they are fully vaccinated.
This raises the question of how employers go about obtaining information from their employees about their vaccination status and what obligations employers need to comply with under the Commonwealth Privacy Act.
The Privacy Act and the associated Australian Privacy Principles established by that legislation apply to businesses with an annual turnover of at least three million dollars.
An employee’s vaccination status is considered sensitive health information under the Privacy Act and higher privacy protections apply.
The Privacy Act is administered by the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner. It has issued guidance stating that an employer must only collect information about an employee’s vaccination status if the collection of such information is reasonably necessary for the employer’s functions or activities (and which may include preventing or managing Covid-19). If an employer was looking to re-open its workplace or office in November for fully vaccinated workers then requesting evidence of an employee’s vaccination status would appear justified.
However employees need to freely consent to providing information concerning their vaccination status and evidence of same such as their MyGov vaccination certificate.
Threats on the part of the employer to impose disciplinary action or to terminate the employee unless they provide the information would not amount to valid consent. For instance in a 2019 Fair Work Commission unfair dismissal case (Lee v Superior Wood Pty Ltd) an employee was sacked for not agreeing to provide his fingerprints for finger scanning on entry and exit to his workplace. All other employees within the workplace had agreed. The Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission held that the employer had committed various breaches of the Privacy Act. For instance, by not having a privacy policy in place and not issuing a valid collection notice to the employee. The Full Bench also stated that if the employee had consented to the collection of his fingerprint data under threat of termination that would not have amounted to a valid consent. As a consequence, the termination was held to be unfair and the employee succeeded in his unfair dismissal claim.
The takeout from this case is that employers seeking to obtain evidence of their employee’s vaccination status ought have a privacy policy in place which specifically deals with and addresses the issue of vaccination information. For instance why the information is needed, how the information will be used and how it will be sought to be collected by the employer.
Novel questions of law could arise if an employer bound by the Privacy Act had employees who refused to provide evidence of their vaccination. If the position under the Privacy Act is that employees have an absolute right not to provide evidence of their vaccination unless they provide their informed consent then that could be regarded as a “workplace right” of the employee for the purposes of the general protections provisions of the Fair Work Act. If the employee is sacked for not providing evidence of their vaccination then the employee could conceivably bring a general protections claim asserting that they were dismissed on account or in connection with their exercise of a workplace right. General protections claims are inherently difficult for employers to defend as there is no cap on the damages which can be awarded and a reverse onus of proof applies whereby the burden is on the employer to demonstrate that they did not terminate for that prohibited reason.
If an employer bound by the Privacy Act has lawfully collected information from its employees regarding their vaccination status then from that point on then it will constitute an employee record and the “employee records” exemption in the Privacy Act will apply to the use of the information from that time on. That is the Australian Privacy Principles won’t apply to the use of the information from then on. The reason why the “employee records” exemption doesn’t apply at the time that the employer seeks to collect information from the employee it because it is the employee’s data or sensitive health information at that time and not a record created or held by the employer.
Query what the position is if an employer does not specifically ask employees for evidence of their vaccination status but merely relies upon a government QR code system to enable or prevent access to the workplace? That is, fully vaccinated staff would be able to check in via the QR code system when arriving at the office. In this scenario, the employer is not necessarily receiving from the employee the information concerning the employee’s vaccination status as the information is uploaded to the government app and not able to be accessed by the employer. However we expect most employers will wish to ask employees in advance whether they are fully vaccinated and able to return to the office. Such employers will need to be cognisant of their obligations under the Privacy Act.
If you have any queries please feel free to contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Ben Drysdale of our Employment Law team.