$4 Million Consequence for Falsified Records and Wage Theft
The Federal Court of Australia has found restaurant chain Din Tai Fung’s guilty of wage theft imposing fines of $4 million. The case was bought before the courts by the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) which secured the second highest penalties in its history.
The Federal Court found that the fast food chain had “deliberately” underpaid staff of $157,025, with $50,588 owing to just one staff member. The court held that Din Tai Fung’s efforts to deprive their workers of their hard earned money had been covered up by falsification of employee related documentation.
The fines were distributed to numerous related parties, however the most notable individual was the former HR coordinator who worked for an external company DTF World Square and was personally charged with $105,084 penalties.
The court found that the HR manager did not simply act as a conduit, rather their efforts were deliberate and unscrupulous. This had been supported be evidence produced by a former payroll officer who stated on numerous occasions they were asked to make “both accurate and inaccurate records” regarding the hours employees worked and their wages. There was further evidence that proved to the courts that temporary 457 visas employees were instructed by the HR manager to work 55 hours or they would have their hours deducted from their annual leave.
This punishment holds particular significance due to the new legislation Closing the Loopholes Act that will be effective in relation to this issue as of 1 January 2025 and makes wage theft a criminal offence at a Commonwealth level. The criminal penalties imposed on individual and companies differ and accordingly, individuals could face a maximum of 10 years in prison and/or fines upwards of $1.5 million dollars whereas companies could face fines upwards of $7.8 million dollarsThe new amendments will incorporate a criminal standard of proof where by individuals who are accused of wage theft will need to be found to have done so beyond reasonable doubt. Further any payment that relates to employees entitlements within their modern Awards, enterprise agreements or what is stipulated in the Fair Work Act will be subject to scrutiny regarding wage theft.
HR managers are encouraged to stay well informed and up to date with the various Awards that relate to their respective employees. Further HR managers should address all issues regarding accidental underpayments promptly by taking the corrective steps which can be discussed with our employment team. Lastly HR managers collectively with their team should work towards implementing preventative measures to ensure underpayments are not occurring before 1 January 2025.
If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.
Pointon Partners Employment Law Seminar: Closing the Loopholes – Is your business ready for the changes?
Is your business ready for the changes that will come into effect due to the Fair Work Legislation Closing Loopholes?
Join us for a seminar as our Employment team discuss:
- Changes to the test for determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor.
- Right to disconnect – A landmark change allowing employees to push back on incursions into their personal time.
- New definition of casual employee and new rules for casual conversion.
Date: Wednesday 8 May 2024
Time: 12:30pm – 1:30pm
Location: Pointon Partners Offices – Level 14, 565 Bourke Street, Melbourne
Firm Speakers: Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman and Ben Drysdale
Catering: Lunch will be provided
Please RSVP by Monday 29 APRIL 2024 by email to Lisa Ograk.
Non-work related injuries – What can the Employer do?
Managing a situation involving an employee suffering non-work related injuries can be challenging, and often difficult to navigate. It is widely misunderstood by employers that non-work related injuries automatically provide legal grounds to terminate an employee, however this is legally not the case. Employers have strict obligations they must adhere to before they can lawfully terminate an employee, and if these precautions are not taken it can lead to an unfair dismissal or general protections claim. We set out below what an employer should be cognisant of when dealing with this issue.
Adhering to Fair Work Act & Regulations
When dealing with an employee who is suffering from non-work related injuries employers are required to comply with the Fair Work Act 2009 (FWA). In accordance with section 352 of the FWA an employer must not dismiss an employee who is temporarily absent due to illness or injury of a kind prescribed by the Regulations. A prescribed injury is one that is supported by a medical certificate or statutory declaration, within twenty-four hours or a reasonable period after the absence. A limitation exists within section 352 of the FWA regarding employees whose absence extends beyond three months consecutively or three months accumulatively within a twelve month period, as this will no longer be considered a prescribed injury under the FWA. In other words, the protection under section 352 of the FWA ceases after an absence extends for more than three months and the employee has exhausted their paid personal/carer’s leave entitlements.
The case of Rezaeifard v Green Leaves ELC Pty Ltd T/A Green Leaves (2021) in the Fair Work Commission (FWC) is a reminder for all employers not to overlook the temporary absence provisions. An educator provided a medical certificate to her employer which highlighted her inability to perform her contractual obligations. Throughout this time the educator had exhausted her paid sick leave entitlements and was therefore directed by the employer to attend an independent medical examination. The report concluded that the educator was unable to perform her job requirements. The employer sought modifications of the educator’s job however this was not successful and subsequently she was dismissed. However and critically, the educator had not used her paid personal leave, consequently the FWC found in favour of the educators claim that she was unfairly dismissed.
FWC issued an important reminder to employers that:
Employees should not lose their job if they have to take six weeks off work to mend a broken bone. Not all employees will have a balance of six weeks of paid personal leave to cover such a scenario. Nor should employees lose their job if they are having surgery such as a hysterectomy, or retina attachment, or are recovering from hepatitis. A three month protection is in place for very good reason.
Determining whether an employee is fit to work?
When determining whether an employee’s non-work related injury prevents the employee from fulfilling their contractual obligations, it may be appropriate to seek external verification through an Independent Medical Examination (IME). The request for an IME must be lawful and reasonable. Depending on the circumstances the employee’s treating physician can be approached to conduct an IME or it can be a medical professional not already involved in the care of the employee. We are able to provide tailored advice to the particular facts involving the employee.
In the lead up to requiring the employee attend an IME it is important to consider the following:
- Determine the inherent requirements – this first step is often crucial to show that there is a genuine need for the information and a reasonable basis for the direction. The inherent requirements of a job are the essential activities that must be carried out to fulfil the purpose of an employee’s position. The job description for the role is often a good place to start in an inherent requirements assessment; and
- Prepare the request for information – the employer’s request for information must be carefully considered by reference to the inherent requirements and any surrounding circumstances that are relevant to the doctor’s consideration.; and
- Discuss the process and obtain consent – the final step is to ideally have a discussion with the employee in relation to the proposed course of action. In some cases, an employee may agree in which case the employer will be able to send the request for an IME otherwise a formal direction to attend may be required. In the circumstance where the employee refuses to attend an IME that was requested on reasonable and necessary grounds an employer should seek legal advice before proceeding to bring the employment relationship to an end.
The 2021 FWC case of Dr Amir Reza Zakaei Fard v Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology (RMIT University) dealt with an employee’s refusal to comply with directions from their employer to complete an IME to assess suitability for work and as a result was terminated for serious misconduct. The FWC when deciding the case considered the efforts which the employer had taken to request that their employee attend an IME. The FWC concluded that due to evidence which proved the employer had made countless efforts over a two month period to request that the employee attend an IME there had been sufficient notice provided to the employee. Ultimately the grounds for the request made by the employer were not only reasonable but were also made sufficiently known to the employee. As such the FWC concluded that the termination of the employment was sound and defensible.
If your employee has sustained non-work related injuries and it is impacting their ability to perform the inherent requirements of their role we would be pleased to discuss this with you. We recommend seeking legal advice before any decisions are made to ensure a clear plan is formulated to support the needs of the employer and the employee in question. This is also important to minimise any claims brought by the employee against the employer.
If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team
New Reform giving employees the right to disconnect
A new Bill, Closing Loopholes No 2, has passed Parliament on 12 February 2024, introducing new reforms allowing employees to disconnect outside work hours. The legislation has come about from a push by the Greens party to strengthen employees’ rights regarding their time away from work.
What is an employee’s ‘right to disconnect’?
Employees will now have the right to refuse to monitor, read or respond to contact, or attempted contact, from an employer outside their required working hours. Additionally this reform extends employees’ rights to refuse contact from third parties regarding work related matters. However it won’t apply when the refusal to communicate is a requirement under Commonwealth, State or Territory laws or it is deemed unreasonable. Considerations that will be taken into account when determining unreasonable communication include:
- The reason for the contact or attempted contact;
- How the contact or attempted contact is made and the level of disruption the contact or attempted contact causes the employee;
- The extent to which the employee is compensated (including non-monetary compensation) to remain available to perform work or be contacted, or for working additional hours, outside of ordinary working hours;
- The nature of the employee’s role and the employee’s level of responsibility; and
- The employee’s personal circumstances (including family or caring responsibilities).
Which employees will be affected and how can workplaces prepare for this new ruling?
For employees in large businesses the right to disconnect will take effect 6 months after Royal Assent, although it is unclear when that will occur. Employees working in small businesses will see this new ruling come into effect 18 months after Royal Assent. A small business is defined under s23(1) of the FWA as a business which employs fewer than 15 employees at a time.
In preparation for the changes employers should communicate to their work force what is the right to disconnect and what that means in relation to their role. Additionally it will be important for workplaces to ensure all employees understand what is deemed reasonable communication and what is not. Businesses can do this by incorporating a list of examples and criteria’s within their workplace policies and guidelines to help their workforce identify what is seen as reasonable and unreasonable communication. However given that employee rights to disconnect depends on the particular role of the employee and their remuneration then personalised guidelines may need to be developed for individual employees or groups of employees performing similar roles and with comparable levels of remuneration. Businesses in the services sector (eg professional service firms) may also need to monitor the extent to which third parties (eg clients) are contacting employees of the firm after hours and seek regular feedback from such employees as to whether such communication is excessive.
Dispute resolution and potential penalties?
If a dispute arises regarding an employee refusing to engage with their employer’s correspondence, a resolution must be sought within the workplace first. Once all resolutions options have been exhausted either party can apply to the Fair Work Commission to have their case heard by the tribunal where either party can apply for a ‘Stop Order’. For employees a ‘Stop Order’ will prevent their employer from sending unreasonable work correspondence outside work hours. Conversely, employers can apply for a ‘Stop Order’ that prevents their employee from unreasonably refusing to engage in work communications beyond work hours. If ‘Stop Orders’ are breached civil penalties of up to $18,000 could be issued under the FW Act.
General Protection Claims:
In addition the right for employees to disconnect outside their required working hours will be incorporated as a workplace right under the general protection regime within the FWA. Therefore employees may be entitled to bring a general protection claim against their employer on the grounds of adverse action. Section 340 of the FWA prohibits an employer from taking adverse action against an employee if they are exercising their workplace rights. Therefore an employee will be entitled to bring a general protections claim against their employer if they feel as though their employment has been affected (such as being dismissed or treated unfairly) because they exercised their right to disconnect. With general protection claims there is a reverse onus on the employer who holds the burden to show that they did not terminate or impose detriment on the employee because they exercised their right to disconnect. It is important to note damages in general protections claim are uncapped, incentivising individuals to bring forward a claim.
Rationale for the reform:
The reforms were implemented due to technological enhancements altering the way employers and employees communicate. In earlier times, all work related communication was restricted to work desktops, now all communication channels such as work email and phone lines are connected to our personal devices, allowing work correspondence to flow at all times. Evidentially workplace cultures have evolved to expect work related conversations to exist beyond paid hours regardless of its importance. The ‘Right to Disconnect’ aims to restructure and strengthen work life balance, improve employees mental health and reduce work related stress by enabling employees to refuse work correspondence when reasonable without suffering consequences.
If you wish to discuss the employee right to disconnect further, or wish to have a policy drafted for your business, please contact our employment team.
If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop of our Employment Law Team.
Pointon Partners Employment Law Seminar: Employee Share and Option Schemes
We continue to see strong interest from employer clients in the establishment of employee share or option schemes as a means of attracting, motivating and retaining staff.
Join us for a seminar as our Partner Michael Bishop discusses:
- reasons to establish an employee share scheme;
- the different types of schemes which may be used;
- structuring a scheme to achieve the employer’s aims and objectives;
- structuring a scheme to achieve optimal tax outcomes for the employees;
- The Corporations Act compliance aspects and applicable exemptions.
Date: Thursday 22 February 2024
Time: 12:30pm – 1:30pm
Location: Pointon Partners Offices – Level 14, 565 Bourke Street, Melbourne
Firm Speakers: Michael Bishop
Catering: Lunch will be provided
Please RSVP by Thursday 15 February 2024 by clicking on the link below
REGISTER
Home Sweet Hostility: FWC Rules that Working from Home on Mandatory Office Days is not a Valid Reason for Dismissal
Late last year, our Employment Team covered the case in which an employee was validly dismissed for failing to be present in the office during her mandatory office days. A recent Fair Work decision has outlined the contrary with the absence of the employee on his mandatory office days not forming a valid reason for dismissal. In substance, the facts of each case are quite different and employers are encouraged to exercise discretion in choosing to dismiss employees on the grounds of being absent on their office days given whether the dismissal constitutes an unfair dismissal depends on individual circumstances.
Background
The employee/applicant, Tomaso Moro, commenced employment with the respondent, Insider AU, on the 8th August 2022 on a full time basis as a Digital Growth Associate. Insider AU is described as an E-Commerce Support and Customer Service Solutions Provider.
The evidence provided by Moro contended that Moro was a high-performing employee, which was evidenced through him receiving awards for achieving the highest performance out of the respondent’s Sales Development Representatives in the first and second quarter of 2023. There was no evidence provided by Insider AU to suggest that Moro was nothing other than a satisfactory employee as he claimed that he had received no prior warnings about his conduct or performance during his employment.
Insider AU alleged that Moro was absent on a mandatory office day on 30 August 2023. These reasons were also canvassed with evidence that Moro was also absent from the office for coffee at a local coffee shop around January and February 2023 and again on or around May 2023. These cited absences led Insider AU to believe that Moro was dishonest, exhibited challenging behaviour and poorly collaborated with his peers. This reasoning should be contrasted with our earlier case where the employee was absent from her in-office days for a period of 3 weeks.
As a result, following his absence on 30 August, Moro’s employment was subsequently terminated on 1 September 2023 and he was awarded payment in lieu of notice for a period of 2 weeks. Interestingly, Moro’s employment agreement clearly stipulated that his notice period would be 8 weeks which Insider AU alleged was a mistake in drafting the contract.
Was Moro Unfairly Dismissed under s387 of the FWA 2009
In considering whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, the Commissioner considered the factors in s387 (a)-(h).
In regard to his absence on 30 August 2023 and its relation to Moro’s performance/conduct at work, the applicant had provided proper notice on his work calendar that he could not go to the office due to a tradesperson working at his house. Surprisingly, the regional director, Mr Bullock of his branch contacted Moro to enquire about his absence. When Moro responded to the enquiry, Mr Bullock responded with:
“Sorry Tom, I’m calling BS on this. This is not good enough – you are supposed to give us a heads up WAY in advance as opposed to having me chase you are, like this”
Further, the absences on or around January – February 2023 and May 2023 where the applicant was getting coffee related to informal work related discussions. The Commissioner was not satisfied that Moro’s breach of the mandatory office days constituted a valid reason for dismissal. This reasoning should be contrasted with the facts of our earlier article where the applicant failed to provide any reasons at all for her absence from the office over a period of three weeks.
The Commissioner also considered the extent to which the size of Insider AU would impact on the procedure impacting dismissal. The Commissioner noted the following “Given the size of the operations and the availability of access to people and culture/legal advice in effecting the dismissal, it is somewhat surprising that the dismissal was effected in the way it was”. Indeed, although Insider AU consisted of 16 people, its international workforce amounted to 1,015 employees spanning over 30 locations. This was combined with the fact that it was the Turkish Office that had effected the dismissal. Given the significant operational capacity of the Insider AU network, the Commissioner implied that Moro’s dismissal should have been handled in a much more formalised manner. The evidence suggested that Moro was not notified for the reason of dismissal, was not given an opportunity to respond to the unfair dismissal and was not provided a support person to assist with discussions related to his dismissal. These reasons supported the fact that Moro was unfairly dismissed.
It is also interesting to note the Commissioner’s discussion of the payment in lieu of notice period. The email from the global teams to Moro outlined that despite his contract stipulating that an 8 week notice period was to be given by Insider AU, the email outlined that this was a mistake and that instead his notice period was two weeks. Additionally the email had the misconception that the maximum notice period for Moro was 5 weeks which informed the respondent’s reasoning that there was a mistake in the employment contract. Rather, the National Employment Standards identify the minimum notice period. Hence, Moro was entitled to a minimum of 2 weeks’ notice.
Key Takeaway
As more white collar workers return to the office following the pandemic, we expect more cases related to WFH arrangements to be brought to the FWC. As seen in the contrasting way in which the FWC decided this case and our earlier article, whether a breach of in-office working days constitutes an unfair dismissal depends on the circumstances of each individual case. For example, whether a valid reason is provided for the absence and where warnings are issued and due process is followed.
Employers are therefore encouraged to exercise care in electing in whether to dismiss employees for breaching their obligation to work in the office. Warnings should first be provided and prior to any termination the employee should have an opportunity to respond to the allegations. A failure to do so may result in significant compensation being awarded as seen in this case where damages awarded to Moro amounted to $26,000.
If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.
Employment Law Update – Office Closure Periods
A ruling earlier this year from the Fair Work Commission has changed the rules around employee leave during office closure period.
As a result of this 4 yearly review of modern awards, from 1 May 2023, employers may no longer require an employee to take unpaid leave during an office closure period.
This is an extensive list of awards and includes the Clerks- Private Sector Award, and the General Retail Industry Award.
This has implications for situations where an employee may not have sufficient annual leave to last the entire office closure period.
What happens if an employee does not have sufficient leave?
Pursuant to the new rules, an employer has four options.
- The employer and the employee may agree for the employee to take unpaid leave during the office closure. This needs to be genuine consent from the employee and agreed in writing.
- If permitted by the applicable award, the employee may agree to take leave in advance over the office closure period.
- The employer may find work that is in line with the employee’s award and direct the employee to continue working during this period.
- If the employee does not agree to take unpaid leave or leave in advance and the employer does not have any work to assign, the employer will have to pay the employee for any days during the closure period which is not covered by the employee’s accrued leave without the employee having to work.
Can I avoid such a situation?
In the future, employers may be able to take certain steps to avoid this situation.
In situations where an employer cannot reasonably be held responsible for the closure of the work place, employers may be entitled to direct employees to stand down pursuant to s 524 of the Fair Work Act. For example, if a head contractor closes down a building site over the Christmas / New Year period, a sub-contractor is likely to not be reasonably held responsible for the stoppage of work.
In businesses where the office closure is an established feature, employers may, within reason, refuse leave requests in the period leading up to the closure on the basis that the employee would not have sufficient annual leave. This is likely to not fall under the definition of ‘unreasonably’ in s 88(2) of the Fair Work Act unless there were some strong countervailing factors.
If you wish to discuss these further, please do not hesitate to contact our employment team.
The Positive Duty on Employers to Eliminate Sexual Harassment
The positive duty was introduced into the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) (SDA) in December 2022 and was a key recommendation of the Australian Human Rights Commission’s (Commission) landmark Respect@Work Report in 2020 led by former Sex Discrimination Commissioner Kate Jenkins.
Organisations and businesses now have a positive duty to take ‘reasonable and proportionate measures’ to eliminate, as far as possible, the following unlawful behaviour from occurring:
- sex discrimination in a work context;
- sexual harassment in a work context;
- sex-based harassment in a work context;
- conduct creating a workplace environment that is hostile on the ground of sex; and
- related acts of victimisation.
The positive duty in the SDA applies to ‘persons conducting a business or undertaking’ (PCBUs) and ‘employers’. Under the SDA, an employer is a person who employs another person, or engages another person to perform work under a contract for services.
A PCBU has the same meaning in the SDA as under the model work health and safety laws. The term is a broad concept that extends beyond the traditional employer/employee relationship and includes all types of modern working arrangements such as public and private companies, partners in a partnership, franchisors and franchisees, sole traders and self-employed people. Regardless of their size or resources, all organisations and businesses in Australia that have obligations under the SDA must meet the positive duty.
Employers in Victoria have had a positive duty to eliminate discrimination, sexual harassment and victimisation as far as possible under the Victorian Equal Opportunity Act 2010.
Employers and PCBUs need to be ready for the Commission’s new enforcement and investigative powers, which commence on 12 December 2023 and allow the Commission to investigate and enforce compliance with the positive duty.
The Federal positive duty imposes a legal obligation on organisations and businesses to take proactive and meaningful action to prevent the unlawful behaviours noted above from occurring in the workplace or in connection to work. The focus in on taking preventative action to help to create safe, respectful and inclusive workplaces. In the lead up to 12 December 2023, employers should ensure they have robust systems in place to comply with their new positive duty obligations. This important change requires organisations and businesses to shift their focus to actively preventing workplace sexual harassment, sex discrimination and other relevant unlawful conduct, rather than responding only after it occurs.
The Unlawful Behaviour
Employers and PCBUs need to ensure they understand the unlawful conduct, which they need to eliminate as far as possible. Firstly, sex discrimination is when someone is treated unfairly, or is unreasonably disadvantaged, because of their sex, or a characteristic that is generally associated with people of their sex.
The kinds of attitudes that can lead to sex discrimination in a work context include making assumptions about the sort of work that people are capable or not capable of performing because of their sex or thinking that people are suited to different kinds of work because of their sex.
Sex discrimination can be either direct or indirect and both forms are unlawful under the SDA. Direct sex discrimination occurs when a person is treated less favourably than someone of a different sex would be treated in the same or similar circumstances. For example, a decision not to hire a qualified woman as an engineer because she is a woman and it is assumed that she will not fit into a workplace with lots of men, would be direct sex discrimination.
Indirect sex discrimination occurs when an existing or proposed condition, requirement or practice (such as a rule or policy) may appear to treat everyone equally, but disadvantages, or is likely to disadvantage, people of a particular sex. It will not be unlawful discrimination, however, if the condition, requirement or practice is reasonable in the circumstances. An example of indirect discrimination, may be a minimum height requirement for a job where height is not relevant to carry out the role. Such a requirement would likely discriminate disproportionately against women andsome minority ethnic groups as they are generally shorter than men.
Secondly, sexual harassment is any unwelcome conduct of a sexual nature that occurs in circumstances in which a reasonable person, aware of those circumstances, would anticipate that the person being harassed might feel offended, humiliated or intimidated.
Sexual harassment can be overt, covert or subtle. It can happen in person and online. Examples include unwelcome physical contact, repeated or inappropriate invitations to go out on dates, sexualised gifts, images or videos and inappropriate staring or leering. The intention of the harasser is irrelevant and it can include one-off incidents, or a pattern of behaviour that makes the working environment uncomfortable or threatening in a sexually hostile way.
Thirdly, sex-based harassment involves unwelcome behaviour that is sexist and demeaning in nature, but that is not necessarily sexual. As with sexual harassment, sex-based harassment is unlawful when it occurs in circumstances in which a reasonable person, aware of those circumstances, would anticipate that the person being harassed might feel offended, humiliated or intimidated. It can happen when a person is degraded, put down or disrespected because of their sex, or a characteristic generally associated with people of that sex.
Examples include asking intrusive personal questions based on a person’s sex (for example, inappropriate questions about menopause), making inappropriate comments and jokes based on a person’s sex, displaying images or making comments that are sexist or strongly prejudiced against a particular sex or asking a person to engage in degrading conduct based on their sex.
The fourth category of unlawful behaviour is conduct creating a workplace environment that is hostile on the ground of sex. A workplace environment may be hostile and intimidating to people of a particular sex, even if behaviour is not specifically directed at them or any person. This is because general actions can contribute to a workplace culture that makes people feel degraded, humiliated or offended in ways that are associated with their sex.
Types of behaviours that might create a hostile workplace environment include, conduct involving gendered stereotypes, such as making only women workers responsible for cleaning the office, making demeaning comments about anatomical attributes or topics such as pregnancy, the display or circulation of obscene, sexist, pornographic or sexual photos or materials and sexist, derogatory, suggestive or sexual emails, phone calls, text messages or online interactions including the use of emojis with sexual connotations.
As with sexual and sex-based harassment, whether conduct creates a workplace environment that is hostile on the ground of sex is determined using an objective test, based on how a reasonable person would interpret the behaviour in that situation.
Finally victimisation involves retaliatory action, or the threat of such action, against a person because they have asserted, or intend to assert, their rights under the law, or because another person thinks that they have. A person can also be victimised if they help someone else to assert their rights for example by being a witness.
Examples of victimisation may include excluding, dismissing, demoting or failing to promote someone because they have made a complaint or excluding a worker in the workplace, or refusing them overtime shifts, because they appeared as a witness in support of a colleague who made a complaint of sex-based harassment.
Commission Guidelines for Complying with the Positive Duty
On 9 August 2023, the Commission released guidance on how to comply with the new positive duty under the SDA. The guidelines set out the following seven standards that the Commission expects employers and PCBUs to comply with to satisfy the positive duty obligations under the SDA:
- Leadership– Senior leaders should understand the positive duty and know specifically what conduct is unlawful. They are responsible for ensuring appropriate measures are taken, updated, reviewed and communicated to workers. An example of senior leaders and managers being informed and engaged about the positive duty is to include sexual harassment and positive duty compliance as a standing agenda item at board and senior leadership management meetings.
- Culture – Create a safe, respectful and inclusive culture, and regularly consult and engage with workers to discuss measures to eliminate potential sexual harassment risks and hazards. This can also be used as an opportunity to promote a ‘speak up’ culture which helps prevent potential legal, reputational and financial risks that could otherwise harm the stability of the organisation.
- Knowledge – Create and enforce policies addressing respectful behaviour and unlawful conduct. Educate employees at all levels to promote a safe, respectful, and inclusive environment, including by setting behaviour standards, informing them of their rights and responsibilities, and their role in preventing and addressing unlawful conduct.
- Risk management – Consult with all stakeholders about sexual harassment risks and hazards and take a risk-based approach to prevent and respond to unlawful behaviours. Identify and assess circumstances that may give rise to the likelihood of sexual harassment incidents. This involves taking a work health and safety approach to sexual harassment and conducting regular risk assessments to identify hazards and then implement control measures to address the hazards.
- Support – Ensure appropriate support mechanisms are in place for workers who experience or witness unlawful conduct.
- Reporting and response – Ensure appropriate processes for reporting and responding to reports of unlawful conduct exist and these are regularly communicated to workers. Also ensure responses to reports of unlawful conduct are consistent, timely and prevent harm and victimisation.
- Monitoring, evaluation and transparency– Collect data to understand the nature and extent of workplace unlawful conduct and use it to assess and improve workplace culture and develop prevention strategies. For example meeting notes of consultation conducted with workers, survey results, feedback and exit interviews.
In the lead up to the commencement of the Commission’s enforcement and investigative powers on 12 December 2023 it is important that employers and PCBUs take positive steps to ensure that their processes and systems are directed at both preventing and responding to sexual harassment and the other unlawful behaviour in the SDA.
It will be important to identify and assess sexual harassment risks and prepare to comply with the positive duty, which may include:
- reviewing incident reports, exit interviews and codes of practice;
- conducting risk assessments, using information from focus groups, surveys, and workplace consultation;
- ranking and implementing controls to deal with sexual harassment from most effective to least effective (e.g., policies, procedures and training); and
- ensuring sexual harassment is considered as a key priority at all safety meetings and at board and senior leadership management meetings.
If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.
Out of the Office, Out of a Job: Unauthorised Remote Work Arrangement Constitutes Valid Dismissal
Flexible working arrangements are becoming increasingly important for organisations attempting to access talent, boost productivity and to improve the work/life balance for employees. Recently, the Fair Work Commission rejected an employee’s claim that she was unfairly dismissed as she was working remotely without her employer’s consent. This case highlights that an employee working from home without the consent of the employer, combined with other reasons, may constitute a valid reason for dismissal.
Background
The employee was initially employed as a Senior Strata Manager in March 2022 and transitioned to a Business Development Associate in late 2022. This required her to relocate to the Sunshine Coast from the Brisbane Office. While her earlier role offered flexible working arrangements, her new role required her to be present at the Sunshine Coast office 4 days a week and the Brisbane office once a week. The applicant was entitled to apply for flexible working arrangements however no such request was submitted.
Around early March 2023, the employer was notified by the Community Manager of the Sunshine Coast office that the employee was not in attendance at the office for over a period of 3 weeks on or around late February. Further, a colleague submitted evidence to the effect that her office was deserted since at least 24 February 2023. Following an investigation and a show cause event, the employer terminated the employee’s position on three grounds:
- She forwarded private internal emails to her personal email and deleted the emails to hide her actions;
- She failed to attend to her duties at the Sunshine Coast office during her usual work hours; and
- She had during her work hours, left for lunch and failed to return to the office for the rest of her working day.
While the applicant contested these allegations, there was overwhelming evidence presented by the employer and her colleagues to confirm these allegations.
Decision
The Commission found that in relation to the second allegation, the failure of the applicant to comply with the respondent’s lawful and reasonable directions concerning the procedure for applying for a hybrid working arrangement, and failure to report on her whereabouts when not in those locations constituted a valid reason for dismissal.
The Commissioner stated that it was apparent from the evidence that the employee was not entitled to the same flexibility arrangements she enjoyed prior to her transition and that she was expected to work in person at the Sunshine Coast office and Brisbane office and to report any absences with her work team.
Further to this, the employee was given sufficient opportunities to respond to the allegations. While the respondent refused a request by the applicant to view internal records for her show cause event, the Commissioner was satisfied that the respondent’s failure to provide this information to the applicant did not affect the outcome whatsoever. As such, the Commissioner found that the applicant was given a reasonable opportunity to respond to the allegations through the show cause process which tipped the case in favour of the employer.
Takeaway
The current working trend seems to favour a hybrid approach. Despite this, employees are still required to follow proper procedures enacted by the employer to access these arrangements. A failure to do so may lead to a valid reason for dismissal. Hence, employers are encouraged to maintain clear policies on how flexible working arrangements can be accessed by their employees. It is important to note that following the Secure Jobs Better Pay Amendments, the following circumstances are when the employee can request flexible working arrangements:
- The employee is pregnant
- The employee is the parent, or has responsibility for the care, of a child who is of school age or younger;
- The employee is a carer
- The employee has a disability;
- The employee is 55 or older;
- The employee is experiencing family and domestic violence
- The employee provides care or support to a member of the employee’s immediate family, or a member of the employee’s household who requires care or support because the member is experiencing family and domestic violence;
- An employee who is a parent or has responsibility for the care of a child; and
- An employee who is returning to work after taking leave in relation to the birth or adoption of the child.
However, employers are still entitled to reject the request if they have reasonable business grounds in doing so.
If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.
Working Hard or Hardly Working at Home? – Unfair Dismissal Claim Falls Short
Working Hard or Hardly Working at Home? – Unfair Dismissal Claim Falls Short
With the work environment progressively adopting a hybrid approach, it is crucial that employers recognise that employee responsibilities remain consistent both when working remotely and in the office. Early last month a Fair Work Commission case decided that an employee’s serious and consistent failure to meet her obligations while working from home constituted misconduct and justified dismissal.
Background
The employer, Insurance Australia Group (IAG), implemented a hybrid approach to work at the end of 2022 allowing its employees the option of working from home. The Applicant, Suzie Cheiko, opted to work from home during this period on an almost permanent basis. IAG alleged that between the period of October to December, the Applicant was not meeting the requirements of her employment with complaints of her performance stretching back to April 2022.
Her colleagues referred to the fact that she had difficulties meeting deadlines, missed meetings and was absent and uncontactable during her work hours. Her employers pointed to the fact that as a result of her failure to perform her duties, IAG had incurred a fine from ASIC arising from her failure to lodge a product disclosure statement. The evidence also established that the Applicant had left home while working to “go to the shops from time to time”. Her low keystroke count also supported the evidence. The employee admitted the following:
“Sometimes the workload is a bit slow, but I have never not worked. I mean, I may go to the shops from time to time, but that is not for the entire day”
Decision
The Commissioner at [28] reiterated that for a dismissal to be valid, the reason for the dismissal must be ‘sound, defensible and well-founded’ rather than ‘capricious, spiteful or prejudiced’. This is a question of fact and will be based on the evidence presented by the parties.
The Commissioner found that the complaints referred to above, namely the Applicant’s absence from work, failure to meet deadlines, attend meetings and low keystroke count served to show that the Applicant ‘was not working as she was required to do during her designated working hours’. The Applicant had not refuted any of the evidence provided by IAG. Her failure to meet obligations also exposed her employer to penalties and posed ongoing risks to customers of IAG and the public broadly.
“The failure of the Applicant to attend to her duties in that period was not of a minor or incidental nature. It was on a scale and at a sufficient level of seriousness to constitute misconduct.”
However the Commissioner did raise some factors in favour of the Applicant per section 387(h) of the Fair Work Act showing that the dismissal may have been unfair. These consisted of:
- the significant and adverse effect of dismissal on the Applicant’s personal and economic situation;
- personal traumatic setbacks 18 – 24 months prior to termination which was reflected in her poor mental health; and
- her long and satisfactory work performance in the years preceding her termination.
The deciding factor here as noted above was the Applicant’s failure to diligently attend to her duties. The consistency and seriousness of the Applicant’s conduct while working from home constituted misconduct. Hence, the Commissioner found that the dismissal was justified notwithstanding the factual matters in the employee’s favour.
Key Takeaway
- If employers can prove that employees are not working diligently and inattentively from home, they are justified in dismissing that employee
If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.