Pointon Partners

Outsourced but Not Outside the Law: the Pascua Case

In this era of growing technological and economic integration, the modern workplace is no longer confined to national boundaries. Businesses are increasingly choosing to outsource various roles such as administrative work or marketing to foreign markets where workers can be engaged at a significantly lower cost. While these decisions can offer clear financial benefits, they also raise complex legal questions particularly around the nature of the relationship between the company and the worker and the entitlements, if any, that the worker may have under Australian law.

These issues were central to the recent decision by the Fair Work Commission’s (FWC) in Ms Joanna Pascua v Doessel Group Pty Ltd [2025] FWC 1833. Whilst the decision itself is an application for an unfair dismissal remedy, Ms. Joanna Pascua, had to first seek leave from the FWC for approval prior to making such a claim. This was heard by the FWC inJoanna Pascua v Doessel Group Pty Ltd [2024] FWC 2669 and the subsequent appeal application heard by the Full Bench in Doessel Group Pty Ltd v Joanna Pascua [2025] FWCFB 43.

This article focuses on the initial application made by Ms Pascua and the subsequent appeal and examines the significance of the characterisation of the contractual relationship between a worker and a business and its role in determining the employer’s potential legal liabilities.

Facts

  1. Ms Joanna Pascua (the Applicant) is a Philippine national who lived and performed work in the Philippines as a legal assistant for the company, Legal Practice Holdings Group Pty Ltd trading as MyCRA Lawyers (the Company).
  2. MyCRA Lawyers operates in Queensland and represents itself as Australia’s only specialist credit repair lawyers. Ms Pascua performed work remotely for the company pursuant to a contract that she had with the respondent, Doessel Group Pty Ltd (the Respondent).
  3. Pursuant to the Contract titled ‘Independent Contractor’s Agreement’ which commenced 21 July 2022, the Applicant was to perform paralegal work for the Company. She was expected to work during times that matched business hours in Australia, was allocated files by email each day, and was expected to liaise with clients and banks and other credit agencies on behalf of the clients. She also had to meet key performance indicators such as four hours of billable per day, or adding $2000 in disbursements per day.
  4. The Applicant also had an email address with the Company’s domain name and a signature block on her emails which identified her as a paralegal for the Company. Within 12 months of her commencement she was performing unsupervised work and also was training others. The Applicant was paid at an hourly rate of $18.00 and the maximum time she could claim was eight hours a day across five days. Of the 83 invoices that she had submitted during her engagement with the Company, 55 were for payment for the maximum 40 hours of work.
  5. On 20 March 2024, the Applicant was terminated. The Applicant asserted that during the last few months prior to the termination, the Company’s principal became increasingly critical, set unreasonable expectations and refused to approve overtime. The Applicant was then terminated on the basis that she had unlawfully copied company information and client information to her personal drive and thus had breached her contract. The Applicant denies that such conduct happened and claims that if such claims are true, then her computer was accessed remotely by someone else who engaged in the conduct.
  6. Accordingly the Applicant contends that she was an employee and was unfairly dismissed. Conversely, the Respondent maintains that the Applicant was an independent contractor and thus was not eligible to access the unfair dismissal regime.

The Issues at Hand:

The primary question at hand before the FWC was whether the Applicant was entitled to access the unfair dismissal regime. This gave rise to two threshold questions:

  1. Whether the Applicant should be considered an independent contractor or an employee; and
  2. If an employee, would the Applicant fall under the definition of a national system employee?

Independent Contractor or Employee

In determining the nature of the relationship, Deputy President Slevin applied the principles set out by the High Court in CFMMEU v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 1 (Personnel Contracting) and ZG Operations Pty Ltd and Jamsek [2022] HCA 2 (Jamsek).

The Principles in Personnel Contracting and Jamsek

The decisions in Personnel Contracting and Jamsek found that if there is a valid, comprehensive and written contract which is not a sham or otherwise altered, then the nature of the relationship must be determined with reference to the contract alone. This means that it is irrelevant whether the subsequent conduct that follows from the contract is consistent with the terms of the contract.

In assessing the contract, the High Court stated that there are two key factors which often help identify the relationship.

Other relevant considerations included the provisions in the contract that relate to remuneration, provision and maintenance of equipment, the obligation to work, the hours of work and the provision of holidays. The High Court also found that the use of labels is not definitive and that ultimately due regard needs to be had to the entire contract.

The Current Test to Assess the Nature of the Relationship

It is important to note that, although the applicable test at the time of the decision at first instance was that set out in Personnel Contracting and Jamsek, this has since been overridden by s 15AA of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the Act), which came into effect on 26 August 2024. Under this new provision, the determination of whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor must consider the contract but also the totality of the working relationship and how the contract is performed in practice.

Since s 15AA of the Act was not in force at the relevant time, Deputy President Slevin applied the principles in Jamsek and Personnel Contracting, and found that the Applicant was indeed an employee. This was due to a variety of factors including:

Ultimately, her work was subordinate to the business of the Company and “it can be seen to have been performed as an employee of that business rather than as part of an independent enterprise conducted” by the Applicant. Upon the application to appeal, the Full Bench of the FWC agreed with the assessment by Deputy President Slevin and found that there was no error in the overall assessment. Thus, the Applicant was found at first instance and later on the application to appeal, to have been engaged as an employee rather than as an independent contractor.

Was the Applicant a National System Employee?

The Applicant worked in the Philippines. The Applicant had never relevantly visited or performed work in Australia. This is relevant because it raises doubt as to whether she is a national system employee as, pursuant to section 380 of the Act ), the unfair dismissal regime only applies to national system employees.

At the first instance, the Deputy President invited submissions on this point however, the Respondent was content to rely on its argument that there was no employment and thus the issue does not arise. In the absence of argument to the contrary, the Deputy President was satisfied that the Applicant was a national system employee.

Upon the application to appeal, the Full Bench of the FWC conducted further analysis as to this issue. The Full Bench found that the Respondent is without doubt a national system employer. Whilst the Full Bench found that it should logically follow that the Applicant, as an employee of the Respondent, is a national system employee it did not provide a conclusive answer.

The Full Bench also provided further commentary about the territorial limits of the Act.

Regulation 1.15F(5) of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) extends the unfair dismissal regime to any Australian-based employee in relation to the Australian employer without territorial limitation. The definition of an Australian based employee can be found in s 35 of the Act.

35 Meanings of Australian employer and Australian-based employee

(2) An Australian-based employee is an employee:

(a) whose primary place of work is in Australia; or

(b) who is employed by an Australian employer (whether the employee is located in Australia or elsewhere); or

(c) who is prescribed by the regulations.

(3) However, paragraph 2(b) does not apply to an employee who is engaged outside Australia and the external Territories to perform duties outside Australia and the external Territories.

The question before the Full Bench was whether section 35(3) applied. The Full Bench identified that there were two limbs to section 35(3) that needed to be satisfied.

  1. Firstly that the employee was engaged outside of Australia and the external Territories; and
  2. Secondly, that the duties were performed outside of Australia and the external Territories.

The second limb was uncontroversial as although the Applicant’s work concerned clients of the business in Australia, her work was performed entirely outside of Australia. The key issue was whether the Applicant had been engaged outside of Australia.

The Full Bench referred to various decisions and affirmed the comments by His Honour in Cohen v iSoft Group Pty Limited [2012] FCA 1071 and found that the location of the formation of the contract conforms to the ordinary meaning of the word engaged.

In other words, a worker will be found to have been engaged in Australia if the contract was formed in Australia. The Full Bench also found that the formation of a contract occurred upon receipt by the offeror of communication of its acceptance by the offeree. Thus, if certain logical inferences were made, the Applicant would have been found to have not been engaged outside Australia.

Ultimately the Full Bench did not make a definitive finding and declined to grant permission to appeal on this jurisdictional issue. The Full Bench held that although the matter is important, it was not in the public interest to grant permission to appeal.

For the purposes of the Applicant though, the unfair dismissal claim could still proceed and in Ms Joanna Pascua v Doessel Group Pty Ltd [2025] FWC 1833 the Deputy President the Deputy President found that the Applicant had indeed been unfairly dismissed and was entitled to compensation amounting to 15 weeks’ pay.

What does this mean for you?

The Pascua case underscores the importance for Australian businesses to accurately characterise their relationships with offshore workers. If the practical and contractual circumstances indicate that the worker is an employee, then the employer may face liabilities under Australian employment law even if the worker is based entirely overseas.

Although the Pascua case deals specifically with unfair dismissal, the fact that she was able to access the unfair dismissal regime may carry broader consequences for Australian employers who engage overseas workers. It means that not only are overseas workers potentially entitled to the protections of the unfair dismissal regime, but if classified as an Australian based employee, they may also be entitled to the National Employment Standards, minimum wages and other award conditions.

While this is an interesting point to note, this was not the subject of the Applicant’s current action and would likely need a separate Federal Court or Federal Circuit Court action.

In light of this, whether you are engaging offshore workers or even independent contractors within Australia, we recommend that you review your contracts and ensure that both the contract and the subsequent conduct accurately reflect an independent contractor relationship.

If you require any assistance with any of the issues described in this article or other employment matters, please contact Michael Bishop, Amelita Hensman or Mark Stephen of our Employment Law Team.

Employee sues for $780k after alleged breach of Right to Disconnect

It has been just under a year since we last discussed the introduction of the new legislative changes to the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FWA) granting employees the right to disconnect. Now, the courts are facing the first public test of how this new right is to be interpreted and implemented, potentially setting a key precedent for how similar cases will be assessed in the future.

The case involves a Queensland teacher who claims she was unfairly dismissed after exercising her right to disconnect by not responding to work-related communications, during a period she maintains constituted school holidays, contrary to her employer’s belief. Throughout this time she had also requested an extension to respond to the allegations, however this was denied by her employer. The Queensland teacher is now seeking $780,000 in damages, comprised of loss of future earnings relating to six years of income and $50,000 for emotional distress.

This matter is significant for a number of reasons. Most notably, it is expected to pave the way for how future claims under the right to disconnect in section 333M of the FWA will be assessed by the courts. In addition to shaping the legal framework around this new workplace entitlement, many legal professionals anticipate that this case will provide much-needed clarity on several key considerations. These include:

The outcome of this case is likely to influence not only future litigation but also how employers approach internal policies, communication protocols and employee entitlements in the evolving landscape of workplace rights.

Employers are strongly advised to proceed with caution when considering disciplinary action in response to an employee’s refusal or failure to engage with work related communications outside of their contracted hours. Legal experts have underscored the critical importance of ensuring managers are appropriately trained to navigate this area of the law, and that clear, well documented policies are in place.

This case serves as a timely reminder for employers to review employment contracts and internal policies to ensure expectations around after-hours availability are clearly defined, particularly in circumstances involving leave, illness, or other personal matters. For those operating or employed in small businesses (with fewer than 15 employees), the right to disconnect obligations will take effect from 26 August 2025.

We will continue to follow this case and provide an update once a decision has been reached.

If you require further advice on managing out of hours contact or how to update your internal policies and employment contracts in light of these changes, please contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.

Employers Beware – $100,000 Fine for Failing to Ensure Safe and Appropriate Workplace

In May 2025, an employer was served with an $100,000 fine for failing to provide a safe workplace for their employees.  In doing so, the Magistrates’ Court found that the employer had failed to create a suitable policy on what was appropriate and inappropriate behavior and implement that policy by training managers, supervisors and employees. This case highlights that employers have an active duty to their employees to ensure a safe work environment and the significant financial penalties and reputational risk if they fail to comply.

Background

Blisspell Pty Ltd, the employer, operated a business under the name of Toy Networx from a factory in Reservoir. A Toy Networx employee had made allegations of inappropriate behavior at the workplace alleging that the director of the employer had made several remarks and had sent text messages of a promiscuous nature that had crossed professional boundaries and intruded into her personal life.

A subsequent WorkSafe investigation commenced in October 2022 and concluded in January 2023 and found that the employer had no “formal system in place to identify, prevent, manage, investigate or respond to the inappropriate workplace behavior alleged, due to an absence of the following:

WorkSafe Executive Director of Health and Safety Sam Jenkin said sexual harassment was a serious workplace safety issue known to cause both psychological and physical harm.

Decision

The employer had failed to appear at the Court hearing and therefore, the prosecution was successful in an ex parte application meaning the case was determined summarily against the employer.

The Court had found that the employer had failed to:

Notably, in passing the sentence, the Court considered:

As such, the employer was served with a $100,000 fine and ordered to pay costs of $6,060.

Takeaways for Employers

This decision highlights the overarching duties that employers have to their employees to keep their workplace safe. Section 21 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Victoria) (the Act) acknowledges that employers have a duty to provide and maintain so far as reasonably practicable, a working environment that is safe and without risks to health.  Section 21 of the Act requires employers to:

A failure to comply with section 21 of the Act may lead to a fine of up to 1,800 penalty units ($366,318) for a natural person and 9000 penalty units ($1,831,590) for a body corporate. Penalty units are used to define the amount payable for fines for many offences. One penalty unit is currently $203.51 as at 1 July 2025.

The Victorian Government has confirmed new psychological health regulations will be introduced by the end of the year. The new Occupational Health and Safety (Psychological Health) Regulations will put psychosocial hazards on the same footing as physical ones and are expected to make a meaningful difference to safety and wellbeing in many Victorian workplaces. Psychosocial hazards are work-related factors with potential to cause harm, such as bullying, sexual harassment, aggression or violence and exposure to traumatic events.

We will continue to keep you informed of these developments as they occur.

If you have any queries, or require assistance in drafting workplace policies or complying with your obligations under the Act please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our office.

Over $400,000 in compensation and penalties ordered against employer for unlawful adverse action

In a Federal Court decision, Justice Shariff has found that an aged care provider, St Basil’s Homes (“Employer”), contravened the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) by dismissing a registered nurse (“Employee”) in breach of her general protections under the Act. The Court held that the Employer took adverse action against the Employee both because she exercised her workplace right to make complaints contravening section 340(1)(a) and due to her race contravening section 351 of the FW Act .

Background

The Employee was of a Chinese background, and was employed at one of the Employers aged care facilities in Sydney. The Employee alleged she had made several complaints during 2019 regarding bullying, overwork, and discriminatory behaviour by her Filipino colleagues. She also raised concerns over staff members’ refusing to assist her when providing care to residents at the home.

Rather than addressing these complaints, the employer issued a “first and final warning” in September 2019 and subsequently terminated her employment in January 2020, shortly after she made further complaints.

Legal Claims

Justice Rares found that the Employer took adverse action against the Employee:

The Court rejected the Employer’s argument and noted that that the Employer’s justification was inconsistent, unsupported by evidence, and appeared to be an attempt to rationalise the true reasons for dismissal.

The Court’s Findings – Termination of Employment
Justice Shariff found that St Basil’s unlawfully terminated the Employee’s employment in serious contravention of the FW Act, both for exercising her workplace rights and because of her race. He agreed with Justice Rares’ findings that St Basil’s failed to properly investigate the Employee’s complaints and instead turned them against her, leading to her dismissal. Justice Shariff rejected the employers defence, concluding the dismissal was not based on genuine concerns about the Employee’s conduct but was instead discriminatory.

Court Decision:

Justice Shariff held that the Employee was entitled to compensation under section 545(2)(b) of the FW Act as her dismissal by the employer contravened her workplace rights and protections against racial discrimination.. His Honour ordered total compensation of $346,559, comprising of the following;

In addition to compensation, Justice Shariff imposed civil penalties under the FW Act, ordering St Basil’s pay $45,000 for the racial discrimination breach (s 351) and $15,000 for the workplace rights contravention (s 340).

Takeaways for Employers

This decision reinforces the importance of genuinely investigating employee complaints, especially those involving discrimination or workplace bullying. Further employers must be cautious in how they respond to complaints and adverse action taken shortly after an employee raises concerns. It is clear that the financial cost to an employer can be significant if it fails to handle employee complaints appropriately. In addition to potential civil penalties employers also need to consider the   risk to reputational damage which can have a significant impact on a business.

Please contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team for any assistance you require in relation to termination of employment or discrimination complaints.

New Wage Theft Laws: What Employers Need to Know to Avoid Criminal Charges

As of 1 January 2025, employers can face criminal charges for intentionally underpaying wages or entitlements. The new wage theft laws are part of the Closing Loopholes legislative changes, and include a significant amendment to the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FWA). This momentous shift follows the lodging of the Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code Declaration 2024 (the Code) on December 16, 2024, with the Federal Register of Legislation, which paved the way for the implementation of the new wage theft criminal offence. These changes are part of broader reform initiatives aimed at addressing and closing gaps in wage compliance.

Under the changes, the intentional underpayment of wages or entitlements is now a criminal offence. This includes instances where employers pay less than the minimum entitlements stipulated under the FWA such as wages, superannuation, and other mandated benefits, as well as deliberately failing to make these payments by the agreed due date.

Penalties for wage underpayment offences vary between businesses and individuals. For businesses found guilty of this offence, the penalty will be the greater of three times the underpayment amount or $7.825 million, however if the underpayment amount cannot be determined, the business may face a fine of up to $7.825 million.

For individuals, penalties could include imprisonment for up to 10 years. Additionally, if the underpayment amount is determined, the penalty will be the greater of three times the underpayment amount or $1.565 million. If the underpayment amount cannot be determined, a fine of $1.565 million will apply.

There is however an exception to the rule. The underpayment of employees’ wages and benefits may not be considered a criminal offence if the court determines that the employer did not intentionally underpay their employees and that the underpayment was the result of an honest mistake.

The Code was developed as a guide to help small businesses prevent the occurrence of wage theft offences. The Code will also be used by the Fair Work Ombudsman to assess whether an employer has intentionally underpaid their employees. However, as the Code does not provide a specific checklist of rules and procedures, the assessment will consider the business as a whole, and taking into account the specific circumstances of the case, to determine whether the Code has been adhered to.

The Fair Work Ombudsman has outlined the following considerations that will be taken into account when assessing an employer’s compliance with the Code:

As an employer it is crucial to prioritise key compliance areas that will help safeguard against unintended breaches and align with evolving wage theft regulations. We suggest that employers consider the following to protect their business against risk:

The introduction of criminal penalties for intentional wage underpayment represents a significant shift in workplace law. Pointon Partners has extensive experience in assisting business compliance and if you have any queries or require assistance please contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.

Employer liability for work Christmas parties

It’s that time of year again when work Christmas parties are being planned. The annual office Christmas party is an occasion to relax and celebrate the year’s accomplishments. However too often inappropriate behaviour fuelled by alcohol occurs which can lead to devastating consequences for employees and the employer alike. For the wellbeing of all attending employees and employers need to understand their rights and responsibilities.

Despite often being held away from the office and even perhaps outside regular working hours, workplace laws apply to work Christmas parties. Employers retain their duty of care towards employees during these events. Critically, employers are vicariously responsible for an employees’ behaviour to another employee, as they have the right and duty to control them. Harm resulting from an employee’s inappropriate conduct, such as discrimination, harassment, or bullying, often exacerbated by excessive alcohol consumption, is a risk for employers.

Therefore, employers should proactively remind employees about what is acceptable behaviour, codes of conduct, workplace and social media policies and responsible alcohol consumption. This communication should be in writing and provided prior to the event.

Importantly, there is now a positive duty on employers and persons conducting a business or undertaking to eliminate workplace sex discrimination and harassment.

This change requires employers to shift their focus to actively preventing workplace sexual harassment and discrimination, rather than responding only after it occurs. The positive duty requires employers to take reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate, as far as possible, sex discrimination, sexual harassment, sex-based harassment, behaviours that create a hostile workplace environment on the ground of sex and related acts of victimisation occurring in a work context or in connection with work.

There are a number of issues that should be considered before, during and post function to manage incidents that may occur at a Christmas work function:

  1. Is the venue appropriate and safe?

Ensuring the venue will safely serve alcohol is important. If you have employees less than 18 years of age, ensure the servers understand this and that they or employees do not provide alcoholic drinks to them. The venue should be able to be accessed by all employees, for example is it mobility impaired friendly? The ambience of the venue should encourage appropriate behaviour and to help employees get home safely a venue accessible by public transport is useful.

  1. What food and drink will be served?

Functions that offer small servings of finger food but freely available alcohol may exacerbate the risk of inappropriate behaviour and injury by increasing the likelihood of employee’s over-indulging. If the employer does not have a food budget to cover a meal for each employee it should also reduce the alcohol budget to ensure safe service. Regardless of the food provided, the employer must provide a range of non-alcoholic drink options.

Consider putting a limit or cap on how much people can drink rather than having an open bar for the duration of the function. Also being mindful of the types of alcohol that is served at the function for example providing beer and wine but not spirits.

  1. Kris Kingle or Secret Santa

If the employer conducts a Kris Kringle or Secret Santa, ensure that employees understand by way of written communication that any gifts they purchase must be ‘G’ rated. This means that the recipient or others who will see the present should not have cause for offence leading to a possible breach of the organisation’s policies.

  1. Timing of the function

It is important to set specific start and end times for the Christmas work function and to let employees know that any after-party events organised by employees are not authorised by the employer.

  1. Staff communication

As noted above written communication to staff is key in risk mitigation. In addition to the practical benefit of reminding employees of their responsibilities and obligations under employer policies and encouraging safe and responsible behaviour it is also evidence that the employer took reasonably practicable steps to prevent conduct in breach of its policies.

  1. Getting home safely

If the venue is not accessible by public transport or public transport is not appropriate given the time the function concludes consider offering employees paid taxis or other paid transport to get them home safely. Alternatively the employer could arrange for end of function taxi or ride share pools to that employees who live in the same direction or area share a ride home.

Finally, many employees also attend other organisation’s Christmas functions in the course of employment such as a Christmas party hosted by a client or supplier. These events present the same risk and liability issues as internal functions so employers need to ensure that employees attending outside gatherings in the course of their employment understand the required standard of conduct.

Well planned office Christmas parties can boost morale and foster camaraderie. By considering and addressing the above issues, both employers and employees can ensure a fun and inclusive celebration while safeguarding their personal and professional reputations, as well as avoiding potential legal issues.

For further information or assistance, please contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.

Racing Clubs Face the Superannuation Stakes

In late July 2024, the AAT held that pursuant to the Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (“SG Act”), jockeys who raced at tracks owned by five race clubs between the period of 2009 to 2014 were employees of the clubs. The AAT found that due to a lack of evidence raised by the clubs, section 12(3) of the SG Act did not apply and s12(8) was the more appropriate provision to apply.

These matters was heard in five separate cases where the AAT found that all the race club taxpayers were employers of the jockeys for the purpose of the SG Act. These cases include:

Given that prior to 2014, the construction of some State’s local rules of racing implicated that the race clubs are employers of jockeys, these lines of cases are important in understanding whether race clubs are liable for any superannuation payments to jockeys prior to 2014.

Facts

The taxpayers in these cases were horse racing clubs operating in NSW. For the 2009 to 2014 financial years, the jockeys of the race horse owners were paid a fee by the clubs in accordance with the NSW local racing rule under LR72. LR72, prior to 2014, stated the following:

Clubs shall pay such fee for a jockey or apprentice jockey in consideration for their riding a horse in a race or a barrier trial as may be set from time to time by the Board …

The ATO contended that the clubs were obligated to make super contributions in relation to the fees paid by the jockeys as they would have been caught under s12(8) of the SG Act. S12(8) relevantly provides:

The following are employees for the purposes of this Act:

A person who is paid to perform or present, or to participate in the performance or presentation of, any music, play, dance, entertainment, sport, display or promotional activity or any similar activity involving the exercise of intellectual, artistic, musical, physical or other personal skills is an employee of the person liable to make payment.

The clubs argued that the jockeys were not their employees for two reasons. First is that section 12(3) should apply as they had a contract principally for their labour with the race horse owners and second, they were not liable to pay the fees as they merely did it on behalf of the race horse owners and were not liable to make payments to the jockeys under LR72.

Decision

Issue 1 – Section 12(3) – Was there a contract that was wholly or principally for the labour of the jockeys?

The AAT found that the race clubs had failed to discharge their burden of proof that the jockeys were the employees of the race horse owners. The clubs had failed to present any substantive evidence which indicated that there was a contract between the jockeys and the horse owners or who the parties were.

Further, the relationship between the jockeys and race horse owners was more akin to a joint venture where there was little scope for control beyond a set of tactical instructions relayed to the jockey before the race. Once the race commenced, the jockey had full agency on how the race would be run. As such, the AAT inferred that the jockeys were contracted to produce a result rather than for their labour.

Issue 2 – Section 12(8) – Were the clubs liable to pay the fees to the jockeys?

The crux of this issue was whether the clubs were liable to pay the fees to the jockeys. As noted beforehand, LR72 provided that it was the clubs which were liable to pay the fees to the jockeys. The clubs contended that LR72 provided an administrative mechanism whereby moneys held by the race clubs were paid to the jockeys on behalf of the owner or trainer for the benefit of the owner or trainers, in discharge of a liability of the owner or trainer.

However the AAT found that there was no express reference in LR72 to payments being made on behalf of someone else. The Tribunal found that the clubs had attempted to import words into LR72 to the effect that they made the payments on behalf of the race horse owners or trainers. The Tribunal found that the interpretation of the clubs flew in the face of the clear plain language of the rule and section. The plain language of LR72 indicated that liability rested solely with the clubs to make the fee payments to jockeys that raced.

This is interesting due to the fact that there is no strict time limit for the ATO to pursue superannuation claims. Given that some State’s respective rules of racing were only modified in 2014 due to the issue outlined above, then any racing club who failed to pay superannuation and were liable to pay under their respective rules of racing may be liable.

This is a considerable issue in Victoria as prior to July 2014, LR32 of Victoria’s local rules of racing stated the following:

Racing Clubs must pay the fees as published in the Prescribed Fee Schedule to Jockeys and riders in consideration for their riding in races conducted by the Club.

The construction of the above clause indicates that much like NSW’s old LR72, the clubs are liable to make the fee payments to the jockeys for riding in the races and would be caught under section 12(8) of the SG Act. As such, given that there is no prescribed time limit in which the ATO can stop pursuing superannuation claims, clubs in Victoria may be liable for their failure to make any superannuation payments to jockeys prior to 2014. A further discussion on possible consequences of failing to meet superannuation obligations may be found here.

Takeaway

These line of cases are an important reminder of the extended meaning of employee for Superannuation purposes, a mere common law employee may be caught under this extended meaning. Further, it highlights that in the context of any sport, entertainment or promotional activity, liability for superannuation rests on whoever is liable to make payments. Clubs should then consider auditing past payments and ensuring that they are in compliance with their superannuation obligations.

If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.

Unfair Contract Terms: New Avenues for Independent Contractors to Pursue Claims

From 26 August 2024, changes to the Fair Work Act 2009 will occur in respect of independent contractors and unfair contract terms. In substance, these changes enable independent contractors who earn below the high income threshold to dispute unfair contract terms in the Fair Work Commission, offering a more efficient way for contractors to pursue redress. The Commission will have the power to vary or set aside contractor agreements, and this change should be noted by all businesses who use the services of independent contractors.

Threshold Requirement

The changes are intended to offer a faster and cheaper way of obtaining relief against unfair contract terms for independent contractors. To this end, two routes are offered to independent contractors to challenge the validity of unfair terms in their contract, depending on whether they earn more or less than the high income threshold (currently $175,000):

Independent contractors who are classified as consumers or small businesses will maintain access to the unfair contract terms regime under the Australian Consumer Law, including the right to raise complaints to the ACCC and to commence legal proceedings.

What’s New for Independent Contractors

The new section 536ND of the Fair Work Act outlines that an independent contractor earning below the high income threshold may apply to the Commission for a remedy on the basis that the services contract contains a term that is unfair, provided the term relates to a “workplace relations matter”.

Unfair Term

In determining whether a term in a services contract is unfair, the Commission will take into account:

Workplace Relations Matters

The Commission can only review a services contract for unfair terms if they relate to a workplace relations matter. This is defined under section 536JQ to include any of the following:

Remedies

Under section 536NC of the Fair Work Act, the Commission can make an order to either:

Penalties

In addition, the contravention of an order made by the Commission in this jurisdiction is punishable by a maximum penalty of 60 penalty units (currently $11,855.30).

Conclusion

This new framework applies to services contracts entered into after 26 August 2024. Businesses that utilise the services of independent contractors should review their current contractor agreements to identify potential unfair terms.

If you require advice regarding th independent contractors or assistance with reviewing template agreements, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Ben Drysdale of our Employment Law Team

Right to Disconnect Rules Commence

We refer to our previous update titled “New Reform giving employees the right to disconnect”.  These changes have now commenced, effective 26 August 2024.

Employees who are employed by a large business, which is defined as a business who employs more than 15 employees, will have the right to refuse to monitor, read or respond to contact, from an employer if such communication is deemed unreasonable.

However these reforms will not take effect until August 2025 for employees working in small businesses, which is defined as a business which employs less than 15 employees.

See below a list of some considerations that will be taken into account when determining unreasonable communication:

For further details on the right to disconnect please see our previous article “New Reform giving employees the right to disconnect”.

If you require additional information or advice regarding the right to disconnect please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.

Increase in High Income Threshold

Unfair Dismissal

Employers should be aware of certain changes regarding the unfair dismissal provisions. For the unfair dismissal provisions to apply, assuming the employee has completed the minimum period of employment, the employee must:

Since the start of the financial year at 1 July 2024, the High-income threshold has been increased from $167,500 to $175,000. As such, for the provisions to apply, the employee must either be covered by a modern award or enterprise agreement or earn less than $175,000 per annum.

High Income Guarantees

Further, employers should also note the application of the increase to high income guarantees and making employees award free. A high income guarantee is essentially an undertaking made by the employer to the award-covered employee that they will be paid more than the high income threshold for a period of 12 months. Employees must accept this promise for the guarantee to apply. Once it is in effect, the employee will be a high income worker and will be award free.

However, a mere promise to pay the employee more than the threshold does not mean that they are a high income worker. This was discussed in Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers Australia v Peabody Energy Australia Coal Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 945. In that case, the court decided that in addition to paying more than the threshold, the employee must agree to the undertaking and the amount of earnings as well as there being a guarantee period for when the employee is paid this amount. Further, the undertaking must be in writing and separate from the contract of employment.

Given the changes in the high income threshold, employers are encouraged to review their contracts and undertaking with employees and assess whether their high income guarantees still apply.

If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team