Pointon Partners

No Shield for HR: Personal Liability in the Modern Workplace

5733

Human Resources professionals are often at the heart of an organisation, with deep visibility across operations, resolving issues as they arise and helping ensure the business functions effectively. However in some work place’s HR managers are often pulled from their core jobs to have a more formative role on how the business in run by assisting with decisions of strategy, risk, and guiding executive action, where such power can lead to greater legal exposure.

Laws which expose HR to legal liabilities:

This shift brings HR into closer proximity with legal accountability. Under Australian law, individuals, not just organisations, can be held personally liable for breaches of workplace legislation. In particular, the definition of an “officer” under section 9AD of the Corporations Act 2001 states an officer is a person “who makes, or participates in making, decisions that affect the whole, or a substantial part, of the business of the corporation;”or “who has the capacity to affect significantly the corporation’s financial standing”.

In addition, section 550 of the Fair Work Act 2009 extends liability beyond the primary wrongdoer.A person who is “involved” in a contravention is taken to have contravened the provision themselves. This includes situations where a person has aided, abetted, counselled or procured the breach; induced it; been knowingly concerned in it whether by act or omission; or conspired with others to bring it about.

These provisions read together significantly expand the scope of personal liability for HR practitioners.

Key Factors Courts Consider When Assessing HR Liability:

Courts do not impose personal liability lightly. However, where HR practitioners step beyond administrative functions and into decision-making, advisory, or enforcement roles, their conduct is closely scrutinised. Several key factors commonly influence whether liability will arise.

  1. Degree of involvement in the contravention
    A central question is whether the HR practitioner was “involved” in the breach within the meaning of section 550 of the Fair Work Act 2009. This does not require direct wrongdoing. Courts will examine whether the individual participated in, facilitated, or failed to prevent unlawful conduct. Even passive conduct, such as knowingly allowing a breach to continue, may be sufficient.
  2. Knowledge and awareness of the breach
    Liability often turns on whether the HR practitioner had actual or constructive knowledge of the unlawful conduct. Where an individual knew, or ought reasonably to have known, that their actions or even inaction would contribute to a breach, courts are more likely to find them personally liable.
  3. Level of authority and decision-making power
    The more senior and influential the HR role, the greater the expectation of accountability. HR professionals who contribute to strategic decisions, approve policies, or influence executive outcomes may fall within the definition of an “officer” as stated above, and therefore owe due diligence obligations. Their failure to exercise that responsibility can expose them to liability.
  4. Participating in unlawful conduct
    Where HR practitioners take deliberate steps that contribute to a breach such as directing others to engage in unlawful practices, endorsing non-compliant processes, or implementing flawed systems courts are more likely to impose penalties. Acting under instruction is not, in itself, a defence if the conduct is known to be unlawful.
  5. Failure to take reasonable preventative steps
    HR professionals are often seen as custodians of compliance frameworks within organisations. A failure to implement, monitor, or enforce appropriate systems such as payroll controls, grievance procedures, or workplace safety mechanisms can be viewed as a breach of duty, particularly where risks were foreseeable and preventable.

Practical Steps to Mitigate Personal Risk

Given the expanding scope of HR responsibility, practitioners must take proactive steps to protect themselves while continuing to support organisational objectives:

Conclusion

The evolution of HR into a strategic and governance focused function reflects its growing importance within modern organisations. However, with increased influence comes increased accountability. Australian workplace laws make it clear that HR practitioners are not merely advisors operating behind the scene, they can be active participants in contraventions, and therefore personally liable.

Employers, Are You Prepared If an Employee Reports Psychosocial Hazards to WorkSafe Victoria?

Victoria’s Psychosocial Health Regulations have been in force for over 6 months now coming into effect on 1 December 2025.

We refer to our previous Update on this topic in December 2025 where we noted a key takeaway for employers was to be able to demonstrate to WorkSafe Victoria that they have in place safety management systems which align with the new requirements and help promote compliance with those requirements.

The Occupational Health and Safety (Psychological Health) Regulations 2025 (the Regulations) require employers in Victoria to identify psychosocial hazards and control risk, so far as is reasonably practicable. Importantly, reliance on information, instruction and/or training will not constitute compliance with the employer’s duty unless the employer has applied the de facto hierarchy of control, focusing on elimination of risks, and considering the employer’s management, systems and design of work.

It is not sufficient to simply rely on existing Sexual Harassment, Bullying and Discrimination polices your organisation may have on hand. This alone will not demonstrate compliance with the Regulations.

Has your organisation identified the psychosocial hazards in your particular workplace? Have you turned your mind to hazards such as high job demands, poor organisational change management, or poor workplace relationships?

The next step is to assess the risk which could affect different employees in your organisation differently.

What control measures is your organisation implementing to control the psychosocial hazards and risks?

Employers should also note that an employee at any time can report psychosocial hazards to WorkSafe Victoria by telephone. They can then detail to an advisor over the phone the specifics of the hazard or WorkSafe Victoria will send them a hazard form for completion. The reality is a disgruntled employee looking to exit your organisation could well utilise this reporting mechanism if your organisation has not taken appropriate steps to comply.

WorkSafe Victoria is currently visiting businesses to check what steps your business has taken to eliminate or control as far as is reasonably practicable psychosocial hazards.

To avoid Provisional Improvement Notices or heavy financial penalties employers are expected to take a proactive approach. Engaging a legal provider to assist your organisation through the process contemplated by the Regulations will assist with showing your organisation takes compliance with these Regulations seriously.

In addition to avoiding the negative consequences of non-compliance astute leaders will appreciate the long term financial and other benefits of compliance with the Regulations. Psychosocial injury is the fastest growing type of injury in every state and territory of Australia and the cost of psychological injury claims are significantly more costly than physical injury claims. Median compensation for serious mental health claims is more than three times higher than for physical injuries. Psychological injuries result in substantially longer time away from work with workers with a serious psychological injury experiencing a median of approximately 35 to 36 weeks off work compared with around 8 weeks for other serious workers’ compensation claims.

Employees, Beware of the Side Hustle

The Fair Work Commission has upheld a dismissal of a senior
staff-member for taking up a secondary job because it contravened
their contractual duties.

With side jobs and secondary careers becoming increasingly
common, this decision highlights the importance of reviewing the
terms of employment before considering taking on an additional
position.

The Facts

The Legal Issues

The primary issues in this decision were as follows:

The Decision

On the question of whether the employer had condoned the
secondary career, the Fair Work Commission established that the
element of 'full knowledge' required for condonation
(summarised in Rankin v Marine Power International Pty Ltd
[2001] VSC
150) is relatively strict. It was accepted that the
employee had discussed their life-coaching business at work and
that evidence, such as their LinkedIn account, would certainly hint
at its existence. Nevertheless, the facts did not clearly affirm
the employer's knowledge and thus they could not be said to
have condoned it. The Commission considered the terms in the
contract, which defined what the employee could do with respect to
a second job.

The employment contract stated that employees were required to
'serve efficiently, faithfully and diligently' and devote
their time and attention exclusively to the employer. It also
prohibited undertaking any other business or profession which would
create a conflict of interest. Persistent or sustained breach of
these duties would constitute serious misconduct.

Emails on the employee's work devices revealed that they
were discussing their secondary career with actual and prospective
clients of the employer, instead of providing them with the
services of his employer. Further emails the employee had sent
discussing the business showed that it was a 'consuming
passion' drawing their attention away from their work for the
employer.

The employer was experiencing a downturn and looking for ways to
reinvigorate; rather than assisting, the employee was creating
extensive social media content and a digital marketing strategy for
their own pursuits.

In light of these facts, the Commission found that there was a
valid reason for dismissing the employee on the basis of the
secondary career.

Section 387 of the Fair Work Act also states that the procedural
requirements for a fair dismissal may be eased if the enterprise is
small and absent a dedicated human resources management specialist.
The employer had recently lost seven employees and was down to just
four at the time the employee was dismissed; the Commissioner found
that this could explain the employer's failure to give the
employee an opportunity to respond to their claims.

The employee also brought an argument that their dismissal was
invalid because it was actually for a different reason than what
was given to them. Under the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code,
employers must be dismissing an employee for the reason stated at
termination. The employee alleged that a dispute over a shareholder
agreement was the true operative factor in his firing, not the
alleged breaches of their employment contract. However, the
Commissioner noted that the employee has the practical onus of
establishing this, and on the evidence put forth this could not
established.

Key Takeaway for Employees & Employers

Employers can lawfully require an employee's undivided
attention even outside of work hours, potentially barring secondary
careers.

However, this will depend on the nature of the position
(managerial vs. lower-level), the relationship between the careers
as well as any terms in the employment contract, particularly those
relating to conflicts of interest and the exclusive
'loyalty' of employees. Contractual terms must still be
lawful and reasonable.

In order for an employer to condone a secondary career and waive
the right to dismiss on that basis, they must have full knowledge
of it; employees should take heed and disclose as early as
possible.

In light of this case employers should review their employment
contracts to ensure they are adequately protected. If you require
assistance with the review of your employment agreement or have any
other queries about this case please contact Michael
Bishop
or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Team.

Unfair Dismissal Claim Fails after Employee Refuses Return to Office Direction

Executive Summary

The Fair Work Commission (FWC) has dismissed an unfair dismissal claim brought by a PaperCut employee who was terminated after refusing to comply with a return to office direction. The Commission found the direction to be lawful and reasonable and held that the employee’s contract did not provide an unconditional entitlement to work from home.

The decision reinforces that employers may lawfully require employees to attend the workplace in accordance with contractual terms and workplace policies, and that refusal to comply with such directions may constitute a valid reason for dismissal.

Key Facts

The Legal Issue

The primary issue before the FWC was whether the employee’s dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable, meaning that it would constitute unfair dismissal under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). To determine this, the Commission considered:

  1. Whether PaperCut’s direction requiring the employee to attend the workplace under a hybrid model was lawful and reasonable;
  1. Whether the employee’s contract conferred an entitlement to work from home; and
  1. Whether the employee’s refusal to comply with the direction constituted a valid reason for dismissal.

The Decision

The FWC dismissed the employee’s unfair dismissal application. The Commission found that PaperCut’s direction was lawful and reasonable in the circumstances.

The Commission determined that the employee’s contract did not provide an unconditional right to work from home and that remote work was permitted only subject to company policy. PaperCut was entitled to introduce and enforce a subsequent return to office policy, and the employee’s ongoing refusal to comply constituted a valid reason for dismissal.

The dismissal was not considered harsh, unjust, or unreasonable, taking into account the employer’s consultation, warnings provided, and opportunity for the employee to comply prior to termination.

Key Takeaways for Employers

This decision confirms that employers may lawfully require employees to attend the workplace when such directions are supported by contractual terms and workplace policies. Contracts that permit working from home subject to policy do not automatically create a permanent or unconditional entitlement to remote work.

The ruling also highlights the importance of implementing return to office directions reasonably, including clear communication, consultation, and providing employees with warnings and the opportunity to comply. Where an employee refuses to comply with a lawful and reasonable direction, this may constitute a valid reason for dismissal.

Key Takeaways for Employees

Employees do not have an automatic or unconditional right to work from home, even if prior practice or contractual language permitted remote work. Flexible work arrangements are generally subject to company policies and lawful directions from the employer.

Refusing to comply with a lawful and reasonable direction, such as a hybrid or return to office requirement, can constitute a valid reason for dismissal. In this case, the employee provided no personal reason for not attending the office, contributing to the Commission finding the dismissal was not harsh, unjust, or unreasonable.

By contrast, in a 2025 Westpac case, an employee successfully challenged a return to office direction after formally requesting flexible work under the Fair Work Act for valid carer and personal circumstances.

The case underscores the importance for employees of providing clear reasons and engaging constructively when workplace directions change. Seeking clarification, communicating individual circumstances, and exploring compromise options can significantly reduce the risk of adverse employment outcomes.

Broader Implications

The FWC noted that on 25 February 2022, the Victorian Government removed its strong recommendation for employees to work from home, encouraging a return to the office as pandemic restrictions eased. This illustrates that the reasonableness of refusing to return to the workplace may be assessed differently in the post pandemic context.

If you are reviewing flexible work arrangements, updating employment contracts or policies, or assessing whether a direction provided by your employer is lawful and reasonable, Pointon Partners has extensive experience guiding both employers and employees through these issues. Please contact our Employment Law team for advice.

Criminal Record Checks at Work: Relevance, Spent Convictions and Privacy Risks for Employers

Criminal record checks are now a routine feature of recruitment in many industries, and are increasingly considered by employers as part of their broader risk management and compliance frameworks. They are often introduced with practical objectives in mind: the protection of staff and customers, meeting insurance or regulatory requirements, and safeguarding reputation.

However, criminal record checks can’t be treated as a simple administrative step. In practice, the legal and operational risks associate with criminal records checks tend to arise from how and when they are requested, how the information is used, and whether decisions made on the basis of results are consistent and lawful.

Can an employer require a criminal record check?

In many cases, yes. Employers can generally request a criminal record check from job applicants, and in certain circumstances from existing employees.

The key question is relevance. Employers must ask themselves if there is a genuine connection between criminal history and the inherent requirements of the role. In practice, that means employers should be able to articulate why the check is being requested for that role, rather than defaulting to a blanket approach without any analysis.

Is a criminal record automatically disqualifying?

A criminal record is not, by itself, an automatic bar to employment.

The more defensible approach is to assess whether any recorded history is relevant to the position, having regard to matters such as:

Is the legal landscape uniform?

Australia does not have a single, uniform regime dealing with “criminal record discrimination” across all jurisdictions.

Some jurisdictions provide more direct anti-discrimination protections concerning “irrelevant criminal record”, while the Australian Human Rights Commission can also deal with complaints about criminal record discrimination in employment under the federal framework.

Even where the available remedies for aggrieved parties are limited, employers should not automatically treat this as low risk. Complaints processes can still require management time and can generate reputational issues if such matters become public.

What about spent convictions?

Spent convictions schemes operate across Australia. Broadly, they limit when older or less serious convictions must be disclosed, and they restrict how that information can be used.

The practical risk for employers is not usually that the police check “misses” a spent conviction, rather, it is that:

Employers should therefore be careful about how questions are framed and how information is handled.

What are an employer’s privacy obligations?

Criminal history information is generally treated as sensitive information. That has implications for collection, access, storage and disposal.

One point employers often miss is that privacy exemptions that may apply to employee records do not necessarily apply to job applicants. In other words, recruitment-stage criminal history information typically needs to be handled with particular care, including limiting access to a genuine “need to know” basis and having a clear retention and destruction approach.

Where do employers conducting criminal records checks come unstuck?

From a practical perspective, the higher-risk scenarios tend to involve:

The aim should be a process that is proportionate, consistent and defensible, and that can be clearly explained if it later comes under scrutiny.

Key takeaways

Criminal record checks can be a legitimate and useful tool for employers. The challenge is implementing them in a way that manages risk without creating new legal exposure, particularly around spent convictions, privacy handling and inconsistent decision-making.

Pointon Partners advises employers on recruitment risk, discrimination issues and employment issues. If you are introducing criminal record checks (or revisiting an existing process), our employment team can assist with policy drafting and practical implementation.

Set-Off Clauses Challenged – Federal Court Clarifies Award Payment Obligations in a Major Wakeup Call for Employers

A landmark Federal Court decision has confirmed that set-off clauses in employment contracts will not always validly discharge award entitlements. In Fair Work Ombudsman v Woolworths Group Limited [2025] FCA 1092, the Federal Court held that employers cannot average or offset award underpayments across different pay periods using a set-off clause.

Facts

Woolworths Group Limited (Woolworths) employed salaried employees covered by the General Retail Industry Award 2010 (Award). These employees were paid an annual salary, paid in fortnightly instalments, which exceeded the minimum rate prescribed by the Award.

The employment contracts contained a set-off clause stating that the salary covered all award entitlements, including overtime and penalty rates, calculated over a 26-week period. As a result, Woolworths did not calculate or separately pay award entitlements in each pay period.

Between 2010 and 2020, Woolworths systematically underpaid more than 4,500 salaried staff by failing to ensure their annual salaries were sufficient to cover all hours worked under the Award.

The company self-reported the issue in 2019, estimating over $390 million in back payments owed to employees across its supermarket and Metro stores.

Despite self-reporting and subsequent remediation efforts, the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) pursued civil penalties against Woolworths and several subsidiaries, arguing that the breaches were serious, long-running, and systemic.

Issue

The FWO alleged that Woolworths had underpaid employees because award entitlements must be paid as they are earned, and employers cannot rely on averaging entitlements over an extended period.

The key issue for the Court was whether a set-off clause could lawfully operate across multiple pay periods, rather than within the pay period in which the entitlements arose.

Decision

The Federal Court held that award entitlements must be paid and set off within the same pay period in which they arise.

Employers cannot:

Award entitlements must be paid in full, as actual payments, and as they are earned. Employers cannot use set-off clauses to contract out of their obligations under a modern award.

Accordingly, the Woolworths set-off clauses were invalid because they attempted to cover award entitlements over a 26-week period. Woolworths was found to have underpaid thousands of salaried staff and incurred a significant penalty.

Penalty

In one of the largest workplace law penalties in Australian history, the Federal Court ordered Woolworths to pay $50 million in penalties for widespread and prolonged underpayments to thousands of salaried employees.

The case serves as a stark reminder to all employers of the serious consequences of payroll non-compliance and the importance of proper award interpretation.

Key Takeaways for Employers

Pointon Partners has experience in assisting clients to successfully remedy underpayments and avoid reputational damage. If you wish to discuss this article or have any queries about how your organisation is utilising set off clauses please contact  Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman from our Employment Team.

Victoria’s new psychosocial health regulations have commenced – Employers are you complying?

Victoria’s new psychosocial health regulations have commenced – Employers are you complying?

Since 1 December 2025 a new positive duty applies to Victorian employers to proactively identify, manage and eliminate psychosocial hazards in their workplace. The Occupational Health and Safety (Psychological Health) Regulations 2025 (the Regulations) strengthen the occupational health and safety framework and recognise that psychosocial hazards are just as harmful as physical hazards.

Under the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (OHS Act), employers already have a duty to provide a working environment that is safe and without risks to health, so far as reasonably practicable. The definition of health includes psychological health.

What is reasonably practicable can be decided objectively and is based on the standard of behaviour expected from a reasonable person. A reasonable person is taken to be committed to providing the highest level of protection for people against risks to their health and safety and proactively taking action to protect people’s health and safety. Employers must do what a reasonable person who is committed to the highest level of protection against risks to health and safety would do in the circumstance.

The Regulations focus on risk management and create specific obligations for Victorian employers to identify psychological hazards and control risks. All Victorian employers need to become familiar with the new obligation and ensure that they have the systems, processes, training and other interventions to discharge the duty.

WorkSafe Victoria has created a Compliance Code for psychological health (Code) which provides guidance to employers on managing risks associated with psychosocial hazards to protect employee health and safety.

A breach of the Compliance Code is not, of itself, a breach of the OHS Act. Nevertheless compliance with the Code will, to the extent it deals with their duties or obligations under the OHS Act or the Regulations, will be taken to be fulfilment of those duties or obligations. As such all employers should review the Code and familiarise themselves with their obligations.

What are psychosocial hazards?

The Regulations define psychosocial hazard as any factor(s) in work design, systems of work, management of work, carrying out of the work or personal or work-related interactions that may arise in the working environment and may cause an employee to experience one or more negative psychological responses that create a risk to the employee’s health or safety.

The Regulations define “work design” as the equipment, content and organisation of an employee’s work tasks, activities, relationships and responsibilities within a job or role.

A psychological response includes cognitive, emotional and behavioural responses and the physiological processes associated with them. The Code specifies examples of psychological responses to include stress, feeling stressed, distress and feeling burnt out, as well as warning signs of psychological harm.

The Code includes a non-exhaustive list of psychosocial hazards:

What do Employers need to do?

The Psychosocial Regulations require employers to, so far as is reasonably practicable:

Identifying Psychosocial Hazards

The Regulations require employers to identify psychosocial hazards so far as is reasonably practicable. Psychosocial hazards will vary for every organisation and sometimes even between groups of employees. For example, employees who deal face to face with customers may be at greater risk of aggression or violence compared with employees from the same organisation who don’t have a customer facing role.

In accordance with obligations in the OHS Act employers must so far as is reasonably practicable, consult with employees on health and safety matters that directly affect or are likely to directly affect them. Employers also need to collect and review relevant information to help identify psychosocial hazards such as incident reports, complaints and human resources information showing for example patterns of absenteeism.

The Regulations reinforce the importance of consultation in managing psychosocial risks, and include detail on how this should occur. If employees have a health and safety representative (HSR), consultation must involve the HSR (with or without the involvement of the employees).

The duty to consult also extends to independent contractors (including any employees of the independent contractor) engaged by the employer in relation to matters over which the employer has control.

Assessing Risk

A psychosocial risk assessment involves examining psychosocial hazards to assess how, and to what extent, they create a risk to the health or safety of employees.

This will help employers to determine the seriousness of the risk, by considering both the likelihood of harm occurring and consequences for affected employees and others.

Employers should also consider how multiple psychosocial hazards might interact, which employees are most at risk, how the hazards are likely to affect these employees and if risks are organisation-wide or apply for example to specific employees or groups of employees or specific work tasks.

Whilst current knowledge and understanding about the risk and how to control it may already exist employers should carry out a risk assessment when it is not clear if the psychosocial hazard may result in harm, it is not clear how hazards may interact to produce new, different or more significant harm, the existing risk controls are not effective or there are changes planned that may affect existing risk controls.

Risk assessments must involve consultation with employees and any HSRs, so far as is reasonably practicable. Risk assessments should include data collection, for example, using workplace data and information from focus groups, interviews and de-identified validated surveys and cite the evidence used.

Controlling Risks

The Regulations require employers to control psychosocial hazards by, so far as is reasonably practicable by eliminating the risk arising from the psychosocial hazard.

If it is not reasonably practicable to eliminate a risk associated with a psychosocial hazard, the employer must reduce the risk so far as reasonably practicable by:

a) altering the:

b) using information, instruction or training, or

c) using a combination of any of the controls listed in (a) and (b).

The Regulations specify that information, instruction or training may only exclusively be used as a risk control measure where none of the risk control measures listed under (a) are reasonably practicable. They further specify that where a combination of risk control measures is used, information, instruction or training must not be the predominant control measure.

Whilst the use of prevention plans is not mandatory, WorkSafe Victoria does encourage employers to use the template that has been developed which can be used by employers to help guide the risk management process for psychosocial hazards.

Reviewing and Revising Control Measures

Reviewing risk controls involves examining whether the control measures are effectively controlling risks, so far as is reasonably practicable.

The Regulations impose a duty on employers to review and, if necessary, revise the control measures when certain circumstances occur:

a) before any alteration is made to any thing, process or system of work that is likely to result in changes to risks associated with psychosocial hazards

b) if there is new or additional information about a psychosocial hazard available to the employer

c) if an employee, or a person on their behalf, reports a psychological injury or psychosocial hazard to the employer

d) after a notifiable incident occurs that involves one or more psychosocial in the workplace

e) if, for any other reason, the risk control measures do not adequately control the risks associated with a psychosocial hazard

f) after receiving a request from an HSR.

If the review finds that the controls are not adequately controlling the risk so far as is reasonably practicable, risk controls must be revised.

Key Takeouts for Employers

Going forward, WorkSafe Victoria will expect all employers to be able to demonstrate that they have in place safety management systems which align with the new requirements and help promote compliance with those requirements.

Employers should review their organisation’s approach and systems for managing psychosocial risks in the workplace, in light of the Code and Regulations. This would include ensuring consultation is occurring and updating as necessary consultation procedures to accommodate the additional steps required for consultation with HSRs.

Employers need to ensure workers and managers are given sufficient instruction, training and supervision on the management of psychosocial risk and systems are established for them to report and respond to risks identified in the workplace.

If you need advice on implementation of the Code and Regulations in your workplace or have any queries in relation to this article please contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.

Beyond Policy – The FWC Reinforces the Duty to Genuinely Consider Flexible Work Arrangements

A recent employment dispute heard by the Fair Work Commission (‘FWC’) has highlighted the obligation that employers have when dealing with requests for flexible working arrangements. In Chandler v Westpac [2025] FWC 3115, the FWC found that the employer, in refusing their employee’s request to work from home, had failed to follow the proper procedure set by section 65A of the Fair Work Act 2009 (‘FWA’).

This case serves as a reminder that strict adherence to policy without properly consulting an employee in the context of their flexible work arrangement request will be a breach of the FWA.

Facts

Ms Chandler was a part-time employee in Westpac’s Mortgage Operations Team. Chandler and her partner had two young children who attended a school that was 25-30 minutes in the opposite direction of Chandler’s workplace. Chandler was primarily responsible for dropping off and picking up her kids from school. Her partner was self-employed and had limited capacity to assist with school drop-offs and pick-ups due to his commitments at work.

Westpac, the employer, had a policy which required its employees to attend the corporate office at least two days a week. The closest offices to Chandler were the Kogarah and Parramatta corporate offices, which required a two hour commute from the employee’s children’s school.

As such, in December 2024, the employee requested approval to work from the Bowral branch, which was significantly closer to the employee, two days per week instead of attending the corporate office. This request was initially approved as a short term ‘olive branch’, but was later refused in January 2025.

Chandler then filed a formal section 65 FWA request, but this was later refused without reason by Westpac. On 19 March 2025, Chandler received an email from Westpac stating that ‘working from home is no substitution for childcare’ and ‘your arrangements for working remotely may change at any time at Westpac’s discretion’.

Decision

Section 65 of the FWA enables employees who meet certain requirements to request flexible working arrangements. If a request is made, the employer is obligated to respond under a set of requirements as set out in section 65A.

In responding to the request, the FWC found that Westpac had failed to follow the procedural requirements set by section 65A. The Commission found that Westpac:

  1. failed to provide Chandler with a written response to the section 65 request within 21 days of her formally making the request (s 65A(1) FWA);
  2. failed to discuss the request with Chandler prior to the refusal being made (s 65A(3)(a)(i) FWA);
  3. did not genuinely try to reach an agreement with Chandler about making changes to her working arrangements (s 65A(3)(a)(ii) FWA);
  4. did not have regard to the consequences of the refusal (s 65A(3)(c) FWA); and
  5. no reasonable business grounds were provided by Westpac to Chandler (s 65A(3)(d) FWA).

The Commission also discussed whether Westpac had reasonable business grounds to refuse the request in depth. In arguing that they did, Westpac emphasised the benefits that having a mixture of in-person and remote work would have amongst a large workforce. These included fostering collaboration in Chandler’s team and meaningful engagement with stakeholders. Further, they argued that having Chandler working from home would disrupt these benefits.

However, the Commission rejected this finding that ‘there was no question that Ms Chandler’s work can be performed completely remotely’. They found that Chandler and her team had performed their work at a very high level with deadlines being met or exceeded with no loss of productivity or efficiency observed as a result of the existing remote working arrangements.

As a result, the Commission found in favour of Chandler.

Takeaway

This decision is notable for employers, as it highlights the need for genuine consideration of their employee’s circumstances and the importance of following the procedure under the FWA when responding to requests for flexible working arrangements. It is also vital that employers properly document the steps taken in doing so. Namely, employers in considering a section 65 request should:

If you have further queries regarding this case or a related matter, please contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.

Should you wish to speak further on this, please contact  Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.

Federal Court Awards $305,000 in Landmark Sexual Harassment Decision

In a recent decision by the Federal Court of Australia a claimant has been awarded $305,000, regarding claims of workplace sexual harassment, making it one of the highest awards ordered under the Federal Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) (‘SDA’).

The case of Magar v Khan [2025] FCA 874 is the first to consider the meaning of ‘sex-based harassment’, one of the recent inclusions to the SDA. While the allegations of sex based harassment were not upheld, the decision sheds some light on how the provision will operate.

This case continued the trend by Courts to award substantial damages in sexual harassment cases. This case illustrates the importance of taking proactive measures to prevent harassment from taking place.

Background:

Ms Magar now a former employee of Mexicali Enterprise Pty Ltd, was employed by Mr Khan, an owner and operator of their franchise restaurant, Mad Mex in Sydney’s Hills District. Ms Magar who was 21 at the time, came to Australia on a student visa from Nepal in 2021 and began working in September of that year. It wasn’t until 2023 where she began experiencing the alleged sexual conduct from her employer Mr Khan. The court heard that Mr Khan showed Ms Magar inappropriate videos at work, made intrusive comments about her sex life and asked her extremely personal and suggestive questions.

Application of new Section 28AA of the Sex Discrimination Act

The Federal Court considered for the first time the application of the newly introduced section 28AA of the SDA, which prohibits harassment on the ground of sex. Unlike sexual harassment, this refers to demeaning behaviour connected to a person’s sex, even if it isn’t sexual in nature – for example, making sexist jokes or comments about a colleague.

Justice Bromwich acknowledged the lack of precedent in interpreting section 28AA and focused on the meaning of the phrase “in relation to.” While the provision does not require the conduct to be directly addressed to the affected person, it must have a clear nexus to them. The Court considered factors such as Ms Magar’s youth, her junior position, and the male dominated workplace, noting the significant power imbalance between her and Mr Khan. However, ultimately found that the behaviour, though inappropriate, was not sufficiently connected to Ms Magar personally to meet the threshold under section 28AA.

Instead, liability were established under section 28A, which deals with sexual harassment. The Court found Mr Khan’s had engaged in unwelcome sexual conduct in contravention of the SDA towards Ms Magar’s which was supported by various text messages. While the claim under section 28AA failed, the judgment sets an important precedent for future cases involving harassment on the ground of sex.

Damages:

Ms Magar was awarded a record breaking sum in general damages for sexual harassment, receiving $160,000, $130,000 for economic loss, which consisted of $90,000 for past loss and $40,000 for future loss.

Ms Magar was also awarded additional compensation in light of Mr Khan’s conduct in response to her complaint and throughout the proceedings. The Court found that Mr Khan had twice threatened defamation action in an attempt to dissuade her from pursuing her claims, a familiar tactic the Court recognised as a form of victimisation. For this, Justice Bromwich awarded a further $10,000 in general damages. In addition, Mr Khan’s conduct during the litigation was found to have intensified Ms Magar’s distress. His behaviour was described by the Court as improper, unjustifiable, and lacking in good faith, leading to an award of $5,000 in aggravated damages.

In total, the Court awarded $305,000 in compensation against Mr Khan. The Court also indicated it would likely order costs against him, pending further submissions.

This case sets a precedent for how courts may approach future claims under section 28AA, and it invites employers and employees to be more conscious of how indirect, systemic, or cultural sexism can manifest in the workplace.

Since December 2022, the SDA has imposed a positive duty on employers to actively prevent sexual harassment and harassment on the grounds of sex. This means it’s no longer enough to simply respond to complaints after the fact and businesses must take proactive and meaningful steps to stamp out these behaviours before they occur.

Sexual harassment complaints can carry heavy legal, reputational and financial consequences and this case showed that victimising a complainant can make matters far worse. Employers must ensure complaints are handled lawfully, sensitively, and without retaliation.

Should you wish to speak further on this, please contact  Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.

Dismissal Decisions and Mental Health Issues – What do you need to be aware of as an Employer?

For employers, mental health conditions are among the most costly types of workplace injuries, often resulting in significantly longer absences from work and higher compensation compared to other injuries or illnesses. Dismissal decisions can also become particularly sensitive where the employee concerned is also dealing with mental health issues.

Safe Work Australia’s 2024 statistics reveal a continued rise in workplace claims related to mental health conditions during 2022–23, with such claims accounting for 10.5% (14,600) of all serious claims. This represents a 19.2% increase from 2021–22 and a staggering 97.3% increase compared to 10 years ago. [1]

Drawing on recent cases considered by the Fair Work Commission (FWC), this article explores some of the key risks employers should be aware of when dismissal decisions intersect with mental health concerns.

  1. Be aware of risks of discrimination when mental health concerns are involved

Mental health conditions are generally recognised as disabilities under anti-discrimination laws, which prohibit discrimination against an employee on the basis of their disability. If an employee can demonstrate that their workplace performance was impaired by a diagnosed mental health condition, and that their employer failed to make reasonable adjustments and relied on the condition as a ground for dismissal, the termination may contravene discrimination laws.

In the recent case of Ms K v Ability Action Australia Pty Ltd,[2] the employee, Ms K, argued that her PTSD, depression, and anxiety contributed to her performance difficulties and that her dismissal constituted discrimination based on her mental health status. She claimed that her condition, along with the limitations it occasionally caused, had been disclosed to her supervisors, who agreed to implement reasonable adjustments, such as allowing her to work from home and reduce her hours on challenging days. However, Ms K claimed that these adjustments were not adequately provided, and she was subsequently dismissed for failing to attend the office and not fulfilling her required hours.

The legal obligation to make reasonable adjustments for employees with disabilities was reiterated in Panazzolo v Don’s Mechanical and Diesel Service Pty Ltd.[3] The Court stated at [137] that Section 5(2) of the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 ‘in general terms, creates a positive obligation’ on employers to make reasonable adjustments that enable an employee with a disability to perform the requirements of the role, except where such adjustments would impose an ‘unjustifiable hardship’.

It is therefore prudent for employers to carefully assess the risk of potential discrimination claims, before dismissing an employee who is dealing with mental health challenges.

  1. Mental health challenges may justify a late general protections or unfair dismissal claim, if ‘exceptional circumstances’ are established

There is a 21-day limitation period for dismissed employees to lodge an unfair dismissal application or a general protections claim with the FWC. If an application is filed outside this period, the FWC may allow an extension of time if it is satisfied that there are ‘exceptional circumstances’. These are defined as ‘circumstances that are out of the ordinary course, unusual, special or uncommon but the circumstances themselves do not need to be unique nor unprecedented, nor even very rare.’[4]

In the case discussed earlier, Ms K lodged her general protections application 22 days after the standard deadline and sought an extension of time on the basis of exacerbated mental distress. However, the FWC found that there was no acceptable explanation for the delay and concluded that Ms K had simply chosen not to comply with the limitation period. Of particular significance was the evidence that she had been fully aware of the availability of a general protections claim well before submitting her application late. The Commissioner also noted that Ms K had not taken sufficient action to challenge her dismissal directly with her employer immediately after it occurred. She only submitted a grievance letter around a month later after the dismissal, which was also well outside the 21-day limitation period.

In the absence of any ‘exceptional circumstances’, the FWC declined to grant the extension. This decision illustrates that while the FWC may exercise some flexibility in cases involving mental health, the burden remains on the employee to demonstrate that their condition genuinely prevented timely action. Where there is no acceptable explanation for the delay and the employee was merely ‘reignited in her desire to challenge the dismissal’ at a later time,[5] an extension of time is unlikely to be granted.

  1. Compensation may be awarded if the termination worsens the dismissed employee’s mental health

Finally, employers should be aware that even if a dismissal is valid, an employee may still be entitled to compensation if the manner in which the dismissal was carried out aggravated their mental distress.

In Alex Yates v Stephanie Muir Ridge,[6] the FWC ordered the employer to pay $9,880 in compensation after finding that the dismissal process had further exacerbated the employee’s psychological distress.

The employer in this case argued that Mr Yates was not entitled to compensation because he had failed to take steps to mitigate his losses, and that in such circumstances, his incapacity for work meant he should not be entitled to compensation. This argument was rejected by the FWC, who accepted that Mr Yates’s efforts to mitigate his losses had been negatively affected by his health issues. Of particularly relevance the letter from Mr Yates’s treating psychologist, which detailed the impact the dismissal and the subsequent unfair dismissal proceedings had on his mental health and ability to work.

Given the complexity associated with the termination of an employee with mental health issues we recommend you seek legal advice specifically tailored to your situation and business.

If you have any queries on the above or require assistance with this, please contact Michael Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Law Team.

[1] Safe Work Australia, Key Work Health and Safety Statistics Australia 2024, Safe Work Australia Data, (released 2 September 2024) https://data.safeworkaustralia.gov.au/insights/key-whs-statistics-australia/latest-release.

[2] Ms K v Ability Action Australia Pty Ltd [2025] FWC 935.

[3] Panazzolo v Don’s Mechanical and Diesel Service Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 665.

[4] Ms K v Ability Action Australia Pty Ltd [2025] FWC 935, [3].

[5] Ms K v Ability Action Australia Pty Ltd [2025] FWC 935, [14].

[6] Alex Yates v Stephanie Muir Ridge [2025] FWC 733.