Pointon Partners

Pointon Partners advises GTA Consultants on sale to New York Listed Stantec Inc. to round out active 12 months for M&A team

Pointon Partners are pleased to have acted on the sale of Greg Tucker & Associates Pty Ltd (GTA) to New York Stock Exchange listed Stantec Inc.

Melbourne based GTA operates a traffic engineering business and Stantec is a professional services company in the design and consulting industry.

The deal was led by M&A Partners Michael Bishop and Felicity Cara-Carson, with Senior Associate Ben Drysdale assisting. Our team worked closely with corporate advisors PwC and accountants ShineWing.

We congratulate GTA’s shareholders on the completion of the deal.

The deal wraps up an active 12 months for our M&A team in the regulated / listed company transaction space. Other regulated transactions we have successfully completed include:

Our team has also advised on significant private M&A transactions within our mid-market transaction specialty (deals valued between $10 million and $100 million).

With M&A activity picking up in 2021, our team look forward to advising clients on further successful transactions.

Reminder of Relevant Principles in Applications for Extension of Time to Convene Creditors’ Meetings

Administrators often find themselves in a position where they need or desire further time to convene a second creditors’ meeting.

The recent Federal Court case of Farnsworth v About Life Pty Limited (Administrator Appointed), in the matter of About Life Pty Limited (Administrator Appointed) [2019] FCA 11, provides a useful summary of the matters taken into account when deciding applications for extensions of time to convene creditors’ meetings.

The plaintiff in Farnsworth was appointed administrator on 17 December 2018 and was due to hold the second creditors’ meeting by 1 February 2019.  The Court granted an extension until 8 March 2019.

General principles of section 439A(6)

The Court has the power to grant an extension where doing so is appropriate in the circumstances to advance the purposes of the administration.  The Court must balance the legislative expectation that an administration will be quick and efficient with the need to ensure that the administration is not concluded without exploring options which may provide better returns for creditors.

The prospects of a more favourable outcome for creditors, through a longer period of administration, may therefore outweigh the need for a prompt resolution of the administration itself.

Applications under s 439A(6) are assessed by reference to whether an extension is necessary to enable the administrator to prepare their report and statements, in order that creditors will be in a better position to decide whether to terminate the administration, execute a deed of company arrangement or place the company in liquidation.

Examples of cases where an extension of time has been granted under section 439A(6)

The Court has recognised a number of categories in which it may be appropriate to grant an extension, including where:

Where the evidentiary case for an extension has been properly prepared, there has been no evidence of material prejudice to creditors, and the administrator’s estimate of time has had a reasonable basis, the Court has tended to grant extensions.

Reasons for the grant of an extension in Farnsworth

The extension in Farnsworth was granted in part because About Life Pty Ltd is involved in complex litigation in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The company’s claims in that matter are substantial, although at the time of the application the proceedings were stayed pending the company complying with a security for costs order.

The Court also noted that:

Lessons from Farnsworth

The statutory scheme governing external administration prioritises speed, however not at the expense of exploring sensible and constructive options in the interests of creditors.

Where an administrator requires more time before a creditors’ meeting to consider options that may provide better returns for creditors, or to enable the company to return to trading in the interests of creditors and shareholders alike, an application can be made to the Court.

Pointon Partners have extensive experience in business recovery and insolvency matters and can assist at all stages of external administration.

Please contact Carl Millington or Ben Drysdale for advice.

Avoid suspension until re-compliance by announcing backdoor listing transaction

In May 2016, the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX) changed its policy on backdoor listings so that an entity’s securities will be suspended immediately from the announcement of a backdoor listing transaction.

However, the ASX has now relaxed this policy change by allowing entities to avoid suspension until re-compliance if they make an announcement of a backdoor listing transaction. This change came into effect on 19 December 2016 and prescribes new minimum disclosure requirements for the announcement.

What are the requirements?

An entity’s securities will be allowed to resume trading under the new minimum disclosure requirements if:

  1. an announcement containing all the information set out in Annexure to Guidance Note 12 (Annexure A) is made; and
  1. the ASX is “otherwise satisfied” that the announcement includes “sufficient information about the transaction for trading in the entity’s securities to take place on a reasonably informed basis”.[1]

Information to be included in announcement

When an entity is required to re-comply with ASX’s admission and quotation requirements due to a merger with, or acquisition of, another entity or business, an announcement containing all information set out in Annexure A is required to be disclosed.[2]

The types of information prescribed by Annexure A includes:

If an entity’s announcement does not include all information set out in Annexure A, the entity’s securities will be suspended from trading.[4]

What if an entity cannot meet the requirements?

An entity can still announce a backdoor listing transaction if they are not able to include all information prescribed in Annexure A.

However, the entity’s securities will remain suspended from quotation until:

  1. “the entity has corrected the deficiency to the ASX’s satisfaction;
  1. the entity has re-complied with ASX’s admission and quotation requirements; or
  1. those requirements cease to apply”.[5]

The choice

As a result of this policy change, an entity who is announcing a backdoor listing transaction effectively has a choice to either:

  1. “comply with the additional requirements prescribed in Guidance Note 12 and have their securities resume trading after the announcement; or
  1. go into suspension”.[6]

If you wish to seek advice in relation to these matters, please contact Michael Bishop or Jess Tomlinson on (03) 9614 7707.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

[1] ASX, Updating ASX’s Admission Requirements for Listed Entities – Response to Consultation (November 2016) Australian Stock Exchange, 16 <http://www.asx.com.au/documents/investor-relations/asx-listing-admission-requirements-market-response-2-11-16.pdf>.

[2] Australian Securities Exchange, ASX Listing Rule, Guidance Note 12, 19 December 2016, Annexure A.

[3] Ibid; above n 1.

[4] Australian Securities Exchange, ASX Listing Rule, Guidance Note 12, 19 December 2016, Annexure A.

[5] Ibid 2.10

[6] Above n 1.

Crowd-Sourced Funding To Be Extended To Include Proprietary Companies

The Federal Government pursuant to its 2017 Budget intends to extend the legislative framework for crowd-sourced funding (CSF) by introducing a new Crowd-Sourced Equity Framework regime for proprietary companies.[1]

Currently, the Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding) Act 2017 (the CAA)[2], which comes into force on 29 September 2017, only creates a CSF framework for public companies.[3]

However, it is the view of the Government that enabling proprietary companies’ access to a new funding source by extending CSF to proprietary companies will “enable small and innovative business types more alternatives to raise capital and easier access to such capital.[4]

What is CSF?

CSF is a type of funding that allows companies to raise funds, typically online, from a large number of individuals who make small contributions towards the company.[5]

This type of funding is often a “preferable type of funding for innovative and early stage companies”.[6]

The current limitation

The CAA “amends the Corporations Act 2001 (the Corporations Act), and makes minor amendments to the Australian Securities and Investment Commission Act 2001, to provide a CSF legislative framework”.[7]

As stated above, this framework only provides for public companies. Section 14 of the CAA inserts section 738H into the Corporations Act. Section 738H(1) provides that a company is an eligible CSF company at a particular time (the test time) if all of the following conditions are satisfied:

Currently the Corporations Act provides that a proprietary company is unable to have more than 50 non-employee shareholders,[9] or make a public offer.

Therefore, in order to be an eligible CSF company, a proprietary company would need to convert to a public company limited by shares.[10]

The extension to include proprietary companies as eligible CSF companies

The Government has released for public consultation a draft bill, the Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017 (the Exposure Draft), that extends upon the CCA to enable proprietary companies to access a CSF without transitioning to public company status.[11]

The Exposure draft intends to repeal section 738H(1)(a) (above) and replace it with the new section 738(1)(a) that extends an eligible CSF company to include a proprietary company as follows:

Further, the existing shareholder cap in section 113 of the Corporations Act, which provides that proprietary companies are unable to have more than 50 non-employee shareholders, is being amended so that CSF shareholders are not counted as part of the cap.[13]

The proposed amendments to the Corporations Act will also impose additional obligations and requirements on proprietary companies accessing the CSF regime in order to provide adequate investor protections.[14]

These obligations and requirements for CSF proprietary companies will include:

It is the opinion of the Government that the additional obligations and requirements imposed on proprietary companies accessing the CSF regime will help ensure the sustainability of the CSF regime and give investors’ confidence in the market by ensuring that minimum standards are meet and investors have basic information available to them.[21]

Summary

If the Exposure Draft is implemented as legislation, proprietary companies will no longer need to transition to a public company in order to access the CSF regime.

At this stage however, proprietary companies may have to face the question of whether to convert to a public company structure to access the CSF regime in September or wait in hopes of accessing the CSF if the Exposure Draft is implemented.[22]

If you have any queries or wish to seek advice in relation to CSF, please contact Michael Bishop or Jess Tomlinson on (03) 9614 7707.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________

[1] Commonwealth, Budget 2017-18, Budget Paper No. 1 (2017) pg 1-24; Commonwealth, Budget 2017-18, Budget Paper No. 2 (2017) pg 165.

[2] The Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding) Act 2017 will commence on 29 September 2017.

[3] Exposure Draft Explanatory Memorandum, Exposure Draft Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017pg 3.

[4] Ibid pg 5.

[5] Ibid.

[6] Ibid.

[7] Australian Securities & Investments Commission, Crowd-sourced Funding (26 May 2017) Australian Securities & Investment Commission <http://asic.gov.au/regulatory-resources/financial-services/crowd-sourced-funding>.

[8] Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding) Act 2017 (Cth) sch 1 cl 14.

[9] Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 113.

[10] Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding) Act 2017 (Cth) sch 1 cl 14.

[11] Exposure Draft Explanatory Memorandum, Exposure Draft Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017pg 3.

[12] Exposure Draft Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017 cl 39.

[13] Ibid cl 5.

[14] Exposure Draft Explanatory Memorandum, Exposure Draft Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017pg 3.

[15] Exposure Draft Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017 cl 14.

[16] Exposure Draft Explanatory Memorandum, Exposure Draft Corporations Amendment (Crowd-sourced Funding for Proprietary Companies) Bill 2017 pg 6, 8.

[17] Ibid pg 11.

[18] Ibid pg 11.

[19] Ibid pg 7, 9.

[20] Ibid pg 10.

[21] Ibid pg 6.

[22] Harry New and John Bassilios, Private companies face public conundrum under new crowdfunding rules (24 May 2017) Australia Financial Review < http://www.afr.com/leadership/entrepreneur/private-companies-face-public-conundrum-under-new-crowdfunding-rules-20170524-gwburg>.

ASX Admission Changes

In November 2016, the ASX released the Response to Consultation paper (Response Paper) updating their admission requirements for entities seeking to list on the ASX (Admission Requirements). This followed the release of the consultation paper ‘Updating ASX’s Admission Requirements for Listed Entities’ (Consultation Paper), which set out a number of proposed changes, and comprehensive public consultations over a six month period.

The changes addressed in the Response Paper became effective on 19 December 2016 and are intended to maintain the quality, integrity and reputation of the ASX, as well as to ensure the ASX market remains internationally competitive.

Overview

In summary, the key changes to the Admission Requirements, now effective, are:

Increase Thresholds

Entities seeking admission to the ASX need to satisfy the ‘Profit Test’ or the ‘Assets Test’.

Listing Rule 1.2 has now been amended to increase the consolidated profit requirement under the Profit Test, to now require applications to have at least $500,000 consolidated profit from continuing operations for the 12 months prior to admission (previously $400,000). The additional requirements of $1,000,000 cumulative net profit in the preceding 3 years and the entity being a going concern, having “conducted the same main business activity during the last 3 full financial years”, will continue to apply unchanged.

Previously, an entity seeking admission to the ASX under the Assets Test must either have Net Tangible Assets of at least $3,000,000 or a market capitalisation of at least $10,000,000. Market capitalisation refers to the total dollar market value of all of an entity’s outstanding shares (this is calculated by multiplying the total number of shares on issue by the price of such shares). Listing Rule 1.3 has modified the Assets Test to now require Net Tangible Assets of at least $4,000,000 or a market capitalisation of at least $15,000,000. This will be relevant for many smaller companies looking to list, such as mining exploration companies.

Standardised Working Capital Requirements

Listing Rule 1.3.3 has now been modified to “standardise the $1.5 million working capital requirement for all entities admitted under the assets test”. The ASX also now requires the $1.5 million to be available after “allowing for the first full financial year’s budgeted administration costs and the cost of acquiring any assets referred to in the prospectus, PDS or information memorandum (to the extent that those costs will be met out of working capital)”. Previously, this requirement only applied to mining, oil and gas exploration entities. Thus this change signifies a tightening of minimum requirements for all other entities.

It should be noted that all entities must continue to confirm that their stated objectives can be met with sufficient working capital.

Audited Accounts

The ASX has now amended Listing Rule 1.3.5 to provide that entities seeking admission under the Assets Test be required to produce audited accounts for the last 2 full financial years prior to admission. It is also required that where an entity is more than 6 months and 75 days into the current financial year, the entity will be required to produce audited or reviewed accounts for the last half year.

It is important to note that the rule changes also apply to any entity or business that is significant in the context of the listing entity and has been acquired 12 months prior to applying for admission or proposes to acquire at or ahead of listing. This has particular effect on back-door listings.

Pursuant to Guidance Note 1, the ASX will generally consider an entity or business to be ‘significant’ if at the time of listing it will account for 25% or more of the applicants: “consolidated total assets; consolidated total equity interests; consolidated annual revenue; or in the case of a mining exploration entity, oil and gas exploration entity or other entity that is not earning material revenue from operations, consolidated annual expenditure; consolidated EBITDA; or consolidated annual profit before tax”.

The ASX has acknowledged that an entity seeking admission under the Assets Test or a significant business or entity may not be in a position to provide 2 full years of audited accounts, particularly if they are a start-up. Accordingly, the ASX has retained discretion to accept less than 2 years of audited or reviewed accounts.

New Free Float Requirements

‘Free float’ is defined by the ASX as “the percentage of the entity’s main class of securities that are not restricted securities or subject to voluntary escrow, and are held by non-affiliated security holders.” Essentially, the term describes the proportion of shares in a publicly traded company that are in the hands of public investors rather than company insiders.

A new requirement of an explicit condition under Listing Rule 1.1 has now been introduced requiring an entity to have a free float of at least 20% at the time of admission.

Previously there was no specific requirement for a minimum free float, although the ASX commonly considered that in order to have a “structure and operations appropriate for a listed entity” (for the purposes of previous ASX Listing Rule 1.1), an entity seeking admission must have free float of at least 10%.

The ASX considers this change to the Admission Requirements to be a “good balance between promoting potential liquidity in the secondary market and providing for more efficient price discovery”, while “not acting as a barrier” for early stage innovation and technology entities admission.

Importantly, this change to Listing Rule 1.1 brings the ASX into line with peer exchanges, including Hong Kong and New Zealand exchanges, which require that 25% of an entity’s issued share capital at listing be held by public shareholders.

Increased spread

In this context, ‘spread’ refers to the number of distinct holders of an entity’s shares. The ASX has now simplified the admission requirements by changing Listing Rule 1.1 to a single tier spread test requiring a “minimum of 300 non-affiliated security holders each holding a parcel of non-restricted securities with a value of at least $2,000.”

The new spread test no longer counts all ‘security holders’ but instead counts ‘non-affiliated security holders’ only. ‘Non-affiliated security holders’ is defined by the ASX as “a security holder who is not a related party of the entity, an associate of a related party of the entity, or a person whose relationship to the entity or to a related party of the entity or their associates is such that, in ASX’s opinion, they should be treated as affiliated with the entity”

The ASX’s previous spread test could be satisfied in one of three ways depending on the entity’s free float levels. This spread test was implemented when the ASX did not have a minimum free float requirement and was not only used to “demonstrate sufficient investor support for the entity’s listing”, but was also to “promote liquidity in the entity’s securities”.

However, with the introduction of the new minimum free float requirement the primary purpose of the spread test will now be to provide a “robust and genuine test” that demonstrates sufficient investor interest to justify listing on a public market.

Backdoor listings

When the Consultation Paper was released on 12 May 2016, the ASX immediately changed its policy on backdoor listings. Trading in a listing shell’s securities will now be suspended immediately from the announcement of a backdoor listing transaction and will not resume until the listed shell has re-complied with ASX’s admission and quotation requirements. This change has been applied to all backdoor listing transactions after this date.

The ASX has now relaxed this policy change by allowing entities to avoid suspension until re-compliance if they make an announcement of a backdoor listing transaction. Under the new minimum disclosure requirements an entity’s securities may be able to resume trade after an announcement that contains all information required as per Annexure A to Guidance Note 12. In addition, the ASX must also be satisfied that the announcement includes “sufficient information about the transaction for trading in the entity’s securities to take place on a reasonably informed basis”.

If an entity does not meet the announcement requirements prescribed in Annexure A, its securities will be suspended from quotation and will continue to be suspended until a supplementary announcement is made.

Reinforcing discretion

The Introduction to the ASX Listing Rules and Guidance Note 1 have been amended to reinforce ASX’s absolute discretion to refuse admission and to confirm that the ASX considers the “reputation, integrity and efficiency of its market” when exercising this discretion.

These changes, particularly to Guidance Note 1, provide potential listing applicants and the market with “greater transparency of the factors considered by ASX when exercising their discretion on admission and quotation decisions”.

If you have any queries relating to the new Admission Requirements or ASX listings generally, please contact Michael Bishop on (03) 9614 7707.