Lost Trust Deeds – Find Your Pathways
A party affected by a lost trust deed would expect much inconvenience and frustration.
This article examines the two main pathways available and the relevant pointers that will come in handy should you be placed in such a circumstance.
On the outset, it is prudent to ascertain whether the missing deed can be located from another source.
A good starting point would be to make enquiries with the following third parties:
- Presumed current and past trustees
- Presumed Settlor
- Legal Representatives or Accountants
- Bank(s)
- Presumed beneficiaries
Should an executed or stamped copy of the deed of trust be found, then it should constitute sufficient evidence under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth).
In any event, searches or enquiries made will be useful to the party (i.e. trustee or legal representative) who undertakes them, as it will form part of the evidence, should an application to the Court be required to be made.
As stated, there are two main pathways, the first being where recourse is not based on Court proceedings, and the second being a more formalistic proceeding undertaken in the Courts.
Pathway 1
In the context of the first pathway, a deed of confirmation can be executed to confirm the original deed, particularly, the key aspects of the trust deed.
However, it should be noted the adoption of this pathway is not without its risks. Primarily, it should be noted that Capital Gains Tax (CGT) and stamp duty liabilities may be applicable should certain circumstances be taken to apply by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) and the State Revenue Office of Victoria (SRO) accordingly.
Pathway 2
On the other hand, if all reasonable steps are taken but no copy of the trust deed can be found, it may be that a formal application to the Supreme Court is taken, seeking to confirm the terms of the lost trust deed and to excuse the trustee from any prior breaches of trust.
This is to be undertaken pursuant to rule 54.02 of the Supreme Court (General Civil Proceeding) Rules 2015 (Vic).
In this regard, the likelihood of success would depend on, but not be limited to, the following:
- Evidence (including extent) detailing the steps undertaken by the relevant parties.
- Detailed affidavits by the trustee(s) confirming that the unexecuted/unstamped version represents and replicates the terms of the lost deed.
It is instructive to consider the case of D.R. McKendry Nominees Pty Ltd [2015] VSC 560. In this case, Digby J highlights required evidence to include:
- Steps being taken to contact surviving descendants and potential beneficiaries.
- Contacting the solicitor who drafted the deed.
- Any relevant communication or correspondence with other professionals (eg. accountants and tax agents) who assisted with affairs of the trust.
- Contacting settlor and revenue authorities.
The Courts have held that the trustee(s) will be required to evince clear and convincing proof; not only of the existence of the document, but also its relevant contents.
Should you lose or have lost your trust deed and require further information and assistance, please contact Michael Bishop on (03)9614 7707.
A Health Check on Your Privacy Obligations
If you or your business are deemed a “health service” provider and hold “health information” for the purposes of the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) (“Privacy Act”), then you need to be aware of your obligations under the Privacy Act and in particular the requirements of the Australian Privacy Principles which are contained in Schedule 1 of the Privacy Act (“APPs”).
What is a health service provider?
For the purposes of the Privacy Act, the provision of a health service occurs where the activity performed is intended or claimed by the individual or person performing it:
- “to assess, maintain or improve the individual’s physical or psychological health; or
- to manage the individual’s physical or psychological health; or
- to diagnose the individual’s illness, disability or injury; or
- to treat the individual’s illness ,disability or injury or suspected illness, disability or illness; or
- to record the individual’s physical or psychological health for the purposes of assessing, maintaining, improving or managing the individual’s physical or psychological health”.[1]
Further, the “dispensing on prescription of a drug or medicinal preparation by a pharmacist” is a health service.[2]
Examples of a health service provider as outlined by the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (“OAIC”) can include a “medical practitioner, private aged care, radiology services, a dentist, a pharmacist, an online health service and a gym or weight loss clinic”,[3] where they provide a health service to another individual and hold any health information in relation to the individual.
What is health information?
Health information is any personal information, including an opinion, about an individual’s:
- “health, including an illness, disability or injury; or
- expressed wishes about the future provision of health services to the individual; or
- health service provided, or to be provided, to an individual”.[4]
As outlined by the OAIC, this can include “notes of your symptoms or diagnosis, information about a health service you’ve had or will receive, dental records, your wishes about future health services and appointment and billing details”.[5]
What are your obligations?
If you or your business is a health service provider and holds “health information” as defined under the Privacy Act, then you will need to consider how you handle personal information in accordance with the Privacy Act
It is important that you also comply with the APPs, which contain 13 principles that govern the rights, obligations and standards in relation to privacy including to the collection use and disclosure of personal information, governance and accountability. For instance, the APPs require you to have an up-to-date privacy policy that is available free of charge (usually on a website) and state that you must not collect sensitive information unless the individual consents to the collection and the information is reasonably necessary for a function or activity, unless an exception applies.[6]
The Privacy Act provides that an APP entity which is subject to the Privacy Act must not do an act, or engage in a practice, that breaches the APPs.[7] Failure to comply with the Privacy Act or the Australian Privacy Principles can result in an “interference with the privacy of an individual” and result in regulatory action and penalties.
For instance, in 2016 the acting Australian Information Commissioner ordered that a medical practitioner pay a complainant $10,000 compensation for non-economic loss.[8] It was found that the medical practitioner breached the APPs when he responded to an email from the complainant including six third party recipients. The response from the medical practitioner was sent to the complainant and such third parties referring to the management of the complainant’s delusional depression. He was found to have breached the APPs for various reasons, including on the basis that the complainant had not provided consent to the disclosure and a permitted exception did not exist. The actions of the medical practitioner were also found to be inconsistent with their privacy policy.
If you wish to seek advice or require assistance in relation to these matters, including privacy policies, please contact Felicity Cara-Carson or Jess Tomlinson on (03) 9614 7707.
[1] Privacy Act 1998 (Cth) s 6FA(1).
[2] Ibid s 6FA(2).
[3] https://www.oaic.gov.au/privacy/health-information/what-is-a-health-service-provider/
[4] Privacy Act 1998 (Cth) s 6FB.
[5] https://www.oaic.gov.au/privacy/health-information/what-is-health-information/
[6] Australian Privacy Principle 3.3.
[7] Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) s 15.
[8] ‘IV’ and ‘IW’ [2016] AICmr 41.
Gym Operators Hiring Personal Trainers – Make Sure You Consider the Options and Understand the Legal Consequences of Getting it Wrong
Gym operators hiring personal trainers –make sure you consider the options and understand the legal consequences of getting it wrong
Commercial gyms may engage personal trainers to work with their clientele and add value to the overall membership experience. Gym operators need to consider their approach to engaging personal trainers to maximise profits and minimise legal issues. This article discusses the options available to gyms and the issues that can arise.
How to engage personal trainers for a commercial gym
There are three main approaches open to gyms seeking to bring on PTs:
- hiring as employees
- engaging as independent contractors
- renting gym space to personal trainers
Personal trainers as employees or contractors
Many operators now seek to avoid employing PTs, instead promoting a system whereby the trainers run their own business from the gym. PTs promote their services personally and split their revenue with the gym on a negotiated basis.
The benefits of this system are obvious, as the gym saves money on wages and avoids the administrative burden associated with employing staff in an industry with relatively high turnover.
However, the arrangement is not without risk, particularly in respect of the punitive sham contracting provisions found in Australian employment law. Legal advice should be sought before making the decision to classify a worker as an independent contractor.
Personal trainers paying rent to use gym space
A more “hands off” approach by operators is to rent out their gym space to PTs for an agreed ongoing fee. This arrangement is little more than a licence to use the gym, leaving PTs to operate their business and collect their own fees from clients among the gym’s patrons.
For operators opting to collect a licence fee, the arrangement must be carefully documented to address issues such as insurance, damage and disputes.
The importance of gyms and personal trainers getting the documents right
No matter which approach a gym opts for, it’s critical that the necessary documentation is drafted correctly. Failing to seek legal advice or attempting to piece together documents from examples found online can prove costly in the long term.
Pointon Partners has extensive experience in assisting gyms and personal trainers with their business structuring. Please contact Michael Bishop or Ben Drysdale to discuss.
Retaining and Incentivising Key Employees
Retaining and incentivising key employees is an issue that nearly all businesses must confront at certain stages of their development and expansion. Generally, multiple options are available with pros and cons that need to be carefully considered based on the circumstances of the relevant business.
The most commonly used incentives are summarised as below.
Incentive: Cash bonus
Operation
· Employee has contractual right to receive cash bonus based on their individual key performance indicators (KPIs) being achieved, which are usually short to mid-term hurdles
· Employee does not have any ownership of the business
Tax
· Employee is taxed on the cash bonus at their marginal rate
· Employer must withhold PAYG and entitled to a deduction for the cash bonus
Costs
· Low cost to implement
· No significant ongoing administrative costs
Termination of employment
· Right to bonus terminates at the same time
· In some cases, e.g. breach of employment agreement, a bonus(es) may be repayable
Incentive: Phantom or shadow equity
Operation
· Employee has contractual right to receive a cash bonus based on financial performance of business over time, usually 3+ years
· Employee does not have any ownership of the business
· Employee incentivised by long term financial performance of the business, as opposed to their own short to mid-term performance
Tax
· Employee is taxed on the cash bonus at their marginal rate
· Employer must withhold PAYG and entitled to a deduction for the cash bonus
Costs
· Low cost to implement
· No significant ongoing administrative costs
Termination of employment
· If employee resigns prior to specific period, e.g. 3 years, or commits breach of employment contract, then generally the right to the bonus also terminates
· Otherwise, employee generally entitled to bonus, if it has not been paid previously
Incentive: Options
Operation
· Employee is granted an option to buy equity (shares / units) directly in the employer or indirectly via a trust controlled by the employer
· Employer must be a company or unit trust
· The employee may hold the option via a family trust or other entity, unless the employer lends funds for the acquisition of the option
· The option is exercisable upon specific triggers being met, e.g. minimum period of employment, KPIs, etc.
· Employee does not have any ownership of the business, until the option is exercised
· Employee incentivised by long term financial performance of the business, as opposed to their own short to mid-term performance
Corporations law
· Disclosure document or product disclosure statement required, unless an exemption applies or ASIC has granted relief
· A unit trust may be a managed investment scheme and may need to be registered with ASIC
Tax
· If the option is issued for market value to buy equity in the future at its current market value, then there is no tax implication for the employee or the employer on the granting or the exercise of the option
· If the option is issued for less than market value, then the amount of the discount will be taxable:
o to the employee when the option is granted, in the case of an option to acquire shares, subject to the employee share scheme concessions, if applicable (see below)
o the employer when the option is granted, in the case of an option to acquire units
· The employer may lend funds to the employee prior to becoming a shareholder on a limited recourse basis to avoid the above tax implications, subject to the financial assistance provisions of the corporations law (if applicable) and the employee personally holding the option
· Disposal of the option may trigger capital gain or loss for the employee
· Exercise of the option will not trigger any tax for the employee or the employer, however disposal of the equity will trigger capital gain or loss for the employee
Costs
· Require an independent valuation to determine the market value of the option and the underlying equity at the time of granting of the option
· Legal costs involved in granting options, preparing shareholders agreement or unitholders agreement (if applicable) and establishing employee share scheme (if applicable)
· Ongoing costs will depend on the complexity of the option granted and any scheme for broad employee participation
Termination of employment
· Unexercised option generally expires upon termination of employment
Incentive: Equity
Operation
· Employee buys equity (shares / units) directly in the employer or indirectly in a trust controlled by the employer
· Employer must be a company or unit trust
· The employee may acquire the equity via a family trust or other entity, unless the employer lends funds for the acquisition of the equity
· Employee has ownership of business in proportion to their shareholding / unitholding
· Shareholders agreement or unitholder agreement may be necessary to set out how company / trust will be operated and restrict dealing with shares / units
Corporations law
· Disclosure document or product disclosure statement required, unless an exemption applies or ASIC has granted relief
· A unit trust may be a managed investment scheme and may need to be registered with ASIC
· If employee holds equity directly, then they will have shareholder / unitholder rights
Tax
· If the equity is issued for market value, then there is no tax implication for the employee or the employer
· If the equity is issued for less than market value, then the amount of the discount will be taxable:
o to the employee when the shares are issued, subject to the employee share scheme concessions, if applicable (see below)
o the employer when the units are issued
· The employer may lend funds to the employee prior to becoming a shareholder on a limited recourse basis to avoid the above tax implications, subject to the financial assistance provisions of the corporations law (if applicable) and the employee personally acquiring the equity
· Disposal of the equity will trigger capital gain or loss for the employee
Costs
· Require an independent valuation to determine the market value of the equity at the time of issue
· Legal costs involved in issuing equity, preparing shareholders agreement or unitholders agreement (if applicable) and establishing employee share scheme (if applicable)
· Ongoing costs will depend on the complexity of the options granted
Termination of employment
· If employee resigns prior to specific period, e.g. 3 years, or commits breach of employment contract, then generally employer has an option to buy back equity at a discount to market value (e.g. 20%)
· Otherwise, employer generally has an option to buy back equity at market value
Employee Share Scheme concession
Start up – the amount of the discount will not be taxable to the employee
-
- The company (or any related company) has been incorporated for less than 10 years and is not listed on a stock exchange
- The company has aggregated turnover under $50 million
- For options – the exercise price is at least the market value of the shares when the option(s) is granted
- For shares – the discount is not more than 15% of the market value of the shares, which may be determined by simplified statutory methods
- The employer is an Australian resident company
- The scheme relates to ordinary shares
- The company is not a share trading or investment company
- Every acquirer of an option(s) / shares must hold their option(s) / shares for at least three years or until termination of employment (whichever occurs first)
- The employee must not hold more than 10% of shareholding and voting power when option(s) is granted / when shares are acquired
- For shares – the scheme must be broadly available to 75% of permanent employees who have completed at least 3 years of service
Deferred taxation – the amount of the discount will be taxable to the employee until the earlier of:
-
-
- no restriction on disposal
- termination of employment
- 15 years after acquisition
-
- The start-up concession does not apply
- The scheme relates to ordinary shares
- The company is not a share trading or investment company
- The employee must not hold more than 10% of shareholding and voting power when option(s) is granted / when shares are acquired
- For options – there is a ‘real risk of forfeiture’ of option(s) or restriction on disposal
- For shares – there is a ‘real risk of forfeiture’ of shares or the shares are issued as part of a salary sacrifice arrangement (up to $5,000)
- For shares – the scheme must be broadly available to 75% of permanent employees who have completed at least 3 years of service
This document does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied on as such. If you require assistance or advice in relation to the above, then please contact Laszlo Konya on (03) 9614 7707.
M&A Update: The Importance of Apportioning the Purchase Price in a Sale of Business Agreement
Apportioning the purchase price in a sale of business agreement among the various assets being sold and purchased may help avoid tax headaches in the future.
A sale of business comprises the sale and purchase of multiple assets, such as goodwill, trading stock, depreciating assets, buildings (including post 1979 capital works), and trademarks, which are all treated differently for tax purposes.[1]
If the parties deal with each other at arm’s length and apportion the purchase price in the relevant sale of business agreement to each specific asset, then the ATO will generally accept that apportionment.[2]
In the absence of apportionment of the purchase price, and subject to certain statutory rules[3], the ATO accepts that each party can make their own ‘reasonable’ apportionment. As to what is a ‘reasonable’ apportionment, this will depend on a case-by-case basis on the assets that were sold and purchased as part of the transaction.
Goodwill
In relation to goodwill, which is a CGT asset, a ‘reasonable’ apportionment would have regard to the market value of the goodwill at the time of the making of the contract.[4] This can result in costly and lengthy disputes with the ATO (or other State revenue bodies in relation to duty on sale of business transactions).
In the recent case of Placer Dome[5], the High Court revisited the legal definition of ‘goodwill’, and confirmed that it “is notoriously difficult to define”.[6] In practical terms, this legal difficulty is compounded by the differing interpretations of ‘goodwill’ used by valuers, accountants and otherwise in general business parlance.
Generally speaking, ‘accounting goodwill’ is the difference between the market value of the whole enterprise, less the market value of the specifically identifiable assets that are not goodwill. This is also known as the ‘top down’ valuation method.
On the other hand, ‘legal goodwill’ is difficult to define, in part, because it is used in differing factual and legal contexts, such that “he definition in one context is more often than not inappropriate in another context”.[7] For example, in the earlier case of Murry[8], the High Court had to consider the definition of ‘goodwill’ in relation to the application of capital gains tax on the sale of a taxi licence[9] and some shares. Whilst in Placer Dome, the High Court had to consider the definition in relation to the application of Western Australian duty on the sale of shares in a landholding company that conducted a gold mining enterprise.
The landholding company in Placer Dome had been acquired for $15.346 billion, and the central question in dispute was whether at that time the value of the company’s land was 60% or more the value of all its property, including goodwill. The purchaser’s external accountants valued all of the company’s identifiable assets at $8.84 billion, and concluded that the difference between this amount and the purchase price was the value of the company’s goodwill (i.e. $6.506 billion).[10] The High Court found that the duty was payable as Placer Dome was a land rich company.
Despite the very different factual and legal contexts, the majority judgment of the High Court in both Murry and Placer Dome confirmed that the ability of a business to attract customers is central to the legal concept of goodwill.[11] Goodwill, that is custom, may be generated from a number of sources, such as physical location, service, personality, price or habit, however such sources must be distinguished from the goodwill itself.[12] For example, a trademark may be a significant source of goodwill, and its value would reduce the value of the goodwill accordingly.[13]
The majority judgment in Murry concluded that a taxi licence is a valuable item of property that allows the licensee to conduct a taxi business, however the licence is not and does not contain any element of goodwill.[14] The value of the goodwill of a taxi business is likely to be small, because most of the custom of a taxi business is new custom, as opposed to repeat custom, and a taxi business is unlikely to generate above average industry earnings.[15]
The majority judgment in Placer Dome concluded that the taxpayer had no sources of goodwill for legal purposes that could add value to its business by attracting customers.[16] The goodwill valued by the taxpayer’s external accountants at $6.506 billion did not equate to the value of its goodwill for legal purposes. The taxpayer submitted that goodwill is a bundle of rights and privileges to use assets of a business to generate income, known as the ‘added value approach’, however this was rejected by the majority.[17] The majority also rejected the taxpayer’s submission that goodwill equates to going concern value, which is the ability of a business to generate income, and stated that going concern value may exist even when there is no goodwill.[18] Unfortunately, the majority judgment did not explain what the premium of $6.506 billion paid by the purchaser in addition to the market value of the taxpayer’s assets relates to, but only that it was not ‘goodwill’.
Practical issues
In practical commercial terms, the relevance of Placer Dome is that it confirms the limited legal definition of goodwill and the difficulties associated with valuing it. In a sale of business scenario, failure to apportion the purchase price may result in a party having difficulty justifying to the ATO (or a State revenue authority, where applicable) that its apportionment of the purchase price in relation to goodwill and other assets is reasonable[19].
Therefore, in order to avoid costly and lengthy disputes with the ATO (or a State revenue authority, where applicable), it is advisable to apportion the purchase price in the sale of business agreement, even if this requires some commercial haggling with the other party[20]. Assuming that the parties are dealing at arm’s length, it is unlikely that the ATO (or a State revenue authority, where applicable) would seek to review the apportionment of the purchase price. However, where the parties are in any way related the ATO may test whether their dealing was at arm’s length in any audit situation.
If you would like to discuss this article, please contact Laszlo Konya or Robert Gordon on (03) 9614 7707.
[1] For example, goodwill, buildings and trade marks are CGT assets. Depreciable assets, which includes copyrights, patents and registered designs, that are wholly used for business purposes and trading stock are taken out of the CGT net (by s.118-24 and s.118-25 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (ITAA 1997)). Any profit or loss on depreciating assets is the subject of the balancing adjustment provisions of Division 40 ITAA 1997. Therefore, the general CGT discount (currently 50%) and the small business concessions are not available in relation to them. Capital works deductions are dealt with in Division 43 ITAA 1997 and, although there is no “claw-back” of previously claimed deductions (e.g. for building works), the deductions do reduce the cost base of the asset.
[2] TD 98/24 in relation to CGT assets; ATO ID 2002/818 in relation to depreciable assets. For an example of where the parties were at arm’s length but they were not dealing at arm’s length, see Collis v FC of T 1996 ATC 4831.
[3] In relation to depreciated assets, reasonable apportionment is mandated by s.40-310 ITAA 1997. In relation to trading stock, there is a provision requiring symmetry between the vendor and the purchaser: s.70-95 ITAA 1997. In relation to capital works, the purchaser (e.g. of an income producing building) is entitled to deduct over time, the cost of the works that have not been deducted by the vendor.
[4] TD 98/24.
[5] Commissioner of State Revenue v Placer Dome Inc [2018] HCA 59 (Placer Dome).
[6] At [52].
[7] At [55].
[8] Commissioner of Taxation v Murry [1998] HCA 42 (Murry).
[9] At the time, s160ZZR Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (ITAA 1936) provided a 50% CGT exemption for small businesses on the sale only of ‘goodwill’.
[10] Placer Dome at [39].
[11] Murry at [20]; Placer Dome at [63].
[12] Murry at [30]; Placer Dome at [64].
[13] Murry at [51].
[14] Murry at [67]-[68]. As the current small business CGT concession focus on the disposal of all ‘active assets’, not just ‘goodwill’, the concessions are much wider than s160ZZR (which became s118-250 ITAA 1997).
[15] Murry at [60]-[61].
[16] Placer Dome at [111].
[17] Placer Dome at [86].
[18] Placer Dome at [98].
[19] TR 1999/16 at [43].
[20] Note that in relation to capital works, whilst there is an obligation for the vendor to provide the purchaser with information concerning the vendor’s undeducted capital works expenditure (under s262A (4AJA) ITAA 1936) within 6 months of the end of the year in which the disposal occurred, it may be better to contract to obtain that information at an earlier date.
Court Puts the Brakes on Ultra Tune
By a decision of the Federal Court on 18 January 2019 by Justice Bromwich national franchisor Ultra Tune was ordered to pay fines totaling $2,604,000. The fines (known as pecuniary penalties) sought by the ACCC and awarded by the Court were for various breaches of the Franchising Code of Conduct (Code) and Australian Consumer Law.
The Court found that Ultra Tune had failed to act in good faith in breach of the Franchising Code, and had made false or misleading representations in breach of the ACL, in its dealings with a prospective franchisee. Ultra Tune made false or misleading representations to the prospective franchisee about the price of the franchise, the ongoing rent of the premises, and the age of the franchise. The prospective franchisee was also told that a $33,000 deposit was refundable when it was not.
Ultra Tune also breached the Code by failing to prepare marketing fund statements within the required timeframes, failing to provide these statements and audit reports to franchisees, and failing to include sufficient detail in the statements.
“The cover up that Ultra Tune attempted reflects a significantly heightened need for deterrence, in relation to conduct that was already a most serious and fundamental breach of the Franchising Code in taking the deposit in the first place, reflecting as it does Ultra Tune’s attitude in relation to its contravening conduct,” Justice Bromwich said.
“There must be no tolerance for manufacturing evidence to deceive a regulator, and even less when the deception is maintained in this Court.”
“Franchisors often have the stronger bargaining position in their dealings with franchisees, which is why compliance with the Franchising Code and the Australian Consumer Law is so important,” said ACCC Deputy Chair Mick Keogh.
“This outcome should be a strong reminder for franchisors to meet their disclosure obligations or face serious consequences.”
Justice Bromwich also awarded the ACCC indemnity costs.
These are the first proceedings that the ACCC has brought against a franchisor alleging a breach of the Franchising Code obligation to act in “good faith” in business dealings with franchisees.
This decision comes at a time when franchisors have been under sustained public scrutiny since the 2018 Senate committee inquiry into ‘The operation and effectiveness of the Franchising Code of Conduct’. The Committee’s report was due for release on 14 February 2019. Many public submissions by franchisees complained about poor Code compliance by franchisors and conduct which they alleged lacked good faith.
The Ultra Tune decision is a reminder that strict compliance with the Code, particularly in relation to disclosure documents and marketing fund reporting, as well as the general requirement to act in good faith, remain of paramount importance for all franchisors. Compliance is not new to the sector but missing Code compliance dates, or being slack with compliance, can carry significant financial and reputational consequences.
Key Learnings for franchisors
Compliance is not negotiable. There is absolutely no excuse for slackness or poor compliance, especially for larger franchisors;
Timeframes set out in the Code for updating and providing documents to franchisees is strict. Being late, even by a few days is not acceptable and the Code does not include a framework to seek an extension of time from the ACCC;
Marketing fund financial statements need to include significantly greater detail. A simple profit and loss statement, or balance sheet, statement will often not suffice. The larger the marketing expense the more detail is required in the financial statements. Franchisors need to work with their franchise lawyers and accountants/auditors to ensure financial statements meet the Code requirement to give “meaningful” information about the receipts and expenses of the fund;
Marketing fund statements must be able to be read and understood in isolation. Communication with franchisees, such as through in-house newsletters, is not a substitute for the need for financial statements to contain ‘sufficient detail’ and ‘meaningful information’;
Fines can be imposed for each and every breach. Where the obligation relates to each franchisee, such as the requirement to provide a marketing fund financial statement and audit report, failing to have, or provide, those documents constitutes a separate breach in relation to each and every franchisee. Massive fines are likely for larger systems if they get compliance wrong across their system;
There is added compliance risk if a franchisor chooses to maintain multiple disclosure documents, or run multiple (or separate) marketing funds;
Good faith requires a franchisor to consider the franchisee’s interests; however, it does not require a franchisor to favour the franchisee’s interests over its own;
Misleading or false representations in a franchise context can also trigger breaches of the ACL, with substantial fines being imposed by the Court. In this case $1M for a single breach. Note: ACL fines are now significantly higher than the maximum $1.1M available in the Ultra Tune case; and
Assessment of fines for Code breaches
Although Ultra Tune admitted most of its Code compliance breaches, there was significant disagreement about the fines that should apply and the quantum of those fines. The ACCC’s primary position was that each breach was a separate breach and referable to the number of franchisees at the relevant time. Given there were 185 and 200 franchisees at the end of each relevant financial year and the maximum fine was $54,000 for each financial year, the potential aggregate of fines could easily have exceeded $10M.
Simon Della Marta
Pointon Partners Sydney
ACCC v Ultra Tune Australia Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 12
Shareholders’ Agreement – Your Legal Relationship Document
When you go into business with other stakeholders you should have a document in place which sets out the legal relationship between you and the other business owners.
Most company constitutions, unit trust deeds or even partnership agreements are not suitable and need to be augmented by an agreement the lays over the top of the generic style company constitution or unit trust deed.
In each case, you would want to make sure there is in place an agreement between the shareholders, unit holders or partners set out in a shareholders’ agreement, unitholders’ agreement or partnership agreement which effectively regulates the legal relationship between the stakeholders.
The main areas that may need to be covered and have a workable solution include:
- Sharing financial obligations and benefits in proportion to equity holding or some other agreed proportion;
- Setting up a structure for decision making processes determining what types of decisions require ordinary, special or unanimous stakeholder approval
- The circumstances in which dividends or profits are declared or distributed;
- Future funding arrangements;
- Method or mechanism for resolving disputes or an impasse between stakeholders;
- What the mechanism is for future allotment of shares and do they have to be equal;
- Restriction of transfer of shares – pre-emptive rights with the exemption for transfers within “family” or to associates. Also, deeming of transfer of underlying interest to invoke transfer provisions. Tag along and drag along provisions.
- The terms of any shareholders loans – agreed interest rate or benchmark rate or interest free;
- What happens in the event of death or incapacity of member and/or director- what are the consequences for transfer of shares, continued running of the business etc;
- Decisions of the Board – which decisions require unanimous or greater than an agreed percentage of directors to vote in favour e.g. restrictions on borrowing, lending, change of dividend policy, incurring expenditure with limits;
- Whether any of the directors or shareholders or other participants are to be employed in the business and if so on what terms;
- Business plan, accounts and reports – what is the timing for these, their content and distribution.
- Whether there should be options for exiting and continuing principals, e.g. the power to nominate a buyer.
- Events that might lead to dissolution or forced exit, e.g. bankruptcy, fraud.
- Funding available for contingencies such as ill-health or death of a principal, e.g. income continuance and equity insurance backed by an agreement or life insurance for trauma events or death;
- Structure for ownership of key assets pre and post exit, e.g. the intellectual property – a principal may have bought into the business and might want to lease or licence intellectual property to the business, rather than to hand it over to the business.
- Whether to have the business assets (including intellectual property) licenced for use by the business risk entity thus protecting those assets from business risk.
Per: Simon Della Marta
Pointon Partners Sydney
How Secure is Your Legal Relationship?
In any business arrangement it is important to ensure the legal relationship between the various interests is carefully defined and documented.
In the Hollywood blockbuster movie, The Social Network, the undefined relationship between co founders Mark Zuckerberg and Edwardo Saverin led to litigation which fortunately for the parties involved led to a undisclosed settlement. Mr Saverin initially had ownership of 24% of the Facebook company which was subsequently diluted to below 10% after a change in the position between the two co-founders. With an implied value of Facebook in October 2007 of around US$15 billion a 14% interest represented US$2.1 billion, certainly enough money to dispute about.
Put in the Australian business context there are various legal frameworks by which businesses are operated whether it be a company with shareholders, a company acting as trustee of a unit trust with the business interest holders owning units in the fixed trust, a partnership of companies acting for discretionary trusts or a simple partnership or joint venture arrangement. There can also be special arrangements for capital injection participants, venture capitalists and sweat equity participants. In each of these structures, it is possible to ensure certainty between various holding interests by putting in place a legal relationship agreement such as a shareholders agreement, unit holders agreement, partnership agreement or joint venture agreement setting out in legally enforceable terms who owns what and what the relationship will be. Senior employee capital interests can be regulated and secured by an employee share scheme. The purpose is to ensure certainty in defining what the legal relationship between the various interests is thereby minimising conflict and energy sapping litigation.
Certainty is in the interest of both major and minority interests. For majority interests (primary business owner or entrepreneur) it ensures that only the interest intended to be granted to minority interests is effective and enforceable. It reduces the risk of subsequent litigation which draws attention away from the operation of the business.
From the point of view of a minority interest it ensures that the ownership interest they think they have is properly defined and enforceable.
Where business owners have combined forces to operate a business or venture together for their mutual benefit having a legal relationship document setting out what the parameters of their rights and obligations are provides a framework by which they get on and make money by concentration on working the business venture. It is healthy to negotiate an operating framework so the various interests know what to expect. When going into a venture it is always easier to come up with a framework by which disputes are resolved before any such difficulty arises. This will allow business owners to negotiate and come up with a solution to resolve friction which they are comfortable with before dispute arises.
The legal relationship agreement can define what the equity interests are, what decisions in the venture must be unanimous or otherwise, what the obligation for making capital contribution will be, what the obligations for contributing to liabilities will be, how much income should be retained for working capital, dispute resolution mechanisms, insurance arrangements and many other issues.
Per: Simon Della Marta
Pointon Partners Sydney
Asset Protection
Protecting your hard-earned assets from legal liabilities and claims makes a lot of sense and involves forward thinking and planning.
Ideally, you would like to ensure that your wealth-creation structures are separated from “risky business”. Any entity conducting business is at risk because of the nature of its pursuits. It is entering into and fulfilling a myriad of legal and statutory obligations wielding a path of protection from issues such as employment laws, superannuation requirements, contractual obligations, duties of care, obligations of fidelity and good faith, trade practices concern, state revenue obligations such as payroll tax and stamp duty, occupational health and safety requirements, privacy obligations, corporate governance, disclosure requirements and the ever present obligations of income tax and GST.
An effective method of protection of assets is ensuring that the assets are held in a different legal entity to the trading risk entity. A manufacturing business for example could have all of its plant and equipment, intellectual property and know-how owned by a separate legal entity as the one operating the business subjected to the risks. It may be possible for the entity owning the assets to license the use of those assets for an appropriate fee to the business operation entity which operates the business using those assets. The business risk entity has the use of the assets to conduct the business but if the business entity finds itself in financial difficulty the assets can be protected from liability.
If your business operating entity is appropriately structured such as a discretionary trust then you can legally ensure that profits from the operation of the business are split between your family members such as your non-working spouse, elderly parents or children in tertiary education thus utilising the marginal tax rates (where the top marginal rate of 45% commences at taxable income of $180,001, the 37% marginal rate commences at taxable income of $90,001 and the 32.5% marginal rate commences at taxable income of $37,001 – all plus 2% Medicare levy)
Where you have a number of proprietors of the business appropriate structures can be put in place to properly protect their interests with a legal relationship document prepared be it a shareholders’ agreement, unit trust agreement or partnership of discretionary trust agreement depending upon the most appropriate legal structure for the circumstances.
Restructuring an existing arrangement may have issues such as capital gains tax and stamp duty to be properly considered before embarking upon a program restructuring your position. Oftentimes a solution for difficulties can be arrived at after careful examination and appropriate legal advice obtained.
Per: Simon Della Marta
Pointon Partners Sydney
Beware of Warranties and Representations in a Sale of Business – Vendors may be ordered to repay significant amounts
In the context of a sale of business, careful consideration must be given to warranties contained in the sale of business agreement, along with any representations made about the present and future performance of the business. Unwary vendors may find themselves defending Court proceedings for breach of warranty or misleading or deceptive conduct.
General principles of warranties in a sale of business agreement
When a business is being sold, the purchaser will generally insist that a number of warranties are included in the sale of business agreement. A ‘warranty’ is a statement of fact that is incorporated into a sale of business agreement to induce a purchaser to enter into the agreement. For example, a simple warranty could be that the vendor has the authority to sell the business or that there are no security interests affecting the business assets.
From a vendor’s perspective, warranties should be specific and limited to facts that the vendor or its representatives can fully verify. A well drafted sale of business agreement should also exclude any pre-contractual representations, to the extent legally possible, and state that the agreement contains the entire bargain struck by the parties. On the other hand, from a purchaser’s perspective, warranties should be as wide and all-encompassing as possible, and the sale of business agreement should not limit the purchaser’s ability to rely on pre-contractual representations.
Representations about future performance
Vendors should also be extremely wary when making any representations about the future performance of the business being sold. A common example is the provision of financial forecasts, which may form the basis of negotiations about the purchase price of the business. Purchasers will be understandably aggrieved when, after completion of the sale, it emerges that such forecasts were exaggerated or inaccurate.
The making of misleading and deceptive representations is prohibited by s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), and cannot be excluded by contract. Importantly for vendors, s 4(2) of the ACL deems a representation about any future matter to be misleading, if there were no reasonable grounds for making the representation.
Where, for example, financial forecasts are provided prior to the sale of a business and a disgruntled purchaser subsequently makes an allegation of misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to the forecasts, the vendor will, in effect, have to prove to the Court that it had reasonable grounds for making the forecasts.
Should the vendor fail to discharge this reverse onus, the Court will find in favour of the purchaser and assess damages. These damages may be awarded on a “no-transaction” basis, meaning that the purchaser’s loss will be assessed as the purchase price less the true value of the business at the time of the acquisition.
When warranties and representations go wrong
The issues outlined above arose in the recent case of Evolution Traffic Control v Skerratt [2018] NSWSC 49 (Skerratt). In that case, a purchaser entered into a share purchase agreement for a trade training organisation with a purchase price of $10 million. The price was calculated as five times the sustainable EBIT of the business. In calculating the EBIT, reliance was placed by the purchaser on financial forecasts provided by the vendors.
The financial forecasts provided by the vendors assumed that the business would maintain the fifty additional government-funded student places that had been allocated the previous year. However, the Western Australian government had imposed a condition for ongoing funding which, by the time of the sale, was effectively impossible to achieve. The vendors failed to disclose this funding condition during negotiations.
When it transpired after completion that such important information regarding the future performance of the business was withheld during negotiations, the purchaser issued proceedings to recover the difference between the purchase price and the actual value of the business at the time of the sale.
The purchasers sued the vendors for misleading and deceptive conduct under the ACL, for breach of the warranties contained in the share purchase agreement and for indemnity against loss pursuant to a clause of the share purchase agreement.
The purchaser relied on two broad warranties: (i) the accuracy and completeness of all information disclosed in due diligence materials during the course of negotiations leading up to the sale; and (ii) that all information that would be material for disclosure to a prudent purchaser had been disclosed.
The vendors in Skerratt were unable to convince the Court that they had a reasonable basis for making representations about the business’ future financial performance, making consideration of the warranty and indemnity arguments unnecessary. The vendors were ordered to pay roughly $4 million as the purchasers had, prior to issuing proceedings, sold the business to a third party for $6 million.
Although the Court did not deal with the warranty claims, because it found in favour of the purchaser for misleading or deceptive conduct, it is worth noting that the warranties were broad and clearly favour the purchaser. The warranties capture the forecasts that were provided by the vendors to induce the purchaser to buy the business for $10 million. It would have been advisable for the vendors to limit these warranties to past or present facts or information, and expressly exclude any forecasts, which, by their nature, can be very difficult to justify. These changes alone would not have altered the outcome of the case, but they serve to illustrate the issue of agreeing to broad warranties.
How to proceed when drafting a contract of sale
Careful consideration must be given to the drafting of a sale of business agreement. For vendors in particular, there are a number of methods by which potential liability can be reduced, including:
- Avoiding representations about the future performance of the business
- Limiting warranties to matters that the vendor can control or has knowledge of
- Including a cap on the amount that can be claimed as damages
- Providing a minimum threshold of damages before a warranty claim can proceed
- Qualifying all warranties with disclosures made during the due diligence period
For purchasers, such clauses in the sale of business agreement are clearly undesirable. Care should be taken to ensure that there will be appropriate recourse against the vendor for undisclosed issues arising post-completion.
Pointon Partners has extensive experience in advising prospective vendors and purchasers in sales of businesses. Please contact Laszlo Konya or Ben Drysdale to discuss.