The Fair Work Commission has upheld a dismissal of a senior
staff-member for taking up a secondary job because it contravened
their contractual duties.
With side jobs and secondary careers becoming increasingly
common, this decision highlights the importance of reviewing the
terms of employment before considering taking on an additional
position.
The Facts
- The employee worked in a managerial position at a small
recruitment firm. - The employee had been conducting a secondary career in
life-coaching outside of this role over a period of many
months. - The employer dismissed the employee on the grounds of breach of
contract, stating that this breached loyalty duties enshrined in
the employment contract. - The employee brought an unfair dismissal action under the
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ('the Fair Work Act').
They argued that the employer had been aware of the secondary
career and that a separate conflict was the true cause of
termination. - The employee also argued that as the secondary career was not
being conducted during work hours, there were no grounds for breach
of contract.
The Legal Issues
The primary issues in this decision were as follows:
- Whether the employer had condoned the employee's secondary
career and thus waived their right to terminate his employment
contract on those grounds; - If they had not waived that right, was dismissal because of the
secondary career harsh, unjust and unreasonable under the criteria
in section 387 of the Fair Work Act.
The Decision
On the question of whether the employer had condoned the
secondary career, the Fair Work Commission established that the
element of 'full knowledge' required for condonation
(summarised in Rankin v Marine Power International Pty Ltd
[2001] VSC 150) is relatively strict. It was accepted that the
employee had discussed their life-coaching business at work and
that evidence, such as their LinkedIn account, would certainly hint
at its existence. Nevertheless, the facts did not clearly affirm
the employer's knowledge and thus they could not be said to
have condoned it. The Commission considered the terms in the
contract, which defined what the employee could do with respect to
a second job.
The employment contract stated that employees were required to
'serve efficiently, faithfully and diligently' and devote
their time and attention exclusively to the employer. It also
prohibited undertaking any other business or profession which would
create a conflict of interest. Persistent or sustained breach of
these duties would constitute serious misconduct.
Emails on the employee's work devices revealed that they
were discussing their secondary career with actual and prospective
clients of the employer, instead of providing them with the
services of his employer. Further emails the employee had sent
discussing the business showed that it was a 'consuming
passion' drawing their attention away from their work for the
employer.
The employer was experiencing a downturn and looking for ways to
reinvigorate; rather than assisting, the employee was creating
extensive social media content and a digital marketing strategy for
their own pursuits.
In light of these facts, the Commission found that there was a
valid reason for dismissing the employee on the basis of the
secondary career.
Section 387 of the Fair Work Act also states that the procedural
requirements for a fair dismissal may be eased if the enterprise is
small and absent a dedicated human resources management specialist.
The employer had recently lost seven employees and was down to just
four at the time the employee was dismissed; the Commissioner found
that this could explain the employer's failure to give the
employee an opportunity to respond to their claims.
The employee also brought an argument that their dismissal was
invalid because it was actually for a different reason than what
was given to them. Under the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code,
employers must be dismissing an employee for the reason stated at
termination. The employee alleged that a dispute over a shareholder
agreement was the true operative factor in his firing, not the
alleged breaches of their employment contract. However, the
Commissioner noted that the employee has the practical onus of
establishing this, and on the evidence put forth this could not
established.
Key Takeaway for Employees & Employers
Employers can lawfully require an employee's undivided
attention even outside of work hours, potentially barring secondary
careers.
However, this will depend on the nature of the position
(managerial vs. lower-level), the relationship between the careers
as well as any terms in the employment contract, particularly those
relating to conflicts of interest and the exclusive
'loyalty' of employees. Contractual terms must still be
lawful and reasonable.
In order for an employer to condone a secondary career and waive
the right to dismiss on that basis, they must have full knowledge
of it; employees should take heed and disclose as early as
possible.
In light of this case employers should review their employment
contracts to ensure they are adequately protected. If you require
assistance with the review of your employment agreement or have any
other queries about this case please contact Michael
Bishop or Amelita Hensman of our Employment Team.