In Australian law, unregistered trade marks and their associated
goodwill are treated as one in the same. Goodwill can have many
shapes and sources, but it is understood generally to refer to the
commercial aspects of a business other than tangible assets that
have attracted custom to it.
Under section 106 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 ('the
Act'), an assignment of a registered trade mark may be with or
without the goodwill of the business concerned in the relevant
goods and/or services. The Act, however, is silent in relation to
the assignment of an unregistered trade mark. A 2020 judgment of
the Full Court of the Federal Court illustrates the position in
Australian law and its far-reaching implications for trade mark
licensing and assignment.
Background
In 2018, Kraft Foods Group Brands LLC ('Kraft') brought
a claim against Bega Cheese Limited ('Bega') over use of an
unregistered trade mark. The trade mark in question was the yellow
lid and clear plastic jar of their peanut butter products
('Trade Dress'), as shown below in examples of products
sold by Kraft Foods Limited, an Australian entity within the Kraft
corporate group which was later renamed to Mondelez Australia
(Foods) Ltd following a restructure ('KFL/MAFL').

Image source: Kraft Foods Group Brands LLC v Bega Cheese
Limited [2020] FCAFC 65, [1].
In July 2017, Bega acquired the assets of KFL/MAFL's
Australian peanut butter business. After removing the Kraft
trademarked logos, Bega continued to use the Trade Dress as it had
been designed and used by KFL/MAFL. Kraft commenced proceedings and
argued that Bega did not acquire the Trade Dress when it bought the
peanut butter business, as it was never KFL/MAFL's to sell.
Instead, Kraft claimed that Bega's use of the Trade Dress was
actually licensed by them, and when that licence expired in
December 2017, Bega had no right to continue using it.
Kraft lost at first instance and appealed to the Full Federal
Court. The Full Court was asked to decide to whom the goodwill of
the mark inured, and which entity could continue to use the Trade
Dress to the exclusion of the other.
Decision
The Full Court highlighted two key principles on which it based
its decision.
Firstly, unregistered trade marks or product 'get-up'
are not species of property in Australian common law. They do not
have statutory infringement provisions like registered trade marks.
Instead, it is the business goodwill or reputation generated
through their use that is recognised and protected.
Secondly, the Court noted that this goodwill is
property capable of assignment. Thus, the sale, assignment or
ownership of an unregistered trade mark is the sale, assignment, or
ownership of business goodwill; the two are inseparable. Their
Honours stated that the rationale for this prohibition against a
"naked assignment of the mark without the accompanying
goodwill" goes to the nature of trade marks and the very
objective of trade mark law, which is to protect consumers from
being misled or confused as to the origin of goods or services.
These principles were fatal to Kraft's claim against Bega.
The Court traced the use of the Trade Dress across various
licensing agreements and restructure documents and ultimately found
that the goodwill inured to KFL/MAFL and that they had maintained
ownership over it during the relevant period. Consequently, when
KFL/MAFL transferred all of the assets that comprised the peanut
butter business in Australia to Bega, this constituted the
assignment of the rights in relation to the Trade Dress from
KFL/MAFL to Bega. Bega was therefore entitled to use the Trade
Dress in relation to the peanut butter products that it
manufactured and sold. Even though some aspects of the peanut
butter business were licensed from Kraft to KFL/MAFL, the Court
held that they never owned the goodwill generated by, and thus the
rights to, the Trade Dress.
Kraft also attempted to prevent Bega's use of the peanut
butter Trade Dress by arguing consumers would be misled into
believing Bega had a connection to Kraft because of the jar style,
regardless of any rights Bega may have. The Court disagreed,
holding that nothing in Bega's conduct beyond their lawful use
of the Trade Dress would cause a mistaken belief of connection in a
reasonable consumer.
Key Takeaways
The Full Court's judgment confirms that in Australian law,
unregistered trade marks do not have property rights like
registered trade marks; the business goodwill they generate is
taken to be inseparable from the business to which it adds value,
and cannot be dealt with except in conjunction with the sale of
that business.
Accordingly, the assignment or licensing of unregistered trade
marks is not possible without the transfer of the accompanying
goodwill. In contrast, registered trade marks (and trade marks
pending registration) can be assigned with or without the
associated goodwill, as expressly provided by section 106 of the
Act.
To avoid any unwitting transfer of underlying goodwill,
businesses should ensure that all important trade marks are
registered with the Trade Marks Office.
Should you wish to speak further on this, or have any queries
relating to your business's IP protection, please contact our
Intellectual Property team David Mazzeo, Stefano Mazzeo or Jess Tomlinson of our office.