Pointon Partners

Think You Are Too Young for a Will? Think Again

For many, the word Will still brings to mind something reserved for the elderly, the wealthy, or those facing serious illness. In reality, a Will is a powerful document that allows you to take control of how your assets, property, and personal affairs are managed and distributed after your death.

As a legal adult, whether you’re 18, 25 or 75, you make decisions every day that carry legal and financial consequences. You enter contracts, purchase property, build savings, and form relationships with legal significance. Yet one of the most important legal decisions of all – what happens to your estate when you’re gone – is often the one most people put off or leave at the bottom of their to-do list. If you don’t have a valid Will, your assets are distributed according to state-based laws which may not be in accordance with your wishes.

Making a Will at any age is about more than just preparing for the worst – it’s about peace of mind and having control over your choices. Whether you’re just starting your career, raising a family, or focused on your next chapter, it’s never too early to protect what you are building and decide what you want to happen after you pass away.

Why You Need a Will, No Matter Your Age

1. You Decide What Happens

If you pass away without a valid Will (known as dying intestate), the law in Victoria steps in and decides what happens to your estate. The Court will appoint an administrator to manage and distribute your assets in accordance with the rules of intestacy. Although these rules are designed to deal with common family situations, they cannot account for the nuances of your relationships, family dynamics, or personal wishes. Without a Will, you lose the ability to choose who inherits your assets and who will be responsible for administering your estate.

Creating a properly drafted Will gives you back that control – allowing you to determine exactly how your estate should be distributed and ensuring your intentions are respected.

2. Your Wealth Doesn’t Have to Be Vast to have a Will

A common misconception is that Wills are only necessary for those with significant wealth. In reality, a Will is essential for anyone who owns anything or has people who rely on them. Even in your 20s or 30s, you may have more to protect than you realise.

Your estate can include savings, insurance benefits, vehicles, sentimental personal items, and an increasing number of digital assets such as online accounts or cryptocurrency. For most Australians, superannuation is also one of their largest assets, but it’s important to understand that superannuation does not automatically form part of your estate or follow the instructions in your Will. Instead, your super fund’s trustee decides who receives your super death benefit, unless you have a valid Binding Death Benefit Nomination in place.

Importantly, a Will goes beyond distributing money or assets. It allows you to make thoughtful and legally recognised decisions about the people, responsibilities and wishes that matter most. For example:

A properly drafted Will ensures these decisions reflect your intentions — not default legal rules — and gives you and your loved ones peace of mind.

3. You Choose Your Executor

Under your Will, you appoint an executor – the person or persons you trust to carry out your wishes after you’re gone. Your executor is responsible for, for example:

Because the role carries significant responsibility, it’s important to choose someone reliable, organised, and capable of handling both practical and emotional demands. If you do not have a valid Will, or your Will does not name a suitable executor, the Court will appoint an administrator to manage your estate instead — and the key difference is that an executor is chosen by you to follow your wishes, while an administrator is appointed by the Court to distribute your estate under intestacy laws.

4. Express Your Values

A Will is more than a legal document – it’s a way to leave a legacy that reflects your values, relationships and what truly matters most to you. Whether that’s gifting something to a friend, supporting a cause by making a charitable donation, passing down treasured personal items or expressing funeral wishes. Without a Will, intestacy rules decide for you, which may lead to outcomes very different from what you had intended.

5. A Starting Point That Can Grow With You

Creating a Will early doesn’t mean you’re locked into a set of decisions forever. Life changes – your relationships, career, and financial situation will shift over time – and your Will can change with them. In fact, it should evolve as your life does. Having a Will gives you a strong foundation that you can update whenever your circumstances or wishes change.

6. Especially Important for Young People Today

Having a Will is important for everyone over 18 — not just those with significant assets. Modern life brings complexities such as blended families, digital assets, superannuation arrangements, and businesses, meaning your estate may be more complicated than you think. A Will allows you to choose who manages your estate, how your assets are distributed, and who is cared for, giving you clarity and peace of mind.

If you pass away without a Will, the law decides how your estate is distributed, which may not align with your wishes. It also means the Court must appoint an administrator, adding delays, extra legal costs, and more stress for your loved ones. Creating a Will early provides a solid foundation that you can update as your life and circumstances evolve.

If you wish to discuss making a Will or have any questions about estate planning, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Jess Tomlinson of our Wills and Estates team.

No Financial Need, No Provision: Carer Wife’s Claim for a Share of Her Husband’s Estate Thrown Out

The Supreme Court has recently dismissed a claim brought by a
surviving wife seeking provision from her deceased husband's
estate, on the basis that the wife could not demonstrate financial
need. The Court found that her claim for a share of her
husband's estate had no real prospect of success and should not
proceed to trial.

The deceased husband left a will made in 2006 leaving his entire
estate to his adult daughter from a prior relationship. He married
the wife in 2006. The will remained in place at the time of his
death and was not challenged.

Throughout the marriage, the husband experienced significant
health issues. During that time, the wife, a medical practitioner,
provided significant care and reduced her working hours.

After his death, she commenced proceedings seeking a share of
the estate, relying heavily on the length of the marriage, her
significant caregiving role and the impact that had on her earning
capacity.

Financial need remains the threshold issue

The Court accepted that the deceased husband owed obligations to
his wife and that the caregiving history formed part of the factual
background. That was not enough.

On the wife's own evidence, she was financially secure. She
owned an unencumbered principal residence, held multiple investment
properties, had superannuation interests and rental income, and
retained earning capacity. The Court found that she was able to
provide for her own proper maintenance and support.

The Court also reiterated the orthodox position that, a will
maker's obligation to a surviving spouse is commonly satisfied
by ensuring secure accommodation, a reasonable income stream and a
fund to meet unforeseen contingencies. On the evidence before the
Court, the wife already had all three from her own assets and
income. She had no need for further provision.

Because financial need is a threshold requirement under the
legislation, the Court concluded that the jurisdiction to make a
family provision order was not enlivened. The claim therefore had
no real prospect of success and was dismissed summarily.

In practical terms, this meant the Court brought the case to an
end at an early stage, without a full trial, because the evidence
did not justify allowing it to proceed.

The decision confirms that family provision claims are not
determined by perceived unfairness, relationship history or past
sacrifice. Unless a claimant can demonstrate a genuine level
financial vulnerability, the Court may have no power to
intervene.

It is unclear whether the wife will be ordered to pay legal
costs.

Importance for executors

For executors, early and careful scrutiny of a claimant's
financial position is critical.

Family provision claims are often treated as inevitable and
allowed to progress on the assumption that settlement will
eventually be required. This case shows that approach is not always
justified. Where a claimant is already financially secure, summary
judgment may be an available procedural mechanism.

Executors are required to uphold the will, not redistribute
estate assets based on sympathy or perceived fairness. Any
settlement must be defensible as a rational compromise of legal
risk, particularly where financial need is not established.

That remains the case even where the claimant is a spouse and
there is an otherwise compelling personal history. The Court was
prepared to bring the matter to an end at an early stage to avoid
unnecessary cost and delay to the estate.

Executors who fail to properly test financial need risk allowing
weak claims to erode estate assets and prolong administration
without good reason.

Importance for claimants

For potential claimants, the decision is a warning against
running family provision claims on the basis of fairness or past
sacrifice alone.

Courts will scrutinise financial position closely. Ownership of
property, access to superannuation, investment income and earning
capacity will be central. Where a claimant is financially secure,
even a long marriage and substantial caregiving history may not be
enough to get the claim past the threshold stage.

Claimants who cannot demonstrate genuine financial vulnerability
risk early dismissal and adverse costs exposure. That is the case,
even where they may have a strong moral claim.

Estate planning context

The will in this case pre-dated much of the marriage and the
later period of illness and caregiving. It was not clear whether
the deceased husband intended to exclude his wife from benefiting
under his estate, or whether the outcome resulted from a failure to
update his will as circumstances changed.

That distinction did not affect the legal outcome. The Court
proceeded on the basis of the will as it stood at death and did not
treat outdated planning as a reason to intervene.

For will makers, the practical point is straightforward. Major
life events — including marriage, second marriages, changes
in family structure and periods of illness — should prompt a
review of estate planning arrangements.

Failing to do so creates uncertainty, increases the likelihood
of disputes, and leaves asset distribution to be determined by
litigation rather than clear instructions.

Practical significance

Financial need remains the gateway issue. Relationship history
and arguments based on past sacrifice do not replace that
requirement.

Summary judgment remains an effective tool where the evidence
shows the claimant is financially independent.

For executors and beneficiaries, the case supports a disciplined
approach to claim assessment. Personal narratives should not
obscure the threshold question of financial need. Where that
requirement is not met, early procedural action may be preferable
to allowing weak claims to erode estate value.

Whether you are an executor or a prospective claimant please
contact Pointon Partners for advice tailored to your
circumstances.

How the Trustee can remove the Appointor

In Staley v Hill Family Holdings Pty Ltd [2025] QCA 95, the Queensland Court of Appeal found that the power of a trustee to remove the appointor of a trust, pursuant to the Trust Deed, highlights the risks involved when establishing trusts without having the proper checks and balances in place. The ability of a trustee to remove an appointor is not a desired result. This is especially so when the appointor is often seen as the ultimate controller of the trust as they often have the power to remove and appoint a new trustee. It is recommended that you carefully review your trust deed to identify key areas of risk.

Background

The Hill Family Trust (the Trust) was established in 2002 by Mr Hill. Upon his death in 2009, his two daughters, Mrs Porter and Mrs Staley succeeded him as the Appointors of the Trust. The Corporate Trustee of the Trust was Hill Family Holdings Pty Ltd with Shirley as the sole director and shareholder. On 30 October 2013, Shirley appointed Mrs Porter as co-director of the Corporate Trustee. Further, on 22 July 2019, Mrs Porter also appointed her daughter, Ms Mitchelmore as a director of the Corporate Trustee.

Mrs Porter died on 31 December 2019 leaving Mrs Staley as the sole Appointor of the Hill Family Trust. Shirley died on 29 September 2022 leaving Ms Mitchelmore as the sole director of the Corporate Trustee.

As the sole director of the Corporate Trustee, Ms Mitchelmore exercised the power found in clause 14 of the Trust Deed to remove Mrs Staley as Appointor of the Trust unbeknownst to Mrs Staley and appointed her father, Mr Porter as the new Appointor of the Trust through a Deed of Variation. Relevantly Clause 14 of the Trust Deed provided as follows (our emphasis):

“14.01 The Trustee may revoke, add to, release, delete, or vary all or any of the trusts, powers or provisions declared or included in this Deed or any trusts, powers or provisions declared by or included in any revocation, addition, release, deletion or variation made to this Deed and may at the same time declare or include any new or other trusts, powers or provisions concerning the Fund PROVIDED THAT the Trustee must not exercise its powers under this clause so as to confer upon the Settlor any beneficial interests in any part of the Fund nor in the income from the Fund or in a way which infringes the law against perpetuities.

14.02 The powers of variation under clause 14.01 may be exercised by Deed, written memorandum or any other method permitted under this Deed.

14.03 The powers of the Trustee under clause 14.01 include the power to appoint or remove beneficiaries.

14.04 Subject to clause 27.01, but otherwise despite anything to the contrary in the Deed, the Appointor may at any time prior to the perpetuity date appoint additional beneficiaries by notice in writing to the Trustee or in the manner prescribed in clause 23.01.”

Clause 2 of the Deed of Variation states as follows:

With effect on and from the Effective Date, the Trustee varies the Trust Deed by inserting the following new clause after clause 22.03:

‘22.04 Special Removal of Appointor

(a)         This clause 22.04 only applies where Kerin Anne Staley is the Appointor.

(b)         The Trustee may in in () its absolute discretion remove Kerin Anne Staley as the Appointor, provided that the Trustee nominates a person (other than the Trustee) to become the replacement Appointor.22

On 19 June 2024, Mrs Staley purported as Appointor to remove the Corporate Trustee and appoint Staley Management Pty Ltd as the new corporate trustee which was at a date after her removal as Appointor.

On learning of her removal as Appointor, Mrs Staley sought declaratory and auxiliary relief against the Corporate Trustee.

Issue

The Appellant, Mrs Staley, sought relief on two grounds:

  1. Clause 14.01 ought not be interpreted so as to allow an amendment to the Trust Deed as it would alter the “substratum” of the Trust or “have the potential to do so”; and
  2. The power conferred on the Trustee by Clause 14.01 is limited in its scope by other provisions in the Trust Deed.

Decision

Issue 1 – Substratum of the Trust

It was submitted that the supremacy of the Appointor, as is often the case, formed an element of the substratum of the Trust, and its removal by a Trustee altered that substratum. The Court referred to the case of Mercanti v Mercanti [2016] WASCA 206 finding that the notion of an alteration to the substratum of the trust is grounded in the equitable doctrine of fraud on a power.

Hely J said that the authorities which suggest that a power to vary a trust deed may be held not to extend to a variation which would ‘alter the substratum of the trust’ may be ‘no more than an application of the equitable doctrine of fraud on the power’. His Honour’s view is, in my respectful opinion, correct, having regard to the decisions of the High Court in Byrnes40 and Montevento, which have held that the rules applicable to the construction of contracts apply also to trusts, and to the decision of the High Court in Bargwanna, in other words, the notion of an alteration to the substratum of the trust is not an aspect of the rules applicable to the construction of a trust deed but is, rather, an application of the equitable doctrine of fraud on a power.”

The Court also referred to the case of Re EM McPherson Settlement [2024] VSC 744 finding that whether the exercise of a power would destroy the substratum of a trust engages the same considerations as the application of the equitable doctrine of fraud. The primary consideration here would be whether the changes to the trust would be so significant that the arrangement cannot be regarded as a variation, but as a resettlement of the trust.

There were however two primary issues that were fatal to the Appellant’s case. The first was that there was a difficulty that the exercise of Clause 14.01 had altered the substratum of the Trust. It was not alleged that the execution of the Deed of Variation was a fraud on the Trustee’s power to amend under Clause 14.01 or akin to a fraud. Secondly, the Appellant had failed to show that the substratum of the Trust included the “supremacy of the Appointor’s role”. It followed that while the office of Appointor formed an integral part of the Trust that does not mean that the supremacy of the Appointor’s role was also integral to the substratum of the Trust. It is noted the Deed of Variation did not abolish the role of Appointor, it merely replaced them.

Issue 2 – Interpretation of the Trust

The Appellants also submitted that the power in Clause 14.01 was limited in its scope by other provisions in the Trust Deed through implied terms. They argued that the power to remove the Appointor was provided for in clause 22 of the Trust Deed which provided for a comprehensive regime for appointment to, tenure of, and resignation from office as Appointor. The Court found that they were unable to discern within clause 22 an implied exclusion from clause 14.01 of a power to vary the provisions of the Trust Deed.

The Appellant argued at [54] that the Trustee had power under clause 14.03 to remove certain beneficiaries and the Appointor had power under clause 14.04 to reappoint those same persons, this necessitated a “circuit-breaker” implied into the Deed such that the Appointor had supremacy over the Trustee.

The Court rejected the Appellant’s argument finding that both the Appointor and Trustee’s power under the Trust Deed were regulated by duties imposed on them by equity. If those duties were transgressed, it would be the Court that acts as the “circuit-breaker”. ‘

As such, the Appeal was dismissed.

Takeaway

It is widely agreed that the Trustee and Appointor hold important positions of power in relation to discretionary trusts. However this case emphasises the importance of how the powers of the Appointor and Trustee may be exercised in accordance with how the particular terms of the trust deed are framed.

In this case, the Trustee was able to successfully remove the Appointor because the wording in Clause 14.01 was unintentionally wide. As such, this case highlights the importance of properly constructing your trust deed to avoid unintended consequences such as this. The powers exercised under a Trust are strictly regulated by how the deed is constructed and as such, a thorough review of your trust deed to identify key areas of risks and to remedy risks is recommended.

Should you wish to discuss any of the topics raised above, please contact Anthony Pointon or Andrew Pointon of our Wills and Estates Team.

The Future of Private Ancillary Funds: A Shift toward “Giving Funds”

Private Ancillary Funds as we know them, may soon be a thing of the past. The Australian government has released a consultation paper with recommendations to reform the operation of both Public and Private Ancillary Funds. The new recommendations embrace a suite of changes which aim to improve support provided to charities. One of the most notable proposals is a rebranding of these structures as “Giving Funds”, to better reflect their core purpose which is giving to Deductible Gift Recipients (ie charities which have their own deductible gift recipient status).

Key Recommendations

The Productivity Commission has recommended the following reforms which are canvassed in the consultation paper:

  1. Aligning and increasing the minimum annual distribution rate for both public and private funds;
  2. Introducing distribution smoothing, allowing funds to average their annual distribution requirement over a three-year period; and
  3. Renaming ancillary funds in tax law to “Giving Funds” to reflect their philanthropic function.

Principles for Setting the Distribution Rate

To guide the determination of an appropriate minimum annual distribution rate, the Productivity Commission outlined three key principles:

  1. Charitable Purpose First
    Giving funds should prioritise delivering benefits to charities, not just preserving or growing their investments.
  2. Perpetuity Is Not Guaranteed
    While long-term sustainability is important, funds should not expect to exist indefinitely without further contributions. At the same time, distribution rates must not be so high that they force trustees into risky investment strategies.
  3. Meeting the Funding Needs of DGRs
    Distribution rates should align with both the immediate and future needs of DGRs.

The current position is that Public Ancillary Funds are required to distribute 4% of their net assets each year whilst Private Ancillary Funds are required to distribute 5% of their net assets. Although no final rate has been set, the Productivity Commission has suggested a range of 5% to 8% per annum. The government broadly supports this range as this undoubtedly benefits the DGRs, however there is a risk that a higher rate could discourage the establishment of new funds. Further there are concerns that those who are discouraged from creating a giving fund will not follow through with making an equivalent donation to a DGR.

To balance these competing considerations, the government has confirmed that the increase to the minimum distribution rate will be subject to a five year transition period from the date of commencement. This delay is intended to give existing funds sufficient time to adjust their investment strategies accordingly.

The proposed shift from Ancillary Funds to Giving Funds is more than a simple rebrand, it represents a fundamental realignment in how philanthropic structures are regulated and assessed. The aim is to ensure that tax-advantaged giving goes beyond a minimum compliance mindset and instead promotes generous, impactful, and timely support for Australian charities.

The consultation period has closed, however we will keep clients appraised of further implementation by the Treasury of the proposed reforms. If you would like to learn more about PAFs, please refer to our previous article titled “Private Ancillary Funds” [HERE].

If you require any assistance in relation to the establishment of Private Ancillary Funds, Public Ancillary Funds or other not-for-profit entities then please feel free to contact Anthony Pointon, Michael Bishop or Andrew Pointon of our office

Pointon Partners Seminar: Discretionary trusts now not so discretionary Landmark Victoria Court of Appeal case

Please join us where our Partner Michael Bishop and Senior Lawyer Jess Tomlinson discuss the case Owies v JJ Nominees Pty ltd [2022] VSCA 142 which dealt with:

Our firm previously presented a webinar on this case in September 2022, but given the importance of the case in the context of end of year planning for family trusts we are re-presenting it by way of an in person seminar.

This is an important case for any family which has a discretionary trust and for advisors of such trusts.

Date: Wednesday 7 June 2023
Time: 12:30pm – 1:30pm
Location: Pointon Partners Offices – Level 14, 565 Bourke Street, Melbourne, Victoria, 3000
Lunch will be provided

Please RSVP by Monday 29 May 2023 to Lisa Ograk of Pointon Partners by clicking RSVP

Estate Planning in a Digital World

In this highly digital world in which we live, the use of digital assets and records has become part of our way of life, and their importance in business and our personal lives has increased.  However, have you ever thought about what happens to these digital assets and records when you pass away or if you become legally incapable of making decisions for yourself? As part of your estate planning, and drafting of your Will and other testamentary documents such as Powers of Attorney, it is important to consider your digital assets and records, as well as any other assets you own, and their treatment upon your death or legal incapacity.

Due to the ongoing and continuous development of digital technology, the definition of what constitutes a ‘digital asset’ or ‘digital record’ is constantly evolving.  A New South Wales (NSW) Law Reform Commission Report (“Report”) on “Access to digital records upon death or incapacity”, which was tabled by the NSW Parliament on 5 March 2020, refers to both “digital assets” and “digital records”, and notes that:

If a person holds digital assets and records, then it is likely that an authorised person such as an executor appointed under their Will to administer their estate or affairs in the event of their death or a person appointed under a Power of Attorney in the case of their legal incapacity, may need access to such digital assets and/or records.  The procedure for accessing these digital assets and/or records however, varies, and can depend on the type of digital asset and/or record, the custodian responsible for them, the terms of applicable agreements with or policies of third parties, confidentiality requirements, transfer prohibitions, security and password protocols, applicable laws, relevant country, and so on.  It is also important to note that some digital assets and digital records may cease or terminate from the moment a user passes away.

For instance, the terms and conditions of use issued by social media account organisations differ and upon the death of a user actions taken in respect of a deceased user’s account can include:

Many digital assets are also password protected and therefore, in order to enable an authorised person to access your digital assets it is important to ensure passwords are kept up to date and stored securely.  Relevant information may also be provided with your Will or other testamentary documents.

Certain countries around the world have now implemented schemes or laws dealing with issues associated with access to a deceased or incapacitated person’s digital records.  For instance, the Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act 2015 in the United States of America, and the Uniform Access to Digital Assets by Fiduciaries Act 2016 in Canada.  In Australia, a nationally consistent scheme regulating access to a deceased or incapacitated person’s digital records was recommended by the Report but has not yet been implemented[5].

If you need assistance with the above or have any queries, then please do not hesitate to contact Felicity Cara-Carson, Michael Bishop or Tony Pointon of Pointon Partners on (03) 9614 7707.

[1] New South Wales Law Reform Commission Report 147, “Access to digital records upon death or incapacity”,

December 2019, para 1.15, p 3.

[2] Ibid.

[3] New South Wales Law Reform Commission Report 147, “Access to digital records upon death or incapacity”,

December 2019, para 1.14, p. 3.

[4] Ibid.

[5] New South Wales Law Reform Commission Report 147, “Access to digital records upon death or incapacity”,

December 2019, para 6.55- 6.69, p 81-83.

Estate Planning – Where the Will is not enough

When we are approached by a client to draft a will, they are often surprised by the number of questions that we ask them that help us determine what matters they will need to consider beyond the drafting of their will.

We set out below a list of issues that we consider our clients should consider beyond the will:

Asset type/control aspect Person assuming control or ownership Source of entitlement
Assets held by joint tenants (as opposed to tenants in common) Surviving joint tenants The common law ‘rule of survivorship’
Superannuation entitlements (under a binding nomination) Member’s nominated dependants Valid binding nomination created in accordance with trust deed
Superannuation entitlements (no binding nomination) Member’s dependants selected by the fund’s trustee Trust deed, trustee discretion or terms of pension
Assets held by a discretionary trust Appointor/ trustee’s legal personal representative or nominee may assume control, depending on the terms of the trust deed Trust deed or relevant Trusts Act
Assets held by a unit trust Assumption of control depends on the terms of the trust deed but in most cases the unit holders will hold the power of appointment Ultimate benefit in trust regulated by trust deed and unit holdings
Private company Surviving directors retain control. Additional directors may be appointed by shareholders. Existing shareholders retain ownership Constitution, shareholders agreement (shareholder’s will may be relevant) or Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Loan to company or trust Lender or legal personal representative of lender Loan agreement may override will
Business interests Surviving business owners/ remaining trustees of a trading trust Business succession agreement or trust deed
Life insurance Policy owner or nominated beneficiary Insurance policy

Please note that this is not a complete list and a full discussion of matters such as current superannuation arrangements, reversionary pensions if any and life insurance beneficiaries is of benefit.

In addition to the above issues, we require our clients to consider many other matters when determining their estate planning. This includes whether the creation of testator trusts are appropriate and where so, the type and purpose of the testator trust.

For example there are:

The importance of the creation of effective powers of attorney both financial and medical, cannot be underestimated and a full discussion of their creation is necessary.

An understanding of the assets that the client have in their possession or under their control is of vital importance to determining the approach. This includes both, understanding the location of the assets and also, in some instances, the nature of the assets whether it be physical, digital or intellectual property.

The clients with international assets, of which there are many due to the multicultural society that we live in, often require consideration of additional estate planning in countries other than Australia. This is best fully understood by the client and the relevant estate planning professionals who understand the nuances surrounding these circumstances.

In circumstances where there are multi-generational family assets, it is also worth considering as part of the Estate Planning exercise, a family arrangement agreement.

Tony Pointon is a member of the Society of Trustees and Executor Professionals (‘STEP’), which is an organisation that internationally recognises professionals in this area. He is also a specialist tax advisor and a Chartered Tax Advisor. He is further the former chairman and executive committee member of LAWorld, and has affiliated member firms in 55 countries.

Tony Pointon leads a team of lawyers within Pointon Partners that have significant experience and expertise in this area of estate planning, and disputes.

If you wish to discuss estate planning or are experiencing a current dispute, please do not hesitate to contact us.

Personal Law Webinar- Discretionary trusts now not so discretionary – Landmark Victoria Court of Appeal case

Please join us for our personal law webinar where our Partner Michael Bishop and Senior Lawyer Jess Tomlinson discuss the recent case Owies v JJ Nominees Pty ltd [2022] VSCA 142 which dealt with:

This is an important case for any family which has a discretionary trust and for advisors of such trusts.

Date: Thursday, 15 September 2022
Time: 12.30pm – 1.30pm
Location: via Zoom – link will be provided to attendees prior to webinar

Please RSVP by clicking on  Register Now.

Testamentary Trust – What is it and should you use one as part of your succession plan

Estate and succession planning can be a crucial consideration at varying stages of your life as it plays an important role when you are starting a family, a business or where your personal, family or financial circumstances change.

As you start thinking about protecting your wealth and provide for the ones you most care about, it is always helpful to plan through the lens of asset protection and tax consequences in the hands of the beneficiaries of your estate.

Proper and careful estate planning can help reduce capital gains tax, stamp duty and other taxes that may arise upon distribution of your estate to your beneficiaries and also protect your assets from creditors, predators and the like.

One of the most powerful modern estate planning strategy is the use of a testamentary trust in your Will.

What is a testamentary trust?

Simply put, a testamentary trust is a trust established under the terms of a Will. Testamentary trusts commonly take the form of a discretionary trust, however, unlike inter vivos discretionary trusts – which are used to transfer assets and gifts during one’s lifetime, testamentary trusts are activated only upon the passing of the Will-maker.

There are different types of testamentary trusts that can be established and each primary/principal beneficiary under your Will can have a testamentary trust that is most suitable to the circumstances of that particular beneficiary.

Some common types of testamentary trusts established under a Will are as follows:

1. Beneficiary controlled testamentary trust

As the name suggests, the beneficiary of a beneficiary controlled testamentary trust is provided with an option to use a discretionary trust structure that he or she controls to receive his or her inheritance. This structure is commonly used as a substitute for an outright gift by making use of discretionary trust structure to enhance asset protection and tax liability.

2. Capital reserved testamentary trust

Under this structure, executors control the trust as opposed to the beneficiary and is commonly used to protect the capital assets in the estate (such as the family home) for an intended beneficiary who is vulnerable because of age or capacity.

3. Protective testamentary trust

Protective trusts are commonly established for vulnerable family members (such as beneficiaries suffering from a disability), and can be an ‘all needs protective trust’ and/or a ‘special disability trust’ depending on the specific requirements and circumstances of the vulnerable beneficiary.

Key benefits of testamentary trusts

One of the key benefits of a testamentary trust structure as opposed to an outright gift under your Will is that it offers the beneficiaries the opportunity to allocate (or split) the income they receive from the inherited assets amongst the wide range of beneficiaries such as their spouse, children, relatives and charities.  This allows the beneficiary to manage his or her tax affairs effectively amongst the family members and related entities similarly to an inter vivos discretionary trust.

Another advantage of using a testamentary trust is that minor beneficiaries under a testamentary trust are taxed in their own hands as adult marginal tax rates unlike an inter vivos discretionary trust, where such distributions are considered ‘unearned income’ for minors and distributions above a nominal reduced tax-free threshold are taxed at penalty rates.

Inheritance held in testamentary trusts are considered ‘trust assets’ and as such provides certain asset protection to the beneficiaries, in particular, assets held in the testamentary trusts are protected from assets being lost through bankruptcy of the beneficiary. Testamentary trusts also offer an enhanced, but not absolute, level of family law asset protection for a primary beneficiary. While a testamentary trust will normally be considered a resource of the primary beneficiary for family law purposes, it is rare for an Australian Family Court to order the division of a testamentary trust between the parties to a domestic relationship.

When should a testamentary trust be used?

A testamentary trust is best used where the testator wants to create a structure which will give each member of the family an option of entering into a trust structure, which can provide the beneficiaries a means to reduce the impact of tax, and to gain asset protection specific to their circumstances.

A testamentary trust may not the best strategy if there are no family interests to protect, for instance where the whole estate is to go to a charity.

If you would like to discuss whether a testamentary trust structure is appropriate for you, then please feel free to contact Michael Bishop or Peter Azam of Pointon Partners.

Personal Law Webinar

On 14 July 2021, members of our Personal Law team presented a webinar on the following topics:

– Medical and Financial Decisions – Planning for who makes the Decision when you can’t.
– The Role of an Executor – What you should know.

The webinar was recorded, should you want to watch please click on the link below:

Topic: Personal Law Webinar
Start Time : Jul 14, 2021 12:14 PM

Meeting Recording:
https://us06web.zoom.us/rec/share/KJw2N2XrBfIhJA4hIoIWbewx6pR09EED0R100xozd3f-CDOdSF8sHWvkdYATdbgq.YrmjuWHGaTSM6xTQ

Access Passcode: g1K2qoL!

Please note that if accessing the above link on a computer, please manually type the passcode rather then copy and paste.