Pointon Partners

The Family Farm – When is the transfer of a farm to a relative duty free?

A farm is a significant asset and the value of the associated business is dependent upon how that business is operated by you now, and later, by your children and their children after them.

The farm may constitute the majority of your family wealth and you may have difficulty passing on  equal interests to your children, or alternatively you may wish to create a level of separation between yourself and your farm for legal or asset management purposes.

Whether for succession planning or asset structuring, there are a number of reasons why you may want to transfer your farm out of your own name or the entity operating the farming business and to a relative or a family trust. It is possible for such a transfer to be duty free.

Section 56 of the Duties Act 2000 (Vic) provides that the transfer of a farm to a relative or a family trust can be exempt from stamp duty where:

  1. The land must be used for primary production (which includes the cultivation of produce, the maintenance of animals or poultry, the keeping of bees or fishing for commercial purposes);
  1. The transferor is either a natural person, a company in which all shares are owned by natural persons who are relatives or a trustee of a trust the beneficiaries of which are relatives; and
  1. The transferee is a relative of the transferor or is the trustee of a trust, the beneficiaries of which are limited to relatives of the transferor and the terms of which restrict the distribution of the primary production land.

Accordingly, it is possible to transfer your farm into a trust for yourself and for your children and not have to split up or give fixed interests in the farm.

This can assist with addressing the risk to the farm as an asset owned by an operational entity as well as solve the issues with planning for the future of the farm and your family.

It is crucial that all requirements for the exemption are satisfied prior to transferring the farm, as a failure to meet even one requirement can result in the imposition of stamp duty on the transfer.

Pointon Partners have successfully obtained exemptions to stamp duty for the transfer of farms to family trusts and have prepared trust deeds that satisfy the statutory requirements of the Duties Act 2000 (Vic).

Please contact Tony Pointon, Amelita Hensman or Daniel Rathner if you have any questions about transferring your farm to a relative or into a family trust or any other aspect of this article.

ATO response to High Court decision in Bywater

In a previous article we discussed the High Court of Australia decision in Bywater & Ors v FC of T: see https://pointonpartners.com.au/australian-tax-residence-for-companies-revisited-by-high-court-after-43-years/

Subsequent to the High Court decision, the ATO withdrew its previous ruling TR 2004/15, and issued a new draft ruling TR 2018/D3, and an exposure draft Practical Compliance Guideline (PCG).

After rejecting most criticisms of TR 2018/D3, the ATO has issued it in final form as TR 2018/5, and issued a draft PCG 2018/D3.

The time for submissions on PCG 2018/D3 have now closed, so it remains to be seen whether any of the criticism of it, results in any material change.

The problem with TR 2018/5 is it reverses 14 years of accepting that the central management & control (CM&C) test will only make a foreign company a tax resident of Australia if the company actually physically carries on business in Australia, in favour of the approach that the earlier High Court decision in Malayan Shipping must be interpreted as meaning that if CM&C is in Australia, that is an act of carrying on business in Australia. Before the decision in Bywater, we had written about CM&C, see https://pointonpartners.com.au/tax-residence-of-individuals-companies/

This change causes far more problems for Australian owned multinationals, rather than foreign owned. This is because an Australian owned multinational is far more likely to have some Australian directors or group policies that make it more likely that the Australian parent’s views for its foreign subsidiary will be followed.

Whereas the earlier TR 2004/15 had examples to highlight the ATO approach to the CM&C issue, TR 2018/5 does not, but relies on PCG 2018/D3 to set out examples of the application of TR 2018/5.

The problem caused by the ATO change of heart are manifest in PCG 2018/D3, especially in relation to the presence of Australian directors on the board, and the use of electronic communication to hold board meetings.

As the Joint Professional Bodies submission dated 25 July 2018 said:

“Example 13 in the Draft PCG provides perhaps one of the most critical safe harbours in terms of practical guidance. However, the conclusion in paragraph 87 that the central management and control of the company is exercised to a “substantial degree in Australia” relies on, in part, that two of the four directors are located in Australia. The Joint Bodies suggest that a more useful example (or additional example) may be where only one of the four directors, all participating equally, are located in Australia. Having a minority of Australian directors on the board of a foreign company is common and so it would be useful to have clear guidance that such an arrangement will not result in central management and control being exercised to a substantial degree in Australia.  Such an example would also provide clear guidance that it is not necessary that the single Australian director is required to physically attend board meetings overseas…

“Our concern is that the Commissioner’s approach to the different forms of communication as articulated in the Draft PCG will engender more awkward Australian participation in relation to foreign subsidiaries of Australian companies. Distinguishing between video conference, circular resolutions, teleconference and physical presence will tend to create inefficiency and artificiality. It may promote situations where an Australian resident director is required to physically travel to the foreign board meeting to avoid central management and control being at least partly in Australia. This raises questions as to whether the Australian resident director might travel to the nearest country outside Australia (for example, Singapore or New Zealand) and participate in the directors’ meeting by video conference or teleconference from that jurisdiction. It might also lead to boards being constituted only with foreign resident directors, therefore making the corporate governance of offshore subsidiaries of Australian companies far more cumbersome. Requiring a minority Australian resident director, or indeed, a number of Australian resident directors to travel overseas to attend board meetings to avoid having a substantial degree of central management and control in Australia is not consistent with a desire to limit ‘red tape’ and to promote business efficiency.”

If PCG 2018/D3 is not amended, there is likely to be a push to have the law changed, perhaps along the lines of the 2003 Board of Taxation suggestion, that only Australian incorporated companies be treated as Australian tax residents. This would be consistent with the US approach, although this is uncommon internationally. Coincidentally, we have recently written about the push to change the tests for tax residence of individuals: https://pointonpartners.com.au/federal-court-decision-highlights-the-urgent-need-for-change-to-income-tax-residency-rules-for-individuals/

Please contact Anthony Pointon if you wish to discuss.

Federal Court decision highlights the urgent need for change to income tax residency rules for individuals

In the recent decision of the Federal Court in Harding v Commissioner of Taxation [2018] FCA 837, it was found that Mr Harding, an Australian citizen who lived and worked abroad for various periods, but focusing on March 2009 to February 2015, was a resident of Australia under the expanded definition of resident in s 6 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (ITAA 36), in the year under consideration (2011).

Subsequent to the handing down of the decision in June 2018, the Government released the Board of Taxation’s (BOT) self-initiated review into the topic, which they were given in August 2017.

The case provides a shining example of why the rules on tax residency for individuals in Australia need to change, as the BOT has recommended.

Background

Mr Harding, an aircraft engineer, lived with his first wife for about 7 years in Saudi Arabia while working for BAE Systems. Mr Harding and his wife had 2 children during this period.

Due to escalating geo-political instability across Saudi Arabia and the region, Mr and Mrs Harding relocated to Australia, where they built a house and had a third child.

Mr Harding spent three years in Australia but, dissatisfied with his reduced salary and, as a result, more modest lifestyle, returned to the Middle East in March 2009 to live in Bahrain, leaving his family behind in Australia. While living in Bahrain, Mr Harding continued to commute daily to work in Saudi Arabia, across the causeway.

Mr Harding made return trips to Australia each year to visit his family, including one trip of 91 days where he tried, unsuccessfully, to persuade his wife to re-join him overseas. They subsequently separated and divorced. He then formed a relationship with a Ms Gonzales in Bahrain, but when he went to work in Oman in 2014, she would not go, and subsequently he married another woman who he met in Oman.

In December 2015, the Commissioner of Taxation issued Mr Harding a Notice of Amended Assessment, stating that he was a resident of Australia and therefore required to pay tax on his overseas sourced income. Mr Harding’s objection to the Amended Assessment was disallowed in an Objection Decision made by the Commissioner in 2017, and the matter then came before Justice Derrington of the Federal Court.

Decision

“Ordinary Concepts test”

Justice Derrington held that Mr Harding did not reside in Australia under the “Ordinary Concepts test” in the relevant income year.

While Justice Derrington agreed with the Commissioner that there were many factors that indicated Mr Harding was a resident of Australia under this test, including the fact that he made return trips to Australia to visit his family, his financial affairs remained substantially located in Australia, including his continued ownership of the family home, and he stated on passenger cards that he was an “Australian resident departing temporarily”, he was satisfied that on balance, the evidence established that Mr Harding’s actual intention was to permanently or at least indefinitely leave Australia and resume living and working in the Middle East.

Mr Harding was therefore not a resident of Australia based on the “Ordinary Concepts test”.

“Domicile test”

Ultimately, however, Justice Derrington found that Mr Harding was a resident of Australia. This was based on the expanded definition of “resident” in s 6(1)(a)(i) of the ITAA 36 (the “Domicile test), which provides that a person is a resident if their domicile is in Australia, unless the Commissioner is satisfied that the person’s “permanent place of abode” is outside Australia.

Note that the taxpayer conceded that his domicile was in Australia. His evidence was that he did not intend to stay indefinitely in any particular Middle Eastern country and that ultimately he may return to Australia[1]. Therefore, the Court was only required to consider the “permanent place of abode” limb of the “Domicile test”.

After deliberating extensively on the proper construction of the test[2], Derrington J decided that the test is concerned with the “enduring quality” of the person’s living arrangements in a foreign country.

In this case, Derrington J paid special consideration to Mr Harding’s living arrangements, including the fact that Mr Harding lived in a serviced apartment in Bahrain, but was able to quickly relocate to one of the two other apartments leased from the same landlord in the building on a number of occasions, and appeared not to use his Bahrain residence as an address for important correspondence. These types of factors indicated, according to the Judge, that Mr Harding’s accommodation was of a temporary nature, and lacked many of the accoutrements that demonstrate a permanent abode.

Accordingly, the Court held that Mr Harding failed the “permanent place of abode” limb of the “Domicile test”.

This result is rather odd after the finding that he had a lease which governed his accommodation throughout the period[1]. It also seems to have made a value judgement on Mr Harding’s lifestyle.

Our view

The decision in Harding is a prime example of why the law on tax residency of individuals needs to change in Australia. It illustrates how uncertain the law is in this area, with its overlapping, broad multi-tiered tests, as acknowledged by Derrington J himself, stating that, as with the “Ordinary Concepts test”, the application of the “Domicile test” “is far from easy or straightforward”, “lacks precision in a number of respects”, and “reasonable persons may differ as to the correct interpretation”.

The decision in this case, with respect, places undue stress on the nature of an individual’s living arrangements, rather than his intention to remain abroad indefinitely, and the fact of him being in Bahrain for 6 years. This in our view, places too high a hurdle for individuals living or moving abroad to obtain non-resident status.

The BOT concluded that the existing residency rules for individuals are “no longer appropriate”, and suggests separate rules for outbound and inbound residence, with the issue usually determined by “bright line” day count tests. For example, an outbound person going overseas to work full time will be a non-resident if they spend less than 31 days working, or 61 days total in Australia in a year of income, and for inbound, a person who has not previously been a resident, will not become a resident if they spend less than 46 days in Australia in a year of income. Such bright line tests are to be welcomed, however, it remains to be seen what changes, if any, will be made by the Government after it considers the Board’s further recommendations. The Minister in charge said she welcomed the report, but has asked the Board to consult further on key recommendations “before the Government takes any position on these matters”.

Please contact Tony Pointon if you wish to discuss.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

[1] See ¶23 of the decision. Such a finding will be important in a case that invokes the “tie-breaker” of a double tax agreement, as the OECD commentary on the model DTA says that a “permanent home” can even be a “rented room”, but not if presence there is of a transitory nature.

[1] Whilst His Honour did not say so, Mr Harding would not have adopted a domicile of choice outside Australia, as Buckley LJ said in IRC v Bullock [1997] STC 409 at 415: “In my judgment the true test is whether he intends to make his home in the new country until the end of his days unless and until something happens to make him change his mind. … the question was whether the person whose domicile was in question had “determined” to make, and had in fact made, the alleged domicile of choice “his home with the intention of establishing himself and his family there and ending his days in that country.” (underlining added). A domicile of origin is not lost easily, compared to a change of residency, and is more often a once in a lifetime event, whereas residency may change several times in a lifetime. Many Australian expats might intend, and in fact do, return to Australia in retirement after their international career ends. The ability to adopt a domicile of choice in another country invariably must be tested against whether it would in fact be practically possible for a foreigner to live for the rest of their life in, for example, a Middle Eastern country that will only allow them to stay to work.

[2] Referring to the concept of “permanent” in the test of domicile as “incongruous” on the ordinary meaning of the word in the expression “permanent place of abode”, but without discussing the many UK cases on domicile, which reveal HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) dogged testing of assertions by UK Expats, that they have adopted a domicile of choice outside the UK, to avoid UK inheritance tax.

BEPS MLI measure in the Australian Parliament

A Bill to enact OECD BEPS Measure 15 was introduced into the House on 28 March 2018, with the government’s hope that it will pass the Parliament before the end of the financial year on 30 June 2018. If enacted, this will make Australia one of the first signatories to implement Measure 15.

Measure 15, the Multilateral Instrument (MLI – signed by Australia and 67 other countries on 7 June 2017), will obtain the force of law in Australia by amendment to the Tax Agreements Act by Treasury Laws Amendment (OECD Multilateral Instrument) Bill 2018 with earliest likely effect from 1 January 2019.

The MLI will have the effect that where parties to a bilateral double tax agreement (DTA) were both signatories to the MLI, and had both elected to adopt the same amendments to their DTAs under the MLI, the bilateral DTA would not need to be individually renegotiated. This approach has the opportunity of allowing the OECD BEPS recommendations to be implemented on a world-wide basis in a relatively short period of time, compared to individual renegotiation of bilateral DTAs.

The MLI had some 16 main features which could be elected to be adopted. Note that Australia’s recent DTA with Germany had already adopted many of the BEPS recommendations for DTA change.

Of particular note is that the OECD BEPs Project ultimately did not deal with E-Commerce separately from other commerce.

Eight DTA Partners Not Signatories

As of 5 June 2018, eight countries with which Australia has DTA’s which have decided not to become signatories to the MLI: the US, Philippines, Thailand, Vietnam, Taiwan, Sri Lanka, PNG and Kiribati. It goes without saying that the US decision not to become a signatory to the MLI is very significant. However, from Australia’s perspective bearing in mind the propensity to outbound treaty-shop through Malaysia, Malaysia’s late decision to sign the Convention (on 24 January 2018) is also quite significant. Malaysia is of interest due to its significant DTA network, its territorial system of taxation, and the application of the Labuan (Malaysia) IBFC under all but around 10 of its DTAs. It may become more utilized if the recent change in the Malaysia government reduces the sovereign risk that had become apparent under the former Prime Minister.

Four DTA Partners didn’t nominate Australia as a CTA

Of Australia’s 43 DTAs, another four countries have chosen not to nominate their DTA with Australia as a “Covered Tax Agreement”, which has the effect that like the nine countries that have not signed the MLI at all, Australia’s DTAs with Austria, Korea, Sweden and Switzerland are also unaffected by the MLI.

Australia hasn’t Adopted Articles 10 or 12

Australia has decided not to adopt the MLI Article 10 – “Anti-abuse rule for permanent establishment situated in third jurisdictions”, and also chosen not to adopt Article 12 – “Artificial avoidance of permanent establishment through commissionaire arrangements and similar strategies”.

Whilst planning using permanent establishments (PEs) in third jurisdictions has been limited in the Australian context, there are some structures where an Australian resident company has traded through a Swiss or Singapore branch. However, such strategies were famous elsewhere, such has the Swiss finance branch of a Dutch company. What is also significant to notice about Article 10 of the MLI is, if it had been applied by both Malaysia and Singapore (well known “mid-shore” rather than “offshore” jurisdictions), it would have impacted upon the Labuan, Malaysia branch of a Singapore company, which is of some interest to Australian multinationals with third country trading income.

Australia’s decision not to adopt Article 12 is highly significant. Had it done so and Australia’s DTA partner also done so, then Australia would have been entitled to tax more income with an Australian source deemed to be associated with a PE in Australia than would currently have been possible, but Australia’s DTA partners would have been able to do the same. That is, tax Australian resident companies on profits sourced in their countries which to date have not been taxable due to their being no PE in the foreign DTA partner. It would appear that Australia has not adopted Article 12 as the increased foreign taxation of Australian resident companies would have correspondingly reduced Australia’s tax on such companies’ income, as Australia would need to give a foreign tax offset for any foreign taxes paid. That is, the adoption of Article 12 by Australia and its treaty partners would have potentially created a net loss of tax to Australia.

However, Australia and Malaysia have both adopted the “Specific Activities Exemption” (Article 13 Option A) which is designed to ensure that the specific activities in DTAs as not constituting a PE, will only continue to be exempt provided they are Preparatory or Auxiliary. Because both countries have adopted the same Option, the provisions of Article 13 Option A will apply between those two countries. Singapore has adopted Article 13 Option B, which also excludes those activities (and unspecified activities unless they are Preparatory or Auxiliary) but as Australia and Singapore have adopted different Options, neither Option will apply between those countries.

US Companies Trading with Australia

As stated above, as the US has not signed the MLI, US companies that do not meet the threshold for being “Significant Global Entities” (SGEs) under the recent amendments to Australia’s general anti-avoidance rule (GAAR – Part IVA, particularly the MAAL), will continue not to pay tax in Australia if under the current bilateral DTA, they did not have a PE. If they are not SGEs, income from trading with Australia through E-Commerce will remain untaxed if there are no other law changes.

Singapore and Malaysia Outbound “Stepping Stones” may Survive

Interestingly for treaty-shopping outbound from Australia, whilst Singapore and Malaysia have both become signatories to the MLI, Singapore has only adopted the mandatory Preamble (Article 6) and “Principal Purpose Test” (Article 7) and Mandatory Binding Arbitration (Article 19). Singapore and Australian have not adopted Articles 10 and 12, and so some “stepping stone” through Singapore is likely to still be available. Whilst the MLI has also has welcomed aspects such as Mandatory Binding Arbitration, which Australia and Singapore have both adopted (but not Malaysia), it would be fair to say that Australia and Singapore’s choices in relation to being signatories to the MLI, will leave Singapore as an outbound “stepping stone” from Australia if there is sufficient substance to the Singapore company’s presence in Singapore.

As Malaysia has adopted Articles 12 & 13 (Option A), it makes the use of Malaysia as a “stepping stone” largely dependent on Malaysia’s DTA partners also adopting Articles 12 & 13 (Option A), although E-Commerce should remain unaffected for electronic downloads of software, and for goods sent directly into the customer’s country rather than being filled from a stock already warehoused in that country.

E-Commerce

Whilst the BEPS Project did not deal separately with E-Commerce (but may be affected by e.g. Article 13), there are moves afoot in the EU (led by France) to introduce turnover taxation on E-Commerce conducted with EU residents. Also, Australian Treasury is expected to shortly deliver an Options Paper on the topic to the Australian government.

If you have any queries about this article, please contact Anthony Pointon on 03 9614 7707.

Musings on 2018 Federal Budget

Image rights for sports people and actors

It is said that the Government will “improve integrity” in the tax system by ensuring from 1 July 2019, high profile individuals are no longer able to take advantage of lower tax rates by licencing their fame or image to another entity.

The Budget papers go on to say that this is currently available. What it does not note is that, the ATO had provided some “safe harbour” to this concept by their release of draft Practical Compliance Guideline PCG 2017/D11.

That draft PCG issued on 1 September 2017 referred to the Supreme Court of Queensland decision in Brisbane Bears-Fitzroy Football Club Ltd, which case dealt with Queensland payroll tax, and that payments for “image rights” received by footballers were wages.

The football club’s appeal from that decision reported at (2017) QCA 233, was dismissed, making it all the more curious that PCG 2017/D11 took the form that it did, and that it is still on the ATO’s website after the Budget.

This Budget announcement therefore seems to be the Government’s reaction to the ATO’s “own goal”, and is reminiscent of the recent problem with introducing the small business company tax rate only for companies carrying on “genuine” trading activities, compared to the now notorious footnote 2 to TR 2018/D2, that the ATO thought that companies generally are incorporated to carry on business, notwithstanding 100 years of case law that this is not necessarily the case.

This announcement is also interesting because, contrary to the liberal attitude portrayed in PCG 2017/D11, the Commissioner withdrew his “guidelines” on taxation of professional practices in December 2017, which continued his campaign to treat professional persons more strictly in relation to income splitting and the like, than non-professional persons (now it seems including sports persons and actors).

Integrity of concessions relating to partnerships

The ATO originally had considerable difficulty explaining why they withdrew the “guidelines” in relation to professional partnerships in December 2017.

The Budget announcement that small business CGT concessions will no longer be available to partners doing Everett Assignments of their interests in partnerships, this now adds a little clarity to one of the mischiefs that they were apparently concerned about.

For a post CGT partnership interest, an assignment of a share of a partnership to a related entity would trigger a CGT liability based on the market value of the partnership interest, and since the Supreme Court of Western Australia decision in Reynolds‘ case (1986 – concerning WA stamp duty, giving a mark valuation of the partnership interest), even though partners may have come and gone without paying for goodwill, the practice of doing Everett Assignments “cooled off”. Interestingly, the Australian High Court decision in Everett (1980) that such assignments are legally effective, did not find favour in either the United Kingdom or New Zealand.

Subsequently, the limitation on the tax deductibility by partnerships of payments to related services trusts took hold (TR 2006/2), the practice of Everett Assignments and claiming small business CGT relief obtained currency. Apparently some partners were making assignments to their family trust with the family trust borrowing money to do so, thus obtaining interest deductions in their trusts, while the proceeds of the assignments were paying out private debt or funding lifestyle.

More recently the ATO has also said the Guidelines were not meant to offer a safe harbour from Part IVA for restructures to come within them. Further they have said that it is necessary to prove that a restructure that moves wealth from a partner in a professional partnership, would need to prove “asset protection” as a motivation, notwithstanding the collapse of Arthur Andersen, or HIH Insurance leaving many professional partnerships uninsured, making asset protection objectively a non-tax reason for the assignment!

The fact that the Budget announcement said that some taxpayers, including large partnerships are inappropriately accessing these concessions, might have something to do with the $6 million net asset test not applying to all of the assets of the partnerships, but rather only to the business assets of the individual partner.

Again, partnerships outside the professions wouldn’t have needed Everett Assignments since there would be no prohibition from introducing non-professionals into the partnership.

Extending director penalty regime to GST

It is said that “what the Lord giveth the Lord taketh away”, and so it is some small relief to directors of companies that fail to pay GST, and who will be made personal liable for the unpaid GST, that as part of the “innovation agenda” of the government, the period of bankruptcy is to be limited to one year from the general three-year limit currently applicable. One wonders how it is likely that to provide more and more exclusions from protection by the corporate veil, will at the same time to stimulate business activity.  More targeted measures such as requiring the purchasers of new residential property to pay the GST direct to the ATO, should have taken some heat out of the issue of lost GST from phoenixing activity.

Introducing new phoenix offences

Whilst no details are available concerning the proposed new offences to target those who conduct or facilitate phoenixing, one must query whether the authorities are using the current powers that they have appropriately, before introducing such new offences. The Banking Royal Commission has recently highlighted issues as to whether ASIC and APRA have appropriately used all of their powers to “crack down” on illegal activities in the financial services sector.  No doubt there will be talk of creating new “offences” to deal with those as well.  The real question that needs to be answered is what laws that we currently have are in fact inadequate.

Clarification of the operation of Div. 7A

The Budget announcement says that the government will ensure that unpaid present entitlements of companies from trust, will come within the scope of Div. 7A.  This measure really does have deep history.  Until 2010, the ATO accepted that an unpaid present entitlement was not within the definition of “debt” owed by a trust to an accumulated profits private company/beneficiary.

When the practice of introducing corporate beneficiaries, in the ATO’s view, got out of hand, they did a “U-turn” on their view (TR 2010/3), but at least as an acknowledgement of making that U-turn, said that they would devote no compliance resources to dealing with UPEs that came into existence before 2009 (PS LA 2010/4).

The reality was that it would have been far preferable for the government to have changed the law back in 2010 instead of what unfolded, which was the introduction of incredibly complex administrative measures to provide some small relief to those adversely affected by the ATO’s U-turn.

Somewhat symptomatically of this government, the measures relating to Div. 7A drawing on a number of recommendations from the Board of Taxation’s post-implementation review of Div. 7A, which were to have applied from 1 July 2018, have also been deferred to a start date 1 July 2019. These measures may force the previously grand-fathered pre 16 Dec 2009 UPEs into the Div. 7A regime, repayable over 10 years from the date of enactment, potentially causing great hardship to taxpayers who had built up large UPEs before 16 Dec 2009.

Deductions to be denied for vacant land

Since the High Court decided Steele’s case in 1999 it has been clear that interest was deductable for a taxpayer who had borrowed money to buy land which was to be developed some time in the future, notwithstanding the development did not actually take place for several years.

The Budget announcement says that deductions will be denied for expenses associated with holding vacant land, and that the measure is to “address concerns that deductions are being improperly claimed as expenses…where the land is not genuinely held for the purpose of earning assessable income”, such measures to take effect from 1 July 2019.

The announcement is also expressed to be warranted on the housing affordability front, because it says that it will reduce tax incentives for land banking, which deny the use of land for housing or other development.

It also says that vacant land will not include land used by the owner to carry on a business, including a business of primary production. So owners who let to sharefarmers, or for agistment may be targets of the measure, as it would be usual practice of land banking urban fringe land, not to simply sit on it.

Whilst the measure says that denied deductions will still be able to form part of the cost base element for CGT purposes, one can only assume that the Government has finally decided to reverse the effect of the High Court’s decision in Steele’s case, without saying so.

Interestingly, for the taxpayer to be claiming deduction for interest on the vacant land, they would have essentially been telegraphing to the Commissioner that the taxpayer was saying that they held the vacant land on revenue account i.e. that it was part of a business, or part of a profit-making undertaking or scheme, which would mean that the profits on ultimate disposal of the land were on revenue account, and therefore not for instance, entitled to a 50% CGT discount.

Whilst details of this measure may make it clearer, the corollary of this measure seems to be that if the interest is going to be denied deductibility, that the profit on disposal of the land will be on capital account, and that the 50% CGT discount will be available?

If you have any queries please contact Anthony Pointon on (03) 9614 7707.

Transfers of land in a partnership in Victoria – Court confirms non dutiable – Refund possibilities if act promptly

The rights of a partner in a partnership have been highlighted  again by the Court of Appeal of Victoria in a judgement handed down in December 2017 (Commissioner of State Revenue v Danvest Pty Ltd BC 201711304).

The case involved one of the partners buying out two other partners. The partnership was based on a unit partnership agreement, which effectively allocates the percentage of ownership between the partners based on the amount of the notional units held.

The court confirmed that the interest of a partner at general law was not a normal  equitable interest in the property of the partnership but a beneficial interest of a special and non-specific kind  relating to an equitable chose in action.

This right or chose in action consists of an equitable right to a proportion of the surplus after the realisation of the assets and payment of the debts and labilities of the partnership. It does not consist of any title to partnership assets prior to dissolution of the partnership.

The immediate effect of this case was to confirm that the State Revenue Office of Victoria has no current right to levy duty on the transfer of equity in a land owning partnership. This is proposed to be changed by legislation on 1 July 2018 by an Amendment to the Duties Act.

However it should also be the same for the entry of partners  in  a land owning partnership and should extend to also partners leaving such a partnership as the law is the same.

Note that this will apply to all partnerships and not just unit partnerships.

If you have been incorrectly assessed on any transfer of land due to changes in the partnership interests and paid duty you may be entitled to a refund of the duty if you act promptly.

We are happy to discuss your rights. Please contact Anthony Pointon if you wish to discuss the contents of this article further.

Vacant Residential Land Tax – Do you need to notify the State Revenue Office?

The lack of housing supply in inner and middle Melbourne has become a major issue for residents and the State Government. In response, the Victorian State Government has sought to free up further housing by introducing a new Vacant Residential Land Tax on residential properties that remain vacant for more than 6 months per calendar year (either continuously or on aggregate).

Under the proposed legislation to take effect from 1 January 2018, you may need to notify the State Revenue Office (‘SRO’) if you own a residential property that has been unoccupied for more than six months in the previous calendar year. If you anticipate that your property will be vacant for more than 6 months, a notification to the SRO needs to be made before the 15 January 2018

The tax will be calculated as 1% of the capital improved value of the residential land, and will apply in addition to any other applicable taxes or surcharges.

Awareness of this new tax is particularly important for:

When and how will the Vacant Residential Land Tax apply?

The tax will apply to residential properties that are unoccupied for more than six months in a calendar year. Residences need to be occupied by either the owner, permitted occupant, or a tenant.

The tax will be geographically restricted to residential land situated in inner and middle Melbourne. A property may only be subject to the Vacant Residential Land Tax if it is located in the following council areas:

Local Council Areas
Banyule Melbourne Glen Eira Port Phillip
Bayside Monash Hobsons Bay Stonnington
Boroondara Moonee Valley Manningham Whitehorse
Darebin Moreland Maribyrnong Yarra

Although the tax will apply from 1 January 2018, it will examine the occupation of residences in the 2017 calendar year. When examining the occupation of residences during the 2017 year, the SRO will be lenient and presume that all land was ‘occupied’ during 1st January 2017 to 30th April 2017. However, any period(s) of vacancy after 30th April 2017 will count.

Exemptions from the Vacant Residential Land Tax

If the property is your principle place of residence, then it will ordinarily be tax exempt as the PPR exemption requires 6 months of owner occupation per year.

However, if your principle place of residence is vacant for more than 6 months, then the PPR tax exemption may cease to apply, in which case both ordinary Land Tax and the Vacant Residential Land Tax will apply.

An exception to this is where PPR properties are taken to be occupied at law under the following circumstances:

When travelling for more than 6 months in a calendar year, it may be necessary to apply to the Commissioner for an exemption under section 56 of the Land Tax Act 2005 (‘LTA’), by asserting that the absence was only temporary in nature and that you are not claiming a PPR exemption in any other state, territory or country.

Further exemptions from the tax may apply in respect of vacant land that is:

Recommended actions:

It is recommended that residential land owners:

Pointon Partners has experience in providing advice on land tax and can assist you in determining whether notification of the SRO needs to occur. Please contact Anthony Pointon or Amelita Hensman of our office.

Small business corporate tax rate: Exposure draft legislation released regarding passive income threshold

In our recent article entitled “Corporate Tax Cuts. What do they mean for you?”, we referred to the relevant minister (Kelly O’Dwyer) questioning the ATO provisional interpretation of when a company would be “carrying on business” for the purpose of the reduction in the small business corporate tax rate.

The Treasury has now released its exposure draft legislation regarding its proposal to limit the small business corporate tax rate to companies that do not exceed a passive income threshold of 80%.

Currently, a company that carries on business and does not exceed the aggregated turnover threshold (being $25 million in FY 2018 and $50 million for FY 2019) is eligible to apply the lower corporate tax rate of 27.5%.

The additional requirement would be that a company’s passive income must not be 80% or more of its assessable income in any financial year, in order to be eligible for the lower rate. Passive income would be exhaustively defined, and includes rent, royalties, capital gains, interest (subject to certain exclusions) and trust or partnership income (to the extent that it consists of passive income).

We note the following about the proposed amendment:

  1. It will apply retrospectively to the start of FY 2017, and therefore may require amendment to returns already lodged on the basis that pure passive investment companies may have thought they were eligible for the lower rate.
  2. A significant capital gain (e.g. as a result of a sale of business) could result in a company failing the 80% passive income test, which would mean that the standard corporate tax rate of 30% would apply to all of the company’s assessable income for that year.
  3. Whilst it may be tempting to direct passive income through an eligible company to obtain the lower corporate tax rate, it may expose assets to insolvency risk, as the company must be conducting a business. Therefore, from an asset protection perspective, the reduced corporate tax rate may not be so attractive.
  4. It is odd that the threshold is defined to be passive income not to exceed 80% as for small business CGT relief it is the other way around i.e. passive assets must not exceed 20%.

The Treasury has completed its consultation process in relation to the exposure draft legislation, and we await introduction of a Bill into Parliament.

If you have any queries, or would like to discuss the above further, please contact us on (03) 9614 7707.

Taxpayers and advisers take note: it will soon be time to pay-out UPEs or convert them to Division 7A complying loans to avoid paying deemed dividends

Background

In Practice Statement 2010/4, the Commissioner set out three safe harbour investment options that taxpayers could avail themselves of to ensure an Unpaid Present Entitlement (UPE) of a company from a trust, did not attract the application of Division 7A. These options involved having the UPE funds invested under a documented agreement between the main trust and the sub-trust in one of three ways:

In brief

Seven-year Option 1 loans are approaching their maturity date, and so, either:

the unpaid principal will be deemed to be a dividend.

The Commissioner’s Treatment of Unpaid Present Entitlements

UPEs are distributions that have been declared by a trustee but not paid out to the beneficiary. For many years it was common for family discretionary trusts to make corporate beneficiaries presently entitled to trust income without paying out the entitlement so that the funds could be kept for use by the trust, or applied for the benefit of other beneficiaries, while paying tax at the corporate tax rate, rather than the higher rate of tax applying to trusts and non-corporate beneficiaries.

In a much criticised Tax Ruling (being TR 2010/3), the Commissioner, concerned that UPEs were being used by family groups to gain a tax advantage, decided to depart from previous practice by determining that a UPE owed to a corporate beneficiary is a loan back to the trust under Division 7A of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (ITAA97). That Division deems purportedly tax-free distributions from a private company to a shareholder or their associate (such as loans) to be assessable, unfranked dividends in certain circumstances.

The Commissioner, however, provided a lifeline to taxpayers affected by the changed position on UPEs, by stating in the same Tax Ruling that taxpayers could avoid the application of Division 7A if the trustee holds the UPE funds on sub-trust for the sole benefit of the private company beneficiary.[1] Those funds could still be used as working capital by the main trust, as long as the funds were invested back into the main trust on commercial terms under a legally binding investment agreement between the main trust and the sub-trust and the benefits from the investment were completely repatriated to the private company beneficiary. Three safe harbour options, outlined above, were created to ensure taxpayers could avail themselves of the administrative treatment set out in TR 2010/3.

To avoid unfairly prejudicing companies with UPEs arising before the Commissioner changed his position, the Commissioner also stated that UPEs that arose prior to 16 December 2009 would not be treated as loans to which Division 7A would apply.[2] However, under proposed changes to Division 7A revealed in the 2016-17 Budget, and which are expected to commence from 1 July 2018, all (pre- and post-2009) UPEs must be rearranged into new complying 10-year loans or be caught under Division 7A.

What this means for taxpayers

Option 1 loans are approaching their maturity date after which time the safe harbour relief from Division 7A will expire.

The loan principal for Option 1 loans entered into in the 2010-11 income year (for UPEs created between 16 December 2009 and 30 June 2010) must be repaid by 30 June 2018, otherwise the unpaid loan principal will be treated as a non-complying Division 7A loan and assessable to tax as an unfranked deemed dividend under 109D.

Additional 7 years relief available for Option 1 loan agreements

Option 1 loans cannot be rolled into an Option 2 loans or 3 investments (or vice versa): PS LA 2010/4.

Practical Compliance Guideline 2017/13, however, which was released on 19 July 2017, may provide some relief to taxpayers. In it, the Commissioner maintains that a trustee must repay the principal of the loan at the end of the loan term.

However, the Commissioner also states that a 7-year Division 7A compliant loan under s 109N ITAA 1936 between the sub-trust and the private company beneficiary may be put in place prior to the private company’s lodgement day to allow a further period of 7 years for the principal to be repaid. If a taxpayer elects to enter into a Division 7A compliant loan, periodic payments of both principal and interest will need to be made.

Note, however, that if the Commissioner determines that there was never an intention at the end of the term of the 7-year Option 1 loan to repay the principal of the loan, the Commissioner may infer that the arrangement was a sham and deem it a dividend in the income year in which it arose.

What needs to be done

If you are a tax adviser, you need to check which clients have Option 1 loans in place and make sure they are aware that such loans may need to be completely repaid by 30 June 2018.

The impending repayment of these loans may pose significant cash flow problems for family groups and require urgent consideration. You may need to consider converting the Option 1 investment into a Division 7A compliant loan by the private company’s lodgement day (e.g. 15 May 2019) to extend the term of the loan for an additional 7 years.

Note, however, that the 30 June 2018 repayment date dovetails with the commencement date of the proposed changes to Division 7A outlined above, which may ultimately supplant the administrative treatment set out in PCG 2017/13 with the conversion of all UPES into 10-year Division 7A complying loans.

According to the Commissioner, some private companies entered into sub-trust arrangements in the 2010 income year, in which case the principal of the loan would have been due for repayment in the 2016-17 income year. Tax advisers and their clients should check that there are no sub-trusts that were created in the 2009-10 income year for which any outstanding loan principal repayments are now overdue.

For taxpayers and advisers who are still unaware that UPEs created after 16 December 2009 are treated as loans under Division 7A, they may need to seek to have the Commissioner exercise his discretion under s 109RB to disregard non-compliance with Division 7A as a result of “honest mistake or inadvertent omission”, as it is likely the Commissioner will soon start taking compliance action in this area. The first and only case so far involving an application under s 109RB was covered in our earlier article here:

https://pointonpartners.com.au/taxation-update-3/.

If you have any queries regarding Division 7A and UPEs, please contact Anthony Pointon on (03) 9614 7707.


[1] TR 2010/3 also states that trustees have the alternative options of simply paying out the UPE or entering into a Division 7A compliant loan in accordance with s 109N ITAA 1936.

[2] Note, however, if a private company beneficiary releases a trustee from paying a pre-16 December 2009 UPE, it may, depending on the circumstances, be deemed a dividend by the Commissioner under s 109C of Division 7A, which broadly deems a financial benefit provided by a private company to a shareholder or their associate to be a dividend (TD 2015/20). Further, even if a UPE is not caught under Division 7A, there is still a risk that the Commissioner will argue that the UPE constitutes a reimbursement agreement under s 100A of ITAA 1936, which means, subject to the relevant exceptions, the beneficiary’s entitlement is disregarded and the trustee is taxed at the top marginal rate under s 99A ITAA 1936. A reimbursement agreement arises where a third party receives the benefit of a trust distribution instead of the beneficiary that was presently entitled to the distribution. In a fact sheet issued on 3 April 2014, the Commissioner indicated that he will generally not consider whether s 100A applies to a UPE to a corporate beneficiary if the retained funds are used as working capital of the trust and, for post-16 December 2009 UPEs, a Division 7A complying loan or investment agreement is in place.

Proposed changes to CGT main residence exemption for foreign residents

The Treasurer has recently released exposure draft legislation (Treasury Laws Amendment (Housing Tax Integrity) Bill 2017) in relation to removal of the CGT main residence exemption for foreign residents. The changes are part of the Commonwealth Government’s ‘housing affordability’ reforms announced in the 2017-18 Budget.

This will affect both Australian tax residents who resided in an Australian property and then became expat, as well as foreigners who never became Australian tax residents as defined, but established a main residence in an Australian property as a question of fact.

If the changes are implemented, then there will be limited opportunities for foreign residents to access the CGT main residence exemption after May 2017, however careful and timely planning may result in significant CGT savings. The same applies for Australian tax residents, who intend to become expats.

Individuals

Currently, individuals are entitled to a full or partial CGT main residence exemption, regardless of their tax residency at the time a CGT event occurs in relation to the property. The exemption is most commonly applied when the main residence is sold and triggers a capital gain.

It is worthy of note that once a property is established as a main residence as a question of fact, while no other property is claimed as a main residence, the owner can be absent during some or all of the ownership period, and the full gain can continue to be exempt if the property is not used to produce any assessable income.

If the property is used to produce assessable income while the owner is absent (e.g. by being let out), then the exemption will continue to apply as long as occupation by the owner is resumed within 6 years or the activity producing assessable income ceases within 6 years.

Where the property is owned and occupied, but used to derive some assessable income (e.g. taking in an arm’s length boarder on commercial terms or operating a home office), the gain on the main residence will be entitled to a partial exemption.

Subject to the transitional measure mentioned below, the proposed legislation would remove this entitlement for foreign tax resident individuals with effect from 9 May 2017. Therefore, individuals who are foreign residents for tax purposes, who enter into a contract of sale after that date will be liable for CGT on any capital gain arising from the sale.

Unlike the withdrawal of the 50% CGT exemption for non-residents, there is no “grandfathering” of the increase in value on the main residence up to 9 May 2017.

There is an opportunity for foreign resident individuals to apply the CGT main residence exemption, if a contract of sale is entered into prior to 30 June 2019 and the individual owned the property (or a part of it) from 9 May 2017 to the date of the contract of sale. Hence, foreign resident individuals should consider selling their Australian main residence, if the other requirements for a full or partial exemption are met, prior to 30 June 2019.

Otherwise, in order to access the CGT main residence exemption after 9 May 2017, a foreign resident individual would need to become an Australian tax resident prior to entering into the contract of sale. However, becoming an Australian tax resident will take time, in order to establish the requisite connection with Australia, which will also depend on any applicable Double Tax Agreement, and will have other usually significant tax issues for them in Australia and the country they are leaving.

Deceased estates and beneficiaries

Currently, trustees of deceased estates, and beneficiaries of deceased estates, are entitled to the CGT main residence exemption, regardless of the tax residency of the deceased or the beneficiaries.

The proposed legislation would remove this entitlement for trustees of deceased estates and beneficiaries in relation to the deceased’s period of ownership, if the deceased was a foreign tax resident at the time of death. If the beneficiary is an Australian tax resident, then the beneficiary will be entitled to a partial exemption in relation to their period of ownership, and subject to the other requirements for the main residence exemption.

In relation to a deceased who was an Australian tax resident at the date of death, the main residence exemption accrued by the deceased will continue to be available to the beneficiary, regardless of the beneficiary’s tax residency. This includes a two year period following the deceased’s death, within which the main residence may be sold. Therefore, a beneficiary, who is a foreign tax resident, may be attributed with the deceased’s entitlement to the main residence exemption following the deceased’s death.

These changes, if enacted, may require wills and succession plans to be reviewed, to confirm that unintended CGT consequences are not triggered by moving or remaining offshore.

Conclusion

The above is a brief summary of proposed changes to a complex area of the tax law. It is possible that the proposed law may be changed prior to enactment, or that it never becomes law. If the above issues are being considered, then professional legal and tax advice should be sought prior to implementing any new strategy.

For an earlier article on recent changes to Victorian stamp duty and non-residents, see:

https://pointonpartners.com.au/foreign-purchasers-of-residential-property-in-victoria-australia-additional-victorian-stamp-duty/

If you wish to discuss any of the issues outlined in this article, please contact us on (03) 9614 7707.