Pointon Partners

State Taxation Series: Issue #7 – New Victorian Government Tax Measures to Support Businesses through Victoria’s State of Emergency

The Victorian Government has recently announced new tax relief measures to support businesses through Victoria’s State of Emergency, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

These tax relief measures announced by the Victorian Government are a welcome reprieve in the current climate.

Payroll tax

All businesses that are liable for payroll tax in Victoria with annual taxable wages up to $3 million will have their entire payroll tax for the 2019 – 2020 financial year waived.

This also means that businesses that have paid payroll tax for the current financial year would be reimbursed any payroll tax paid.

Businesses should note that they must continue to lodge returns, even if the tax payable is waived.

Further, businesses should note that the new measures also include a deferment of payroll tax for the first quarter of the 2020 – 2021 financial year.

Land tax

Victorian land owners with at least one non-residential property will be pleased to note that they have the option of deferring their payments for the 2020 land tax assessments.

The State Revenue Office has indicated that the deferment will apply until after 31 December 2020.

Please note however that the land tax deferral will apply only for land owners whose total taxable landholdings are below $1 million.

Liquor licence fees

Although not a tax, the State Revenue Office has announced that it will administer the reimbursement of renewable liquor licence fees for 2020. This will occur regardless of whether the licence fee was paid to the Victorian Commission for Gaming and Liquor Regulation or the State Revenue Office.

Those who have yet to pay will also have the liquor licence fee waived.

Please do not hesitate to contact Tony Pointon of our firm on (03) 9614 7707 should you require assistance with further understanding these measures, assistance with obtaining tax relief or any other legal matters.

State Taxation Series: Issue #6 – Foreign Purchaser Additional Duty: Milestone Changes from 1 March 2020

The foreign purchaser additional duty (“FPAD”) provisions were introduced in Victoria with effect from 1 July 2015.

The additional duty provisions for foreign purchasers were incorporated in section 28A of the Duties Act 2000 (Vic) (“the Act”)

A foreign purchaser is either a foreign natural person, corporation or the trustee of a foreign trust.

A foreign trust means a trust in which a substantial interest (i.e. more than 50%) is held by either a foreign corporation, foreign natural person or person holding a substantial interest of another foreign trust.

The Act also states that should the trustee of the trust have a power or discretion as to the distribution of the capital of the trust estate to a person(s), that person is taken to have a beneficial interest in the maximum percentage of the capital of the trust (i.e. 100%).

On its website, the SRO states that it has previously taken a practical approach for family discretionary trusts:

In response to initial stakeholder representations after the provisions were introduced, the State Revenue Office adopted a practical approach in respect of family discretionary trusts: …so that trusts that have foreign beneficiaries who have not and who are, based on available information, unlikely in the future to receive any distributions, will not be considered a foreign trust.

However, the SRO has subtly announced recently that it will stop being practical in its approach, and will now adopt the strict statutory approach contained in the Act from 1 March 2020.

From 1 March 2020, all discretionary trusts that do not explicitly exclude foreign beneficiaries and intend to purchase property in Victoria may be liable to FPAD, which is currently at 8% of the dutiable value of a property.

This means that even if your family trust does not have any listed primary beneficiaries who fall under the definition of “foreign beneficiary” and never intends to distribute capital to foreign beneficiaries, it will be deemed by the SRO as a foreign trust!

The monetary implications of this are shown in the table below, indicating the difference in stamp duty applicable for a property purchase in Victoria worth $800,000:

TYPE OF STAMP DUTY DUTY PAYABLE
FPAD not applicable $43,070.00
FPAD applicable $107,070.00

Due to the significant monetary implications and the uncertainty as to how rigidly the SRO intends to apply this non-practical approach, please contact David Mazzeo on (03) 9614 7707 of our firm to make all necessary amendments to your discretionary trust deeds and to ensure FPAD will not be applicable for your property purchase in Victoria.

State Taxation Series: Issue #5 – Section 67 – Exemption of Primary Production Land in an urban zone in Greater Melbourne

Issue 5 of our State Taxation Series considers the newly amended section 67 of the Land Tax Act (Act) relating to the primary production land (PPL) land tax exemption.

The amended provisions in section 67 of the Act received Royal Assent on 19 November 2019. As of 20 November 2019, these amended provisions came into operation.

Other than the requirements that the land comprises one parcel that is wholly or partly in greater Melbourne, and wholly or partly in an urban zone, the two main requirements are whether:

Business of primary production

Section 67 of the Act stipulates that for the exemption under section 67 to apply, the land must be solely or primarily for the “business of primary production”.

The satisfaction of the “business of primary production” requirement in section 67 involves a much higher threshold than the “purpose of sale” requirement in section 65, necessitating proof indicating a primary production business being carried on.

The distinction between “purpose of sale” and “business of primary production” may seem insignificant at first instance. However, the fundamental difference to these statutory requirements is that the former does not require evidence of profit, whereas the latter does, among other factors.

In ascertaining whether a business is carried on; objective and subjective references to the nature and extent of the activities under review, purpose of the individual engaging in the activities, whether the activities are systematic and organised, scale of the activities, and commercial character of the transactions are all important factors.

Ownership Requirements

The ownership requirements for the exemption are dependent on the type of ownership and the legal capacity of the owner(s) of the land:

s 67A – Non-trustee natural person
The owner:

A relative of the owner

s 67B – Non-trustee proprietary company

s 67C – Trustee of superannuation trust

s 67D – Trustee of a discretionary trust

s 67E – Trustee of a trust (other than discretionary or superannuation trust) or unit trust scheme

s 67F – Joint ownership

These new amendments now make it a requirement that there is a connection between the landowner and the business of primary production, where those landowners carry out the business of primary production and where the principal business of the landowner is that business.

It is welcoming to note that the current provisions have completely removed the ambiguous requirement for primary production “of the type”, in which our firm has had experience litigating with the State Revenue Office.

However, the new legislative provisions also pose its own set of uncertainties due to it being unclear as to what exactly is meant by, or the ambit of the words “that business”.

At present, the only guidance is that from the Explanatory Memorandum explaining that the amendments have the effect of reforming the exemption to require a connection between the landowner and the business of primary production conducted on the land.

Our State Taxation Team at Pointon Partners regularly provides advice on primary production matters and have also successfully assisted numerous clients with PPL disputes and reviews undertaken by the State Revenue Office.

NB: Landowners who own land currently exempt under section 67 which has been exempt under this provision may no longer be exempt, and land tax may be applicable for the 2020 land tax year onwards.

Please contact Tony Pointon, Amelita Hensman or Andrew Pointon on (03) 9614 7707 if you wish to discuss this article or any State Taxation matter.

State Taxation Series: Issue #4 – Section 36A Duties Act 2000 (Vic) – Property passing to beneficiaries of discretionary trusts

Issue 4 of our State Taxation Series looks at section 36A of the Duties Act 2000 (Vic) (“the Act”).

The transfer of property from trustee to beneficiary is exempt from duty, with various exemptions from duty available under Chapter 2 of the Act.

Section 36A governs the exemption from duty when a transfer of dutiable property subject to a discretionary trust takes place.

To satisfy the requirements in section 36A, the following must be met:

  1. The duty (if any) charged in respect of the dutiable transaction that resulted in the property becoming subject to the principal trust has been paid or will be paid;
  1. The beneficiary was either:
  1. The transfer of dutiable property is to the beneficiary absolutely or to the beneficiary as trustee of another trust of which all the beneficiaries are relevant beneficiaries.
  1. The Commissioner is satisfied that the transfer is not part of a sale or other arrangement under which there exists any consideration for the transfer.

It is a relatively easy exercise ascertaining whether Items 1 – 3 have been satisfied as they involve fairly general factual enquiries.

On the other hand, Item 4 dealing with “consideration” is not as straight-forward, and can rightfully be characterised as a legal enquiry.

In law, consideration is extremely broad, and is anything that is troublesome to oneself, not necessarily having to be a cost incurred or a monetary sum exchanged.

The recent decision in Astakhov v Commissioner of State Revenue [2018] VCAT 1363 highlights that consideration under the Act is technical and complex.

The decision reflects a common factual scenario where discretionary trusts are in place, that being an in specie distribution of property to beneficiaries.

Astakhov is instructive because it confirms that the forgiveness of a debt can constitute consideration in the context of section 36A of the Act. The decision also makes it clear that forgiveness of a debt (eg. loan) does not need to be an express act, but can be implied by conduct.

The decision also serves as authority and a reminder of the complexities surrounding the harmonisation of trust accounts with the actual (or perceived) legal position, particularly so in the context of consideration in the stamp duty context.

Our State Taxation Team at Pointon Partners regularly provides advice on stamp duty matters and have also successfully assisted numerous clients with stamp duty disputes and reviews, as well as litigation involving the State Revenue Office.

Please contact Tony Pointon, Amelita Hensman or Andrew Pointon on (03) 9614 7707 if you wish to discuss this article or any State Taxation matter.

State Taxation Series: Issue #3 – Exemption of Primary Production Land (PPL) outside Greater Melbourne

Issue 3 of our State Taxation Series considers primary production land (PPL) and the exemption available under section 65 of the Act.

More particularly, this issue looks at the definition of “primary production” under section 64 of the Act and the exemption contained in section 65 of the Act for land situated outside greater Melbourne.

Definition of primary production

Section 64 of the Act defines “primary production” as—

(a)     cultivation for the purpose of selling the produce of cultivation (whether in a natural, processed or converted state); or

(b)     the maintenance of animals or poultry for the purpose of selling them or their natural increase or bodily produce; or

(c)     the keeping of bees for the purpose of selling their honey; or

(d)     commercial fishing, including the preparation for commercial fishing or the storage or preservation of fish or fishing gear; or

(e)     the cultivation or propagation for sale of plants seedlings mushrooms or orchids;

It is crucial to note that the mere existence of evidence indicating primary production activities taking place will not be sufficient to satisfy “primary production” for the purposes of section 64 of the Act.

In fact, it will be observed that each of the definitions do not only contain reference to the relevant PPL activity, but also incorporates the fundamental requirement that such PPL activity be conducted for the purpose of sale.

The inquiry of whether a person engages in any of the defined PPL activities takes place at midnight on 31 December of the relevant land tax year.

The Courts have held however, that it is too narrow to inquire only at midnight, with such assessment to be based during a period not overlong and over-short of the relevant date, with a reasonable period typically stated as constituting six months before and after the relevant date.

Exemption of primary production land outside greater Melbourne

Section 65 of the Act states:

(1)     Land outside greater Melbourne that is used primarily for primary production is exempt land.

(2)     If a part of any land outside greater Melbourne is used primarily for primary production that part is exempt land even if an activity other than primary production is carried on on any other part of the land.

To attract the exemption in section 65, a cardinal requirement is that the land must be used primarily for primary production.

It is widely understood that this requirement of “primarily” is not satisfied if the relevant PPL activities undertaken are minimal, slight, spasmodic or token.

On the contrary, to satisfy the requirements in section 65, it must be shown that the PPL activities have some degree of substance and intensity to them.

The ascertainment of the purpose of the PPL activity carried out and whether that purpose is one that can be recognised as the primary use of the land is not linear.

When regard is made to the fact that a taxpayer bears the onus of proof (especially so in PPL matters), it is all the more imperative that information put forward to the State Revenue Office adequately and accurately represents your factual circumstance based on the applicable law.

Our State Taxation Team at Pointon Partners regularly provides advice on primary production matters and have also successfully assisted numerous clients with PPL disputes and reviews undertaken by the State Revenue Office.

Please contact Tony Pointon, Amelita Hensman or Andrew Pointon on (03) 9614 7707 if you wish to discuss this article or any State Taxation matter.

State Taxation Series: Issue #2 – Land Tax Trust Surcharge – Nomination of beneficiary and notice of beneficial interests

The first issue of our State Taxation Series looked at section 46F of the Land Tax Act 2005 (Vic) (“the Act”), and the three circumstances where a nomination can still be lodged for a discretionary trust that owns any pre-2006 land.

This issue looks at statutory requirements for the nomination of beneficiaries and providing notice of beneficial interests (as applicable) for the obtainment of relief from the trust surcharge rate of land tax in other circumstances (eg. post-2006 land) or trust structures (eg. unit and fixed trusts).

Unit and Discretionary trusts: Nomination of PPR beneficiary

Section 46A of the Act stipulates what the requirements are for the trust surcharge rate not to apply for unit and discretionary trusts:

  1. Nominated beneficiary (or nominated PPR beneficiary accordingly) for the land must be in force;
  2. The particular land must be used and occupied as the principal place of residence of the nominated PPR beneficiary;
  3. The land is not used to carry on a substantial business activity.

Should the requirements under section 46A of the Act be satisfied, then land tax will apply at the general rate.

Fixed trusts: Notice of beneficial interests

Section 46B of the Act states that a trustee of a fixed trust may lodge a written notice of the beneficial interests in the land.

When such a notice is in force under section 46B, the beneficiary of the trust is deemed to be the owner of land subject to the trust (proportionate to the beneficial interests held), and is to be assessed at the general rate for land tax on the land, including other taxable land owned by the beneficiary.

Unit trusts: Notice of beneficial interests

Section 46C of the Act prescribes that a trustee of a unit trust scheme to which land is subject may lodge a written notice of the unit holdings.

Similar to section 46B, when such a notice is in force, a unitholder is deemed to be the owner of land subject to the trust (proportionate to the beneficial interests held), and is to be assessed at the general rate for land tax on the land, including other taxable land owned by the beneficiary.

Fixed and Unit trusts: Beneficial interest as trustee of another trust

Section 46D of the Act states that under a trust (the first trust), should a beneficial interest be held by a person in the capacity as trustee of another trust (the second trust), the person is deemed to be the owner of land subject to the first trust (proportionate to the beneficial interests held in the first trust).

Accordingly, the person so deemed to be the owner of land of the first trust is assessed at the general rate of land tax.

It is also worth noting that section 46D(1)(a) of the Act relates to a fixed trust and section 46D(1)((b) relates to a unit trust.

Our following article discusses primary production land and the land tax exemption available under section 65 of the Act for land situated outside greater Melbourne.

Please contact Tony Pointon, Amelita Hensman or Andrew Pointon on (03) 9614 7707 if you wish to discuss this article or any State Taxation matter.

State Taxation Series: Issue #1 – Section 46F (Nomination of beneficiary of pre-2006 discretionary trust for land tax purposes) – Are you completely out of time to nominate?

The Land Tax Act 2005 (Vic) (“the Act”) imposes land tax on all taxable land in Victoria, with the owner of the particular land liable to pay land tax on 31 December of each calendar year.

The rate of land tax is stipulated in Schedule 1 of the Act, with a person who is the owner of land as trustee of a trust liable for land tax at the surcharge rate set out in Part 3 of Schedule 1, where the taxable value of the land does not exceed $3 million.

Division 2A of Part 3 of the Act contains various concessions (if applicable) from the surcharge rate, where certain statutory pre-conditions are met.

Section 46F is one such section which provides for a concession from the surcharge rate for land held by a discretionary trust, if the trust property includes any pre-2006 land.

The statutory requirement stipulating the timing for the nomination of a beneficiary pursuant to this section is contained in sub-section (4)(b):

(b) to be lodged with the Commissioner on or before the later of—

(i)            30 June 2006; or

(ii)          3 months after the day on which a liability first arises for land tax on land subject to the trust.

The legislative requirement for the nomination to be lodged before 30 June 2006 is widely known, and discussed in Grove Auto Electrical Pty td as trustee for the R Foster Property Trust v Commissioner of State Revenue (Review and Regulation) [2017] VCAT 505 at [9] – [11], and more recently in Polux Pty Ltd as trustee for Iatrou Business Trust No 2 v Commissioner of State Revenue (Review and Regulation) [2018] VCAT 528 at [7] – [10].

However, it is often overlooked that nominations can still be put under section 46F for pre-2006 land in the following three limited circumstances:

  1. Liability to land tax first arises on land subject to the trust (eg. Where previously exempt agricultural land becomes re-zoned, or where the total value of land held by the trust now exceeds the trust threshold of $25,000). Note: The nomination in this instance must be put in within three (3) months of such a land tax liability first arising.
  2. The nominated beneficiary dies.
  3. The nominated beneficiary revokes the nomination.

It should be highlighted that section 46F(9) states that a nomination done due to the death of a nominated beneficiary or a nominated beneficiary revoking the nomination can be done on more than one occasion (as the case requires).

Also worthwhile noting is that should no nomination have been made before the deadline of 30 June 2006 for pre-2006 land held by a trust, if the beneficiary is using the land as their PPR, the trustee may nominate a PPR beneficiary for land used by that beneficiary as their PPR to obtain relief from land tax trust surcharge.

Our following article in this series looks at land held on trust and the circumstances where the nomination of PPR beneficiaries in the context of the various types of trusts provide relief from land tax trust surcharge.

Please contact Anthony Pointon, Amelita Hensman or Andrew Pointon on (03) 9614 7707 if you wish to discuss this article or any State Taxation matter.

The Breakfast Club – “Recent developments in the tax residence of individuals, companies and trusts”

Robert Gordon of our firm has written an article for the Tax Institute Breakfast Club in relation to recent developments in the tax residence of individuals, companies and trusts.

Please click on the link below to view full article.

The Breakfast Club – Recent developments in the tax residence of individuals, companies and trusts – By Robert Gordon

Unlimited Time Frame for Assessing Tax in Australia Criticized

Please see link below to view William Hoke’s article, “Unlimited Time Frame for Assessing Tax in Australia Criticized”.

Hoke (04-01-2019)

Proposed changes to the monster that is Division 7A

Submissions to Treasury

Submissions have now closed to Treasury concerning their Consultation Paper “Targeted Amendments to Div. 7A Integrity Rules” (October 2018– Consultation Paper).

Whilst it is hoped that the submissions to Treasury may finally provide some worthwhile improvements to Div. 7A, the fact that this whole process started in May 2012, and as of today, the limited proposed amendments still lack the required detail, there is little doubt that the monster Div. 7A has turned into, is not about to be constrained.

Div 7A replacement to s108 in 1997

When Div. 7A was introduced in 1997 to replace section 108, dealing with the release of private company profits to shareholders (or associate of shareholders), they seemed to be largely sensible measures that would allow a taxpayer to self-assess whether they had a deemed dividend, rather than the Commissioner having to form an opinion that there had been a release of profits before section 108 applied.

50% CGT discount in 1999

The introduction in 1999 of a choice for individuals and trusts (with presently entitled beneficiaries) to elect to take a 50% discount on capital gains (in place of indexation), created a bias in favour of appreciating capital assets being held in trusts rather than companies.

UPEs to fund trust trading

This together with the fact that many private enterprises preferred trusts as their trading and asset holding entities, rather than companies, put together with a desire to access the lower corporate rate (30%), led trusts to make corporate beneficiaries presently entitled to trust income, but the entitlement was not paid out (an Unpaid Present Entitlement-UPE). This method obtained the corporate tax rate, but allowed for the ongoing funding of the business activities of the trust.

ATO U-turn on UPEs

In December 2009, alarmed by these developments, the ATO changed its position in relation to UPEs owed by trusts to companies, and argued that the allowing of the UPE to remain outstanding represented a “financial accommodation”, to be within the extended definition of “loan” in section 109D of Div. 7A. This was a U-turn, which was met with considerable dismay resulting in the ATO proposing some ameliorating measures to soften the blow of their change of position (TR 2010/3 & PSLA 2010/4). As a result of this turmoil, in May 2012, the Government commissioned the Board of Taxation to undertake a “Post-implementation review of Div. 7A”.

Board of Taxation

The Board’s First Discussion Paper was released in December 2012. In November 2013 the terms of reference were extended to include consideration of Div. 7A in the context of the broader tax framework, a Second Discussion Paper was released in March 2014. The Board then provided its Final Report to Government in November 2014.

The Board’s Final Report made far reaching recommendations in relation to the operation of Div. 7A.

Government’s response

The Government’s response to the Board’s Final Report was to announce, with very little detail, relatively modest amendments as part of the 2016/17 budget, to apply from 1 July 2018:

In the 2018/19 Budget, the Government announced that it was deferring the start date of the 2016/17 proposed amendments, and in addition, confirmed that UPEs would come within the scope of Div. 7A (rather than be administratively treated as such).

All amendments were specified to take effect from 1 July 2019.

Treasury consultation

Treasury released a Consultation Paper on 22 October 2018 posing, in reality, some 22 issues upon which they wanted to hear from stakeholders.

Distributable surplus

Some of Treasury’s consultation points are indeed alarming as they do not go into the detail of seeking to implement the Board’s recommendations in its Final Report, but rather, propose the complete opposite. For example, the Board recommended that the concept of “distributable surplus” be maintained, but Treasury proposes to abolish it! This would mean that capitalising up a private company with $1M, and then borrowing the money straight out again would give a $1M deemed dividend. This is outrageous.

Pre-Dec 2009 UPEs

On the other hand, the Board recommended that pre-December 2009 UPEs be brought into Div. 7A, whereas Treasury asked the question of whether they should be, without any discussion. The 2018/19 Budget certainly made it clear that future UPEs would necessarily come within the scope of Div 7A.

Submissions to Treasury have made it clear that bringing pre-December 2009 UPEs into Div 7A would be a highly retrospective amendment and cause affected taxpayers considerable hardship.

10 Year Loan Model

Other measures upon which Treasury are consulting are a proposed 10-year Loan Model to replace the existing unsecured 7-year and secured 25-year loan arrangements, and rejecting the Amortisation Model recommended by the Board. The Amortisation Model proposed by the Board contemplated flexibilities to the payments of both interest and principal, with minimum payments of interest and the principal not required annually, but rather at the end of years 3, 5, 8 and 10. The Amortisation Model had garnered broad support as it represents an appropriate balance of flexibility for borrowers in terms of cash flow management and the need to ensure, from a policy perspective, that regular payments of both principal and interest are made to the company lender.

No “Business Income Election”

The Board has also recommended that if the Amortisation Model was adopted, trusts should be allowed to make a once and for all election for loans from companies (including UPEs owed to companies), to be excluded from the operation of Div. 7A (the “Business Income Election”). The Treasury Consultation Paper does not refer to the Business Income Election, which is also disappointing.

Start Date

Whether the 1 July 2019 start date can be relied on, needs to take into account that the Federal Election must be held by May 2019, with the Government having scheduled only 10 sitting days before it anticipates going into caretaker mode, so that no new legislation will be introduced from the date of the announcement of the election. Further, that the next Budget has been brought forward to April 2019, which may result in further changes to the proposed amendments.

If you have any queries please contact Anthony Pointon.