Pointon Partners

Can a director of a building company be personally liable for misleading or deceptive conduct by failing to obtain domestic building insurance?

Domestic building insurance covers building owners for costs incurred in rectifying structural defects for up to six years and non-structural defects for up to two years to a maximum of $300,000 in the event a builder dies, disappears or becomes insolvent. This form of insurance must be provided by a builder when the cost of building work is more than $16,000 (including labour and material costs).[1]

The establishment of this obligation is indeed a cornerstone of the Domestic Building Contracts Act 1995 (Vic)[2], and is further entrenched in the builder-owner relationship by the requirement that a builder must not enter into a major domestic building contract unless the contract sets out among other things the details of the required insurance[3].

But what happens when a builder fails to obtain domestic building insurance, even though the contract purportedly sets out the details of the intended cover? Section 18(1) Australian Consumer Law provides “a person must not, in trade or commerce, engage in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive”. Can a building owner maintain the director of the builder has engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in such circumstances?

This issue arose in a decision recently handed down by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal.[4] The dispute consisted of a series of claims brought by the applicants/owners against a number of individuals and companies allegedly involved in the construction of three townhouses in Mitcham.[5] Briefly, the relevant facts were:

  1. In 2012, the applicants engaged the first builder to construct three townhouses.
  2. By 2015, a dispute had arisen between the applicants and the first builder.
  3. The applicants subsequently entered into a second building contract with a second builder to complete the construction of the units.
  4. The first builder went into liquidation on 23 December 2015, and the second builder was deregistered on 14 August 2016. Despite this, building works continued until about May 2017, at which time, according to the applicants, works were abandoned uncompleted.
  5. The applicants were indemnified under the domestic building insurance policy with the first builder, but the insurer denied indemnity for the works carried out by the second builder on the grounds that no policy had been issued for those works.
  6. The applicants alleged among other things that the director of the second builder made a representation in the building contract that there was or would be domestic building warranty insurance in place with QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd, that no such policy in fact existed, and that the director had therefore engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, as a result of which the applicants had suffered loss and damage.

The applicants’ claim against the director failed.  The Tribunal observed that the applicants needed to do more in order to prove the necessary elements of the claim.[6]

Firstly, the Tribunal was not satisfied the representation had been made by the director personally. The alleged representation was in writing in the building contract, but the director was not a party to the contract, and the applicants led no evidence that the director had made the representation in his personal capacity. The director did not send the building contract to the applicants, and was not present at the time it was signed.[7]

Secondly, even if there was a representation in the building contract, it was representation as to a future matter i..e., that the second builder would obtain an insurance policy. In order for a representation as to a future matter to be misleading, it must be shown that the representor did not have reasonable grounds for making it.[8]  The applicants had led no evidence that at the time the representation was made, there was no reasonable basis for a belief that it could not be carried out.[9]

Thirdly, the applicants had not led any evidence to establish that they relied on the representations when entering into the building contract (a necessary element of a claim for misleading or deceptive conduct). It was only after entering into the contract that they asked for a copy of the insurance policy, and they first noticed there was no insurance only after the second builder had stopped work, some two years after entering into the contract.[10]

Fourthly, the applicants failed to establish what loss and damage flowed from being misled or deceived as a result of the representation. Rather than such evidence being non-existent, the manner in which the applicants had prepared their evidence made it impossible for the Tribunal to determine which amounts related to defects caused by the second builder, whether the defects were in fact breaches of the statutory warranties,[11] whether those works were part of the scope of works under the second building contract, whether the amounts claimed were reasonable, and whether those items would have been covered by any insurance policy.[12]

Finally, it emerged during the trial that at least some of the defects had already been the subject of a settlement.[13]

Conclusion

It is trite to say that insurance plays a fundamental role in the potential risks undertaken by a building owner in the context of domestic building works. To reiterate, this has been enshrined in the legislation.[14] And although the director successfully defended the claim made against him in Sarab, builders should be cautious about taking reassurance from this decision if they happen to find themselves in similar circumstances. The Building Act provides for significant penalties for failing to hold relevant insurance.[15] Further, the Tribunal was required to consider the various elements of a claim for misleading or deceptive conduct, and decided on the facts of the case that the claim was not open to the applicants. But that is not to say that a different set of circumstances might arise in which an owner could satisfy those elements with appropriate evidence, and leave a director exposed to the risk of personal liability, in addition to any penalties that might apply.

Please contact us if you would like further advice on this or any other building or property related matter.

[1] Section 135 Building Act 1993 (Vic) empowers the Minister to require various building practitioners and owner builders to purchase particular types of insurance. The requirement of domestic building insurance is sourced from the Order published in Special Government Gazette S98 on 23 May 2003, and which took effect on 1 July 2003, as varied by the Order published in Government Gazette G22 on 29 May 2014, and which came into effect on 1 July 2014.

[2] See sections 1(c) and 4(c).

[3] Section 31(l) Domestic Building Contracts Act 1995 (Vic).

[4] Sarab v. M Property Group Victoria Pty Ltd [2022] VCAT 817 (20 July 2022) (Sarab)

[5] Sarab paragraph 1.

[6] Sarab paragraph 27.

[7] Sarab paragraph 29.

[8] Section 4 Australian Consumer Law.

[9] Sarab paragraph 32.

[10] Sarab paragraph 33.

[11] Section 8 Domestic Building Contracts Act 1995 (Vic).

[12] Sarab paragraph 37.

[13] Sarab paragraph 38.

[14] See footnote 2 above.

[15] See section 136(1) and (2) and section 137.

Is an owner obligated to give a builder an opportunity to rectify defective building works?

It’s an unfortunate reality. A homeowner engages a builder to construct or renovate a home. A developer engages a builder to construct one or more homes, and then sells them. In either case, the owner/purchaser is susceptible to having to deal with defective building works.

Sometimes the relationship can sour, and it can become both tedious and frustrating for both the owner and the builder to continue working together in circumstances where the areas of disagreement between them seemingly cannot be resolved. That dynamic can be exacerbated by delays, with or without the added complication of COVID restrictions.

Can an owner throw in the towel and engage a new builder to rectify defective workmanship? If so, when?

Building contracts generally provide for a “defect liability period”.  Such contracts give an owner a right to require a builder to rectify defective works. The period will vary from contract to contract – it can be 3, or 12, or even 24 months. The defect liability clause may prescribe the process by which the clause is enlivened, including the manner in which notification is to be given to the builder, and what the notification must contain.

Such a clause can be complemented by other clauses in the contract which allow the owner to retain a certain percentage of the contract price until the defects have been rectified.

From the builder’s perspective, this contractual framework can be beneficial in that it will invariably be cheaper for the builder to rectify any defective works rather than the alternative scenario in which the owner engages a new builder, and pays a premium for the rectification works (which is typically 20-30% of the original cost), and then chases the previous builder for that premium, or seeks to offset that money against any outstanding amounts payable to the previous builder.[1]

Homeowners need to be aware that any failure to follow the contractual procedures for the rectification of defects can leave them at risk of being in breach of contract. Owners should consider whether the contract obliges them to give the builder an opportunity to rectify defects, or whether they have a right to engage a new builder and hold the previous builder responsible for any additional costs.

Likewise, a builder who does not satisfactorily follow the contractual procedures for defect rectification can be exposed to the risk of a claim for breach of contract and possibly termination. In that event, there may be a need to hold off from engaging a new builder if the defective works are to be the subject of a VCAT claim, unless the rectification works are urgent.

A less common situation arises outside of the framework of the defects liability period, such as for example where the defects emerge after the expiration of that period, or where the contract does not contain a defects liability clause.

As a general proposition, an owner must take all reasonable steps to mitigate the loss flowing from any defective works resulting in a breach of contract by the builder.[2] Unsurprisingly, each case will depend on its facts.

In Woodlands[3], the English Court of Appeal upheld a decision from the Southampton County Court in which the owners recovered no loss in respect of the relevant defects as a result of their failure to mitigate in circumstances where:

  1. the owners were aware of the defects;
  2. the owners failed to notify the builder of those defects;
  3. the builder had the resources to remedy the defects;
  4. the builder was not given the opportunity to return to the site to rectify those defects; and
  5. the builder was denied the opportunity to request his own subcontractors return to the site to rectify the defects.[4]

In contrast however, circumstances may arise where an owner can reasonably refuse a builder an opportunity to rectify defective works. In such a case, the owner may not be in breach of any obligation to mitigate.

In Ryan[5], the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal found that the owners were reasonable in refusing to allow a builder to rectify where the builder refused to admit most of the defects until well into the trial. Quoting from VCAT’s decision in Oliver, “a builder who fails to undertake rectification work promptly, or who is unwilling to do the necessary scope of works, is less likely to succeed when submitting that it should have been given an opportunity to repair”.[6] In that case, VCAT was not satisfied that the owner’s failure to invite the builder to repair amounted to a failure to mitigate in circumstances where:

  1. the builder’s offer came far too late;
  2. it was far from clear that the builder was offering to do everything the experts agreed should be done;
  3. it was by no means clear that the builder had time to undertake the repairs;
  4. the builder allowed his domestic building registration to lapse after he received the owner’s letter of demand.[7]

In Avonwood[8], a liquidator argued the owners failed to mitigate their loss in engaging a new builder after their first builder went into provisional liquidation. The liquidator maintained the owners should have allowed the builder, through the liquidator, to complete the building contract, which would have cost the owners no more than the original contract price. VCAT held that in the face of the failure by the liquidator to provide specific undertakings as to dates of completion and the meeting of any consequential costs such as renting alternative accommodation and the storage of fittings and effects, the owners had not acted unreasonably, were entitled to make their own arrangements, and had not failed to mitigate their loss.[9]

In summary, owners and builders should look to the contract to determine the appropriate mechanism for addressing defective works. If the contractual provisions have been rendered obsolete because of the effluxion of time, or otherwise do not exist, owners should provide a builder with an opportunity to rectify at first instance. Not doing so will expose them to the risk of an argument by any appropriately advised builder that they have failed to mitigate their loss if they look to the builder to recover any additional costs they incur. Likewise, builders need to be responsive and vigilant when given an opportunity to rectify, to avoid outcomes like those in the Ryan and Oliver decisions.

Please contact our Dispute Resolution Team if you would like further advice on this or any other building or property related matter.

[1] See Oliver & Jasmine Investments P/L v. White [2013] VCAT 740 at para 94

[2] Ibid, at para 91, citing Johnson v. Perez (1988) 166 CLR 351 @ 357; [1988] HCA 64, Avonwood Homes Pty Ltd (in liq) v. Jaffer & Anor [2003] VCAT 443 @ paras 7.5 & 7.6. See also, in different contexts, Pansuriya v. Black Cabs Combined Pty Ltd [2019] VCAT 1490 @ paras 42-43 and Callaghan v. O’Brien [2018] VCAT 101 @ paras 45-46

[3] Woodlands Oak Ltd v. Conwell and Anor [2011] EWCA Civ 254

[4] Ibid, @ paras 23-25

[5] Ryan v. EJ Lowe trading as Urban Builders [2005] VCAT 2031

[6] Oliver & Jasmine Investments Pty Ltd v. White [2013] VCAT 740 @ para 95

[7] Ibid, @ paras 101-102

[8] Avonwood Homes Pty Ltd (in liq) v. Jaffer & Anor [2003] VCAT 443

[9] Ibid, para 7.13. See also para 7.15, and as to damages, para 7.31

Re-introduction of commercial tenancies rent relief scheme: Victorian Government passes Commercial Tenancy Relief Scheme Act 2021 and finalises new Regulations

Further to our previous update, the Commercial Tenancy Relief Scheme Act 2021 (‘New Act’) received royal assent by the Victorian Government on 6 August 2021 and the Commercial Tenancy Relief Scheme Regulations (‘Regulations’) were released on 24 August 2021.

The Regulations

The Regulations operate from 28 July 2021 through to 15 January 2022.[1] The aim of these Regulations is to help small and medium businesses (‘SME’) that generate less than $50 million in annual turnover to apply for rent relief. Such tenants must have ‘eligible leases’ (retail or non-retail) in order to apply.

What is an eligible lease?

In order to be an ‘eligible lease’ the lease must:[2]

  1. be in effect as at 28 July 2021;
  2. have an ‘eligible tenant;’
  3. not be a lease operating for agriculture purposes or where the tenant is a listed company.

Who is an eligible tenant?[3]

An eligible tenant is a tenant that:

  1. operated its business at the rental premises as at 28 July 2021:
    • as a tenant carrying on a business in Australia; or
    • as a non-for profit body pursuing its objectives in Australia; or
    • as a deductable gift recipient that was or operated a public fund; and
  2. is a SME entity i.e. a business making less than $50 million at the end of 30 June 2021; and
  3. satisfies the ‘decline in turnover test’ (as set out below); and
  4. is neither a tenant under an excluded lease i.e. a lease operating for agriculture purposes nor a tenant that is a listed company.

What is the decline in turnover test?[4]

To determine whether a tenant satisfies the ‘decline in turnover test’ the tenant must:

  1. identify a decline in turnover in any three consecutive months between 1 April 2021 to 30 September 2021 (‘turnovertest period’)[5]; and
  2. identify the turnover in the corresponding three consecutive months in 2019 (‘comparisonperiod’);[6] and
  3. show a decline of 30% or more in the turnover between the ‘comparison period’ and the “turnover test period”.[7]

For Example: If the annual turnover of the months of July, August, and September 2019 (i.e. comparison period), compared to the annual turnover of the months of July, August, and September 2021 (i.e. turnover test period), was a 35% drop, then there is a  shortfall of 35% (i.e. the relevant comparison turnover) and the tenant would have satisfied the ‘decline in turnover’  test.

How does a tenant request rent relief?[8]

As set out in last year’s update, during the operation of the previous COVID-19 regulations, the request for rent relief is relatively the same.

Rent relief is inclusive of outgoings, and the tenant and landlord must comply with the steps set out below.

Tenant’s obligations[9]

The tenant must:

  1. make a request in writing to the landlord accompanied by a statement from the tenant that states

2. within 14 days of making the written request, provide evidence supporting the figures in its statement which include at least one of the following:

A statutory declaration by the tenant or authorised officer of the tenant must also be provided stating that the tenant is an eligible tenant and that the information provided by the tenant is true to the best of the tenant’s knowledge and belief.

If the tenant does not provide this information within 14 days, the rent relief request lapses but the tenant may apply for a new request. If the tenant makes more than three rent relief requests and they all lapse, the tenant cannot make any further requests.

Landlord’s obligations[10]

Upon receipt of the above, the landlord must offer rent relief under the eligible lease:

  1. within 14 days after receiving evidence required to support the tenant’s statement; or
  2. a different period as agreed by parties in writing.

The offer for rent relief (‘Offer’) must be made in writing by the landlord and must:

  1. relate up to 100% of the rent payable under the eligible lease during the relief period; and
  2. at a minimum be proportional to the tenant’s decline in turnover; and
  3. provide no less than 50% rent relief offered by the landlord be waived unless the parties agree in writing.

The tenant is taken to have accepted the Offer after 14 days have lapsed since the offer was made. The rent relief agreement may be confirmed by varying the existing lease or by any other form of agreement.[11]

Disputes

The New Act provides the Victorian Small Business Commissioner (‘VSBC’) will facilitate and arrange to resolve any disputes by mediation and monitor compliance between the parties in dispute under an eligible lease.[12]

If you are a commercial landlord or tenant and need assistance with understanding your rights under the New Act and/or Regulations please contact our Property Team for assistance.

[1] Regulations, r 4.

[2] Regulations, r 5.

[3] Regulations, r 9.

[4] Regulations, r 12.

[5] Regulations, r 13.

[6] Regulations, r 14.

[7] Regulations r, 15.

[8] Regulations, r 27.

[9] Regulations, r 27(2).

[10] Regulations, r 27(7).

[11] Regulations, r 12(12).

[12] New Act, s 10 and Regulations, r 40.

Victorian Government reintroduces commercial tenancy rent relief scheme

On Wednesday the Victorian Government announced by press release that it was reintroducing the commercial tenancy rent relief scheme which operated from May to December of last year.  That scheme permitted JobKeeper employers with turnover of less than $50 million to seek rent relief from their landlords proportionate to their reduction in turnover.  The rent relief was required to take the form of 50% waiver of rent and 50% deferral of rent.  Obviously the Federal Government’s JobKeeper scheme is no longer in operation but in its press release the Victorian Government stated that only tenants whose turnover had fallen by 30% would be eligible to seek rent relief.  The press release stated that the scheme would commence from Wednesday but at this stage it is unclear how long it will operate for and what accounting periods the tenant will need to refer to when seeking the rent relief from their landlord.  These details will be included in legislation which will be introduced into the Victorian Parliament.  We will keep you updated with details of the draft legislation once it is available.

During the course of last year we acted for landlords and tenants involved in rent relief negotiations and are available to assist during the operation of the reintroduced scheme.  If you do have any queries regarding the rent relief scheme please feel free to contact Michael Bishop or David Mazzeo.

Important Update: 2021/22 Victorian Budget and Changes in the Property Sector

Last Thursday, Victorian Treasurer Tim Pallas announced the Budget plans for 2021/22. The property sector in particular will be significantly impacted as a result of the announcements made.

The table below outlines the changes announced and proposed start date.

Tax Change Effective on
Stamp Duty Premium stamp duty introduced
Premium stamp duty will be introduced to property transactions above $2mil – $110,000 of duty plus 6.5% of dutiable value in excess of $2mil. This percentage is fixed and not adjusted annually depending on inflation.

Previously, the highest general rate was 5.5% for transactions with dutiable value in excess of $960,000.

1 July 2021
Temporary Concessions
For contracts entered into 1 July 2021 to 30 June 2022, and do not qualify for a Tax Exemption, the Victorian Government will extend the 50% stamp duty discount on new residential properties in the City of Melbourne Local Government area. 1 July 2021 to 30 June 2022
For contracts entered into from 1 July 2021 and ending 30 June 2023, there will be an increase in the eligibility threshold for the off-the-plan duty concession to $1 million for all home buyers. 1 July 2021 and ending 30 June 2023
Temporary Exemptions
For contracts entered into 21 May 2021 and ending on 30 June 2022, a full exemption on stamp duty for new residential properties worth up to $1million and have remained unsold for 12 months or more since completion of construction i.e. the stamp duty is waived. 21 May 2021 to 30 June 2022
Waiver
The 25% Stamp Duty waiver will cease for existing or vacant residential land 1 July 2021
Land Tax Increased percentage
·        0.25 per cent for taxable landholdings exceeding $1.8 mil and no more than $3 mil; AND

·        0.30 per cent for taxable land holdings in excess of $3mil.

2022 land tax year
Concessions
Will not apply to private gender exclusive clubs 2022 land tax years
Threshold
For contracts entered into from 1 July 2021 to 30 June 2023 the land tax threshold will increase from $250,000 to $300,000. The Land Tax Threshold for land held on trust still is $25,000. 1 July 2022 to 30 June 2023
Vacant Land tax
Exemption for new developments are temporarily extended for up to two tax years. 2022 land tax year
New tax: Windfall Gains Tax ·         introduced for properties where value has boosted by a council rezoning.

·         Will only apply where the property’s value is boosted by more than $100,000 with a 50% tax on windfalls above $500,000.

·         Victorian Government expects to raise $2.7 billion from the suite of measures.

·         Victorian Government expects a $124 million increase over four years.

·         Not part of Budget Bill but will be in a separate legislation.

1 July 2022

The penalty unit has also increased by 10%, making the new unit $181.74 per unit. This change will take effect on 1 July 2021.

If you need any assistance in relation to your property or business, please do not hesitate to contact our Property Team on (03) 9614 7707.

Further Extension of COVID-19 rent relief to 28 March 2021

The Victorian Government confirmed on 22 December 2020 that the rent relief period under the COVID-19 Omnibus (Emergency Measures) Act 2020 (Act) and the COVID-19 Omnibus (Emergency Measures) (Commercial Leases and Licences) Regulations 2020 (Regulations) are extended up until 28 March 2021.

There has been no substantive change to the Act and Regulations other than the end date.

Eligible tenants that previously applied for rent relief are able to apply to a landlord in writing for further relief from 1 January 2021 to 28 March 2021 if they still meet the requirements in the Regulations.

Our Property Update released on 23 September 2020 highlights what the eligibility requirements are.

A landlord would not be obliged to extend the tenant’s rent relief period until 28 March 2021 if a tenant’s business no longer meets these requirements, particularly if the tenant no longer is participating in the JobKeeper scheme. However, this does not prevent landlords and tenants from negotiating to enter into arrangements or agreements deemed appropriate.

On the other hand, if the requirements under the Regulations are met, a landlord must extend the rent relief period from the date the application was made until 28 March 2021.

This particular rent relief extension applies to the following protections::

  1. Further rent relief granted to tenants up to 28 March 2021;
  2. Deferred rental payments extended to commence only after 28 March 2021;
  3. The prohibition on Landlords evicting tenants for non-payment of rent and outgoings extended to 28 March 2021; and
  4. The restriction on rent increases extended to 28 March 2021.

In the instance where tenants and landlords are unable to reach an agreement for rent relief, they are both able to apply for free mediation with the Victorian Small Business Commission to help resolve the dispute.

Whether you are a tenant or a landlord, if you are seeking assistance regarding the extension of the Act and Regulations and what this means for your premises or for any further questions, please contact David Mazzeo on (03) 9614 7707.

Pointon Partners Important Property Law Changes Webinar

Thank you to those who joined the webinar yesterday, it was a successful session!

The webinar was presented by David, Michael and Thomas. The following topics were covered:

The webinar was recorded, should you want to watch please click on the link below and enter the passcode:

Topic: Important Property Law Changes Webinar

Date: Oct 14, 2020 2:00 PM Canberra, Melbourne, Sydney

Meeting Recording: https://zoom.us/rec/share/MqXJ1Tii8neAscPclRxnOvFOZFgfekerppwOjpcZPzmgaDi25OXZKeBqmdFqUXt_.8shaxU5lloRGuTU3

Access Passcode: 70jX^4j

Extension of rent relief measures for commercial tenants

In our Property Update released on 4 May 2020 we commented on the new Victorian Regulations which provided certain tenants of commercial premises with the right to negotiate rent relief measures with their landlords.

Eligible tenants were those with turnover of less than $50 million and who were participating in the Federal Government’s JobKeeper scheme.  Any offers by landlords were required to take into account the reduction in the tenant’s turnover during the Covid pandemic. Rent relief was designed to take the form of waiver of rent as to 50% of the relief and rent deferral as to the remaining 50%.

However if no rent relief agreement was agreed upon between the landlord and tenant then the tenant was able to apply to VCAT for a binding determination regarding rent relief though VCAT was not obliged to award rent relief proportionate to the tenant’s reduction in turnover.

Those Regulations were scheduled to expire on 29 September 2020.  However late last month the Premier announced by press release that the rent relief scheme would be extended until the end of the year. In recent weeks legislation has been introduced into and passed by the Victorian Parliament enabling the issuing of further Regulations extending the scheme until the end of the year (or indeed up until 26 April 2021 if the Government considers it necessary).

The exact form of these new Regulations will be important as in his press release the Premier announced some modifications to the existing scheme.  This includes empowering the Victorian Small Business Commissioner, and not just VCAT, to make binding determinations.

In addition, binding determinations will be required to provide rent relief proportionate to the tenant’s reduction in turnover whereas under the existing scheme this is merely a relevant consideration and VCAT’s powers are more discretionary. We will update you once the new Regulations are issued and keep you appraised of relevant developments.

During the course of the pandemic Pointon Partners have been handling rent relief negotiations on behalf of both landlords and tenants.  If you require any assistance with such negotiations please feel free to contact Michael Bishop, David Mazzeo or Andrew Kaspen of our office on (03) 9614 7707.

Attention All Off-The-Plan Vendors of Real Estate: Important Changes to Sunset Date Legislation

In line with recent legislative changes, all vendors under an off-the-plan contract will no longer be able to exercise its sunset date termination rights without first:

If the vendor cannot obtain the consent of the purchaser, it will have to apply for, and obtain, an order from the Supreme Court allowing the vendor to terminate the contract.

The above will apply to all off-the-plan contracts which were entered into on or after 23 August 2018.

In addition to the above, there is also a new notice requirement. The following notice must be included in off-the-plan contracts moving forward.

NOTICE TO PURCHASERS OF PROPERTY “OFF-THE-PLAN”
(Section 10F Sale of Land Act 1962)

If the above notice is not included in an off-the-plan contract, the contract will still remain enforceable. However, there are financial penalties that can be imposed on non-complying vendors. The penalty can be as much as $198,264 for a corporate vendor and $39,652 for an individual.

If you are in the process of selling off-the-plan and you are affected by the above changes or you are not sure, please contact our office on (03) 9614 7707. We can assist you in updating your master off-the-plan contracts as required on account of the above changes.

You should also regularly check in with us to ensure the Section 32 Statement attached to any contract of sale is up to date at the time a contract of sale is entered into (not just when it is prepared) and discloses all matters required to be disclosed. If not, the contract of sale may be voidable by the purchaser any time prior to settlement.

Residential Construction and Land Tax: What happens if there is a delay in construction?

Whilst homes in Victoria that are occupied as a principal place of residence are exempt from Land Tax, building works or disputes that result in homes being unoccupied for extended periods of time can have the unexpected result of a Land Tax liability.

These assessments can be particularly frustrating if there have been significant delays, resulting in multiple years of land tax being imposed on land that can neither be occupied nor rented.

Is the builder liable for the Land Tax, if they have caused the delay?

Assuming that the owner is ineligible to seek a refund from the State Revenue Office (see next section), and that Land Tax would not otherwise have been imposed (i.e. if not for a delay caused solely by the builder), it is possible that owner could make a claim against a builder for this loss.

However, most standard form construction contracts limit a builder’s liability, in the event of a delay, to a fixed weekly rate for liquidated damages. It is important, therefore, when negotiating a liquidated damages rate in a building contract, to ensure that the rate is high enough to compensate a home owner for a potential land tax liability that might arise out of the construction taking longer than anticipated.

Refund Applications

In appropriate cases, owners can apply for a refund of up to four years of land tax if they subsequently occupy the property as their principal place of residence continuously for at least 6 months.

A refund will be granted if the relevant requirements under section 61 of the Land Tax Act 2005 (Vic) are satisfied:

  1. The owner has paid the land tax assessments; and
  2. The owner has actually occupied the property continuously as their principal place of residence for 6 months following the completion of the construction or renovation.

A refund for the first two years will only require evidence in relation to the two above factors. Importantly, the owner must initially pay the assessments on time during the construction or renovation period, even if there was a delay in construction that was not the fault of the owner.

However, when applying for a refund for the third and fourth years, the taxpayer may need to provide additional evidence proving that there was an ‘acceptable delay’ in relation to the start or finish of construction that was due to reasons beyond the control of the owner.

In preparing the refund application, it is important to consider and gather evidence in relation to a range of factors, including:

Can I apply for a PPR exemption during construction?

Unfortunately, the Victorian legislation only allows owners to apply for refunds following a period of 6 months of subsequent occupation. A pre-emptive application for an exemption during the period of construction is not available in Victoria, unlike in some other states such as NSW and South Australia. Also, refusing to pay and objecting to the assessments issued during this period is generally not advisable, as significant interest may accrue on the outstanding amounts.

Vacant Residential Land Tax

Additionally, owners may also be charged with the newly introduced Vacant Residential Land Tax. This is particularly relevant during construction involving the demolition or significant renovation of an existing home within inner or middle Melbourne.

The SRO can deem land as ‘vacant’ and ‘residential’ at law during this period, even if the land was not habitable during the relevant year(s) of construction. The Vacant Residential Land Tax of 1% of the capital improved value will apply on top of regular land tax, and has a separate application process regarding exemptions.

When applying for an exemption from the Vacant Residential Land Tax, a range of factors need to be considered, including:

Notification Requirements

Additionally, the onus is on owners to notify the SRO when they can no longer reside at their home due to ongoing construction or renovations (typically an absence that is in excess of 6 months prior to the assessment date of 31 December). Otherwise, owners may be liable for penalty tax if they do not notify the SRO of the construction and change in their living arrangements. To avoid this, it is important that home owners notify the SRO as soon as a property is no longer occupied as a principal place of residence.

Key Takeaways

  1. Before signing a building contract, think about how much Land Tax will be payable while the property is unoccupied, and whether the weekly rate for liquidated damages is high enough to cover land tax as well as other expenses you will incur if the project is delayed.
  2. Notify the SRO as soon as you cease to occupy a property previously claimed as your principal place of residence
  3. If you are out of the property for more than 6 months in any calendar year, expect to receive a Land Tax assessment
  4. Pay the assessment
  5. Keep records of how long the build is meant to be taking, and the reasons for any delays
  6. Apply for a refund once you’ve been back in the property for more than 6 months.
  7. Always apply for a refund if you’re claiming back less than 2 years’ worth of Land Tax.

At Pointon Partners, we are experienced in providing personalized building and tax advice, assisting with the preparation of the relevant exemption and refund applications, as well as negotiating and settling disputes with the State Revenue Office.

If you would like to discuss this article, please contact Tony Pointon, Amelita Hensman, or Andrew Pointon on (03) 9614 7707.

Pointon Partners also has a strong building advisory division headed by Matthew Francke and Andrew Kaspen if you have any queries concerning your building project.