Pointon Partners

Tranche 2 of AML/CTF: Are Accountants In?

The Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Act 2024 (Cth) (‘AML/CTF’, ‘the Amendment’) amends the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006 (‘the Act’) by extending to additional services, including services provided by real estate agents, lawyers, and accountants that are high risk for money laundering and terrorism financing.

Section 5 of the AML/CTF Act defines ‘reporting entity’ as provider of designated service. To this end, section 6 of the AML/CTF Act provides an extensive list of designated services.

Accountants providing the following services fall under the definition of reporting entity:

(a) Assisting or acting on behalf of a person in a transaction to transfer real estate.

(b) Assisting or acting on behalf of a person in a transaction to transfer a body corporate or legal arrangement, or those involved in corporate restructuring.

(c) Receiving, holding and controlling or managing a person’s assets.

(d) Facilitating equity or debt financing.

(e) Transferring shelf companies.

(f) Acting as or arranging for another person to act as substitute office-holder in corporate governance (director, power of attorney, shareholder etc.).

(g) Providing a registered office address or principal place of business.

However, businesses that only or incidentally receive, hold and control or manage a person’s assets without performing any of the other designated services will not be covered. As such, routine tax/audit services or smaller firms not involved in financial management may be exempt.

What are your obligations if you are providing designated service?

The AML/CTF Act is currently scheduled to cover tranche 2 entities from 1 July 2026 and mandates the following:

I. Enrol & Register

You must enrol your business with AUSTRAC. The application must include all relevant details about your business, including approximate annual turnover and earnings, as well as a description of the designated services you provide. Some designated services like remittance providers require registration, however these services were already captured by the pre-Amendment legislation. Enrolment for tranche 2 entities opens on 31 March and must be completed by 29 July.

II. AML/CTF Program

You must implement an AML/CTF Program, which needs to include a risk assessment of how the firm could be used for money laundering or terrorism financing (‘ML/TF’). It must cover policies, procedures and controls with respect to mitigating the risks, and arrange for oversight from senior management staff. These obligations are ongoing and thus there needs to be updated mechanisms and a formal review at least once every 3 years.

The reporting entity must have an AML/CTF compliance officer who has sufficient authority to oversee and enforce the Program and is a ‘fit and proper person’ with respect to matters outlined in the Act. This individual will communicate with AUSTRAC on behalf of the reporting entity. Businesses must designate the officer within 28 days of the provision of designated services, and must notify AUSTRAC of the individual’s identity within 14 days of designation.

Under section 26F(4)(f), an independent evaluation by a qualified individual of an entity’s AML/CTF Program must take place every 3 years and be appropriate to the nature, size and complexity of the reporting entity’s business.

III. Staff training

Part 5-9 of the AML/CTF Rules provide that a reporting entity’s Program must provide employees with training on their AML/CTF policy at both initial hiring and on an ongoing basis throughout their employment. It must have regard to the particular function performed by the person and its specific AML/CTF risks.

IV. Customer Due Diligence (‘CDD’)

Part 2 of the Act outlines the CDD required in Programs.

Initial CDD

Must occur before providing designated services, unless an exemption applies. Referred to as Know Your Customer (‘KYC’) information, this includes establishing and taking reasonable steps to verify:

Using the above information, the reporting entity must identify the ML/TF risk of the customer.

The beneficial owner of a customer is defined as the individual who:

(a) Directly or indirectly owns 25% or more of an entity; or

(b) Directly or indirectly controls the customer.

The definition of politically exposed person is listed in part 1-5 of the AML/CTF Rules, but in brief covers individuals in positions of public authority resulting in a higher risk of ML/TF.

Under Division 4 Section 32, if the ML/TF risk of a customer is particularly high, for example if they live in a high risk jurisdiction, are a politically exposed person or if the designated service provided is part of a nested services relationship, enhanced CDD appropriate to the risk must be applied and documented.

Ongoing CDD

Section 30 of the Amendment stipulates that CDD obligations do not cease at the initial phase of dealings, nor does an already existing business relationship ease the requirements. Reporting entities must review current customer information and continue to monitor for unusual transactions and behaviours which may give rise to a suspicious reporting matter obligation, as outlined below. Unusual transactions and behaviours are generally those not in line with your understanding of the customer. They must also review and update KYC information where there is a significant change which engenders doubt as to its adequacy.

V. Reporting Obligations

Suspicious matters

Entities must make a report to the AUSTRAC CEO if the service provider has reasonable grounds to suspect anything listed in section 41 of division 2, mostly pertaining to the customer’s identity and suspected ML/TF. Applies even where person is merely inquiring about designated services. The window for reporting is short – for more serious matters, you must make report within 24 hours after suspicion forms.

Threshold transactions

Entities must also report transactions of physical currency where the total amount is $10,000 or more, however specified amount is variable for different services.

Compliance reports

In the first three months of each calendar year, reporting entities must submit a report to the AUSTRAC CEO through their website relating to their compliance with the Act.

VI. Record Keeping

Under the Act, reporting entities must maintain records of:

For a period of 7 years after the preparation of documents, the provision of the service or when the Program ceases to be in force.

Reporting groups

The Amendment replaces designated business groups with reporting groups, in which reporting entities may form groups with a lead entity. This lead entity can:

It is important note however that should a group member breach a civil penalty provision, both, that member and the group leader are taken to have breached the Act.

When “remedy defects” means “pay damages”: lessons from Grech v Biltar Pty Ltd [2025] VSC 636

A recent Supreme Court decision illustrates the risks of settling a building dispute by requiring a builder to “remedy defects” rather than paying money. Even where the obligation to remedy defects is contained in a formal settlement deed, the Court will rarely compel specific performance of building works.

In Grech v Biltar Pty Ltd [2025] VSC 636, the owner sought orders compelling the builder to specifically perform its obligations under a settlement deed to carry out rectification works. The deed required the builder to fix defects identified by an independent expert and to complete those works to that expert’s satisfaction. When the builder delayed and sought an extension, the owner refused, citing concerns about the builder’s cash-flow position and reliability, and applied to compel specific performance of the deed.

The Court’s approach

Associate Justice Efthim reaffirmed that specific performance of building contracts is an exceptional remedy. Courts are reluctant to supervise construction work and will only order specific performance of a building contract where:

  1. The work is clearly defined by the contract.
  2. The owner has a substantial interest in performance that cannot be adequately met by damages.
  3. The builder is in possession of the site.

The deed and the right to specific performance

The case was unusual in that the deed of settlement itself expressly contemplated specific performance as a remedy. Clause 7.4(b) provided that if the builder materially defaulted in its obligations under clause 5 (that is, to complete the rectification works identified by the expert to the expert’s satisfaction), the owner could:

“commence proceedings in a court of competent jurisdiction against the Builder seeking specific performance of the terms of this Deed plus interest and costs.”

The owner argued that this clause demonstrated the parties’ intention that the Court should compel specific performance if the builder defaulted. The Court accepted that the clause entitled the owner to seek such an order, but emphasised that it did not bind the Court to grant it. The equitable discretion to refuse specific performance still applied.

Unclear scope of works

The rectification process under the deed relied on an independent expert’s reports, but those reports left the scope of work uncertain. Items such as balcony compliance, glass panel holes and brickwork cleaning were expressed in open-ended terms, leaving questions unresolved.

His Honour found that this lack of precision made the obligations unsuitable for enforcement. Even though the deed established a mechanism for resolving disagreements, it still required ongoing cooperation and judgment calls that the Court could not sensibly supervise.

Damages and practical alternatives

The owner argued that damages were inadequate because hiring another builder in a regional area would be costly and difficult, and because the builder appeared financially weak. The Court accepted that the builder had experienced cash-flow problems but emphasised that those concerns did not automatically justify compelling specific performance.

The builder was insured with the Victorian Managed Insurance Authority (VMIA), which provided cover up to $300,000. There was no evidence that the cost of rectifying the defects would exceed that cap. Without such evidence, damages remained an adequate and practical remedy.

Importantly, the existence of VMIA insurance significantly reduced the solvency risk relied upon by the owner. That statutory cover is triggered if a builder dies, disappears, becomes insolvent, or fails to comply with a VCAT or court order to remedy defective works.

Associate Justice Efthim observed that many of the owner’s concerns, such as expense, delay and the inconvenience of engaging a new builder, were common to most building disputes and did not warrant an order compelling specific performance.

Conduct and relationship

Past hostility between the parties reinforced the impracticality of forcing cooperation under court order. The Court was not prepared to compel a working relationship that had already broken down. This was a further reason to deny the equitable relief sought.

The result

The application to compel specific performance was dismissed. The Court held that damages, supported by the VMIA warranty cover, provided a sufficient remedy and that the rectification mechanism under the deed was too uncertain to enforce, notwithstanding that the deed expressly contemplated specific performance.

Key lessons for owners

What it means in practice

This decision is a reminder that in the majority of situations the best settlement is one that ends the relationship, not one that tries to patch a broken one back together. Even where a deed expressly provides for specific performance, the Court will be slow to compel it. Where obligations are vague, the builder’s solvency uncertain and the working relationship strained, a promise to “remedy defects” can prolong the dispute instead of resolving it. In most matters, taking money and moving on will produce a cleaner, quicker and more enforceable outcome.

If you do settle on a “remedy defects” basis, consider structuring the settlement deed to provide for payment of the costed value of the defects in the event of default.

This ensures the owner retains a practical monetary remedy without the need to seek specific performance or re-litigate the underlying issues.

Please contact Carl Millington with any queries regarding this article.

Agents: Don’t pay for the privilege of working for free

A recent County Court decision (Cellmore Real Estate Pty Ltd v Funston [2025] VCC 1205) is a sharp reminder for estate agents. If an authority is not completed properly, the agency cannot recover marketing fees.

In Cellmore, the Exclusive Sale Authority listed advertising costs as “TBA.” The Court found this failed to comply with the Estate Agents Act 1980 (Vic). As a result, the agency could not recover its marketing spend.  The first campaign with another agent had failed. Cellmore was then engaged on an Exclusive Sale Authority with payment of marketing deferred. Buyer interest was limited, the authority expired, and a dispute over marketing costs followed.

Marketing campaigns are expensive, and in a competitive environment many agents agree to fund advertising upfront to win the listing. But the risks are real. In this case the agent ended up with no commission, unrecoverable marketing fees, and tens of thousands in legal costs after a dispute about recovering those fees. A charging clause or caveat provided no protection.

When taking on a second or third hand listing, ask yourself: is the juice worth the squeeze?

There may be a reason why the previous agents have failed to sell the property. If you are expected to fund marketing costs out of your own pocket, the risk is magnified.

The key points for agents:

Pointon Partners regularly acts for agents in commission claims and related disputes. If you would like to review your documents and processes, or if you are already involved in a dispute, we can help.

Challenging market rent determinations under the Retail Leases Act: key lessons for landlords and tenants

Retail leases commonly include provisions for the rent to be reset to market value at the commencement of a further term, usually following the exercise of an option by the tenant.  In these cases, an independent specialist retail valuer is appointed to determine the current market rent – a process that sets the rent payable for the new lease term.  These determinations can have significant financial consequences for both landlords and tenants.

But when can such determinations be challenged?

A recent decision of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal in Dalziel v Veev Pty Ltd [2025] VCAT 681 provides useful guidance on the narrow circumstances in which a market rent determination can be set aside.

Background

The dispute arose between landlords of a regional hotel and their tenant, Veev Pty Ltd, following the tenant’s exercise of a five-year option under a retail lease. The lease required the appointment of a specialist retail valuer to determine the current market rent, in accordance with section 37 of the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) (RLA).

The landlords believed the determined rent was too low and sought to have the valuer’s determination set aside on two main grounds:

  1. The valuer failed to have proper regard to section 37(2)(b) of the RLA.
  2. The valuer failed to provide detailed reasons as required by section 37(6) of the RLA.

The law

The RLA requires that a determination of current market rent:

Courts and tribunals have consistently held that a rent determination can only be set aside where there is fraud, collusion, or a mistake so fundamental that it renders the determination inconsistent with the contractual terms, often referred to as the valuer’s “charter”.

The Tribunal’s decision

VCAT dismissed the application and upheld the rent determination, making several key findings:

  1. Failure to have regard to s 37(2)(b)

The landlords alleged that the valuer had not properly considered what rent the premises might reasonably attract if offered on the open market. However, the Tribunal found that this complaint was effectively about inadequate reasoning and was better considered under the second ground.

There was no evidence that the valuer had disregarded this statutory requirement; rather, the landlords simply disagreed with how comparable properties were assessed.

  1. Adequacy of reasons under s 37(6)

The Tribunal examined whether the valuer had provided “detailed reasons”, as required by law. The landlords pointed to four areas they claimed lacked adequate explanation:

In each case, the Tribunal found that the valuer had disclosed sufficient information to explain how the determination was reached. It accepted that the valuer:

Crucially, the Tribunal held that disagreement with a valuer’s conclusions, or a desire for more granular detail, is not a basis to invalidate the determination.

Practical takeaways

For landlords and tenants involved in market rent reviews under the RLA, this decision reinforces several important points:

How we can help

If you are a landlord or tenant facing a market rent review, or if you are considering challenging a determination, it is critical to seek legal advice early. We assist clients by:

Please contact us to discuss how we can protect your commercial interests in rent review disputes.

Please contact Carl Millington with any query regarding this article or leasing disputes generally.

Retaining a tenant’s goods after lease termination? Think twice

Pointon Partners’ regularly advises commercial landlords and property managers on their rights and obligations when a lease is terminated. A recent decision of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT), Cristiano v Prime Kwality Foods Pty Ltd [2025] VCAT 580, is a timely reminder of the legal and financial risks associated with retaining the tenant goods following lease termination -even where the tenant owes substantial rent arrears.

What happened?

In Cristiano, the landlords terminated a commercial lease over a warehouse following repeated non-payment of rent.  The landlords re-entered the property. Following the re-entry the tenant, a food distribution business, left behind a substantial quantity of business property, including:

The landlord, through their managing agents, refused to allow the tenant to retrieve the goods unless rent arrears were paid. Over time, they moved the goods into commercial storage, sold some items and treated others as abandoned.

The tenant brought a counterclaim alleging that the landlords had unlawfully retained and converted its goods.

The Tribunal’s findings

Senior Member Edquist found that:

Financial consequences

The Tribunal awarded the landlords approximately $19,560 in respect of their claim for unpaid rent and associated costs. However, the tenant’s counterclaim succeeded, and the landlords were ordered to pay $98,827.27 in damages for conversion. This was more than five times the value of the landlords’ claim.

Damages for conversion were assessed based on the value of the goods at the time they were wrongfully withheld. The Tribunal also considered consequential loss in some cases, such as where perishable goods had deteriorated in storage or where items could not be recovered or resold.

Key Takeaways

Landlords are responsible for their agents’ actions

The Tribunal held the landlords were responsible for the actions and communications of their managing agents, as the agents acted with actual authority. Depending on the particular facts landlords may have recourse against the agent for any losses incurred because of the agent’s actions, but this does not relieve landlords of their responsibility to the tenant.

It is therefore critical that managing agents understand the relevant laws and act cautiously — if agents are unsure, they should promptly seek legal advice to avoid exposing both themselves and their landlords to significant risks.

Avoiding costly mistakes
This decision is a clear reminder that even significant rent arrears do not justify holding on to a tenant’s goods without a lawful basis. In Cristiano, the damages awarded to the tenant far exceeded the amount of unpaid rent.

Apparently rational but unlawful actions by landlords or their agents can result in serious financial consequences.

Please contact Carl Millington with any query regarding this article or leasing disputes generally.

Vacant Residential Land Tax Exemptions and Significant Amendments to Holiday Home Exemption – Do not Buy your New Holiday House in a Family Trust

On the 3rd December 2024, the State Taxation Further Amendment Act 2024 (‘Amending Act’) introduced significant changes to several taxes, foremost of which include the exemptions in the vacant residential land tax (‘VRLT’) (which take effect 1 January 2025) with the addition of companies and trustees to the holiday home exemption. The current exemptions in Division 9 of Part 4 of the Land Tax Act 2005 (‘The Act’) are equally as applicable and importantly, should receive consideration from individuals, vested beneficiaries as well as corporations and trustees of trusts.

There is a holiday home exemption when the property was owned in the trust prior to 28 November 2023, and used as a qualifying holiday home, but any property purchased in a trust post 28 November 2023 cannot under current legislation be exempt from VRLT except in its first year of purchase.

This article will give an in-depth discussion of each of the exemptions in Part 9 of the Act and how this will affect how you structure the purchase of your property.

1 – Holiday Home Exemption

Section 88A of the Act includes several prerequisites before VRLT may be exempt on a residential property. This includes:

1A – Owner of the land or a Vested Beneficiary of a trust?

Section 10 provides the definition of what an owner of land is and includes the following:

A vested beneficiary is provided under section 3 of the Act to mean a natural person, hence cannot be a corporation (however the amendments provide for this later), and has a vested beneficial interest in possession in the land or is the principal beneficiary of a special disability trust.

A vested beneficial interest is a common law concept which in relation to land and for the purposes of the Act requires a beneficiary who has a right to possess the land. This goes beyond merely listing a beneficiary as a class of person but rather requires the trust to entitle a person to that land.

1B – Used and occupied land in Australia as PPR – Used and occupied the land as a holiday home

This requires that the land or vested beneficiary of the land to have a principal place of residence in Australia. However, it should be noted that the greater the distance from the holiday home, the more relevant the factor in determining whether this is a holiday home or not for the purposes of ss 1B and 2. The principal place of residence is defined as the sole place of residence in section 3 of the Act and typically used to describe a person who occupies land as their home.

Additionally, the land needs to be occupied as a holiday home. Whether the land is a holiday home is subject to the discretion of the Commissioner of State Revenue and is discussed further in part 1C of this article.

1C – Discretion of the Commissioner of whether land is a holiday home or not

Subsection 2 describes the factors the Commissioner must have regard to in considering whether the land is being used as a holiday home. This includes:

In considering the purchase of a holiday home, you should consider whether an ordinary lay person would consider that the land is being used as a holiday home in regard to the factors above. Hence, a home located in Richmond that is purchased by an owner whose principal place of residence is located at Toorak is unlikely to qualify the house in Richmond for the Holiday Home exemption.

Contrastingly, if that person purchased a home in San Remo and used it once a year for a getaway, in the view of the Commissioner, it is likely this property will qualify for the Holiday Home exemption.

2 – Corporations and Trustees of Trusts

The Amending Act has changed the Holiday Home exemption with the introduction of new provisions to section 88A of the Act. Hence, companies and trustees of land may satisfy the VRLT exemption for holiday homes provided certain conditions are met. From 1 January 2025, sole shareholders of landowning companies or trustees of trusts may be eligible if:

One or more eligible natural persons used another property in Australia as their PPR in the preceding tax year and used and occupied the holiday home (whether continuous or aggregate) for 4 weeks in a calendar year as follows:

2A – Natural person who must occupy holiday home – Relatives and Specified Beneficiaries

Given the wide ambit of “relative” in the English language, the Act confines the definition of relative and therefore the natural person who may occupy the holiday home to:

A specified beneficiary, of a discretionary trust, is defined in section 3 of the Act to mean a beneficiary who is specifically named in the trust deed or specifically declared in writing pursuant to the trust deed as a beneficiary to or in whom, by the terms of the trust, the whole or any part of the trust income or property may be distributed or vested.

This gives rise to further considerations. The first is that you should carefully review your trust deed to see who the specified beneficiaries are. While the deed may use different wording such as “primary beneficiary” or “principal beneficiary”, the SRO ought to accept these beneficiaries as specified beneficiaries.

Further, the relative of a deceased specified beneficiary will still qualify for the holiday home exemption (assuming the specified beneficiary meets the requirements in s88A) under the new section 88AB. For example, if you occupy a home in San Remo as a holiday home where that holiday home has been beneficially owned by a close relative who is recently deceased, that home will still qualify for VRLT exemption under s88A.

2B – 28 November 2023 Deadline

Companies and trusts also need to note that only land owned prior to 28 November 2023 will qualify for the Holiday Home exemption from 1 January 2025. The home needs to be continuously owned from 28 November 2023 meaning that any change in ownership, brief or otherwise, means that the purported holiday home will not qualify for the exemption.

In regard to trusts, transfers between relatives or transfers for the purpose of making a change to the trustee following 28 November 2023 is permitted. As such, a transfer of a holiday home from a specified beneficiary to their spouse after 28 November 2023 is permitted.

2C – How to structure Trusts and Companies taking into regard the Holiday Home exemption

In the context of restructuring a company or trust, whether that be through a sale or not, the following should be taken into account if you want the Holiday Home exemption to apply to the property:

3 – Exemption for land used for purposes of attending place of business or employment

Another notable exemption you may consider for the purposes of VRLT is exemption for land occupied for the purposes of attending a place of business or employment. Land is exempt from VRLT if the owner of the land or a vested beneficiary of a trust to which the land is subject is:

Importantly, the Amending Act does not change this exemption to include companies or trustees of trusts such that residential properties owned by companies and trusts will not qualify for this exemption.

3A – Specified Geographical Area

Specified geographical area is defined in section 34D of the Act to mean all the areas of the municipal districts of the Councils listed in Schedule 2A. As such, this includes land that lies within the following councils:

3B – Use as a place of business or work

The property must have been used by the owner or a vested beneficiary as a place of business or employment.

For example, if you lived in Geelong but needed to travel to Melbourne CBD for at least 140 days in the year for your medical practice business and you own a residential property there, you will qualify for this exemption given you use that residential property in the CBD for the purpose of attending to your medical practice business.

4 – Land that has been transferred recently, becomes residential land or becomes residential land during the second year preceding tax year that has not been used or occupied or changed ownership

Other exemptions to the VRLT that may apply that you could consider include:

4A – Section 88C

The basic requirement for this exemption to be met is that land that has changed ownership in the preceding tax year is exempt from VRLT.

For example, if you purchase a property in 2024, that property will be exempt from VRLT in 2025.

4B – Section 88D

Land will be exempt from VRLT under this exemption if:

So if you were to purchase a block of apartments which at 1 January 2024 was a warehouse before it was converted, that land will be exempt from VRLT in 2025.

4C – Section 88E

In addition to 4B, land will be exempt from VRLT from two years preceding the tax year the land was converted into residential land. A further requirement is that from that period to the tax year, the land must not have been used or occupied and the land must not have changed ownership.

5 – Residential Land

It should be noted that for the purposes of Part 2 Division 6 of the Act, residential land does not include vacant land that does not have a house on it. Section 34B of the act outlines that land is residential land if it is capable of being used solely or primarily for residential purposes or:

6 – Conclusion

In regard to individuals, companies and trusts, these exemptions and changes introduced to the Amending Act are significant given the quantum involved with VRLT. As a reminder this is from 1-3% of the Capital Improved Value of the property.

Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact Tony Pointon or Andrew Pointon of our Taxation Team.

Temporary Changes to Off-the-Plan Duty Concessions

On 19 November 2024, the Duties Amendment (More Homes) Act 2024 (Vic) (‘ the Act’) received Royal Assent. The Act introduces temporary changes to the off-the-plan land transfer duty concession, providing more buyers with the opportunity to access greater stamp duty savings.

The Expanded Concession

The previous off-the-plan duty concession allowed first-home buyers and owner-occupiers to deduct construction costs from the dutiable value of the property when calculating stamp duty, where the value was below $750,000 (for first home buyers) and $550,000 (for owner-occupiers).

This meant that many purchasers were excluded from the existing concession, such as purchasers whose off-the-plan dutiable value exceeded the thresholds, or those who enter into contracts later during the construction phase of the development.

The new temporary changes include:

Under the expanded concession, purchasers will be able to deduct construction costs incurred on or after the contract date. The stamp duty will then be calculated on the reduced dutiable value of the property, meaning the duty payable will be based only on the land contract price.

Eligibility for the Expanded Concession

To be eligible, the property must be:

  1. A residential property consisting of a single dwelling; and
  2. One that is in a strata subdivision with a common property, such as a shared driveway, hallway or garden. Importantly, this means that purchasers of house and land packages or other dwellings that are not part of a strata subdivision will be illegible to claim the new concession.

Additionally, the contract of sale must be signed on or after 21 October 2024 and before 21 October 2025. If a contract was entered into before 21 October 2024, the purchaser will be ineligible for the new concession, even if the settlement occurs within the 12-month window.

Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact David Mazzeo of our Property Team.

Vacant Residential Land Tax Expansion and Key Changes for Property Owners in Victoria Starting January 2025

Owners of vacant properties outside of inner/middle Melbourne ought to know of an expansion to the Vacant Residential Land Tax (“VRLT”) starting from 1 January 2025. Starting next year, properties which are left unoccupied for more than 6 months for the preceding year in which the VRLT applies to, must notify the State Revenue Office of this vacancy and any applicable exemption by 15 January 2025 through their online portal.

This now applies to all properties in Victoria, regardless of whether they are in inner/middle Melbourne.

What is the VRLT?

As a refresher, VRLT is a tax upon the Capital Improved Value (‘CIV’) of a residential property which starts at 1% of the CIV of the property and increases sequentially to up to 3% over subsequent years.

Example 1

Your property in Ocean Grove was owned, not as your principal residence, in 2024, and was assessed for VRLT of 1% of the CIV which was $1,000,000. Due to this, you will be subject to a $10,000 VRLT and land tax of $4,650 for 2025 unless you occupied it for more than 6 months or for more than four weeks as a holiday home by yourself and/or relative and make application for VRLT exemption.

If the property is still vacant for more than 6 months in 2025 and 2026, the VRLT will increase to 2% and 3% for those years respectively. In 2026 and 2027, you will be subject to VRLT of $20,000 and $30,000, respectively, unless an exception applies.

What is the Change to the VRLT?

From 1 January 2018 to 31 December 2024, the VRLT only applied to residential properties in inner and middle Melbourne that was vacant for more than 6 months in the preceding year. However starting from 1 January 2025, all properties in Victoria, regardless of whether they are located in inner/middle Melbourne, or not, will be subject to VRLT.

Notification Requirement

Importantly, given the deadline is coming up soon, if you believe that your residential property is subject to VRLT, you will need to notify the SRO by 15 January 2025 if you own land in Victoria and that land is vacant for more than 6 months. You can do so through the SRO’s online portal.

A failure to notify the SRO by the deadline will be considered a notification default and you may be subject to penalty tax of:

Exemptions

Holiday Home Exemption

Owners or vested beneficiaries of trusts that own the home may qualify for VRLT exemption if they occupied the home for at least 4 weeks in a calendar year and they have a principal place of residence in Australia.

Example 2

Mark lives in the US and owns a holiday home in Mildura. In 2024, he used the holiday home for 5 weeks. In 2025, Mark will be subject to VRLT given that his principal place of residence is in the US.

Nathan has lived in Brisbane for several years and owns a holiday home in Altona. He uses this holiday home for 9 weeks of the 2024 year. Nathan will not be subject to VRLT in 2025 as he is a resident of Australia and has used the home for more than 4 weeks in the 2024 year.

Whether the exemption applies is up to the discretion of the Commissioner of State Revenue. As such, the Commissioner will have regard to:

A notable change to this exception is that from 1 January 2025, a relative of the owner or a relative of the vested beneficiary can satisfy the 4 week use and occupation requirements. Further, from 1 January 2025, companies or trustees of a trust will be eligible for the holiday home exception provided they have owned the home since 28 November 2023, there have been no changes in beneficial ownership of the land since November 2023 and a natural person has used the property as their PPR in the preceding tax year and occupied it for 4 weeks.

Change of Ownership

A property subject to VRLT may qualify for the change of ownership exemption for the current calendar year provided that the property has changed ownership in the preceding year.

Example 3

Anne owns a home in Bendigo which she purchased in 2023. She has not occupied the home at all. Anne will not be subject to VRLT in 2024 as the home had changed ownership in 2023.

The Property becomes Residential Land

There are two notable sub-exemptions worth discussing here. First, land that becomes residential land for a calendar year will not be subject to VRLT in the subsequent year.

Additionally, where land has become residential land and the land has not been used or occupied and the ownership of the land remains unchanged, VRLT will not apply for up to 2 tax years following the change to residential land.

Work Accommodation Exception

This exemption applies to owners of land or vested beneficiaries of trusts to which the land is subject provided they:

Example 4

Jason lives in Geelong but he is required to work 4 days a week in Maribyrnong. Jason owns a home in Maribyrnong which he uses while working there and used it for more than 140 days a year. Due to this, his home in Maribyrnong is not subject to VRLT in the subsequent year.

Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon of our Taxation Team.

Matching the Settlement Receipts to the CGT Liability: Returning CGT and Remission of Interest Applications in Respect of Delayed Property Developments

In the case of delayed property settlements that are on capital account and subject to Capital Gains Tax, these taxpayers should be aware of taxation consequences for delayed settlements as well as how these issues may be circumvented. The payment of CGT tax may arise well before the receipt of sale proceeds at settlement.

Our Taxation team have frequently given advice on the taxation consequences in delayed property settlements and have successfully enabled clients to delay their taxation responsibilities until the settlement proceeds are available.  As such, this article will discuss:

ATO’s Treatment of Delayed Property Settlements

During the sale of a property, there are two notable events; the execution of the contract where both parties agree to the sale, and the settlement date where the property is transferred to the buyer. The completion of the contract usually takes place at the time of settlement where the purchaser hands over the monies over to the vendor and title is transferred from the vendor to the purchaser.

Ordinarily CGT event A1 applies to when the CGT asset, the property, is disposed of, this would be during the contract date. Section 104.10(3) Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 states that the time of the event is when “you enter into the contract for the disposal”. Therefore, the CGT event occurs when you enter into the contract of sale. Due to this, the capital gain made from the property must ordinarily be included in the income year in which the contract has been entered into. For example, if a contract for the sale of land is entered into on 31 May 2023 and settled on 31 July 2027, CGT will be assessed on the year ending 30 June 2023.

However because the proceeds received by the taxpayer for the sale often occurs after the contract is signed, often over a period of several years, the vendor would not have received the capital proceeds to pay tax related to the sale of the property. This is especially concerning when the vendor has invested significant capital into the development of the property meaning they would have little to no funds to pay the capital gains tax that arises when they enter into the contract.

Another issue is that per section 5.15 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, interests accrues on the unpaid CGT daily for the unpaid amount. This is a significant expense especially when the settlement date has been delayed for months or years at a time. As a reminder, the current General Interest Charge rates are 10.46% annually or 0.0287% if calculated daily.

It seems that the vendor has two options here:

How this issue may be avoided and interest remitted entirely

A method to circumvent this issue is not found in legislation but rather the taxation determinations and rulings provided by the ATO. It should be noted that although these rulings and determinations include references to provisions that have been replaced or repealed, they are still binding on the ATO.

Taxation Determination 94/89 acknowledges that a taxpayer is not required to include any capital gains in the appropriate year, when they enter into the contract, until an actual change of ownership occurs. Further, when settlement occurs, the taxpayer is then required to include any capital gains in the year of income in which the contract was made.

What this means is that if a contract of sale of land is entered into on 31 May 2023 and settled on 31 July 2027, the CGT event does not need to be declared on the year ending 30 June 2023 but rather the vendor/taxpayer can amend their returns for that income year following the settlement on 31 July 2027. Resultantly, the taxpayer would not need to pay CGT during the income year when they entered into the contract and the capital proceeds have not been paid.

Despite this, interest still accrues under the former section 170AA(1). Taxation Ruling 94/29 states that the discretion under former section 170AA(11) would be exercised to remit interest in full where requests for amendment are lodged, and where relevant, self-amendments are made within a reasonable time after the date of settlement.

Usually, the ATO considers that a period of one month following settlement to be a reasonable time after settlement. No specific guidance has been provided to indicate what else a reasonable time is if the vendor is experiencing fails to amend their returns within the one month period. However, our opinion is that this will be assessed on a case-by-case basis of each taxpayer’s individual circumstances if they fail to meet that one month timeline following settlement and reference may be had to PSLA 2006/8. As such, it would be appropriate for vendors/taxpayers to amend their returns as soon as possible following settlement to avoid paying any interest that accrues as a result of the delayed sale of property.

Takeaway

Where the one month rule is not met, then consideration needs to be made for an application for remission to the ATO under PSLA 2006/8.

Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact Anthony Pointon of our Taxation Team.

Retail tenant obtains injunction, preventing landlord from terminating lease and subdividing premises pursuant to demolition clause

A recent VCAT decision[1] provides helpful guidance for landlords, tenants and developers about the ability of landlords to rely on demolition clauses to terminate retail leases.

What is a ‘demolition clause’?

A demolition clause is a clause permitting a landlord to terminate a lease prior to the expiry its term if the landlord decides to demolish, or substantially renovate, the leased premises.  Such clauses are, in our experience, relatively common in well-drafted leases.

Demolition clauses in retail leases must be read subject to section 56 of the Retail Leases Act 2003 (the Act), which provides:

‘Demolition’ is defined in sub-section 56(7) of the Act as including “any substantial repair, renovation or reconstruction of the building that cannot practicably be carried out without vacant possession of the premises.”

Facts

The tenant leased a shop (the Premises), inside the Bacchus Marsh Village Shopping Centre from the landlord.  The tenant operated a remedial massage clinic from the Premises.

The landlord served a demolition notice (the Notice) on the tenant, notifying it that the landlord intended to redevelop the centre, and that its redevelopment would involve the termination of the lease and the subdivision of the Premises into two new tenancies.

The tenant applied to the Tribunal for an interlocutory injunction preventing the landlord from acting on the Notice.  The tenant relied on 3 grounds in support of its application:

The Decision

Deputy President Reigler, in granting the tenant’s application for an injunction, held that on the evidence before him, the works proposed to be undertaken by the landlord did not constitute ‘demolition’ within the meaning of section 56(7) of the Act.

The injunction preserves the status quo, and means that the landlord cannot terminate the lease unless and until the matter can be finally determined at trial.

Demolition?

The Tribunal considered the dictionary definition of the term ‘demolition’, ‘renovate’ and ‘reconstruct’ before ultimately deciding that:

“[31]…. the concept of demolition including substantial repair renovation or reconstruction is different to the concept of redevelopment… Clearly, the concept of redevelopment encompasses bringing something to a more advanced or developed state, which could incorporate changing the Premises from a single leasehold into two separate leaseholds.

[32] … the concept of demolition including any substantial repair, renovation or reconstruction is premised on the subject building requiring building work, either because of disrepair or dilapidation , or the requirement to otherwise reinstate it to its original form.  Subdividing leased premises, and the work incidental to that objective, appears to fall outside of what is contemplated by the concept of demolition.”

Landlord’s motivation and the duty of good faith?

In some good news for landlords and developers, the Tribunal found that a landlord’s commercial objectives or motivations for seeking to terminate the lease were “largely irrelevant” and that what is relevant “is whether there is a genuine proposal to demolish”.

In support of this proposition Deputy President Riegler relied on authority from the New South Wales Supreme Court in the case of Blacker v Felpure Pty Ltd[2] where it was held:

“[61] It is not my view open to contention by the whether the [landlord’s] decision to demolish, repair, renovate or reconstruct the building is reasonable or appropriate; it is sufficient if it is a genuine proposal.  Nor in my opinion is it open to debate whether the could in some way modify the [landlord’s] proposal so as to continue to accommodate the lessee after the premises have been demolished, repaired, renovated or reconstructed.  The opportunity to break a lease, retake possession and take advantage of the demolition clause is a contractual opportunity made available to the by the terms of the lease itself, including the provisions notionally incorporated by , it is not injurious to the [landlord’s] position whether the has decided to take that advantage, and it is not relevant that the has in view occupying the premises itself, or selling them after reconstruction, or leasing them again…

Key takeaways

1. Landlords should ensure a demolition clause is included in all leases. The ability to terminate a lease in accordance with a demolition clause is valuable, particularly if the premises has development potential.

2. When a decision is made to terminate a lease in reliance on a demolition clause, landlords should ensure tenants are provided with a carefully drafted demolition notice that provides sufficient details of the proposed works, to show that the proposal:

3. When considering acquiring a development site, developers should be alive to the prospect of recovering vacant possession in reliance upon a demolition clause without having to wait for a lease to run its term.

4. Tenants should be aware of and seek appropriate advice in relation to their rights under s 56 of the Act when a landlord purports to serve a demolition notice, including their rights to:

Please contact Pointon Partners’ disputes or property lawyers with any query in relation this article, or with any query in relation to a retail-leasing dispute.

[1] Zen Holistic Health Group Pty Ltd v Bacchus Marsh Centre Pty Ltd (Building and Property) [2022] VCAT 716

[2] [1999] NSWSC 958, [61]; cited with approval in Skiwing Pty Ltd v Trust Co of Australia (trading as Stockland Property Management) [2006] NSWCA 276.