RESTRUCTURING- PART 3: THE BASIC BUILDING BLOCKS
Welcome to Part 3 of our restructuring series.
In Part 1 we looked at basic factual and issues and special issues that can influence the best structure and in Part 2 we analysed in table form how these issues worked for each structural component, be it a trust or company.
For any structure, the basic building blocks need to be understood in respect of their commercial and taxation factors relating to them.
The most basic is the use of a company as a building block with a discretionary trust owning shares, which is best described in diagram 1 in the attachment below together with key factors:
DIAGRAM 1
The second most basic is the use of a discretionary trust as set out in the diagram 2 in the attachment below together with key factors:
DIAGRAM 2
In relation to the Restructuring, we have developed significant expertise and welcome your enquires. Please do not hesitate to contact Anthony Pointon or Felicity Cara-Carson and Michael Bishop to discuss.
RESTRUCTURING- PART 2: ANALYSIS OF STRUCTURE COMPONENTS
Welcome to Part 2 of our restructure series.
We have discussed in Part 1 of this series, why restructuring is so common and so important to consider for all businesses including asset protection reasons. We discussed the basic factual issues and special issues that can influence the best structure for a business.
Here we analyse all the structural components for various commercial and taxation considerations in a table form for ease of reference:
|
Primary Individual |
Spouse |
Disc Trust (DT) |
Unity Trust w/Ind Unitholders |
Unit Trust w/DT Unitholders |
Company with Ind S/holders |
Company with DT S/holders |
Part’ship Of DTs |
| Asset Protection |
x |
√ |
√ |
x |
√ |
x |
√ |
x (9) |
| Flexibility of Distribution |
x |
x |
√ |
x |
√ |
x |
√ |
√ |
| Access to Cash |
√ |
√ |
√(1) |
√(1) |
√(1) |
x |
x |
√ |
| Access to 30% tax rate or less |
x |
x |
√(2) |
x |
√ |
√ |
√ |
√(2) |
| CGT 50% discount |
√ |
√ |
√ |
√ |
√ |
x (6) |
x (6) |
√ |
| SB CGT 50% Discount |
√ |
√ |
√ |
√(4) |
√(5) |
√(7) |
√(7) |
√ |
| CGT Retirement |
√ |
√ |
√(3) |
√(3) |
x |
√(8) |
x |
√ |
| Privacy of accounts |
√ |
√ |
√ |
√ |
√ |
x (10) |
x (10) |
√ |
Notes:
- If there is a corporate beneficiary in the relevant year of income, subject to entry into of a Div. 7A loan agreement or creation of a sub-trust: TR 2010/3;
- If use corporate beneficiary;
- Subject to distributions in year of sale;
- Cost base reduction when distributed;
- Available to unit trust, but not to unitholders, unless unit trust wound up within 12 months of the sale or the disposal of the active business;
- Shareholders may get when sell shares;
- Company entitled if 90% or more of shares traced to “significant individuals” and their “CGT concession stakeholders”, but cannot distribute tax free, unless company is wound up within 12 months;
- Subject to significant individuals;
- For small business CGT relief it is necessary that there is a “significant individual” so that person will need to get at least 20% of the gain in the year it is made. If that person is the “at risk” person, then asset protection is not available. If it is the spouse of the “at risk” person who is the significant individual, then asset protection can be achieved in relation to the distribution of the gain;
- Audit and disclosure via ASIC required if large propriety company.
In relation to the Restructuring, we have developed significant expertise and welcome your enquires. Please do not hesitate to contact Anthony Pointon or Felicity Cara-Carson and Michael Bishop to discuss.
RESTRUCTURING- PART 1: PURSUING THE PERFECT STRUCTURE
Welcome to our restructuring series.
Asset protection is a major driver of restructuring and involves different components of your business separating from each other and also separating your assets from your business risks.
All businesses begin at a time where circumstances of that moment determine the structure chosen. As businesses develop, it is important to regularly review what its requirements are currently and going forward and to restructure to meet these requirements.
Before looking into how you move from one structure to another, it is important to identify the commercial and taxation factual issues in respect of the business’ requirements.
The basic commercial and taxation factual issues are as follows:
- Asset protection, including separating business risk from other assets.
- Access to cash:
- Dividends/distributions;
- Loans.
- Corporate tax rate 30% (or less).
- Flexibility of distributions; income splitting.
- Ability for “partners” to come and go.
- Is there planned to be a gain made on the sale of the business or other assets.
- Privacy of financial information.
- Ability to offer equity to employees.
In addition to the basic factual issues, there are many special issues which may have a bearing on the choice of business structure e.g.:
- avoiding or delaying stamp duty on property development or investment in landholders, and different duties in different States;
- structuring property development so passive land owners can retain CGT treatment on their gain;
- preserving pre-CGT status for as long as possible e.g. avoiding change in “majority underlying interest” of entities;
- delaying the taxing point for a long as possible e.g. by the use of options and other methods;
- the use of “earnouts” when buying or selling a business, and ensuring the tax liability isn’t incurred before the proceeds are received;
- dividend access shares, and companies that start with multiple classes of shares with discretionary rights, so as to mimic a discretionary trust;
- expanding the business into overseas markets, and
- seeking deferral of Australian tax where foreign tax can be minimized; or
- seeking a credit for foreign tax in the hands of ultimate owners, where foreign tax is still significant.
- “exit” planning for overseas operations, including principals becoming non-residents and potentially taking gains free of tax;
- succession and asset protection planning using trusts, onshore and offshore; and
- use of South Australian or offshore trusts to avoid having to vest in 80 years.
In relation to the Restructuring, we have developed significant expertise and welcome your enquires. Please do not hesitate to contact Anthony Pointon or Felicity Cara-Carson and Michael Bishop to discuss.
31 December 2020 Deadline for Amending Discretionary Trusts Which Hold Residential land in NSW
If a discretionary trust (therefore a special trust) holds residential land in New South Wales the trust will be liable for additional land tax and stamp duty purchaser stamp duty if any one of the potential beneficiaries is a foreign person. To avoid these additional charges a discretionary trust needs to exclude foreign persons as a discretionary beneficiary and include a provision that the trust cannot be amended to result in a foreign person being a potential beneficiary. The change must be done before midnight on 31 December 2020.
Surcharge purchaser duty (8%) applies to acquisitions of NSW residential land by foreign persons, and surcharge land tax (2%) applies to foreign persons who are owners of residential land in NSW. Surcharge purchaser duty and surcharge land tax (together, the foreign surcharges) are payable in addition to any other duty or land tax payable.
For transactions dated on or after 1 July 2017, the new rate of surcharge duty is 8 percent on top of the usual transfer duty.
Where an interest in a property is acquired directly or indirectly by or held through a discretionary trust, the trustee of the trust may be liable for foreign surcharges if any one of the potential beneficiaries is a foreign person.
Each beneficiary in a discretionary trust is deemed to have the maximum percentage interest in the income or property over which the trustee may exercise a discretion to distribute.
Potential beneficiaries are not limited to persons named in the trust instrument. The term extends to the members of any class of persons to whom or for whose benefit trust property can be distributed or applied pursuant to the exercise of the discretions of the trustee under the trust.
Potential beneficiaries are often nominated by class rather than name for a number of reasons. They could be foreign persons for the purposes of surcharge purchaser duty and surcharge land tax. In such circumstances, it follows that the trustee of a discretionary trust will be a foreign person.
A person is a ‘potential beneficiary’ of a discretionary trust if the exercise or failure to exercise a discretion under the terms of the trust can result in any property of the trust being distributed to or applied for the benefit of the person.
To avoid being a foreign trustee, the discretionary trust must meet both of the following requirements:
- no potential beneficiary of the trust is a foreign person (the “no foreign beneficiary requirement”); and
- the terms of the trust must not be capable of amendment in a manner that would result in a foreign person being a potential beneficiary (the “no amendment requirement”).
If the trustee of a discretionary trust is liable for surcharge purchaser duty on a transfer of dutiable property that occurred before 24 June 2020 or after that date but before midnight on 31 December 2020, the trustee will still not be liable if the terms of the trust have been amended before midnight on 31 December 2020. If surcharge purchaser duty was paid, the trustee is entitled to a refund if the amendment is made before midnight on 31 December 2020.
If the trustee of a discretionary trust is liable to pay surcharge land tax in respect of the 2017, 2018, 2019 and/or 2020 land tax year, the trustee will still not be liable if the terms of the trust have been amended before due date for the payment of land tax or after the due date but before midnight on 31 December 2020. If surcharge land tax was paid, the trustee is entitled to a refund if the amendment is made before midnight on 31 December 2020.
If, before 24 June 2020, a special trust satisfied the no foreign beneficiary requirement under section 104JA of the Duties Act 1997 or section 5D of the Land Tax Act 1956, the trustee will be exempt from surcharge purchaser duty and surcharge land tax without having to satisfy the no amendment requirement.
You’re generally considered a foreign person, unless:
- you’re an Australian citizen
- you’ve lived in Australia for more than 200 days in the 12 months before the purchase date, and you’re:
- a New Zealand Citizen, who holds a subclass 444 visa or
- a permanent resident of Australia.
For further advice contact Simon Della Marta, Partner from our Sydney office on (02) 9790 0640 or 0416 295 925.
Heard it through the grapevine: Facebook defamation suit between congregation members leads to >$200,000 judgment
A string of recent, high profile defamation decisions, for example those involving actors Rebel Wilson and Geoffrey Rush, have shown that Courts are prepared to award significant damages to successful complainants. But it is important to remember that defamation disputes are not exclusively between celebrities and the print and television media. Disputes, particularly those within community groups, churches, sporting or industry bodies, can and often do play out on social media and can give rise to defamation actions.
Gayed v Abdelmak [2020] VCC 1814, a recent decision of the County Court of Victoria, illustrates that defamatory publications via social media platforms can have enormous consequences.
What you need to know
The plaintiff borrowed $30,000 from an associate within his Church congregation, and was awarded more than $200,000 (including costs) after the associate accused him on social media of being a “scammer”, “liar” and a thief” when his family’s café business failed and he was unable to pay back the loan.
The “grapevine effect” within the Church congregation and the damage to the plaintiff’s reputation caused by the posts, which the Court found imputed that the plaintiff was dishonest, were serious factors and justified the significant award of damages.
The Facts
- The plaintiff and the defendant were each members of a particular Church congregation.
- The plaintiff’s son had purchased a café business, which subsequently encountered financial difficulty.
- The defendant, who had previously supported members of the congregation in need, loaned the plaintiff $30,000 to assist with the café business.
- Despite the loan, the café business ultimately ceased to operate and entered liquidation and the plaintiff failed to repay the defendant.
- The defendant, using his wife’s Facebook account, posted a series of Facebook posts in which he:
- made allegations that the plaintiff had deceived him and was asking the entire congregation at their Church for money;
- stated that the plaintiff (and his family) were “thieves” that the Court needed to deal with;
- called the plaintiff a “scammer”, “thief”, “liar” and “a disgrace” and stated that “he owes everyone money”; and
- implied that the Church’s priest was aware of his dealings with the plaintiff and the fact that the plaintiff had been asking the congregation for money.
- (the Posts)
- The Court found (following contested evidence) that the Posts:
- were marked ‘Public’;
- remained visible for approximately 2 months from their publication (and were ‘liked’ and ‘shared’ by at least 20 persons);
- were “intentionally directed to the Church congregation”;
- had led to the plaintiff feeling he could no longer attend Church (and from which he absented himself for approximately 1 year); and
- had had a detrimental effect on not only the plaintiff, but also his family.
- While there was no dispute that the plaintiff owed the defendant money, and had not paid it back, the plaintiff sued the defendant in defamation seeking damages, focussing on imputations of dishonesty alleged to have been conveyed in the Posts.
- The defendant initially sought to defend the case brought by the plaintiff on the grounds that the imputations arising from the Posts were true or were an honest opinion.
- The defences were subsequently abandoned by the defendant and the trial proceeded as an assessment of damages only.
- While the defendant had offered an apology, the apology offered was not a “full and unqualified withdrawal of the defamatory comments”.
The Decision
His Honour Judge Smith (at [14]) clarified that there are three purposes for awarding damages in a defamation claim:
- Consolation for the personal distress and hurt caused to the plaintiff by the publications;
- Reparation for the harm done to the plaintiff’s personal and (if relevant) business reputation; and
- Vindication of the plaintiff’s reputation – the amount awarded is the minimum necessary to signal that vindication to the public.
His Honour (at [72]) found that the “defamatory sting” of the Posts was plainly serious and stated:
I am satisfied in a relatively tight religious and cultural community such as the community of Melbourne, the “grapevine” effect arising from the publications would have been substantial. Members of the community who had read the posts or had them brought to their attention were high likely to discuss them or bring them to the attention of other members.
In relation to the fact that the plaintiff was in fact indebted to the defendant, His Honour at [76] held:
It may be correct that owes money to the defendant and possibly, to others. But that is not to say that he is a thief or is dishonest. Many people, for a variety of reasons, encounter hard times financially; many companies are wound up for a variety of reasons; many persons are unable to pay debts when due; many require financial assistance from time to time. These are concepts which are not indicative of dishonesty…
The plaintiff was ultimately awarded damages in the sum of $120,000, together with interest of $8,473.35 and costs fixed at $85,000. Importantly, the plaintiff did not seek an award of aggravated damages which may have increased the award of damages.
The case serves as a useful reminder that users of social media need to be aware of the potential consequences of posting comments which may offend or aggrieve one of more individuals. Defamation claims arise not only in the national media and at the “big end of town”, where they are seen, perhaps, as a cost of doing business, but can also significantly affect smaller communities with more modest levels of publication of information. Relative to the parties’ financial resources, community and grassroots defamations can have much higher stakes for the parties involved.
Pointon Partners can and has previously assisted both plaintiffs and defendants in relation to defamation proceedings.
Vendor continuing to be employed post-settlement; the interplay between the Sale of Business/Sale of Shares Agreement Restraints and the Employment Contract Restraints
We are increasingly acting in transactions where the purchaser is requiring that the vendor, or the vendors if more than one, continue to be employed in the business post settlement. This is a function of the knowledge oriented nature of today’s economy where value lies in intangibles such as specialized skills, knowledge, reputation and relationships with clients.
In many business transactions today what purchasers are really acquiring are the people whereas in past decades value may have been in tangible assets such as plant, equipment and leasehold or freehold interests used to conduct the business.
Purchasers of knowledge based businesses today will often try to eliminate risk by including earn out provisions in the transaction documents tying the quantum of consideration to the financial performance of the business over a specified period post settlement. For instance, one to three years. From the purchaser’s perspective this helps to ensure that the vendors remain incentivized to continue to manage the business in the manner it was pre settlement and allow the purchaser sufficient time to cement relationships with key clients and stakeholders.
However to provide the purchaser additional comfort and protections the transaction documents will also contain restrictive covenants seeking to prohibit the vendors from damaging key relationships which the business has if the vendor does depart the business, either voluntarily by resignation or even if the termination is at the initiative of the new owner of the business. For instance, if the working relationship between such parties has broken down.
The restrictive covenants are generally of three forms:
- a non-compete clause seeking to prevent someone from operating in the industry generally for a specified period of time following the termination of employment or a settlement of a sale of business or sale of shares.
- a non-solicitation of clients clause.
- a non-solicitation of employees clause.
At law the prima facie position is that any restraint of trade provision is invalid and the onus rests on the party seeking to enforce it to demonstrate that it is reasonable in all the circumstances. In terms of the question of reasonableness, regard must be had to the geographical scope of the restriction and the time period it purports to operate for.
Courts are more inclined to uphold some terms of restraint more readily than they are with others. For instance, as a general proposition a non-solicitation of clients clause will be more readily upheld by a court than a general non-complete clause. And non-solicitation of employee clauses are notoriously difficult to enforce due to the difficulty in quantifying the exact loss occasioned by the movement of an employee to another business. Though NSW courts do appear more amenable to upholding non-solicitation of employee clauses than Victorian courts.
To add to the complexity, what a court may view as reasonable in one form transaction document may be regarded as unreasonable and unenforceable in one of the other transaction documents even if the drafting is broadly the same. For instance, a non-compete clause in a sale of assets/sale of shares agreement prohibiting the vendor from working in the same industry for say three years post completion may be viewed by a court as entirely reasonable, whereas a non-compete clause contained in the employment contract of the vendor prohibiting them from competing for say three years (or even a much lesser period such as three to six months) following the termination of employment may have very little prospect of standing up in court.
The different approach adopted by the Courts is very much linked to the fact that any form of restraint is easier to uphold if person bound by the restraint has received some consideration for entering into it.
The situation is complicated even further by the fact that what might be reasonable in relation to a major shareholder vendor may be unreasonable if applied to a minority shareholder vendor who may be receiving minimal consideration for the sale of their shares. For instance, employee shareholders who may have acquired shares as part of an employee share program. It might be entirely legitimate to impose a general non-compete clause upon a major shareholder vendor whereas in the case of a minority employee shareholder it may be that the best that can be achieved is a non-solicitation of clients clause applying for a specified period of time post completion and for up to twelve months following the termination of employment.
Another instance where difficulties can arise even in the case of majority shareholder vendors is if the purchaser seeks to impose a general non-compete covenant upon such vendor in their employment contract following the termination of employment. That non-compete clause can therefore potentially spring into operation at a time after the non-compete clause in the sale agreement has expired. There is a risk therefore that a court will regard the purchaser as overreaching and will strike down the non-compete clause in the employment agreement on the basis that the purchaser is already adequately protected by the restraint in the sale agreement.
Given all of the above, the negotiation and inclusion restrictive covenants in sale agreements and the associated employment agreements if the vendors are remaining with the business require careful analysis and consideration.
If you have any queries regarding the above, please feel free to contact Michael Bishop, Anthony Pointon and Felicity Cara-Carson.
Not for Profit entities – what legal structure should be used?
Our team members at Pointon Partners are regularly requested by clients to establish not for profit bodies. The activities proposed to be undertaken may be charitable in nature, community oriented or the body may be being established to operate as a sporting club. Or possibly to act as a peak sporting body to represent the interests of or oversee the activities of a number of sporting clubs which will be members of the peak body.
We thought it would be useful to provide a snapshot of the different legal structures available and which type of body may be suitable, depending upon the activities to be conducted.
1. Charitable Trust
One of the oldest types of legal structure with a history dating back centuries. Quite a flexible structure and which is established by way of a trust deed. Can have one or more individuals acting as trustees or alternatively a company can be incorporated to act as trustee. Quite a good structure to use if the charity is going to be associated with or controlled by one individual rather than being more democratic in nature. The trust deed we have developed also provides for such an individual to be named as the “Patron” of the charity. Applications can be made:
- with the Australian Charities & Not for Profits Commission, to have it included on its register;
- with the ATO for tax exempt status; or
- with the ATO for deductible gift recipient status (‘DGR status’), though obtaining this status is not necessarily easy and involves demonstrating that the activities conducted by the charity fall within particular categories specified in legislation.
The charity may also be required to register with Consumer Affairs Victoria under the Fundraising Act if it is raising more than $20,000 per annum from the public each year.
2. Private ancillary fund
A private ancillary fund is a private philanthropic vehicle typically established and operated by a high net worth individual or family. Private ancillary funds do not carry out charitable activities themselves on a day to day basis but instead act as a sieve through which the high net wealth individual or family is able to stream donations to charities which have their own DGR status. In fact they are the only charities to whom the private ancillary fund can make donations to. The high net wealth individual is able to obtain an immediate tax deduction for making a donation to the private ancillary fund. Hence we occasionally see private ancillary funds being established in say the year when a successful business is sold and the individual or family may otherwise be liable for a significant capital gains tax bill.
Private ancillary funds are completely creatures of statute and have to comply with strict requirements in relation to:
- the form of trust deed;
- only operating in Australia;
- distributing at least 5% of their net assets each year;
- dealing at arms length with the founder and their associates; and
- having at least one trustee, or if a corporate trustee is acting then at least one director, who is a “responsible person”. This is defined as someone with a degree of responsibility to the Australian community as a whole (eg because they perform a public function or belong to a professional body which has a code of ethics) and includes an individual before whom a Statutory Declaration can be made.
Provided that the above requirements are satisfied then upon registration with the ATO the fund is automatically granted DGR status without separate application having to be made.
3. Public Ancillary Fund
Somewhat similar to a private ancillary fund in that it operates as a sieve through which donations can be made to charities which do have DGR status. However as the name suggests the rules of the fund must reflect that the public are to be invited to contribute.
Public ancillary funds can be established by way of a deed of trust or a Will though the ATO also provides a model trust deed which may be used.
Public ancillary funds have to comply with rules regarding:
- the trustee, which will generally be a constitutional corporation;
- it operating on a not for profit basis and it being registered with the Australian Charities and Not for Profits Commission;
- a majority of the directors of the trustee must be “responsible persons”; and
- it must distribute at least 4% of its net assets each year.
4. Incorporated associations
This is a structure commonly used by local sporting clubs and community groups. Though it can also be used by a charity and particularly if the intent is for the charity to be democratic in nature and have members as opposed to merely donors. The incorporated association is established pursuant to the Associations Incorporation Reform Act (Vic) Application is made to Consumer Affairs Victoria for registration. Consumer Affairs Victoria provides a form of model rules which may be used. These can departed from but if so then then the rules of the incorporated association have to address specific requirements set out in the legislation.
5. Public company limited by guarantee
This is a structure established pursuant to the Corporations Act and commonly used by peak sporting bodies, whether at a state or federal level. It is also regularly used by larger sporting clubs such as private sandbelt golf clubs. It is also often used as a structure for the running of large scale not for profit events such as the Melbourne Food & Wine Festival.
Conclusion
Pointon Partners does have significant experience in:
- advising on which legal structure ought be adopted by a not for profit venture;
- establishing the structure including drafting of its constitution, trust deed or rules;
- advising on and drafting any subsequent amendments to the constitution, trust deed or rules;
- advising on applications for tax exempt status, DGR status or applications pursuant to the Fundraising Act;
- advising on corporate governance issues affecting not for profit entities; and
- transitioning the body to a new legal structure if the old one has passed its use by date.
Our lawyers also have extensive hands on experience in managing the affairs of not for profit entities as board or committee members.
Michael Bishop has been a committee member of the Eyes for Africa Charitable Foundation for over ten years and the President of the Mornington Peninsula Athletic Club for the last three years.
Tony Pointon was a board member of the Melbourne Food & Wine Festival between 2005 and 2014, chair of the corporate governance committee during that period and the firm remains as legal counsel. He is also current Chairman of Laworld, a not for profit association of approaching sixty legal firms with over 1200 lawyers.
If you require any assistance in relation to the establishment or operation of a not for profit entity then please feel free to contact Michael Bishop or Tony Pointon.
Don’t Pay Twice! Business Email Compromise
If you pay a debt to the wrong account because of a fraud you could well be required to pay twice.
In the past three years losses due to business email compromise have risen from $3.8 million[1] to $132 million[2].
Typically such frauds take the form of a “man in the middle” attack where fraudsters insert themselves between a business making a payment (payer) and the intended recipient (payee). Access to email credentials can be gained in a number of ways, including by an email phishing attack. The fraudsters then send an email changing the account details of the intended payment to an account they control. Once the payment is made the funds are immediately forwarded on in ways that elude tracing. The two innocent businesses are then left to deal with the loss.
Increased awareness of the risk of such scams has resulted in:
- better email credential protection using unique complex passwords that are regularly changed;
- greater awareness of email phishing attacks;
- verification of payee account information and changes by telephone;
- offering of specialised “cyber” insurance policies or increased cover to manage such risks.
Litigation generally occurs when the payer refuses to make what they regard as further payment and the payee sues on the basis that the fraudulent payment has not discharged the original obligation.
In Australia a number of instances of such fraud are working their way through the Courts, but none have yet resulted in superior court judgments.
In a case in the United Kingdom last year, the High Court refused leave to appeal from a GAFTA Board of Appeal, effectively upholding the contractual analysis of risk carried out by the Board. A JLex note of the case[3] referred to the possibility that a future case might address the issue of whether fault could displace contractual allocation of risk. In the UK case the evidence did not establish that compromise of the emails was the fault of either party.
In Australia, however, the starting point for analysis is set out in Federal and State legislation which effectively provides:
…. unless otherwise agreed between the purported originator and the addressee of an electronic communication, the purported originator of the electronic communication is bound by that communication only if the communication was sent by the purported originator or with the authority of the purported originator[4].
In this context, the term “purported originator” means the person from whom an electronic communication, such as an email, appears to have been sent.
The effect of this provision is that a person from whom an electronic communication appears to have been sent will be bound by that communication only if the communication was actually sent by that person or with his or her authority.
So, for example, if a purchaser of goods receives an email advising of an account number to which the purchaser should transfer funds in payment, and the email has in fact been sent by a fraudster who has provided a false account number, a payment made by the purchaser to that false account will not discharge the purchaser’s payment obligation. That is, the vendor won’t be bound by that payment, because the email was not actually sent by the vendor or with his or her authority.
In short therefore, unless the parties agree otherwise, the risk is with the purchaser and he or she may have to pay a second time if the validity of the first payment is challenged by the vendor.
Pointon Partners can assist in drafting contractual terms that alter the above position and shift the risk of business email compromise. This may be appropriate where:
- a specialised form of communication which reduces such risk has been agreed between the parties and they wish to enable each other to rely upon communications through such channel; or
- Insurers require that contractual documents alter the allocation of risk under the legislation.
Please contact Andrew Cox or Simon Della Marta of our office should you have any enquiries regarding the above.
[1] https://www.accc.gov.au/media-release/australian-businesses-hit-hard-by-email-scams
[2] https://www.scamwatch.gov.au/news-alerts/business-email-compromise-scams-cost-australians-132-million
[3] https://jlex.com.sg/2019/11/19/notes-from-the-bar-who-bears-the-loss-of-cyber-fraud/
[4] Electronic Transactions Act 1999 (Cth), s.15; Electronic Transactions (Victoria) Act 2000, s.14(1); Electronic Transactions Act 2000 (NSW), s.14(1); Electronic Transactions (Queensland) Act 2001, s.26; Electronic Communications Act 2000 (SA), s.14; Electronic Transactions Act 2000 (Tas), s.12; Electronic Transactions Act 2011 (WA), s.16 and Part 3.
The Racing Industry during 2020 and the ‘Fred’ Racehorse Ownership App
It has been gratifying to see that the horse racing codes, both thoroughbred and harness, have been able to continue to stage meetings throughout the Covid-19 pandemic. The implementation of strict bio-security measures for participants and other measures, such as the absence of crowds, has meant that the racing product has been able to be seamlessly delivered to off-course fans & punters. Turnover figures have remained strong helping to sustain prize-money and the livelihoods of the thousands of Victorians employed in the racing industry. Full credit must go to the racing authorities for the pro-active steps they have taken and the discipline exhibited by participants in observing the directives which have been issued. Whilst minor scares and positive Covid tests may occur from time to time it appears that the industry is well placed to contain and confine these.
Pointon Partners has a long history of providing legal advice to racing industry participants and institutions. This traces all the way back to the 1990’s when we were involved in advising on the creation of large scale racing syndicates for clients. These were established by way of public company and accompanying prospectus and which was the first occasion such a structure had been used for racing syndicates in Australia.
Since that time we have acted for and advised:
- group 1 winning trainers;
- racehorse syndicators;
- thoroughbred and harness breeders and which has included advice concerning the shuttling of stallions from the Northern hemisphere;
- thoroughbred and harness owners;
- racing publications;
- ventures which have established JV arrangements with wagering operators in relation to innovative new betting products;
- a peak body in the racing industry in relation to various aspects of its operations including broadcast rights.
This engagement with our racing industry clients has remained very active and robust during the course of this year.
We would like to take this opportunity to give a shout out to one of our clients, Friends of Mr Ed Pty Ltd, which has developed a social networking app for racehorse owners called ‘Fred’. The ‘Fred’ app has recently gone live for download for both IOS and android users. It provides a platform on which a racehorse owner can follow the weekly progress of their horse and also connect with and interact with other owners of the horse. This has never been more important than now when there isn’t the opportunity to meet fellow owners at the track and either celebrate with, or commiserate with, them following a race. Friends of Mr Ed Pty Ltd was established by Amy Thompson and Richard Busso who are passionate racehorse owners and also very experienced in the digital media space. We wish Amy and Richard all the best with their venture and would encourage you to download the ‘Fred’ app and see if it will enhance your racehorse ownership experience. We are sure it will. The app is available for download via this link Download Fred today or their website www.friendsofmred.com
We wish yourselves, your families and your businesses well at the current time. If you do need any advice or assistance on legal issues relating to the racing industry then please don’t hesitate to contact Michael Bishop or Tony Pointon.
Sale or purchase of financial planning practices
The last couple of years has been a tumultuous period for the financial planning industry. We have seen the Hayne Royal Commission into Misconduct Superannuation and Financial Services industry and the handing downs of its findings. We have also seen AMP change the terms of its Buyer of Last Resort (BOLR) Policy and which has resulted in a class action being filed against AMP in the last month on behalf of AMP financial planners who have seen the value of their businesses affected as a result of changes to BOLR. Over the course of this year Pointon Partners has been advising a number of AMP financial planners in relation to their rights against AMP.
We have also seen a number of financial planning networks including AMP seek to consolidate their networks by serving notices of termination upon smaller planners bringing their authorised representative agreements to an end.
And all of this amongst the significant volatility on financial markets occasioned by the Covid-19 pandemic which has caused distress and concern amongst financial planners and their clients alike.
Pointon Partners has significant experience in acting for financial planning practices including:
- handling sale or purchase of financial planning business;
- acting for AMP Planners involved in BOLR transactions with AMP;
- preparing or advising on sale agreements relating to the sale of books of business from one financial planning practice to another;
- advising financial planning practices who have received notices of termination from their licensee;
- advising financial planners on restraint of trade issues and their rights to continue to work in the industry or deal with their former clients.
If you require advice or assistance regarding any of the above then please feel free to contact Michael Bishop or Andrew Cox.