Pointon Partners Employment Law Presentation
Last October our partner Michael Bishop delivered a client webinar on the subject of employee share & option schemes. He discussed the different types of schemes which can be used, the reasons why an employer may establish a scheme and whether an employee share & option scheme may be suited for your business. Since the webinar was delivered we have experienced ongoing interest by employer clients in such schemes. They are seen as an important retention mechanism in today’s very tight employment market. Or as a means of attracting new employees to your business.
As a result, Michael will be delivering his presentation again but this time in person for anyone who missed the webinar. Or if you did attend the webinar you are more than welcome to attend this presentation also in a more interactive setting.
Date: Thursday, 5 May 2022
Time: 1:00pm
Venue: Pointon Partners Boardroom, Level 14 / 565 Bourke Street, Melbourne.
Please RSVP by 26 April 2022 by clicking on Register Now.
Changes to the Franchising Code of Conduct
If you are a franchisor or a franchisee, it is important to note that amendments were made by to the Franchising Code of Conduct (“Code”) on 1 June 2021. Most of these amendments will apply to franchise agreements entered into, renewed or extended on or after 1 July 2021, unless an exception applies.
Some of the changes which have been made to the Code are as follows:
Pre-entry disclosure information
More information is required to be provided by a franchisor to prospective franchisees before entering into a franchise agreement (subject to the timeframes specified in the Code), such as:
- a key facts sheet (which is in addition to any disclosure statement required to be provided to a prospective franchisee under state or territory laws);
- information about leases, if relevant, including a copy of the lease or if no copy can be obtained, a summary of the commercial terms, and any other written information that has to be given to a tenant in accordance with state or territory law;
- additional information is to be included in the disclosure statement, including in relation to:
-
- rebates and other financial benefits that franchisors receive from suppliers;
- leases for the operation of the franchised business;
- dispute resolution;
- termination of the franchise agreement, including the circumstances in which the franchisor and franchisee can terminate the franchise agreement early;
- restraint of trade obligations;
- capital expenditure; and
- goodwill and franchisees’ rights.
Cooling Off Period
The Code now provides that a franchisee may terminate a franchise agreement within 14 days after the parties enter into a new franchise agreement (cooling off period).
In addition, there is also a cooling off period for existing agreements that are transferred between an old franchisee to a new franchisee under the franchise agreement.
Legal Costs
A franchisor may require that a franchisee make payment of the franchisor’s legal costs relating to preparing, negotiating or executing the franchise agreement, before the franchisee starts the franchised business and provided that the amount is specified in the franchise agreement in accordance with the requirements of the Code.
Varying a Franchise Agreement
The Code provides that a franchisor must not vary a franchise agreement with retrospective effect unless the franchisee has given written consent to the variation.
Restraint of Trade
Amendments have been made by the Code in relation to the inclusion of restraint of trade clauses in franchise agreements. For instance, the Code provides that a restraint of trade clause in a franchise agreement has no effect after the agreement expires if immediately before expiry, the franchisee was not in serious breach of the agreement or any related agreement.
Dispute Resolution
Provisions have been included in the Code in relation to the types of dispute resolution options available such as: conciliation, mediation and alternative dispute resolution methods, dispute notifications between parties and resolving disputes of multiple franchisees with a single franchisor.
Termination
The Code sets out the circumstances in which franchisors and franchisees can terminate the franchise agreement early as well as procedures.
Marketing Funds
Marketing fund obligations have now been clarified by the Code to apply to the fund administrator. For instance, this may be a franchisor, a master franchisor or a third party authorised to administer the fund.
If you wish to discuss matters relating to this article, then please feel free to contact Felicity Cara-Carson or Jess Tomlinson on (03) 9614 7707.
Key considerations when establishing a family discretionary trust
Discretionary trusts are most commonly established under a trust deed and governed by the terms of the trust deed. Therefore, careful consideration and drafting of the terms of the trust deed followed by regular reviews and amendments are required to ensure their effectiveness and to accurately reflect the current requirements of the trust.
The followings are the 5 key issues that you should consider when establishing a trust or reviewing the trust deed of a trust.
1.Control and Succession
Most discretionary trusts include an ‘Appointor’ role which generally has the power to appoint and remove trustees. Unlike the trustee, the role of an Appointor is a creature of the trust deed, and once created, it can have effective control of the trust depending on the terms of the trust deed. Therefore, it is critical that the trust deed has sufficient succession provisions to deal with both voluntary and involuntary vacation of the role, in particular, in the events of death and loss of capacity of the current Appointor. Also depending on the specific terms of the role, legal personal representatives such as executors of the estate or attorneys under powers of attorneys may not be able to act on behalf of Appointors unless specifically provided for under the trust deed.
2. Definition of trust income and income streaming
The definition of ‘income’ in the trust deed should be reviewed in light of High Court decision in Bamford v. FCT [2010] HCA 10 as it can have undesired tax outcomes if not properly defined. ‘Trust income’ generally will not include capital gains made by the trust or franking credits under its ordinary meaning and if not defined appropriately to be equal to ‘income’ under tax laws, the trustee or certain beneficiaries may be liable to pay tax without actually receiving any income. Further, the trust deed should also provide the trustee with sufficient powers to stream a particular class of income to any one or more of beneficiaries at its discretion to best utilise the character of the particular class of income (such as distributing capital gains to offset capital losses of a particular beneficiary).
3. Takers in default
Takers in default are the beneficiaries of a trust who are specified to receive the distribution from the trust in the event that the trust fund is not wholly disposed of in a particular financial year or upon vesting. Having appropriate default distributions provisions in the trust deed ensures that the trustee is not taxed at the highest marginal tax rate if for any reason, the trust fund was not fully or validly distributed to beneficiaries.
4. Vesting day
Unlike companies, discretionary trusts have a limited life span under the rule against perpetuities, where trusts generally vest in 80 years from the date of establishment. However, this depends on the governing jurisdiction of the trust and also the terms of the trust deed. A shorter than maximum allowable vesting day in the trust deed can lead to significant CGT and other tax implications if overlooked. The trust deed should therefore have a mechanism not only to extend the vesting day within the perpetuity period but also to bring it forward if the trustee wishes to wind up the trust earlier than the predetermined vesting day.
5. Variation power
Given the rapidly changing nature of tax laws applying to trusts, it is critical that the trust deed provides a sufficiently broad power of variation to the trustee to amend the terms of the trust as and when appropriate or necessary. Narrower variation powers may lead to a trust resettlement and consequent CGT implications upon the trustee exercising such powers.
If you are considering setting up a discretionary trust structure as part of your business or wealth planning or need advice on operation and taxation of trusts, please feel free to contact Michael Bishop or Peter Azam of Pointon Partners.
High Court Defamation Ruling
The High Court has handed down a hugely significant decision regarding whether media companies are responsible for potentially defamatory statements posted by third party users on the Facebook pages established and operated by the media companies. By a majority decision the High Court held that the media companies were, for the purposes of defamation law, the publishers of third party posts which were posted on the Facebook pages of the media companies in response to news stories posted on the Facebook pages by the media companies.
The position taken by the media companies in the proceedings was that:
- they did not make the defamatory comments available to the public;
- they were not instrumental in the publication;
- they merely administered a public Facebook page on which members of the public could publish material; and
- to be a publisher for defamation purposes the defendant must intend to communicate the defamatory matter complained of rather than just provide the platform on which it is communicated.
However five of the High Court judges (by way of two separate judgments) did take the view that the media companies ought be regarded as the publishers of the third party posts. The conclusion outlined in one of these joint judgments was as follows:
“Each appellant ((being the media companies) intentionally took a platform provided by another entity, Facebook, created and administered a public Facebook page and posted content on that page. The creation of the public Facebook, and the posting of content on that page, encouraged and facilitated publication of comments from third parties. The appellants were therefore publishers of the third party comments.”
This was the view of the majority notwithstanding that the “Comment” function was a standard feature of the Facebook service which could not be disabled and comments could not be deleted in advance.
Two other judges, who each delivered their own separate judgments, took a different view. Edelman J took what might be described as a compromise approach and held that the news stories posted by the media companies were not an invitation to the world at large to post comments on anything and everything however unrelated to the news story. In Edelman’s view, the media companies ought only be liable if the comments posted had some connection to or relevance to the news story posted by the media company. For example, if the media company posted a story about the weather the media company ought not be liable for third party defamatory posts made about a completely unrelated individual.
Steward J adopted an approach most favourable to the media companies and stated that, in his view, by maintaining a public Facebook page and posting news stories on it the media company is just commencing an electronic conversation. And even though the media companies posted such news stories on Facebook with the intent of promoting or encouraging members of the public to make comment the media company ought not be construed as the publisher of those subsequent posts unless it could be said that the media company had procured or provoked the defamatory comment made by the member of the public.
Conclusion
This High Court decision has major implications for any business which maintains a public Facebook page on which potentially defamatory comments could be posted. Or indeed any business which operates or maintains a social media platform on which subscribers, consumers or members of the public can make posts. If you have any queries regarding the decision and how it may affect your business please contact Michael Bishop for advice.
Doyles Corporate & Commercial Law Ranking Survey
We congratulate our Partners Tony Pointon and Michael Bishop on being included in the Doyles survey in the following categories:
- Leading individuals with respect to M & A, Capital Markets and General Corporate Advisory.
- Leading individuals working within local firms with respect to small to medium sized business transactions.
Pointon Partners was also included in the survey with respect to “law firms operating at the highest level on corporate matters (including M & A, ECM and general corporate advisory) of the Victorian Legal Market.
Doyles is an independent and highly regarded organisation which provides annual rankings of lawyers and law firms in various practice areas. The survey is used to enable voting by peers and following an extensive process of client interviews Doyles produces a listing of the:
- Market Leader in terms of the individual lawyer and law firm;
- pre-eminent and leading lawyers and law firms; and
- recommended lawyers and law firms.
Inclusion in the Doyles Ranking Survey is recognition of the active year our M & A team has had as highlighted in our Commercial Update of 14 April 2021.
Pointon Partners advises GTA Consultants on sale to New York Listed Stantec Inc. to round out active 12 months for M&A team
The Financial Planning Industry – A Changing Landscape
In our Commercial Update of 14 August last year (Sale or purchase of financial planning practices) we commented on the significant volatility and turmoil which the financial planning industry had experienced in the preceding several years. That included, amongst other things, the Royal Commission and the filing of a class action by AMP planners challenging the changes made by AMP to its Buyer of Last Resort (BOLR) Policy.
The class action is winding its way through the Federal Court. Andrew Cox and Michael Bishop of our office have been advising AMP planners on various aspects of their exit from AMP including in connection with associated finance arrangements with AMP Bank but also regarding how to exit AMP whilst seeking to preserve their rights to participate in the class action.
On the transaction front, during the course of this year we have been seeing significant deal flow in the financial planning sector in relation to sale of financial planning practices but also the sale of books of business between planning businesses. These transactions have been underpinned by robust valuations and generous multiples. Pointon Partners has significant experience in acting in such transactions including advising on exit arrangements with the existing licensee and review of documentation provided by a new licensee.
If you require advice or assistance regarding any of the above then please feel free to contact Michael Bishop or Andrew Cox.
Commercial Law Webinar – Readying your Business for sale – An essential webinar for anyone thinking of selling their business in the next 12 months.
Our Commercial Law Partners Michael Bishop and Felicity Cara-Carson together with Andrew Cassin held a webinar on 7 July 2021 in relation to Readying your Business for sale – An essential webinar for anyone thinking of selling their business in the next 12 Months.
Andrew Cassin is the author of “On Your Terms – 101 Ways to Prepare a Business for Sale of Succession.”
The webinar was recorded, should you want to watch please click on the link below:
Topic: Commercial Law Webinar – Readying your business for sale
Start Time : Jul 7, 2021 12:11 PM
Meeting Recording:
https://us06web.zoom.us/rec/share/H-V6eNT_lx9_a98Zk0bv6aDoNTPGiC1qf0aiQR4h8X-ZPwzw5Ivfbs4SGUL36zmv.7ME_V4qyRnqRCbpc
Access Passcode: V5@AKc4v
Please note that if accessing the above link on a computer, please manually type the passcode rather then copy and paste.
RESTRUCTURING- PART 6: RESTRUCTURING YOUR EXISTING BUSINESS STRUCTURE TO THE BETTER STRUCTURE
To move from your existing structure to the better structure you need to consider the income tax rollover provisions available and the stamp duty implications that are applicable.
The most common income taxation rollovers that provide for capital gains tax deferral, that need to be considered are:
- 615 – Rollovers for Business Structures;
- 328-G – Restructuring for small businesses where your turnover is less than $10 million;
- Subdivision 124-M – Script-for-script rollover
- 124 – Replacement Asset Rollovers – Other rollovers in addition to the script-for-script rollover.
- 122 – Rollover for the disposal of assets to, or the creation of assets of a wholly-owned company.
We now attach a discussion of these provisions:
Restructuring Presentation (2)
In relation to the Restructuring of your existing business structure referred to above, we have developed significant expertise and welcome your enquires. Please do not hesitate to contact Anthony Pointon or Felicity Cara-Carson and Michael Bishop to discuss.
RESTRUCTURING- PART 5: SEPARATION OF ASSETS IN BUSINESS STRUCTURES
Following from our earlier articles on Restructuring, we now discuss the importance of the separation of assets within a business structure.
Business structures should always attempt to separate business assets of worth, such as property or even a trademark intellectual property, from the conduct of the business. Issues such as actions from unsecured creditors or from litigation (product liability, negligence, and employee action) can and do occur regularly.
Personal assets should generally be held and protected in another structure altogether.
There is one example of a structure that separates assets. We cannot stress enough that you need to have tailored advice to the situation of the business. Please click on the link below to view this structure.
Diagram – Structure to Separate Assets
In relation to the Restructuring, we have developed significant expertise and welcome your enquires. Please do not hesitate to contact Anthony Pointon or Felicity Cara-Carson and Michael Bishop to discuss.
RESTRUCTURING- PART 4: THE THREE TRUST STRUCTURE ALTERNATIVES
Following from Part 3 and the basic building blocks article, we turn our attention to analysing the three trust structure alternatives Unit Trust, Hybrid Trust and Partnership Trust.
Unit Trust
Please select the attachment below.
Unit Trust
Classic Trust/Hybrid Trust:
Please select the attachment below.
Classic.Hybrid Trust
Partnership of Trusts:
Please select the attachment below.
Partnership of Trusts
In relation to the Restructuring, we have developed significant expertise and welcome your enquires. Please do not hesitate to contact Anthony Pointon or Felicity Cara-Carson and Michael Bishop to discuss.