Skip to content
Pointon Partners
News & Publications

Insolvency

Can a director set off a loan account against an insolvent trading claim?

20 November 2026

Double doors chained and padlocked shut, representing a company that has ceased trading

Short answer: no, not in Victoria. The Supreme Court of Victoria has held that a director cannot set off money the company owes them against their liability for insolvent trading under section 588M of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

What happened in the case?

In Re Baretail Chadstone Pty Ltd (in liq) [2026] VSC 743, the liquidator brought an insolvent trading claim against the director. The director said the company owed her more than $1 million and sought to set that amount off against the claim. The Court rejected the set-off and found her liable for $610,800.63, plus interest.

Why was set-off not allowed?

Section 553C of the Act allows mutual debts and dealings to be set off in a liquidation, but the circumstances giving rise to them must exist before the winding up. The liquidator’s right to recover compensation for insolvent trading only arises because the company is wound up, so it is not a mutual dealing that existed beforehand.

The Court applied the reasoning of the High Court in Metal Manufactures Pty Ltd v Morton [2023] HCA 1, which held that set-off was not available against an unfair preference claim. It held that the earlier Federal Court decision in Smith v Bone [2015] FCA 319, which had allowed a director’s set-off, must be taken to have been overruled.

What does this mean for directors?

A director’s loan account is not a defence to an insolvent trading claim. The director must pay the compensation in full and can only prove in the liquidation for any valid debt the company owes them, receiving whatever dividend is available to creditors.

What does this mean for liquidators?

Liquidators now have direct Victorian authority to reject a director’s set-off, even where the claimed debt is larger than the director’s liability.

For advice on pursuing or defending an insolvent trading claim, contact our Restructuring & Insolvency team. Read the full case note: Insolvent trading: Victorian Supreme Court shuts the door on director set-offs.

This article is general information only, current at the date of publication, and does not constitute legal advice.

For advice on how this update affects your business, contact Carl Millington or the Insolvency team at Pointon Partners.

This article is general information only, current at the date of publication, and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek professional advice tailored to your specific circumstances before acting on anything in this article.