The Supreme Court of Victoria has held that a director cannot set off money owed by the company against liability for insolvent trading under s 588M of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act).
In Re Baretail Chadstone Pty Ltd (in liq) [2026] VSC 743, the director claimed the company owed her more than $1 million. She sought to set that amount off against the liquidator’s insolvent trading claim. Fary AsJ rejected the set-off and found her liable for $610,800.63, plus interest.
Section 553C of the Act allows mutual debts and dealings to be set off in a liquidation. However, the circumstances giving rise to those debts or dealings must exist before winding up.
In Smith v Bone [2015] FCA 319, the Federal Court had allowed a director to set off money owed by the company against insolvent trading liability.
The High Court subsequently held in Metal Manufactures Pty Ltd v Morton [2023] HCA 1 that statutory set-off was unavailable against an unfair preference claim. Before winding up, the company owed money to the creditor, but the liquidator’s statutory right to recover the preference did not exist.
Fary AsJ applied the same reasoning to insolvent trading claims. The liquidator’s right to recover compensation under s 588M depended on the company being wound up and could not be set off against an existing debt owed to the director. His Honour held that Smith v Bone must be taken to have been overruled by Metal Manufactures.
Liquidators facing a director’s loan account as an answer to an insolvent trading claim now have direct Victorian authority to reject the set-off, even where the claimed debt exceeds the director’s liability. The director is left to prove for any valid debt in the liquidation and receive whatever dividend is available.
Please contact us if you would like advice on pursuing or defending an insolvent trading claim.