The Victorian Court of Appeal has confirmed that a developer may terminate off-the-plan contracts for industrial lots to secure a more profitable outcome, provided the contract permits it.
Industrial warehouses have become increasingly attractive to property investors, offering the potential for higher rental yields and fewer regulatory obligations than residential investment properties. The decision is therefore particularly relevant to developers and purchasers in the industrial property market.
In Fuller Road West Pty Ltd v LVL Transport Pty Ltd [2026] VSCA 266, the Court upheld a developer’s decision to terminate contracts for industrial warehouse lots following a substantial increase in the value of the underlying land.
The decision reinforces the importance of carefully drafted termination provisions and the willingness of courts to enforce commercial bargains, even where the outcome favours one party.
Background
Fuller Road West Pty Ltd (Developer) owned approximately 20.8 hectares of industrial land in Ravenhall, which it proposed to subdivide into 45 lots to be used for industrial warehouses.
In 2020, the Developer entered into contracts for the sale of 21 lots. Each contract was conditional upon registration of the plan of subdivision within two years.
The contracts contained several provisions favourable to the Developer, including broad termination rights relating to the timing and commercial viability of the development.
In particular, special condition 8.4 permitted the Developer to terminate having regard to matters including market demand, its financial position, financing arrangements and other commercial considerations.
The subdivision was delayed by planning requirements, including changes to drainage designs and the need for ecological reports and surveys. By August 2022, the subdivision had not been registered and the underlying land had increased substantially in value. The Developer terminated the contracts. There was no suggestion that the Developer had deliberately delayed registration to facilitate termination. The trial judge found that the Developer had taken reasonable steps to achieve registration at the earliest possible date.
Three purchasers (Purchasers) challenged the termination of the contracts and sought specific performance.
The decisions
The County Court found that the Developer had terminated the contracts to retain the benefit of the increase in land value.
The trial judge considered that allowing termination for that reason would effectively give the Developer an option to walk away whenever the agreed sale prices became commercially unattractive. His Honour considered that this was not a businesslike outcome and ordered specific performance.
The Court of Appeal disagreed. It held that special condition 8.4 gave the Developer a broad discretion to terminate by reference to its own commercial interests, including to achieve a more profitable outcome.
The Court rejected the trial judge’s approach, finding that his Honour had substituted his own views of commerciality for the words of the contract and the bargain the parties had made.
The Court also considered the other termination provisions, observing that the contracts had been drafted with an abundance of caution. The overlap between those provisions did not justify reading down the broad language of special condition 8.4.
The Developer was therefore entitled to terminate the contracts, notwithstanding that its purpose was to retain the benefit of the increase in land value.
Implications for developers
The decision confirms that developers may reserve broad contractual termination rights, including rights exercisable by reference to their own commercial interests.
The fact that termination allows a developer to obtain a better financial outcome does not, of itself, prevent the exercise of an express contractual right.
Importantly, the contracts concerned industrial land, rather than residential property. The statutory restrictions on sunset clauses under the Sale of Land Act 1962 (Vic), which apply to residential off-the-plan contracts, did not apply. The decision should therefore not be taken as giving residential developers equivalent termination rights.
For developers, the decision highlights the value of carefully drafted termination provisions and confirms that courts will not rewrite commercial bargains merely because their operation favours one party.
For information or assistance with disputes concerning off-the-plan contracts, please contact us.