End of March Weekly Tax Update
This article provides an update on key developments in taxation law for accountants and participants in the tax advice industry up to late-March. This update in summary covers:
- The revised commencement dates for the 2024-25 Budget measure Strengthening the foreign resident capital gains tax regime
- Increased funding to the ATO to target high-risk practitioners
- Top500 Private Group Tax Performance program currently underway
1 – Revised Commencement Date – 2024-25 Budget Measure Strengthening the foreign resident capital gains tax regime
The 2025-26 Budget Measure has advised that the 2024-25 Budget measure Strengthening the foreign resident capital gains tax regime will have its commencement date changed from 1 July 2025 to the later of 1 October 2025 or the first 1 January, 1 April, 1 July or 1 October after the Act receives assent. This deferment is expected to provide some certainty given the forthcoming Federal election in May.
As a reminder, in terms of CGT changes, there were three major changes aimed to amend the rules in Division 855 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997.
- Clarifying and Broadening the Foreign Resident CGT Base
The 2024-25 Budget Measure acknowledges the narrow CGT base for foreign residents and the failure of federal tax legislation in defining real property. The omission of this term, and leaving it to State legislation, has resulted in “the potential for inconsistent tax treatment on the same type of underlying asset depending on the location of the assets in different States or Territories.”
The new measures, if the Act receives Royal assent, assets with a close connection to Australian land and/or natural resources will be captured in tax legislation where they weren’t before. The following examples are types of assets with a close connection to Australian land and/or its natural resources:
- Leases or licenses to use land situated in Australia;
- Australian water entitlements in relation to land situated in Australia;
- Infrastructure and machinery installed on land situated in Australia, including land subject to a mining, quarrying or prospecting right of an entity;
- An option or right to acquire one of the above assets;
- A non-portfolio membership interest in an entity where more than 50 per cent of the underlying entity’s market value is derived from the above assets.
- Extending the Testing Period for the PAT
The current Principal Asset Test operates at a point in time. The issue here is that this approach presents an integrity risk that allows foreign residents to avoid CGT by planning the sale of their membership interests at a time when the underlying entity does not satisfy the test.
The new measure amends the testing period for the PAT to the previous 365 days before the time of disposal of the Indirect Australian Real Property Interest (IARPI).
- ATO Notification of the Non-IARPI Vendor Declarations
This measure ensures that a foreign resident vendor disposing of a membership interest, exceeding $20m in value, must notify the ATO of a vendor declaration they make to a purchaser that the sale is not an IARPI.
2 – Increased funding to the ATO to target high-risk practitioners
Further, the ATO is to receive a significant increase in funding to ensure taxpayers comply with their tax obligations. This will comprise of a further $999m funding to the ATO over the next 4 years for the ATO to extend and expand its tax compliance activities.
In addition to this, extra funding to the Tax Practitioners Board will be provided with further options of regress available to the TPB and enabling them to undertake further compliance activities against high-risk tax practitioners over the next 4 years.
3 – ATO’s Next 5000 Private Group program currently underway
We further note that the Next 5000 program is currently underway with many private groups being issued a notification letter. The purpose of this program is to ensure that Australia’s largest privately owned groups are paying the right amount of tax. Groups covered by this include Australian resident individuals who, along with their associates control more than $50 million in wealth.
For your reference, the ATO will effectively engage with private groups through the following steps:
- Notify you in writing
- Meet with you to understand your business
- Formally request further information
- Contact you to discuss further steps
Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon of our Taxation Team.
Landmine Div 7A decision for Commissioner – FCT v Bendel 2025 FCAF 15 (31 March 2025 – Backfire for Commissioner – Section 109D Div 7A attack on Corporate Beneficiaries fails and causes Commissioner other problems)
The Full Federal Court, in Bendel, has confirmed the earlier AAT appeal decision in favour of the taxpayer in a landmark decision on Division 7A, causing a series of landmines for the Commissioner in respect of his past interpretations on Div 7A ITAA 36 in which the Commissioner assessed deemed dividends to a trust that had made a distribution to a corporate beneficiary but not paid it.
The Federal Court did not fully endorse the earlier AAT decision, however did find that an unpaid present entitlement was not a loan (including the provision of financial accommodation) but was further also a debt for a sum certain that however did not qualify as a debt forgiven under s109D(3) ITAA36.
Bendel is an intriguing case that will have further developments given the Commissioner has already lodged an application for special leave in the High Court and if granted a further decision. On the face of it, it is difficult to see where the Full Federal Court has gone wrong and whether the Commissioner would get satisfaction in pursuing this. The Legislature was not trying to potentially double tax amounts owed to the company by shareholders and associates as the Commissioner has been arguing for by implication.
The purpose of Division 7A is to ensure that shareholders of private companies are not able to enjoy effective distributions of company profits in a tax-free form.
In Bendel, the Commissioner decided to assess the Trustee in respect of a Trust distribution to a corporate beneficiary that had not been paid to it and where there was also a clear loan out to a related beneficiary from the Trust, via Section 109 D ITAA 36, rather than by assessing a related beneficiary using Subdivision EA ITAA 36, which was designed to assess the related beneficiary in these circumstances.
The earlier Tribunal had held that the amount owing by the Trustee to its beneficiary company was a right in equity created by the entitlement to trust income (or capital), and that the balance of any outstanding/unpaid present entitlement is not a loan to the Trustee under s 109D(3) (see paragraphs 33-34 of the Federal Court judgment). Further the Tribunal held that if the amount was a dividend, it would not be the same amount as determined by the operation of s 95 and 97 for the company Gleewin Investments as the threshold conditions for s 6-25 do not arise in the present circumstances.
If the Commissioner had succeeded then there was potentially a double taxation situation that could have arisen due to the fact that the beneficiary, Bendel, could also have been assessed under Subdivision EA if there was an assessment issued in the time limits.
The Commissioner was unsuccessful and the Courts have upheld the long standing legal position that an unpaid present entitlement is not a loan but a trust entitlement, due to it being for a sum certain is also a debt owed as has been earlier determined by the High Court (see below – Fischer v Nemeske Pty Ltd (2016) HCA 11). The debt owed does not fall within the terms of a Section 109B (and therefore 109D) due to there being no forgiveness of a debt.
Nor does this case mean that that Subdivision EA is ineffective and in our current view it is likely to remain effective, noting that the Commissioner did not make this second assessment in this case, although could have, and we await further action on this topic. Subdivision EA is briefly discussed at para 82 of the judgement and includes:
In ascertaining the meaning of the statutory text, it is necessary to accord a harmonious operation to the language of the division in its entirety. Part of Div 7A includes Subdiv EA. In the simplified outline of Div 7A, s 109B relevantly states:
An amount may also be included in the assessable income of a shareholder or shareholder’s associate if:
(a) a company has an unpaid present entitlement to income of a trust; and
(b) the trustee makes a payment or loan to, or forgives a debt of, the shareholder or associate.
(See Subdivision EA and EB.)
However, it should be noted that the Commissioners requirements in respect of unpaid present entitlements that were created before the introduction of Subdivision EA and EB may need to be revisited by clients and their accountants in light of this decision.
The ATO guidelines for compliance PS LA 2010/4 and TD 2022/11 will need to be reviewed regardless of the recent ATO interim impact statement. We also note that in addition to the ATO’s refusal to revise the current views relating to private company entitlements to trust income, the Commissioner may elect to apply s 100A instead. For your reference, s 100A is an anti-avoidance provision which seeks to prevent a tax benefit arising under a pre-existing arrangement between two or more people in which:
- A beneficiary is made presently entitled to a share of trust income;
- A party other than the beneficiary receives a benefit in some way, shape or form;
- At least one of the parties to the agreement has a purpose of reducing the amount of tax that would otherwise be paid;
- The agreement is not entered in the course of an ordinary family or commercial dealing.
As per PCG 2022/2 and the interim decision impact statement, the ATO may apply s 100A where “a trustee retains funds that a corporate beneficiary has been made entitled to without converting that entitlement to a loan at least as commercial as the terms set out in Division 7A”.
The Background
- The facts of Bendall showed a classic family trust distribution to amongst other beneficiaries, a corporate beneficiary.
- The distribution was not paid to the corporate beneficiary.
- There was a loan account owed by the individual Bendell to the Trust.
- The Commissioner assessed the Trustee Gleewin. In paragraph 12, it is stated that Gleewin Investments (the corporate beneficiary) had unpaid present entitlements to prior year trust income and these prior year unpaid present entitlements comprised loans within the meaning of s 109(3) made by Gleewin Investments in the current year to Gleewin.
- The loans were taken to be dividends by virtue of se109 D (1) ITAA 36. They were taken to be paid out of Gleewin Investments profit by operation of s 109D (1) ITTA 36.
- Further the dividends were taken to be paid out of profits of Gleewin Investments by operation of s109Z to the extent there was a distributable surplus.
- The dividends taken to be paid out of profits were assessable income by virtue of section 44 ITAA 36.
- The beneficiaries entitled to the income were assessed to be liable under section 97 ITAA 36.
- There was no attempted assessment of the amount owed by Bendall to the Trust under subdivision EA (sections 109 XA and XB) to Bendall. Note that Section 109 XB assesses the amounts determined under section 109XA which in turn refers to amounts that if loaned by the trustee to a shareholder or associate of the corporate beneficiary of the trust which has an unpaid present entitlement , it would be a The AAT Tribunal in the earleir determination was concerned about the possible double taxation of the same amount The Tribunal believed that Subdivison EA would be the lead provision because it was the more specific provision and should be the method of assessment rather than s109 D. ( see paras 31 and 32).
- Section 109 B ITAA 36 treats the following transactions as dividends:
- The payment of amounts (includes a transfer of property ) by the company to a shareholder or a shareholders associate (s109C) .
- The loan of amounts by the company to a shareholder or shareholders associate ( ( 109 D & E) ; and
- The forgiveness by the company of an amount of a debt owed by a shareholder or a shareholders associate.
- The earlier Tribunal decision was discussed at paragraphs 32 – 34 of the Federal Court judgement and noted :
Subdivision EA was considered by the Tribunal (at TR [100]) to be the “lead provision” where the terms of that subdivision are satisfied because it was the more specific provision.
The Tribunal concluded at TR [101] that:
… a loan within the meaning of s 109D(3) does not reach so far as to embrace the rights in equity created when entitlements to trust income (or capital) are created but not satisfied and remain unpaid. The balance of an outstanding or unpaid entitlement of a corporate beneficiary of a trust, whether held on a separate trust or otherwise, is not a loan to the trustee of that trust.
The Tribunal concluded (at TR [108]) that if it were wrong on the application of s 109D(3), s 6-25 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) (1997 Act) did not apply because:
The amount taken to be a dividend paid by Gleewin Investments to Gleewin was not the same as the amount determined to be assessable income by operation of ss 95 and 97 for Gleewin Investments. The threshold condition for s 6-25 to apply does not arise in the present circumstances.
- The Court held that in construing legislation, the purpose of the legislation must be derived from the legislation itself, not from any assumption about the desired or desirable reach for operation of the provisions. (para 85-90)
- It however interpreted section 109 D (3) such that unpaid present entitlement is not a loan or financial accommodation however it is a debt as it is an unconditional obligation to pay a specified amount of money to a beneficiary . See Fischer v Nemeske Pty Ltd [2016] HCA 11
“a trustee who admits to having an unconditional obligation to pay a specified amount of money to a beneficiary can thereby become liable to an action at law for the recovery of that amount as money had and received to the benefit of the beneficiary, so as to overlay the equitable relationship of trustee and beneficiary with the legal relationship of debtor and creditor. That has been settled since at least the middle of the nineteenth century” at [105]
- “However, s 109D(3) requires more than the existence of a debtor-creditor relationship. It requires an obligation to repay and not merely an obligation to pay. The Commissioner contended before the Tribunal that the non-exercise by Gleewin Investments of its right to call for payment of its present entitlement amounted to the provision of financial accommodation. The Commissioner contended that Gleewin Investments had consented or acquiesced to Gleewin not paying the present entitlement by making a decision to refrain from calling for payment. However, the consensual arrangement relied upon by the Commissioner did not involve the payment of a sum by or at the direction of Gleewin Investments that was required to be repaid.”
- “In those circumstances, applying the correct construction of s 109D results in only one conclusion being open. Section 109D is not satisfied. Although – based on the concessions made by the taxpayer – a debtor creditor relationship was created by the trustee resolution and the entry in the trust accounts, there was no loan or creation of an obligation to repay an amount as opposed to an obligation to pay.”
Conclusion
This is a landmark decision in respect of the interpretation and operation of Division 7A in respect of distributions to corporate beneficiaries of trusts. In our view, it is unlikely to change current accounting practice in respect of all amounts distributed post the introduction of subdivision EA and EB. As noted above, the Commissioner may choose to apply section 100A in regard to unpaid present entitlements to corporate beneficiaries.
Amounts that were distributed prior to the introduction of these subdivisions on 16 December 2009 may need to be reviewed by accountants and their clients.
Assessments made by the Commissioner under s109D in the past decade may be incorrect and when this occurred, accounting advisors should seek advice as to challenging the incorrect assessment. We would be happy to advise and assist. The Commissioner’s practice of using section 109D to assess rather than subdivision EA and EB may change.
Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon of our Taxation Team.
Mixed Use Land for Primary Production? Whether Mixed Use Land is Exempt from Stamp Duty
In Wylarah Pastoral Co Pty Ltd ATF Tallong Family Trust v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2024] NSWCATAD 366, the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) found that a rural property which had mixed uses did not qualify for the primary production exemption in NSW. This case is significant to owners of properties with mixed uses in that state and has some interesting issues for discussion in respect of Victoria which refers to the land “primarily” being used for primary production in sections 65 – 67 Land Tax Act 2005 (Vic), rather than the “dominant use”. In particular, owners that also have rented out residential premises on their properties should be aware of this case.
Background
The taxpayer initially purchased land located in NSW in May 2022 with a view to maintain cattle, claiming that because they had intended to purchase the land to maintain cattle, they would be exempt from land tax.
Throughout 2022 and 2023, significant work was carried out to prepare the land for cattle. However during these years, there was no income being generated from the sale of cattle. A residence was located on the land which the taxpayer rented out for $650 a week during the 2022 and 2023 years. This was the only revenue being derived from the land.
On 24 September 2024, several cattle were stocked on the land with expectations of future income from their sale. However during this time, the main source of income from the land remained with the rental payments from the residential property.
On 30 January 2023, the Chief Commissioner issued a land tax assessment for the 2023 and 2024 years denying the taxpayer from claiming land tax exemption on the basis of the primary production exemption.
The main issue was whether the dominant use of the land was for the maintenance of cattle for sale, thereby qualifying for the primary production exemption from land tax.
Decision
Under section 7 of the Land Tax Management Act 1956 (‘LTMA’) land tax is to be levied and paid on the taxable value of all land in NSW unless an exemption applies. The exemption that the taxpayer relied on was section 10AA of the LTMA which provides the following (our emphasis):

There was no contest that the land was rural land. The overarching issue was whether the dominant use of the land was for the maintenance of cattle, which the taxpayer claimed was the case. In assessing the authorities, the Tribunal noted that there is no single factor that can determine the dominant use, to the exclusion of other relevant factors. The factors that may be taken into account to determine which use is dominant include:
- The nature and intensity of competing uses;
- The extent of the physical area in which each use takes place;
- The time and labour spent for each use;
- The money spent or assets deployed for each use; and
- The value derived from each use.
The taxpayer asserted two factors supported the view that the dominant use of the land was for the maintenance of the cattle. These included the two national Vendor Declarations and Waybills which showed the presence of cattle on the land and their maintenance on the land as well as the significant works being done on the land to prepare it for cattle maintenance. Of note here is the aerial images obtained by the Chief Commissioner which did not indicate that there was any cattle on the land. Further, there were discrepancies in the Vendor Declaration and Waybills which cast significant doubt on whether cattle was being maintained on the land.
The taxpayer’s most convincing point, which the Tribunal accepted, were factors which indicated that the dominant use of the land was for the maintenance of cattle, were the significant preparatory works being conducted on the land for the purposes of the maintenance of cattle. These included the improvement of pastures, improvement of fencing, application of fertilisers, application of insecticides, improvement of roads, the installation of a stormwater system around the machine shed and installation of water tanks and plumbing. Further, in regard to the intensity of competing uses, the taxpayer stated that given 5% of the land was being used for the generation of rental income and the rest was planned for the maintenance of cattle, this was a strong indicator that the land’s dominant use was for the primary production purpose.
On the other hand, the Chief Commissioner contended that the rental payments, amounting to $650 per week and $58,500, for the years in question, indicated that the dominant use of the land was for the provision of accommodation to secure rental income. Significantly, the tribunal found that the expenditure in relation to the residence outweighed the expenditure on the land itself.
Hence, while there was evidence to suggest that the dominant use of the land was for cattle maintenance, this did not outweigh the evidence presented by the Commissioner that the dominant use was for the generation of rental income and residence.
Analysis and Key Takeaway
This case underpins the difficulties in assessing whether land is used dominantly for primary production in NSW (or primarily for primary production in Victoria) where there are multiple uses for that property.
A fatal aspect of the taxpayer’s case included the fact that the expenses relating to the residence outweighed that of the primary production purposes, as well as the fact that the documentation for the Vendor Declaration Waybills had discrepancies. We believe that there may have been a different outcome had the documentation been properly kept and the income from the primary production exceeded the expenses from the rental activity.
As such, to ensure that your property remains exempt from stamp duty under the primary production exemption:
- Proper documentation is necessary. For example, keeping financials on income and expenses coming from each use (residential/primary production) as well as proper documentation indicating that it was for primary production (the taxpayer here failed to do this given there was a discrepancy in their Vendor Declaration and Waybill.
- Assess the expenses being devoted to primary production in contradistinction to the rental activity.
- Analyse what the main source of income from the land is. In this case, the fact that the only income was from the residence was a significant factor in determining that the land was not for primary production.
Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon of our Taxation Team.
Mid-March 2025 – Tax Update
This article provides an update on key developments in taxation law for accountants and participants in the tax advice industry up to mid-March. This update in summary covers:
- The ATO’s taxpayer alert in regard to restructuring trusts to access the MIT Withholding Regime
- New Taxation Determination 2025/D2 on section 109R ITAA36
- Tribunal decision on Ordinary Concepts Test and Domicile Test
- ATO shifting non-compliant small businesses to monthly GST
1 – TA 2025/1 – ATO relays concerns with restructuring trusts to access Managed Investment Trust Withholding Regime
On 7 March 2024, the ATO issued a taxpayer alert highlighting its concerns with arrangements that restructure an existing trust or inward investment structure to inappropriately access the MIT withholding regime. It is clearly directed to restructures to achieve an MIT outcome done without any underlying commercial purpose.
Of note, the ATO suggests that the following arrangements and features are of concern:
- An Australian entity holds passive assets, but does not meet the requirements to access the MIT withholding tax regime, for example, because:
- It is not a trust (for example, it is a company that is not c corporate collective investment vehicle (CCIV)
- It is not a unit trust directly owned by a single unitholder (and therefore does not meet the requirements of being a managed investment scheme (MIS))
- The management of the trust does not satisfy the requirements in section 275-35 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997.
- Restructure steps are undertaken to seek to satisfy the requirements to access the MIT withholding tax regime, for example, by:
- Unnecessarily restructuring the ownership of the entity or underlying assets so that:
- The inward investment structure includes an Australian unit trust
- That unit trust is wholly directly owned by 2 or more unitholders who are not all MITs, to meet he pooled investment requirements o be a MIS, and
- It is wholly indirectly owned by a single foreign entity covered by subsection 275-20(4) of the ITAA 1997, or
- Changing arrangements such that the management of the trust is provided by an entity which meets the licensing requirements in section 275-35 of the ITAA 1997.
- The restructure steps are done for the purposes for accessing the MIT withholding regime.
Further, the Government has announced that they will amend the income tax laws to ensure that legitimate investors can still access the concessional withholding tax rates in Australia. As such, the amendments will attempt to make it clear that trusts ultimately owned by a single widely-held investor will be able to access the MIT concessions.
2 – TD 2025/D2 – Certain payments under section 109R ITAA36 disregarded
Recently, the ATO released its draft determination disregarding certain payments under section 109R ITAA36. As a reminder, section 109R operates to disregard certain payments made by an entity to a private company in relation to loans provided by that private company. This is important given its is enshrined with Division 7A of the ITAA36 and is intended to prevent shareholders and their associates from avoiding the operation of Div 7A.
In summary, TD 2025/D2 sets out two views:
- Section 109R of the ITAA36 can apply to disregard certain loan repayments to a private company where the repaying entity is taken to have obtained a loan from the company by the interposed entity rules in sections 109T and 109W of the ITAA1936.
- Where a private company is taken to have made a notional loan under sections 109T and 109W of the ITAA 1936, section 109R of the ITAA 1936 can apply to disregard certain repayments when determining how much (if any) of that loan has been notionally repaid.
Once finalised, this determination will apply retrospectively.
3 – Quy and FCT [2025] ARTA 174 – Taxpayer not a resident under Ordinary Concepts Test but confirmed resident under Domicile Test
In this case, a taxpayer who lived and worked in Dubai was a tax resident of Australia under the domicile test.
The taxpayer was transferred from his company in Perth to Dubai in 2015. From then on, he lived in an apartment which was leased by his employer. He continued to own his family home in WA as well as two properties in Sydney where he continually paid the mortgages and other costs. The taxpayer continually visited his family for 29-47 days out of the financial year, however he spent 119 days in Australia during the 2016 income years.
The initial AAT case, Quy and FCT [2024] AATA 245, confirmed that the taxpayer was neither a resident under the domicile test and ordinary concepts test.
However the ART concluded that the taxpayer was a resident under the domicile test. The factors which influenced this included the fact that he did not have a permanent home he stayed at outside of Australia and his continual connection with Australia, through him visiting his family and ownership of the family home and other properties was objectively inconsistent with him abandoning his residence in Australia, thereby making his permanent home in Dubai.
4 – ATO to shift non-compliant small businesses to monthly GST
From 1 April 2025, the ATO will move 3,500 small businesses with a history of non-payment, late or non-lodgement, or incorrect reporting from quarterly to monthly GST reporting to improve their compliance. The purposes of this is to ensure that small businesses will remain vigilant in reporting their obligations.
The ATO will contact small businesses as well as their taxation professionals when their reporting obligations have been changed from quarterly to monthly.
Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon of our Taxation Team.
Common Employee or not? When grouping provisions do not apply
It is a common misconception that only related entities may be grouped under the Payroll Tax Provisions. However, this is often not the case as many of our matters have consisted of several unrelated SMEs being grouped despite having no connection with each other. We understand that these circumstances arise commonly in the context of where Management Agreements are used for the provision of services in a business premise. As such, this is quite relevant in the context of pharmacies, vets and medical practices, where management agreements are commonly used and more than one business operates within a single business premise.
This article will discuss the following:
- What are the grouping provisions;
- How the common employee grouping rules will apply to you;
- Case study on how the grouping rule applied to many of our clients and how we successfully degrouped them; and
- How to avoid being grouped for the purpose of the payroll tax provisions.
What is Grouping?
The grouping rules under the Payroll Tax Act 2007, and its equivalent provisions in other State laws, seek to aggregate several entities for the purpose of payroll tax liability. As noted in Tasty Chicks Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue, the purpose of these rules is to prevent entities from splitting their business activities among different entities such that they stay under the respective payroll tax thresholds, currently $900,000.
Take for example the below:

At first glance, none of these companies would be caught under the grouping provisions as the wages paid in the 2023-2024 year is under the $900,000 threshold. However, if these companies were grouped, on the basis that Holding Company A owns 100% of Subsidiary Company B, the threshold will be met and all the companies in this group would have to pay payroll tax. This is in addition to the General Interest Charge and Penalties that may arise in failing to pay their respective payroll tax liability.
There are several ways in which companies may be grouped for payroll tax purposes. These consist of the following:
- Related Entities – Companies may be grouped pursuant to the fact that they are related body corporates within the meaning of the Corporations Act 2001. This means that a company that either controls a subsidiary company’s board, holds more than 50% of the voting rights in the subsidiary company or holds more than 50% of the share capital in said subsidiary company will as a whole constitute a group for the payroll tax provisions.
- Common Control – An entity that has a controlling interest in two or more entities will be grouped.
- Common Employees – Entities that employ the same entities will be grouped.
The first two ways in which businesses may be grouped is often quite obvious, however the common employee method of grouping is often more ambiguous. As noted in the case of Liquid Rock (our emphasis):
The application of s 71 can be difficult because its terms are apt to cover more than the policy of the legislation would suggest. The mere provision of a service to someone by a person employed by another who is otherwise wholly independent, could come within the literal application of the section although that could not be thought to be the purpose, intention or reach of the provision …A person may appear to be performing duties for someone other than the employer when careful analysis will show that not to be the case. It is commonplace for an employee to discharge duties for an employer by provision of duties to another as provision by the employer rather than for or in connection with the business of the other.
This highlights some of the difficulties the SRO may have in applying these provisions. Due to the complexities that may be involved in management agreements, especially in pharmaceutical businesses, and whilst it appear that two businesses may share employees based on their shared premise, the onus is on the SRO to carefully review these arrangements before deciding whether these two businesses should be caught under the provisions.
In our experience, the SRO often errs in deciding that two businesses that operate on the same premise/s do share employees and therefore ought to be captured by the grouping provisions. The following sections will discuss how to avoid this.
How to avoid being Grouped and Degrouping
While the wording of these provisions vary across states, they commonly apply in the following circumstance:
- An employee that performs duties for a business carried on by their employer and another party, the employer and that other party will be grouped.
In light of the above, there are several factors which the SRO should look at in assessing whether two businesses are grouped by virtue of the shared employee grouping provisions.
The first thing that is looked at is the degree of autonomy that each business has from each other. In assessing this, the SRO should have regard to the nature and degree of ownership and control of the business, the nature of the business and other matters they may consider relevant.
In assessing independence, the SRO will also look at the following factors, including but not limited to:
- The degree of commercial transactions between the businesses, including the value and proportion of the entity’s total business conducted with the other entity;
- The degree to which the members share resources, facilities, and/or services;
- The level of control the entity has over, of its involvement in, the managerial decisions and day-to-day operations of the other business (and vice versa);
- The respective duties of each businesses’ employees; and
- The type of connection between the nature of the businesses of the entities.
Whether both businesses/entities share the same management (e.g. whether the directors are the same);

Ordinarily, the employees of PRU and XYZ at the Ascot Vale premise are not shared employees given they are employed with their respective employers and not both. However we have often seen the SRO group these entities together due to the fact that they operate in the same premise.
In many of these cases, we find that the employees of PRU and XYZ often are providing services to each other rather than providing duties which would be caught under the grouping provisions. For example, the employees of XYZ are employed to carry out general, non-pharmaceutical services in the Ascot Vale pharmacy. They fall short of providing duties to PRU because the employees of XYZ are unable to provide duties associated with being a pharmacist. In many of our matters, we have successfully argued for degrouping by arguing that the employees of PRU and XYZ are wholly separate, being that one operates in the pharmaceutical industry and the other retail. They merely provide services to each other to ensure that the businesses are efficient and professionally run and enabling one business of the premise to focus solely on their day to day operations leaving the matters within the purview of the management agreement with the other business and their expertise.
Further to this, an application to degroup is also necessary. In assessing whether to degroup XYZ and PRU the level of independence between these two entities is a significant factor.
In these circumstances, the following is influential in determining a favourable outcome for clients like PRU and XYZ:
- Whether they share directors/partners with each other;
- The types of employees they employ and whether they are separate;
- The necessity to operate through a management agreement due to regulations;
- Whether the employees of PRU and XYZ may direct each other on their duties; and
- The fact that PRU and XYZ do not hold any shares or interests in each other.
While we see these provisions applying to the context of pharmaceutical businesses, other businesses that utilise management agreements may unknowingly be caught by the grouping provisions despite operating wholly different businesses. The ambit of these provisions of often wide and unjustly captures businesses that are independent of each other.
If you wish to discuss this further and how the grouping provisions may apply to your business, please contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon of our Taxation Team.
Contract Nomination Exercise – Unpacking the Double Duty Trap – Inherent Risks in Land Developments and Additional Consideration for Property Transactions in Victoria
A common issue our taxation team encounters in relation to a property transaction is the imposition of double stamp duty on purchasers. This occurs as a result of a second sale of land to a subsequent purchaser, often referred to as the nominee. As a result of this, the State Revenue Office will charge duty on the first transfer between the vendor and first purchaser as well as the subsequent purchaser, or nominee/s, meaning duty is imposed twice. As such, it is important for prospective purchasers of land to understand their stamp duty implications when they agree to a sub-sale to avoid the double duty implications imposed by the Duties Act 2000 (“The Act”).
This article will highlight:
- When double duty will arise in a property transaction; and
- How to prevent the SRO imposing double duty on your property transaction.
Circumstances that will lead to double duty
Section 32J and 32C of the Act outline the circumstances in which duty will be payable in a property transaction which involve a nomination. Broadly speaking, double duty will arise in two circumstances:
- A subsequent purchaser or nominee gives or agrees to give additional consideration (nomination fee) to obtain the transfer right; and
- There is land development before a nomination occurs.
Additional Consideration
This is defined under section 32B of the Act to mean any consideration given by a nominee in order for the nominee to obtain the transfer right (i.e. the right to purchase the property following the contract of sale) if:
- The nominee obtained the transfer right from the initial purchaser and the consideration provided by the nominee exceeds the consideration given or agreed to be given to the vendor by the first purchaser; or
- If a subsequent nominee obtained the transfer right from the nominee that exceeds the consideration provided by the nominee.
For example, if a property transaction was valued at $100,000 and the nominee paid $120,000 with a $20,000 premium for the property, duty will be due and payable on the $100,000 sale as well as the $120,000 sale.
It is also important to note the application of section 32B to parallel arrangements. This is defined as an arrangement where the nominee or associate of the nominee obtains a transfer right under a sale contract where the first purchaser of the property enters into a construction contract with the nominee to build a home on the land. Under section 32B(5) of the act, a parallel arrangement is deemed to be additional consideration and would be considered under the ambit of section 32B.
Land Development
While the ordinary definition of land development may suggest a physical change to the land (e.g. construction of a house or demolition of fixtures), land development under the Act has a very wide definition. We have frequently seen developers, purchasers, and other parties inadvertently caught under section 32J when applying for a building permit, due to the broad definition of land development.
Under section 3 of the Act, land development means, in relation to land, any of the following:
- Preparing a plan of subdivision of the land or taking any steps to have the plan registered under the Subdivision Act 1988;
- Applying for or obtaining a permit under the Planning and Environment Act 1987 in relation to the use or development of the land;
- Requesting under the Planning and Environment Act 1987 a planning authority to prepare an amendment to a planning scheme that would affect the land;
- Applying for or obtaining a permit or approval under the building Act 1993 in relation to the land;
- Doing anything in relation to the land for which a permit or approval referred to in paragraph (d) would be required;
- Developing or changing the land in any other way that would lead to the enhancement of its value.
A common scenario (our taxation team encounters) in the context of a property transaction where double duty is imposed can be seen in the example below:
Example –
The taxpayer has entered into a Contract of Sale of Real Estate for the purchase of the property for $1,000,000. Following this, the taxpayer lodges an application for a planning permit with their local council.
Through a nomination form provided for under the Contract of Sale, the taxpayer nominates a corporate trustee as the substitute purchaser of the property under the contract. By a transfer of land instrument, the property was transferred to the corporate trustee for the stated consideration of $1,000,000.
Because the nomination occurred after the land development took place (i.e. the application for the planning permit), the property transaction is liable under section 32J on both the transaction between the vendor and taxpayer as well as the taxpayer and corporate trustee. The total dutiable value here would then be $2,000,000.
If land development is planned, it is crucial that applications for permits or subdivision plans are made after the nomination. Otherwise, parties should ensure that nominations are made as soon as possible to avoid the imposition of a second round of duty on the transaction. Helpfully, the Commissioner has provided guidelines in determining whether an action taken would constitute land development in its Ruling DA-064.
In considering whether an activity would constitute land development for the purposes of the Act, the Commissioner will consider the following:
- Facts, circumstances and contexts of each matter;
- Tangible and intentional actions associated with developing and changing the use of the land; and
- Overall effect and consequence of the activity.
Points 1 and 6 above bear considerable importance due to the confusion that they may cause.
Under the first point, the Commissioner views that initial activities undertaken to prepare a plan of subdivision or measures towards registering a plan of subdivision or consolidation under the Subdivision Act 1988 will constitute land development. These activities consist of:
- Drafting or re-drafting a plan of subdivision or consolidation;
- Commissioning a professional review of a plan of subdivision or consolidation for the purpose of amending the plan or preparing a new plan;
- Lodging a plan of subdivision or consolidation for council for certification;
- Undertaking any other works required to obtain a Statement of Compliance;
- Submitting the plan of subdivision or consolidation for registration.
Activities that the Commissioner does not consider to be land development includes:
- Preliminary research and analysis on the market and the area in order to identify the general development potential of the property, including:
- consulting with real estate agents and reviewing sales data
- reviewing and considering any planning scheme zoning, schedules, overlays, and other council/state planning guideline, policy or requirement that applies to the property
- looking into the costs involved in the process of subdividing a property.
- Performing routine property searches or checks against title or an existing plan of subdivision commissioned by another party.
- General and preliminary inquiries about the process for preparing a plan of subdivision or an amendment to an existing plan.
- Informal surveys and measurements of a property.
Point 6 is a catch-all limb that is focused on activities that enhance the value of the property. The Commissioner’s ruling states that even if the first 5 points are not met, the activity may constitute land development under this point if it leads to the enhancement of the value of the land. This would purportedly include:
- Decontamination of land
- Purchaser replacing certain parts of the property (e.g. roof or windows) and etc.
Interestingly, the Commissioner also notes in the ruling that activities that do not alter the physical characteristics of land may still amount to land development if they lead to an enhancement of the value of the land. This purportedly includes changes in legal obligations in relation to the land such as the removal of a covenant as well as rezoning of land where:
- A Minister rezones land as a result of submissions from any parties to the contract; or
- Any of the parties to the contract made a submission in support of a proposed rezoning of land.
Avoiding Double Duty
Under section 32J, duty is only charged separately and distinctly between the vendor/purchaser and purchaser/nominee in circumstances where the land development occurs prior to the nomination. Subsection 5 excludes duty from being charged separately and distinctly if the land development did not occur before the nomination.
This is particularly important given that the standard contract of sale of land provided by the LIV provides for the purchaser to nominate an entity. Due to this, it is of particular importance for purchasers and nominees to understand that if they want to avoid falling into the double duty trap, they should plan accordingly.
If land development is being entertained for the property, it is important that any applications for a permit or plan of subdivision ought to occur following a nomination.
Otherwise, the parties should ensure that any nominations should occur as soon as possible to avoid any possibility of a second tranche of duty being imposed on the transaction.
If you intend to use the nomination clause in a contract we recommend that you note the above and nominate as early as possible prior to any development activities.
Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon of our Taxation Team.
Uber’s Legal Lift: Tax Assessments Take a Backseat – Uber Successful in Challenging SRO’s Payroll Tax Assessment of $81m
On Friday, 6 September 2024, The Supreme Court of NSW ruled in favour of Uber in Uber Australia Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2024] NSWSC 1124. Chief Justice Hammerschlag ruled that Uber’s objection to six payroll tax assessments amounting to $81,515,923 from 2015 to 2020 should be upheld.
This case, assuming the Chief Commissioner does not appeal it, will have significant implications for taxpayers and Chief Commissioners in other States and Territories on how payroll tax ought to be regulated in regard to the gig economy. In respect to taxpayers who employ contractors or operate on models similar to Uber, it highlights how the manner in which contractors are paid may determine whether the employer will be liable for payroll tax in their respective state.
Background
The Plaintiff, Uber, applied to the Court to review the decision of the Defendant, the Chief Commissioner, disallowing Uber’s objection of six payroll tax assessments.
Uber is a rideshare system which enables riders in contact with drivers of motor vehicles offering the service to pick them up and transport them to their destination. This service is achieved by way of Uber’s software described as the Driver and Rider App.
The following is broadly how Uber’s service is structured:

The Chief Commissioner assessed Uber should have paid payroll tax on the basis that the amounts received by Uber from the Rider and remitted to the Uber drivers and are wages as amounts paid or payable for or in relation to the performance of work relating to a relevant contract. The Commissioner did so on the basis that Division 7 of the Payroll Tax Act treats certain payments to contractors as wages and caught under the payroll tax regime.
The issues in this case may be summarised as follows:
- Section 32 Payroll Tax Act 2007 – Whether there is a relevant contract between Uber and its Drivers
- A sub-issue here is whether services were undertaken by the Drivers;
- If those services were for or in relation to the performance of the work;
- Whether the services were supplied to Uber under a contract;
- Whether any statutory exceptions applied; and
- Whether the amounts paid by Uber were for or in relation to the performance of the work rendered by the Drivers.
Judgement
Issue 1 – Section 32 – Was there a relevant contract?
The issue here required the identification of what services was supplied to Uber and the existence of a relationship between the services and the performance of work which results in those services being “for or in relation to” that work.
The Court acknowledged that the term, ‘services’ has a wide meaning as per IW v City of Perth (1997) 191 CLR at 11 defining it as an act of helpful activity. In characterising the services provided by the Drivers to Uber, the Court accepted the Chief Commissioner’s contention and adopted a trichotomy analysis moving forward. The Chief Commissioner argued that the following were services supplied by the drivers to Uber:
- Transporting riders from their pickup point and transporting them to their destination;
- Giving feedback about riders at the end of the trip; and
- Referring people to Uber for the purpose of them becoming drivers.
Further, Uber was supplied with the above services in relation to the provision/performance of the work, that being the transportation of riders to their destination.
In regard to whether the services were suppled to Uber under the contracts, the Court, referring to Commissioner of Taxation v Sara Lee outlined that the contract under which something occurs is to be identified by determining whether it is properly seen as the source of the obligation to do that thing. The crux here being that if what is done is the exercise of a right, the determination is whether the contract is properly seen as the source of the right.
Although the drivers had the right to determine when to provide the services, the obligation imposed on them on when and where they could exercise their right to drive the customers was sourced in the contracts.
“The Contracts give drivers and partners the right, if and when they drive, to use the Driver App. They have the right to use the Driver App even if they choose not to drive. The right to use it, and all the entitlements and benefits stemming from its use, including the opportunity to drive, or to decline to drive, for gain, have their source in the Contracts”.
Issue 2 – Are there any Statutory Exceptions
Ancillary Exclusion
It was found that the rating services provided by Uber whereby the drivers rated the riders at the end of the trip was ancillary to the use of the goods which were the property of the driver. On the other hand, the driving and by extension the referral services were one and the same with the provision of the vehicle. The Court outlined that it cannot be properly described that driving as a service is ancillary to the use of the vehicle. There is no room for separating the two, that being the provision of the vehicle and the act of driving the vehicle to the rider’s destination.
The consequence of the finding that the driving and referral services were not ancillary meant that section 32(2B) applied to ‘denude’ Uber of the benefits of the ancillary exclusion for its rating service. This was interestingly a consequence of the Court and the parties to this case accepting a trichotomy analysis, where the services were assessed as a whole, as opposed to a holistic analysis where the three services provided to Uber by the drivers would have been assessed separately.
90 Day Exclusion
Whether this exception applies depends, in relation to each driver, whether the services provided by the drivers were supplied for less than 90 days during the financial year. The Chief Commissioner argued here that if a driver supplied services of any kind during the day, regardless of the brevity of said service, that day would be counted as a day for the calculation of whether the 90 day threshold has been met. Uber on the other hand argued that working for a specified period of the day means working for that many hours notionally equivalent to that which would have been worked by a full-time employee.
The Court rejected Uber’s approach outlining that the selection of 7.6 hour days is “random and imports ambulatory operation”.
To the Public Generally Exclusion
This exception applies if the services performed by the drivers are of the type ordinarily performed by the driver to the public generally.
Uber’s contention was that there are drivers that held taxi licences and hire car licences during the relevant period. Uber argued that the services supplied by said drivers to Uber are of the same kind provided to the public by the taxi drivers and hire car drivers and the exception applied.
However the Court found that there was insufficient evidence to establish the frequency of the taxi or hire car driving by the drivers to enable the Court to conclude that the drivers ordinarily engaged in that activity.
Issue 3 – Are Amounts Paid or Payable to Uber taken to be Wages Paid or Payable under s35(1)
The crux of the issue here is whether the there was a connection between the payments made by Uber to the Drivers and the services/work done by the Drivers.
The Court found that it was not Uber who pays the driver to establish that connection. The rider does that. Uber was characterised as a mere payment collection agent. While Uber had to account to its drivers for what it received as an agent, by the time Uber has done that, the driver has already been paid and the rider has discharged their obligation to pay the driver for the ride. The Court highlighted the following clause in the Driver Contract which indicated this:
“You appoint Uber as your limited payment collection agent solely to accept the Fare, applicable Tolls, and , depending on the region and/or if requested by you, applicable taxes and fees from the User on your behalf via the Uber Services’ payment processing functionality, and agree that the User’s payment made directly by the User to you”
While there was certainly a relationship between the payment made by Uber to its drivers and the work which said driver performed, that relationship cannot be described such that the payments made by Uber as payment collection agent was in relation to the work done. The said work had already been done by the driver. In particular, the Court noted:
“There is no element of reciprocity or calibration between the driver and Uber or the rider and Uber with respect to the money paid by the rider. Those elements exist only between the driver and the rider. The payment here is made pursuant to an obligation to account, and no more
…
What the rider pays the driver is for or in relation to the work done by the driver. What Uber pays the driver is in relation to the payment Uber has received, not in relation to the work itself”
Indeed, what the rider pays the driver is for or in relation to the work done by the driver. What Uber paid is in relation to what Uber has received, not in relation to the work conducted by the driver itself.
As a result of this, the Court allowed the Uber’s objection to the six payroll tax assessments by the Chief Commissioner.
Observation
This case is noteworthy given it would need to be considered alongside similar cases, such as payments made by medical practices to their doctors. This case is similar to Homefront Nursing Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2019] NSWCATAD 145 where the Tribunal found that payments made by patients to the Practice where made as a matter of convenience in a way quite similar to using the Practice as a bank. Contrastingly, the Tribunal in Thomas and Naaz Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2021] NSWCATAD 259 found that the availability of the Medicare benefits which was made to the GPs was a direct consequence of the provision of the services provided by the GPs to the Practice.
It would be interesting to see how future cases considering payroll tax in the context of medical practices or other entities that purport to act as mere payment collection agents in the employer/contractor context would apply this case with Homefront Nursing and Thomas and Naaz. In particular, [68] of the Tribunal’s decision in Thomas and Naaz presents an interesting question in regard to [179 – [181] of the Uber case given an indirect relationship between the work done and payments is sufficient:
“There is a clear relationship between the provision of the services and the Payments. The availability of the Medicare benefits to the Doctors was a direct consequence of the provision of the services. The Payments were the amount of those benefits less a 30 per cent deduction. Whilst the relationship between the provision of the services and the Payments was not direct, there was a clear indirect relationship sufficient to satisfy the terms of the section. There is nothing in the context of the section nor its legislative history to suggest that such a relationship is insufficient.“
Again, this decision may not be set in stone given that the Chief Commissioner has 28 days from the 6th September to appeal the decision.
Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon of our Taxation Team.
Vesting Interests: Stamping Out Capital Confusion – CGT and Victorian Stamp Duty Consequences of a Trust Vesting
In our collective experience, our Taxation Team has observed that there have been innumerable family trusts that have been established in the 70s and 80s prior to the introduction of Capital Gains Tax and with short vesting dates of 40 or 50 years. This means that for the next decade or so, various family trusts will start vesting. Depending on how the affairs of the Trust are structured, there are important CGT and Stamp Duty implications of these trusts vesting. Further to this, the actions of the trustee/s and beneficiaries following the vesting date may also affect whether a Capital Gains Event has occurred and whether Stamp Duty is payable.
Our Taxation Team has noticed that there has been a marked increase in the number of clients requesting advice on the consequences of their trusts vesting. Hence, this article will discuss the CGT and Stamp Duty consequences of trusts vesting.
What does Vesting Mean?
Usually, a trust deed specifies a date in which the interests in a trust becomes vested. This can be described as the vesting date or termination date within the deed. On the vesting date, the interests in the property of the trust become vested in interest and possession.
CGT Consequences of Trusts Vesting
In assessing whether or not a CGT event has happened, the ATO in their TR 2018/6 acknowledged three possible CGT events that may occur when a trusts vests:
- CGT Event E1 – A new trust has been created
- CGT Event E5 – A beneficiary becomes absolutely entitled against the trustee
- CGT Event E7 – Disposal to beneficiary to end capital interest
CGT Event E1
Ordinarily, the vesting of a trust will not cause a new trust to come into existence. Although a bare trust may be created, this is a mere continuation of the trust in the form of a bare trust and would not constitute the creation of a new trust. Section 104.55 notes that CGT event E1 occurs when a person creates a trust over a CGT asset by declaration or settlement. Indeed, the phrase “declaration and settlement” implies that the trust will need to be expressly created, for example, through the voluntary disposition of the interest in an asset by the person creating the trust in favour of another. This will rarely ever be triggered in the vesting of a trust.
There may circumstances in which the actions of the trustee or beneficiaries may result in a new trust to be created by declaration and hence trigger CGT event E1. TR 2018/6 provides the following example to illustrate in what circumstances a new trust will arise following the vesting date:
|
Example 4 – purported extension after vesting date
A discretionary trust holding several rental properties had a vesting date of 30 September 2016.
On 1 June 2017, the trustee became aware that the vesting date had passed and, with the acquiescence of the takers on vesting, continued to manage the trust as if the trust had not vested. On 29 June 2017, the trustee executed a deed of extension that purported to extend the trust’s vesting date to 30 September 2057.
The subsequent execution of a deed of extension is void and ineffective to change the trust’s vesting date that has already passed. Any power of the trustee to extend the vesting date ceased on 30 September 2016.
Note: if, once it is realised that the deed of extension is ineffective to change the trust’s vesting date, all of the takers on vesting agree that the trust assets should continue to be held on a new trust on the same terms as the original trust, and this was effective to create a new trust over the assets by declaration or settlement, CGT event E1 would happen in relation to the trust assets.
|
As a result of the above, trustees and beneficiaries should take note of the following:
- In considering any extension of the trust’s vesting date (Prior to the trust’s vesting date), trustees and beneficiaries should take account of the fact that any deed purporting to extend the lifespan of the trust past 80 years from the creation of the trust will be void as it contravenes the rule against perpetuities in Victoria; and
- Any attempt to create a new trust over the existing trust assets following the vesting date will trigger CGT event E1.
CGT Event E5
Whether CGT event E5 occurs depend on whether a beneficiary becomes “absolutely entitled” to a CGT asset of the trust as against the trustee as per section 104.75. The ATO notes that at paragraph 20 of the ruling, whether any beneficiaries become absolutely entitled to an asset depends on the particular interests of the trust on vesting.
The phrase, “absolutely entitled” has been extensively considered. In Oswal v FCT, Edmonds J outlined that CGT event E5 could not arise as the beneficiaries could not become absolutely entitled to an asset where the trustee had a lien over the assets for their right to be indemnified out of the trust. With this in mind, noting that various trust deeds explicitly provide for the right of a trustee to be indemnified out of a trust, the beneficiaries may rarely become absolutely entitled to the CGT assets of the trust. Note that trustee will always have the common law right of indemnity against trust assets in respect of performing its duties.
In addition to the above, Draft TR 2004/D25 takes the view that a class of beneficiaries may only be absolutely entitled to the CGT assets of the trust where a single beneficiary has the right to all of the assets. Hence, in circumstances on a trust vesting where there is more than one beneficiary who is entitled to the assets of the trust, none of the beneficiaries will be absolutely entitled to the assets of the trust and CGT event E5 does not occur.
CGT event E7
CGT event E7 will not usually occur post vesting unless there has been a distribution of the CGT assets of the trust to the takers on vesting. TR 2018/6 provides an example of this occurring is upon actual distribution of CGT assets to beneficiaries. As such, if the trustee distributes the assets of the property out of the trust to the beneficiaries such that the beneficiaries’ interest in the trust has ended, CGT event E7 will occur.
It should be noted that given that there has been a disposal of a CGT asset, CGT event A1 would also arise. However, by virtue of section 102.25 ITAA97, if more than one event does happen, the taxpayer is required to use the more specific event to their situation. Given that CGT event A1 is the broader event, it would be appropriate to apply CGT event E7 instead in these circumstances.
Stamp Duty Implications on Trust Vesting
On a trust vesting, it is unlikely that Stamp duty will arise in Victoria. Section 77 of the Duties Act 2000 (Vic) states that duty is chargeable over relevant acquisitions. Relevant acquisitions occur when a person acquires an interest in a landholder and that interest is a significant interest. A significant interest in respect of an acquisition in a private company occurs if a person in the event of a distribution of all the property of the landholder is entitled to more than 50% or more of the property distributed. Hence, upon the initial vesting of the trust and where the ownership of the property remains within the trust, no stamp duty arises.
If the trust decides to pass its assets to the takers on vesting, then stamp duty may be applicable depending on whether the stamp duty exemption under section 36A of the Duties Act 2000 (Vic) applies. Note that section 36A provides that no duty is chargeable in respect of a transfer of dutiable property subject to a discretionary trust to a beneficiary of the trust if the beneficiary was a beneficiary at the relevant time and no consideration is payable. The relevant time in this provision is defined to mean in relation to a dutiable property that is subject to the trust, the time at which the property first became subject to the principal trust. As such, the section 36A exemption is only to those beneficiaries who were beneficiaries at the time the trust had acquired the dutiable property and where consideration is not considered by the SRO to have passed from the beneficiaries. This must be carefully considered in each case.
Takeaway
- Awareness of Trust Vesting Date: beneficiaries and trustees should be aware of the specific vesting date of their trusts. This is because vesting in the near future may have several CGT and stamp duty implications that need to be addressed.
- Post-Vesting Actions: Some actions taken by trustees and beneficiaries after the vesting date are crucial. For example, if the trustees continue to manage the trust as if it has not vested without properly extending the lifespan of the trust, this may trigger CGT event E1.
- CGT Implications: the vesting of a trust may have several CGT consequences. These include:
- CGT Event E1 – This is unlikely to occur unless the trustees and beneficiaries agree the new assets are to be held on a new trust on the same terms as the old trust.
- CGT Event E5 – Unlikely to occur due to the right of indemnity the trustee has over the trust and usually in family trusts, there is more than one beneficiary.
- CGT Event E7 – Will occur if the trustee does make a distribution of trust assets to the takers on vesting.
- Stamp Duty Implications:
- Not generally triggered as a result of the vesting of the trust if the asset remains in the trust.
- If the trustees do decide to make a distribution of dutiable property, trustees should consider whether section 36A applies and whether the current beneficiaries were beneficiaries at the time the trust acquired the dutiable property and the distribution was for no consideration.
Should you wish to discuss the above, please contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon of our Taxation Team.
Employees versus Contractors: ATO Indicators and Audit Resource Allocation
The ATO has also released their Practical Compliance Guideline 2023/2 which sets out the approach of the Commissioner to businesses that classify their workers as either employees or independent contractors. As such, the guidelines sets out how the Commissioner allocates audit compliance resources based on the risk structure as seen below and are worthy of consideration.
Businesses are also encouraged to assess their risk rating and if applicable, adjust their hiring practices. As seen below, this may include ensuring that:
- both parties intended their relationship to be classified in a specific manner, either An independent contract or employee relationship;
- there is a comprehensive written agreement between the worker and employer;
- both parties knew of the taxation implications of being characterised as an independent contractor or employee;
- the performance of the arrangement has not deviated significantly from the initial agreement;
- specific advice as to the nature and tax implications of the employer and worker relationship was obtained to avoid unnecessary liability; and
- advice obtained from the compliance guideline was also communicated to the worker.
These are the ATO risk zone classifications.
| Risk Zone |
Unpaid superannuation query |
Proactive case selection |
| Very Low |
No further compliance resources will be applied. |
No further compliance resources will be applied. |
| Low |
Compliance resources will be applied to test whether the worker meets the extended definition of employee under the SGAA. |
No further compliance resources will be applied. |
| Medium |
Compliance resources will be applied to test whether the worker is an employee under the ordinary meaning or meets the extended definition of employee under the SGAA (or both). Medium-risk arrangements will be given lower priority than arrangements that are rated high risk. |
Compliance resources will be applied to test whether the worker is an employee under the ordinary meaning or meets the extended definition of employee under the SGAA (or both). Medium-risk arrangements will be given lower priority than arrangements that are rated high risk. |
| High |
Compliance resources will be applied to test whether the worker is an employee under the ordinary meaning or meets the extended definition of employee under the SGAA (or both). High-risk arrangements will be given the highest priority resourcing.
Engaging entities may be subject to higher penalties if it is found that they failed to correctly classify their workers.
|
Compliance resources will be applied to test whether the worker is an employee under the ordinary meaning or meets the extended definition of employee under the SGAA (or both). High-risk arrangements will be given the highest priority resourcing.
Engaging entities may be subject to higher penalties if it is found that they failed to correctly classify their workers.
|
These are the ATO criteria they will consider when determining a risk zone and audit.
| Criterion |
Very Low |
Low |
Medium |
High |
| 1 |
There is evidence that both parties intended for the worker to be classified in the same way, either as an employee or as an independent contractor |
There is evidence that both parties intended for the worker to be classified in the same way, either as an employee or as an independent contractor |
There is evidence that both parties intended for the worker to be classified in the same way, either as an employee or as an independent contractor |
Any arrangements that do not fall within the other 3 risk zones |
| 2 |
There is a comprehensive written agreement that governs the entire relationship between the parties |
There is a comprehensive written agreement that governs the entire relationship between the parties |
Not applicable |
Any arrangements that do not fall within the other 3 risk zones |
| 3 |
There is evidence to show that both parties understood what the worker’s classification meant, and what the tax and superannuation consequences of that classification would be |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Any arrangements that do not fall within the other 3 risk zones |
| 4 |
The performance of the arrangement has not significantly deviated from the contractual rights and obligations agreed to by the parties |
The performance of the arrangement has not significantly deviated from the contractual rights and obligations agreed to by the parties |
The performance of the arrangement has not significantly deviated from the contractual rights and obligations agreed to by the parties |
Any arrangements that do not fall within the other 3 risk zones |
| 5 |
The party relying on this Guideline is meeting the correct tax and superannuation obligations that arise for their intended classification, and reporting appropriately |
The party relying on this Guideline is meeting the correct tax and superannuation obligations that arise for their intended classification, and reporting appropriately |
The party relying on this Guideline is meeting the correct tax and superannuation obligations that arise for their intended classification, and reporting appropriately |
Any arrangements that do not fall within the other 3 risk zones |
| 6 |
The party relying on this Guideline obtained specific advice confirming the classification was correct |
The party relying on this Guideline obtained specific advice confirming the classification was correct |
Not applicable |
Any arrangements that do not fall within the other 3 risk zones |
| 7 |
An engaging business relying on this Guideline also obtained specific advice confirming the application of the extended meaning of employee under the SGAA, and communicated this outcome to the worker |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Any arrangements that do not fall within the other 3 risk zones |
Regardless of whether employers classify their workers as employees or independent contractors, employers are encouraged to review their relationship with their workers given the changes the ATO has implemented in classifying workers as either contractors or employees.
In doing so, businesses should assess review their existing contracts in reference to the updated risk and assessment framework to minimise the risk of an ATO investigation or audit.
We suggest that each employer or employee or contractor read this to determine when they believe the ATO would classify the relationship and therefore proceed to audit or not.
If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon of our Melbourne Office.
Importance of the original employment contract in respect of determining who is an employee for PAYG
Late last year, the ATO released their new Taxation Ruling 2023/4 which sets out the ATO’s view on whether a worker is an independent contractor or employee. The purpose of this ruling is to assist businesses – who employ independent contractors and employees – in determining whether they have to withhold amounts from a worker’s salary, wages, commission bonuses or allowances in respect to their PAYG obligations. The ruling applies only to PAYG obligations under s12-35 of the Taxation Administration Act 1953, it may also assist with other laws administered by the Commissioner of Taxation such as Superannuation Guarantee, Fringe Benefits Tax and Single Touch Payroll Reporting, but note that those acts have differing provisions.
This ruling is notable for employers given that the penalty for failing to comply with PAYG obligations may be significant being the amount that would be withheld normally. Additionally, penalties for failing to comply with Superannuation Guarantee (as examined in our earlier article), FBT and Single Touch Payroll Reporting could also apply. Although the ruling was released on 6 December last year, it applies to both before and after the date of its issue.
Taxation Ruling 2023/4
As opposed to the past ruling which held that the totality of the relationship between the parties is relevant in determining whether a worker is an independent contractor or employee, the ambit of this consideration has been narrowed down with regard being had only to the legal rights and obligations which constitute that relationship and they have been guided by the Courts consideration of these issues.
This means that the contract of employment has taken a central role in ascertaining the relevant legal rights and obligations. Despite the fact that regard is only had to the legal rights and obligations forming the relationship, recourse may also be had to events, circumstances and things external to the contract which are objectively known to the parties at the time of entering into the contract which could assist with identifying the purpose or object of the contract.
The Courts have in separate considerations of employment contracts relating to restrictive covenants referred back to the validity and effect of these terms as at the date of the original contract. If the employee was a cleaner at the time of the contract the restrictive covenant will be read as such and not relating to the employees current role as for example manager.
Hence, assuming the contract is valid, evidence of how the contract was performed, including subsequent conduct and work practices are irrelevant considerations. Indeed, there are good reasons to not consider subsequent conduct and practices. As noted in CFMMEU v Personnel Contracting, the nature of the legal relationship may change with the unilateral conduct of one of the parties:
“on the day after a contract is formed, the parties may be in an employer/employee relationship, but six months or a year later, having regard to the parties’ subsequent conduct, their relationship may have changed to one of principal/independent contractor”
Resultantly, as the nature of the legal relationship may change without the other party knowing, this would have consequences in the ways that they conduct their affairs.
Once the legal relationship has been construed, the Commissioner notes that the indicia presented in case law offers as useful approach in characterising the legal relationship. These indicia include whether:
- the worker serves in the business of an employer as opposed to providing services to the business. An important question to ask here is whether the worker is working in the business or enterprise of the employer;
- the employer has control and the right to control the actions of the worker. However the right to control must be viewed in the context of the relationship. In ZG Operations, the high Court found that a clause requiring carriage of goods as reasonably directed did not confer the necessary control for an employer/employee relationship to subsist;
- the worker may delegate their work to others. Where the worker has an unfettered right to delegate their work to others, this is a strong indicator against them being an employee;
- the substance of the contract was for an end result. Consideration paid for a specified job is often a fixed sum paid on completion of the particular job as opposed to an amount paid to an employee for their hours worked, activities performed or a commission;
- the worker has to provide their own tools and equipment. This serves as an indication that the worker is an independent contractor ;
- either party bears the risk or is solely responsible for the generation of goodwill. For example, if a contract prevents any goodwill from accruing for a worker’s possible business, this may indicate that the worker is instead serving in the engaging entity’s business.
If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact Tony Pointon and Andrew Pointon.