Off-The-Plan Sales Rescission Risk – What Changes To Subdivision Plans Will “Materially Affect” Lots?
In Lockwood v PSP Investments Pty Ltd [2013] VSC 10, the Victorian Supreme Court recently confirmed that an amendment to the plan of subdivision contained in an off-the-plan contract need not be ‘adverse’ or ‘affect rights deleteriously’ to materially affect a lot and give the purchaser a right to terminate the contract.
This case provides further guidance as to the basis on which a purchaser may rescind an ‘off-the-plan’ contract where the vendor amends the plan of subdivision in a way which will “materially affect the lot to which the contract relates”. It also demonstrates the Court’s continuing shift toward protection of “vulnerable purchasers”.
FACTS
In January 2010, Lockwood (the purchaser) entered into eight separate off-the-plan contracts of sale with PSP Investments Pty Ltd (the vendor) to purchase lots in a development in Windsor called Ecosquare. Four contracts related to apartments and four contracts related to car parks. At the day of sale, the plan of subdivision was unregistered.
After the contracts were signed and the deposits were paid by the purchaser, the proposed plan of subdivision was amended due to Local Council requirements. Consequently, the car parks were converted to common property and other amendments were also made to the plan of subdivision which increased the common property and varied the lot liabilities and entitlements of the apartments in the development.
The vendor did not notify the purchaser of the changes to the plan of subdivision until after the plan of subdivision was registered. The purchaser sought to rescind each of the four apartment contracts on the basis that the amendments to the plan of subdivision would “materially affect the lot to which the contract relates” under section 9AC of the Sale of Land Act 1962 (Vic). The car parks no longer existed and were no longer available for sale. Accordingly, the purchaser demanded a refund of the deposits that it had paid in respect of all eight contracts. When the vendor refused to refund the deposits paid in respect of the apartment lots, the purchaser brought an application to establish that the contracts were validly rescinded pursuant to section 9AC(2) of the Act and for the return of the deposits under section 9AF of the Act.
ISSUE
The issue before the Supreme Court was whether the amendments to the Plan materially affected the lot, and therefore entitled the purchaser to rescind the apartment contracts under section 9AC(2) of the Act.
The defendant argued that the deletion of the car parks did not materially affect the apartment lots. It stated that the ‘substance of what had been contracted for’ had not been altered by the amendments and, therefore, Lockwood had no right to rescind.
The plaintiff argued that the increase in common property and associated owners corporation entitlements materially affected the apartment lots. Moreover, the deletion of the car parks had materially changed the essential elements of the scheme as a whole. Also, the apartment contracts should be considered as connected to the car park contracts.
DECISION
The Supreme Court decided:
- For an amendment to a plan of subdivision to materially affect a lot, there is no requirement in section 9AC(2) of the Act that the amendment needs to be deleterious, or adversely affect the lot or the rights of the purchaser, in order to give the purchaser the right to rescind.
- When considering the impact of the amendment, the car park and apartment contracts should be considered together, as both parties would have understood that the car parks were purchased for use with the apartment lots, and that the car park lots enhanced the value to the purchaser of each apartment.
- In essence, the transaction as a whole was for four packages of an apartment and car park.
- Even if the contracts were to be considered in isolation, the amendments materially affected the apartment lots both by removing the car park lots and by increasing the common property. Consequently, this lead to a substantial change to the bundle of rights and lot entitlements/liabilities of each apartment lot owner.
The Supreme Court ultimately held that the deletion of the car park lots and the defendant’s inability to complete those contracts materially affected the apartment lots. Thus, the court concluded that Lockwood had validly rescinded each apartment contract pursuant to s 9AC(2), and ordered that the apartment deposits be returned to Lockwood pursuant to s 9AF of the Act.
IMPLICATIONS
This decision highlights the importance of timing for developers and the need for plans of subdivision to be finalised as much as possible prior to entering into contracts of sale.
It seems that the Supreme Court of Victoria will support rescinding purchasers when the Plan of Subdivision is altered. Accordingly, amendments to plans, whilst at times unavoidable, should therefore be kept to a minimum, especially in relation to changing lot entitlements and common property, and should be communicated to Purchasers in writing as soon as possible following a proposed amendment and prior to registration of the plan of subdivision.
Developers will need to take care to ensure that they comply with the relevant provisions of the Sale of Land Act 1962 if there are any changes being made to a Plan of Subdivision between a sale off-the-plan and the registration of the relevant Plan.
In order to determine whether a propose amendment will materially affect a lot, developers should:
- consider the affect of the amendment on the project as a whole and whether it changes the context in which the purchaser entered into the contract;
- note that changes to common property and lot entitlement/liability can be treated as materially affecting lots; and
- remember that even changes which are arguably beneficial to purchasers can be found to materially affect lots and create rescission risk.
POINTON PARTNERS
Our dedicated property services team can assist with the full spectrum of your property development needs, including:
- acting in complex negotiations for sales and acquisitions of development sites and sale documentation;
- preparing off-the-plan contract documentation and managing high volume off-the-plan sales;
- property joint ventures, development management, project management and consultancy agreements;
- property syndications and managed investment schemes;
- finance issues including security and mezzanine debt financing arrangements;
- assisting with property and contract due diligence investigations;
- advising on Capital Gains Tax, GST, stamp duty and land tax issues affecting property transactions;
- assisting with the planning process including permit applications and rezoning;
- facilitating subdivision, including liaising with surveyors, planning authorities, financiers and land registry;
- fixed fee conveyacing & contract administration;
- security issues; and
- dispute resolution.
If you have any further queries, please contact our office on 03 9614 7707.
Victorian retail leases – Landlords beware: are you providing the right form of disclosure?
Background
Leases of retail premises in Victoria are governed by the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) (Act) and the regulations. The former regulations were replaced by the new Retail Leases Regulations 2013 (Regulations), which took effect in 2013.
Introduction of four Disclosure Statements
The most significant effect of the new Regulations was to replace the multi-purpose Disclosure Statement with four separate Disclosure Statements. These statements are to be used in the following scenarios in connection with Victorian retail leases:
- Retail premises not located in retail shopping centres;
- Retail premises located in retail shopping centres;
- Renewal of a lease; and
- Assignments of a lease with an ongoing business.
Consequences of failing to give disclosure
There are serious consequences where a Disclosure Statement is not provided by a landlord, or if false, misleading or incomplete.
If the landlord fails upon entering into a new lease to provide a Disclosure Statement within the required time, and in the form prescribed by the Regulations, the tenant may, between 7 days and 90 days after entering into the lease, give the landlord written notice that they have not been provided with the prescribed Disclosure Statement.
In the case of renewal of a lease, if the landlord fails to provide a Disclosure Statement within the time, and in the form prescribed by the Regulations, the tenant may, at any time up to 90 days after the date by which the landlord was required to provide the Disclosure Statement, give the landlord written notice that they have not been provided with the prescribed Disclosure Statement.
If a tenant gives the landlord one of the notices referred to above, then the tenant:
- May withhold the payment of rent until the day on which the landlord provides the Disclosure Statement;
- Is not required or liable to pay rent for the period commencing on the day the notice was given by the tenant until the landlord gives the tenant the Disclosure Statement; and
- May terminate the lease at any time within 7 days from when the landlord gives the tenant the Disclosure Statement.
In the case of an assignment of lease, where a landlord fails to provide a tenant with a Disclosure Statement within 14 days of such a request being made by a tenant, the landlord may be subject to financial penalty.
Timing for giving Disclosure
The Act imposes different disclosure obligations on the landlord and strict timing requirements for giving disclosure depending on the circumstances which the landlord must be mindful of.
New items of disclosure
There are some key differences in the new forms of disclosure provided in the Regulations.
All forms of disclosure required to be given by the landlord now require disclosure concerning any alteration or demolition works, planned or known to the premises or building/centre in which the premises are located (including surrounding roads and to the land adjacent to or in close proximity to the premises or building/centre in which the premises are located) during the term or any further term or terms.
In addition, the statement for the assignment of a lease also requires a tenant to disclose any matter not connected to the lease agreement, planned or known to the tenant, which may materially affect the viability of the ongoing business over the remaining lease period. The outgoing tenant must also disclose whether the landlord has issued any notices to the tenant pursuant to the Act and any material variations to the Lease.
The Disclosure Statement for a renewal of a retail lease is quite different from the former multi-purpose Disclosure Statement. The renewal disclosure only requires the landlord to disclose any costs arising under the new lease, and any alteration or demolition works or other matters that may affect the tenant’s business (as noted above).
Form of Disclosure
A Disclosure Statement is required to be given in the form provided under the Regulations. The layout however, such as the appearance and font, may be altered. It is important to ensure when altering a statement that none of the wording of the prescribed form is removed or varied, even where a section may not be applicable.
It is important that both landlords and tenants are aware of the above changes to ensure that their disclosure is made in the correct form and at the appropriate time.
Pointon Partners have an experienced team that can assist Landlords, Tenants, Property Managers and Real Estate Agents with all leasing arrangements, including provision of the appropriate lease and disclosure documents.
We advise on commercial, industrial, and retail leases and can assist with the negotiation, preparation, variation surrender and assignment of leases, sub-leases, licence agreements, agreements to lease, shopping centre leases and mortgages of lease.
We are well versed in helping our clients understand their rights and obligations under leasing agreements and our practitioners regularly appear at VCAT and mediations by the Small Business Commissioner on leasing dispute matters.
If you have any queries about disclosures, please contact Ted Vlahos at Pointon Partners on 03 9614 7707.
Am I a Retailer For Leasing Purposes?
PROPERTY ALERT: CONFIRMED INTERPRETATION OF THE RETAIL PREMISES DEFINITION
In summary:
• The Supreme Court of Victoria has recently confirmed its position with respect to the interpretation of what constitutes a Retail Premises under the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) (the Act). In the recent case of Fitzroy Dental Pty Ltd v Metropole Management Pty Ltd & Anor [2013] VSC 344 (Fitzroy Dental) the court confirmed a broad interpretation of the definition of a Retail Premises as set out in section 4 of the Act.
• The Supreme Court has reminded those entities that are subject to the Act that their disputes are to be raised in the jurisdiction of VCAT as set out in part 10 of the Act.
The case of Fitzroy Dental dealt with the question of whether the premises in question were, under the terms of the lease, “used predominately for … the sale or hire of goods by retail, or for the retail provision of services.” (1) The Supreme Court in this case clarified its position on the interpretation of what is a Retail Premises by testing if the services or goods that are supplied by the tenant are supplied to the “ultimate consumer”.
Facts and Decision in Fitzroy Dental
As noted above the case was centred on the interpretation of what is a Retail Premises and if the premises subject to the dispute fell under this definition. The motive behind determining if the premises were a Retail Premises for the purposes of the Act was that the Plaintiff, being the Landlord, had five (5) years prior to the dispute arising taken possession of the title to the premises and also had been assigned the lease agreement with the First Defendant from the previous landlord. The lease was at some later time assigned from the First Defendant to the Second Defendant following the appointment of an administrator of the First Defendant. The Plaintiff, in separate proceedings in the Supreme Court, had sought for an order for possession of the premises (amongst other orders).
The First and Second Defendants made an application to the Supreme Court for a declaration that the lease was a Retail Leases Act lease and as such that the dispute is a retail tenancy dispute and it should be dealt with by VCAT and not the Supreme Court where the Plaintiff had made the application for possession.
The permitted use for the premises was a conference centre, cafe/restaurant area and associated office and storage space. There was no dispute between the parties regarding the permitted use of the premises, the only dispute regarding the premises was if it was a Retail premises or not.
The court found, after consideration of several precedents, rules and an application of the premises’ permitted and actual use to those precedents and rules that the premises were a Retail Premises as defined by the Act. The reasons for the court’s conclusion are as discussed below.
What is a Retail Premises?
A Retail Premises as defined by section 4 of the Act is a premises, not including any area intended for use as a residence, that under the terms of the lease relating to the premises are used, or are to be used, wholly or predominantly for:
(a) The sale or hire of goods by retail or the retail provision of services; or
When applying the ‘ultimate consumer’ test the ultimate consumer must be a person that does not use the service as a resupply of service or product as this would be wholesale. If the services of the conference centre in Fitzroy Dental are provided to the ‘ultimate consumer’ then it would be a retail provision of services, which it was found to be due to it being an input into providing a subsequent, different service.
His Honour stated that there “are two transactions involving the retail provision of services – first the provision of services to the conference or function provider … and then the provision of different services to the attendee.”(2)
The fact that a general passerby could not walk in off the street and use the conference centre (as booking was essential) is immaterial. Nor does it matter if an accounting firm, for instance, hired out the venue to provide a conference for its clients. The accounting firm would be the ‘ultimate consumer’ in the eyes of the conference centre and the attendee’s at the conference would be the ‘ultimate consumers’ of the advice or presentation provided at the conference by the accounting firm.
In adopting a previous decisions regarding a caravan park held to be a Retail Premises (3) Croft J applied that decision to Fitzroy Dental by the following reasoning:
“Foreshadowing discussion of the issue whether services are available to members of the public I observe that a caravan park is closer on the spectrum to the type of premises the subject of this application (the conference centre) in that, unlike a “shop”, whether it be a cabaret, discotheque or nightclub, it is not premises necessarily open and inviting to a casual passerby as may be the case with an ordinary shop. Rather it may be necessary to make a booking and, as the facilities are finite, the desired booking may not be fulfilled.” (4)
Further in his Honour’s judgement, he explained that there is no basis in the provisions of the Act or the authorities for constraining the concept of “open to the public”. As in the instance of a conference centre, it would not affect its retail ability if it were not open to those walking on the street as the ordinary course of that type of business would be to make a booking over the phone or by email.
Conclusion
The findings in the most recent case focusing on the definition of what is a Retail Premises provide the following guides to what would likely be considered a Retail Premises for the purposes of the Act.
For the purposes of section 4(a) of the Act a leased premises is likely to be a Retail Premises if:
– The premises is used for the provision of goods or services for retail; and
– The goods or services are sold or provided to an ‘ultimate consumer’ (ie a consumer that does not on sell the goods or services in the same state that they bought them in).
If your leased premises fall within the above definition then it is more than likely that the Act will apply to that lease. It is important to remember this as there are some onerous provisions of the Act that will apply. We recommend that you seek our advice if you are unsure about the characterisation of your property or leased premises.
For further information, or if you have any queries relating to this area, please contact Ted Vlahos, David Mazzeo or Brigid O’Dwyer of our office on 03 9614 7707.
(1) Fitzroy Dental Pty Ltd v Metropole Management Pty Ltd & Anor [2013] VSC 344 at 12
(2) [2013] VSC 344 at 49
(3) FP Shine (Vic) Pty Ltd v Gothic Lodge Pty Ltd [1994] 1 VR 194
(4) [2013] VSC 344
Buying and selling
Conveyancing
Before signing a Contract you should engage in the services of a lawyer who will guide you through the process.
Buying
What Pointon Partners will do for you:
- Review the Contract of Sale before signing
- Ensure that your legal rights are protected and that you acquire the title to what you have purchased
- Investigate any issues affecting the property
- Prepare all legal documentation required to transfer the property into your name
- Prepare Statement of Adjustments and Settlement Statement, which includes council rates, water rates, land tax and owners corporation (if applicable)
- Co-ordinate lawyers, banks and agents to ensure settlement occurs by the Settlement Date.
- Attend Settlement on your behalf
- Prepare Notice of Acquisition of Land and forward to the relevant rating authorities
- Keep you updated on the progress of the conveyance.
Selling
What Pointon Partners will do for you:
- Ensure that your legal rights are protected and that the transaction progresses to settlement
- Prepare all legal documentation required for a Sale, e.g. Contract of Sale and Vendor’s Statement with required Certificates
- Review all legal documentation
- Liaise with your mortgagee to arrange release of the mortgage
- Liaise and co-ordinate lawyers, banks and agents to ensure settlement occurs by the Settlement Date
- Attend settlement on your behalf
- Prepare Notice of Disposition of Land and advising the relevant rating authorities that you no longer own the property
- Keep you updated on all matters arising out of the sale
For further information, or if you have any queries relating to this area, please contact Anthony Pointon or Ted Vlahos of our office on 03 9614 7707.
When selling and buying, we can co-ordinate both the Sale and Purchase to happen simultaneously to enable a smooth transition to your new property.
Pointon Partners can deal with any complexities that may arise in a professional manner.