Vendors Beware – Purchasers Of Australian Property Worth $750,000 Or More May Now Be Required To Withhold 12.5 Per Cent Of Purchase Price At Settlement
If you are a vendor or purchaser of an Australian property with a market value of $750,000 or more, the Government’s recent reforms to improve housing affordability may directly affect you.
The Government announced, as part of the 2017-18 Budget, that purchasers of certain taxable Australian properties from foreign resident vendors will be required to withhold 12.5 per cent of, generally, the purchase price and pay it to the ATO.
Vendors who are not foreign residents will be deemed to be a foreign resident unless a valid clearance certificate has been obtained from the ATO and has been given to the purchaser prior to settlement.
This withholding obligation now applies to all contracts entered into on or after 1 July 2017 for the acquisition of Australian property that has a market value of $750,000 or more.
The changes
The original foreign resident capital gains tax (CGT) regime came into effect on 1 July 2016 to assist in the collection of CGT liabilities from foreign residents or those deemed to be foreign residents. It required that purchasers of property with a market value of $2 million or more withhold 10 per cent of the purchase price from the foreign resident vendor.
Current taxation law now requires a purchaser to pay 12.5 per cent of the purchase price to the ATO if a foreign resident capital gains withholding payments obligation arises.
The obligation will arise in relation to a capital gains tax asset if the market value of the asset is $750,000 or more and the asset is a “taxable Australian real property or the holding of an indirect taxable Australian real property interest causes a company title interest to arise”.[1]
Why
This change to the foreign resident capital gains tax is part of the Government’s range of reforms to improve housing affordability and crack down on tax avoidance.
MP Michael Sukkar stated that “by clamping down on tax avoidance by foreign investors in real estate, the government is ensuing home ownership is more achievable for ordinary Australians, and that they have access to secure and affordable housing”.[2]
To further implement the Government’s reforms to improve housing affordability, foreign and temporary residents are also now denied access to the CGT main residence exemption.
However, if you held the property prior to 7:30pm (AEST) 9 May 2017 you will be able to access the main residence exemption until 30 June 2019.
Impact
These changes to the withholding obligation will impact both the purchaser and vendor of the property.
If you are the purchaser, you will need to ensure that the contract of sale gives you a contractual right to withhold the money from the vendor at settlement. Even though the withholding obligation is a statutory requirement, you may be in breach of the contract of sale if there is no such clause.
If you are a foreign resident vendor or deemed to be a foreign resident vendor the impact of the withholding obligation may create cash flow issues if not managed properly.
If you wish to seek advice in relation to these matters, please contact Jess Tomlinson on (03) 9614 7707.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
[1] Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) sch 1 cl 14-215.
[2] MP Michael Sukkar, ‘Treasury Laws Amendment (Foreign Resident Capital Gains Withholding Payments) Bill 2017 Second Reading’ (Speech delivered at the House of Representatives, 1 June 2017).
From 1 July 2017 stamp duty will be payable on certain transfers between spouses and domestic partners
The stamp duty exemption on transfers of property is about to change. The Victoria Government pursuant to its 2017 Budget and the introduction of the State Taxation Acts Amendment Bill 2017[1] (the Bill) intends to withdraw the exemption for payment of stamp duty between spouses and domestic partners in relation to transfers of non-principal place of residence properties.[2]
The exemption for not requiring stamp duty to be paid will apply only to transfers between spouses and domestic partners concerning their principle place of residence.
Exemption from paying stamp duty on transfer of investment properties or holiday houses will no longer apply and stamp duty will be payable in respect of such transfers from 1 July 2017.
This is a significant change to stamp duty concessions previously applied.
The law today
At present no duty is chargeable on a transfer of dutiable property pursuant to section 43 of the Duties Act 2000 (Duties Act), if you are a spouse or domestic partner of another and no other person takes or is entitled to take an interest in the property under the transfer.[3]
The change
The Bill proposes to substitute section 43 of the Duties Act and introduce new sections 43A to 43D.[4]
The new section 43 provides that no duty will be payable in respect of a transfer of dutiable property if you are a spouse or domestic partner of another and:
- no person takes or is entitled to take an interest in the dutiable property being transferred; and
- there is no consideration for the transfer; and
- the property is residential property.[5]
In addition, there has been introduced a requirement for you or your spouse/domestic partner to occupy the land as your “principal place of residence for a continuous period of at least 12 months commencing within the 12 month period immediately after the transfer”.[6]
How might this change affect you?
If the Bill is passed and assented to, any transfer of non-principal place of residence properties between yourself and your spouse or domestic partner will no longer be exempt from stamp duty. This means that stamp duty will be payable on such transfers based on the current market value of the transferring property.[7]
These changes to stamp duty exemptions do not apply to transfers of property following a relationship breakdown.[8]
If you are considering or should be considering a spousal or domestic partner transfer, now is the time to seek advice in relation to the same as rules are likely to significantly change come 1 July 2017.
If you wish to seek advice is relation to these matters, please contact Jess Tomlinson on (03) 9614 7707.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
[1] The second reading of the State Taxation Acts Amendment Bill 2017 was moved on 9 May 2017.
[2] Tim Pallas, ‘Getting on with the job’ (Budget Paper No.5, Victoria State Government), 150; Tim Pallas, ‘Getting on with the job’ (Budget Paper No. 3, Victorian State Government) 112.
[3] Duties Act 2000 (Vic) s 43.
[4] State Taxation Acts Amendment Bill 2017 33, 10.
[5] Ibid 34, 1.
[6] Ibid 34, 10.
[7] Duties Act 2000 (Vic) ss 20, 22.
[8] Above n 1.
Variations to the plan of subdivision – Are you jeopardising your presales?
Securing presales is a critical aspect of any property development project – but that’s only half the battle. The trick is making sure they settle.
Long construction lead times and project delays mean settlement may not occur until up to several years after a purchaser signs a contract. The occurrence of an economic downturn during that time or a change in the purchaser’s circumstances may cause the purchaser to seek to avoid their contract.
A purchaser has various bases for avoiding their contract. One such basis that is becoming an increasingly common cause for dispute between purchasers and vendors is in respect of variations to the plan of subdivision prior to settlement.
Section 9AC of the Sale of Land Act 1962 (Vic) deals with what happens if the plan of subdivision has to be amended. It provides that the purchaser may rescind their contract at any time prior to settlement where an amendment “materially affects the lot to which the contract relates”. This section is critical to off the plan sales.
Recent Court decisions have demonstrated the Court’s continuing shift toward protection of “vulnerable purchasers” in property transactions and emphasises the narrow scope for a developer to amend a plan of subdivision prior to settlement without jeopardising existing contracts.
While there is no definitive answer as to what constitutes a ‘material’ change, leading cases in this area have provided some guidance. It is important for developers to be aware of the following:
- An amendment which does not adversely affect a purchaser, and objectively benefits them, may still be considered a ‘material’ change that gives the purchaser a right to terminate.
- An amendment does not need to necessarily affect the physical lot in order for it to be considered material. A purchaser’s rights and entitlements associated with ownership of a lot cannot be separated and thus, a change to a purchaser’s lot entitlement and liability, including changes to common property may materially affect the lot.
- Changes which may be seemingly minor or insignificant may still be considered ‘material’.
- The Courts have held that in assessing materiality, the whole development and the context of what the purchaser has invested in, including the development scheme and arrangements, must be taken into account. In particular, the Courts consider it artificial to look at each contract on a standalone basis when considering the impact of any amendment
To avoid settlement risk, developers/vendors should ensure plans of subdivision are finalised as much as possible prior to entering into contracts of sale. Any subsequent changes should be kept to a minimum wherever possible. Additionally, if changes must be made, legal advice should be sought before implementing them to ensure all statutory requirements are complied with. The contract of sale used to secure presales should be carefully drafted to ensure loopholes that purchasers can exploit are avoided and the vendor has sufficient flexibility to make any necessary amendments, subject to the statutory rights of the purchaser.
Pointon Partners is a leading provider of property related legal services to the property sector and a proud member of the Property Council of Australia. It is currently handling a broad range of Victorian property development projects.
Don’t Risk Not Collecting on Your Performance Bond or Bank Guarantee
As a result of the High Court of Australia’s recent decisionin Simic v New South Wales Land and Housing Corporation [2016] HCA 47, those providing performance bonds or bank guarantees in respect of property-related matters are on notice that if the name of the person to benefit from the documentation is misstated, this will preclude that person from calling on the performance of the bond or bank guarantee.
In this case, the Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ANZ) refused to honour a performance bond due to a misstatement in the documentation, causing the New South Wales Land and Housing Corporation to expend large amounts of time and money in applying to Court to have the error rectified.
Performance Bonds
Performance bonds are commonly, but sometimes mistakenly, referred to as bank guarantees. A performance bond is issued by a bank to guarantee the satisfactory performance of a particular project by a contractor; they are a promise that the bank will pay to a third party (the Favouree) an amount up to a specified limit with conditions (or unconditionally) and without reference to the underlying contract. By contrast, a bank guarantee ensures that the liabilities of one party will be met in the event of the other party’s default.
Facts of the case
In 2010, the New South Wales Land and Housing Corporation (the Corporation) entered into a contract with Nebax Constructions Australia Pty Ltd (Nebax) for the demolition of existing buildings and the construction of unit blocks in Bomaderry (the Contract).
A term in the Contract required Nebax to provide two unconditional guarantees to the value of $146,965.06 in favour of the Corporation upon execution of the contract (the Undertakings). The Corporation provided a draft of the Undertakings to Nebax, which erroneously listed the following non-existent entity as favouree: “New South Wales Land and Housing Corporation (ABN 24 960 729 253) trading as Housing NSW (ABN 45 754 121 940)”.
Daniel Simic, then director of Nebax, approached and liaised with Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ANZ) employee Ms Hanna to complete the Undertakings. Mr Simic requested for the Undertakings to be “made out to New South Wales Land & Housing Department trading as Housing NSW” as favouree, and although the Contract correctly referred to the Corporation, a copy of this was not shown to Ms Hanna by Mr Simic. Accordingly, the mistake went unnoticed and the Undertakings were executed by Mr Simic and Ms Hanna on behalf of their respective employers.
The proceedings
This dispute arose when the Corporation demanded payment and ANZ refused to honour the Undertakings because the Corporation was not the favouree named in the Undertakings.The Corporation commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales seeking the following:
- A declaration that the description of the favouree be construed as referring to the Corporation; or, alternatively
- An order that the Undertakings be rectified by substituting the name of the Corporation as the name of the favouree.
The Supreme Court of NSW held that the Undertakings could be construed as referring to the Corporation, after which Nebax appealed to the High Court of Australia (HCA).
Construing the Undertakings
The HCA held that it was not possible to construe the Undertakings as being in favour of the Corporation; rather, the Undertakings could be rectified so that they referred to the Corporation as favouree. Therefore ANZ was ultimately bound to make payment to the Corporation, and Nebax was bound to indemnify ANZ.
The HCA said it could not construe the Contract as favouring the Corporation for following reasons:
- Nebax incorrectly instructed ANZ to complete the Undertakings. Accordingly, the Undertakings reflected the erroneous instructions. ANZ would have been in breach of its contractual obligations if it had honoured the Undertakings by treating the Corporation as the favouree rather than the non-existent entity.
- It was a condition of the Contract that Nebax provided the Undertakings in the form of two performance bonds favouring the Corporation. The Corporation should have reviewed the Undertakings following completion by Nebax and ANZ. If the Corporation had noticed the error, it had cause to give notice to Nebax that it was in breach of its obligations under the Contract.
- The banking system relies on the efficacy and veracity of documents like the Undertakings. Where, as in this case, the documents can be presented at any branch of the bank in Australia, to employees who have no official understanding of the transaction, it is risky for the bank to do anything but strictly comply with the conditions of the documents. Further, the Undertakings expressly stated that ANZ was not required to make inquiries to ascertain the intended, as opposed to the specified, favouree.
Rectification
It is presumed that a written agreement expresses the intentions of the parties unless it can be shown that there was a common mistake. The HCA emphasised that an order for rectification of a contract can only be made in circumstances where the written instrument, at the time that it is executed, does not conform to the common intention of the parties.
In this context the HCA had to objectively consider the common intention of Nebax and ANZ at the time the Undertakings were completed. It was noted that ANZ was aware that Nebax had entered into the Contract with the Corporation and, further, if Mr Simic and Ms Hanna had been made aware that the name of the favouree was wrong, their mistake would have been obvious to both of them. This reasoning was used to justify the order for rectification of the Contract.
The take-home message
Although this case involved performance bonds, it would seem that it would equally apply to bank guarantees. For all of those persons involved with the preparation of such documents, this case serves as a cautionary tale: banks will only act in accordance with the explicit terms of the guarantee. If the name of the favouree is listed incorrectly in the documentation, and the bank refuses to honour the guarantee, the favouree will have to apply to Court to seek rectification. It is not sufficient to argue that the parties’ names are almost the same, or that the underlying contract clarifies the error.
If you have any queries in relation to performance bonds, bank guarantees or property law in general, please contact Nicholas Brand or Lachlan Chisholm on (03) 9614 7707.
IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT: Purchaser Purchasing 2million Plus Property From Foreign Vendors After 1 July 2016 Required REQUIRED To Pay 10% Of Sale Price T A.T.O.
The Commonwealth Government have introduced new legislation that received Royal Assent on 25 February 2016 which provides that where a foreign resident disposes of property for over 2 million dollars, 10% of the purchase price is required to be withheld by the purchaser and paid directly to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO). Through a certificate clearance model, the onus will now fall on the purchaser to withhold this taxable amount and where they fail to do so, they will be liable to the ATO for a minimum amount of $200,000 in respect of residential property. This onus now forces purchasers to undertake a much higher degree of due diligence and ensure those that act on their behalf are not only competent but resourceful. This new withholding regime will apply to contracts entered into on or after 1 July 2016.
WHAT PROPERTY IS AFFECTED?
Where a foreign resident disposes of a taxable Australia property, the purchaser of that property will be required to withhold 10% of the purchase price and pay this amount to the ATO. A taxable Australia property is one of the following:
1. Real property in Australia- land, buildings, residential and commercial buildings;
2. Lease premiums paid for the grant of a lease over real property in Australia;
3. Mining, quarrying and prospecting rights;
4. Interests in Australian entities whose majority assets consist of the above types of property or interest (this is called an indirect interest); and
5. Options or rights to acquire the above types of property or interest.
There are a number of exclusions, however, including:
a. Where the real property is valued under $2 million;
b. Transactions on the approved stock exchange; and
c. If the foreign resident vendor is under external administration or in bankruptcy.
ENSURING ACCOUNTABILITY
In order to ensure that all parties comply with their obligations, this legislation has introduced a clearance certificate model. If a property’s purchase price is more than $2 million, vendors will now be required to apply for and obtain from the Commonwealth Government a clearance certificate. This certificate will state (if provided) that the withholding tax is not required to be withheld by the purchaser and will usually be provided within 1 – 14 days post application. The certificate must then be provided to the purchaser before or at settlement. If the clearance certificate is not produced, the purchaser must assume that 10% of the purchase price must be withheld and paid to the ATO at settlement. If the purchaser is not presented with the certificate and they fail to withhold the 10%, the purchaser will be imposed with a penalty to the amount that was supposed to be withheld.
EXAMPLE 1
Adam has entered into a contract with Leah for the purchase of Leah’s property for $3.5 million. Leah is a foreign person and is aware of the 10% tax required to be withheld by Adam. When Leah and Adam attend settlement, Leah does not present Adam with the clearance certificate and expects Adam to withhold the 10% tax, but Adam is unaware of the law and pays Leah the full amount. Leah takes advantage Adams naivety and obtains the full amount of the purchase price and returns to her home in Germany. The ATO has now issued Adam with a $350,000 penalty being the 10% tax he was supposed to withhold from Leah.
EXAMPLE 2
Greg is a foreign person and is selling his house to Irene for $2.8 million. When the pair attend settlement, Greg has failed to produce the clearance certificate. Irene informs Greg she must withhold 10% for payment to the ATO. Greg says that if she does that the sale is off. Irene, not wanting to lose the property and feeling pressured by Greg, pays the full amount to Greg in the hope no one will find out. Shortly after Greg has returned home to Italy, the ATO hands down a penalty of $280,000 to Irene for failing to comply with her obligations.
APPLICATIONS FOR VARIATION
If the foreign person (Vendor) is not eligible for a clearance certificate, yet believes that the 10% withholding tax is unreasonable, they may apply to the Commissioner of Taxation for a variation. A variation application will usually be assessed and provided within 28 days of receipt.
PROTECTING YOURSELF
The level of due diligence required of purchasers has substantially raised following this new legislation. In order to protect yourself against substantial penalties, it is fundamental that you conduct all the relevant searches into the property and when unable, engage the services of a diligent lawyer or conveyancer.
If you have any queries regarding any of the above, please contact Anthony Pointon or Laszlo Konya.
Foreign Purchasers of Residential Property in Victoria, Australia – Additional Victorian Stamp Duty
INTRODUCTION
New legislation has been passed by the Victorian Government which provides that where an interest in a residential property is transferred to a foreign purchaser after 1 July 2015, the foreign purchaser is required to pay an additional duty of 3% of the full contract property value (the additional duty) for their share in that property, unless an exemption applies. This means foreign purchasers may have to pay to the Victorian Government a total duty as high as 8.5% of the purchase price and is something that most purchasers are unaware of.
WHEN YOU ARE REQUIRED TO PAY
For a person to be required to pay the additional duty, they must:
1. Be a foreign purchaser; and
A foreign purchaser is defined as anyone who is a foreign natural person, a foreign corporation or a trustee of a foreign trust.
A foreign natural person is anyone who is not:
1. A citizen or permanent resident of Australia;
2. The holder of a permanent visa within the meaning of section 30(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth); or
3. A New Zealand citizen with a Special Category Visa (Subclass 444).
Even where a foreign natural person purchases a property with their spouse who is not a foreign purchaser, they are still required to pay the additional duty for their interest in the property. This duty is assessed on the purchase price provided at settlement.
EXAMPLE 1.
Sarah is an American citizen who holds a Partner (Provisional) Visa allowing her to stay in Australia until her permanency is decided. Sarah and her partner Ben, who is an Australian citizen, decide to purchase a house in Melbourne at a dutiable value of $500,000.00 with each party contributing $250,000. As required by the new legislation, Sarah is required to pay an additional $7,500 (3% of $250,000) in additional duty.
EXAMPLE 2.
If the purchase of the above example was an off the plan purchase, and the value of land and the building in existence at the date of the contract is $100,000 but the full contract purchase price is $500,000, then the value of the additional stamp duty will be based on the full contract purchase price of $500,000 even though the ordinary stamp duty will be based on $100,000.
2. Have received an interest in a residential property.
This interest can be received in the following ways:
a. Purchase of a residential property;
b. A gift of a residential property;
c. A transfer of a residential property from a deceased estate; and
d. Certain leasing arrangements.
A residential property is defined as either (a) a building on a property designed and constructed primarily for residential purposes, or (b) a property which will have constructed a building designed primarily for residential purposes. In respect of commercial property, the additional duty does not apply unless it is primarily used as a residential property.
EXEMPTION AND CONCESSIONS
An additional duty will only be payable where a land transfer or land holder duty is payable. If an interest holder in residential property is not required to pay the land transfer duty, then by default, they will not be required to pay the additional duty regardless of whether they are a foreign purchaser or not. Foreign purchasers, however, are not entitled to any duty concessions or concession rates on any additional duty that is payable, even if they are eligible for duty concessions on the initial duty payable.
EXAMPLE 3
Leah, a foreign purchaser, has just purchased a residential property off-the-plan for $400,000 (existing land and building value at date of contract $100,000) which she intends to use as her principal place of residence (PPR). Leah is not eligible for the PPR as she is not an Australian citizen and is eligible for the off-the-plan concession on the land transfer duty payable.
However, even though Leah is eligible to these concession, she must still pay the normal stamp duty based on the value of $100,000 and additional duty of 3% of the dutiable value of $400,000 of the property under these provisions.
NOMINATIONS AND SUB-SALE EVENTS
Where a foreign purchasers is nominated by a title holder after 1 July 2015 and the nomination triggers a sub-sale, that foreign purchaser must pay the additional duty even if the original contract date was before 1 July 2015. This ‘nomination trigger’ will also apply where the transfer occurs under an off-the-plan contract.
If nominations do not trigger a sub-sale (i.e. the transaction involves no consideration passing between the parties and no land development), contracts entered into before 1 July 2015 will not attract the additional duty.
EXAMPLE 4
Kevin purchased a residential property in St Kilda for $500,000 off-the-plan; construction has commenced and the residence is due to be complete in March 2016. The contract was signed by Kevin on 20 February 2015. On 2 February 2016 Kevin nominated his new girlfriend Mary to take a transfer of the residential property for $200,000. Mary must now pay additional duty of 3% of the dutiable value of $200,000 on top of the initial transfer duty payable.
SUMMARY
The imposition of the additional duty payable by foreign purchasers means they may be liable for a total of 8.5% once the transfer of the residential property has occurred. The additional 3% is on the contract build value and may be overlooked by inexperienced conveyancers and can really hurt one financially when they do not expect it. Always ensure when purchasing property you have an experienced and reliable conveyancer who is aware of and keeps up to date with the law. There may be some strategies a purchaser planning should be obligated at the time of purchase that should also be discussed.
If you have any queries regarding any of the above, please contact Anthony Pointon or Laszlo Konya.
FOREIGN PURCHASERS OF RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY IN VICTORIA, AUSTRALIA – ADDITIONAL VICTORIAN STAMP DUTY
INTRODUCTION
New legislation has been passed by the Victorian Government which provides that where an interest in a residential property is transferred to a foreign purchaser after 1 July 2015, the foreign purchaser is required to pay an additional duty of 3% of the full contract property value (the additional duty) for their share in that property, unless an exemption applies. This means foreign purchasers may have to pay to the Victorian Government a total duty as high as 8.5% of the purchase price and is something that most purchasers are unaware of.
WHEN YOU ARE REQUIRED TO PAY
For a person to be required to pay the additional duty, they must:
- Be a foreign purchaser; and
A foreign purchaser is defined as anyone who is a foreign natural person, a foreign corporation or a trustee of a foreign trust.
A foreign natural person is anyone who is not:
1. A citizen or permanent resident of Australia;
2. The holder of a permanent visa within the meaning of section 30(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth); or
3. A New Zealand citizen with a Special Category Visa (Subclass 444).
Even where a foreign natural person purchases a property with their spouse who is not a foreign purchaser, they are still required to pay the additional duty for their interest in the property. This duty is assessed on the purchase price provided at settlement.
EXAMPLE 1.
Sarah is an American citizen who holds a Partner (Provisional) Visa allowing her to stay in Australia until her permanency is decided. Sarah and her partner Ben, who is an Australian citizen, decide to purchase a house in Melbourne at a dutiable value of $500,000.00 with each party contributing $250,000. As required by the new legislation, Sarah is required to pay an additional $7,500 (3% of $250,000) in additional duty.
EXAMPLE 2.
If the purchase of the above example was an off the plan purchase, and the value of land and the building in existence at the date of the contract is $100,000 but the full contract purchase price is $500,000, then the value of the additional stamp duty will be based on the full contract purchase price of $500,000 even though the ordinary stamp duty will be based on $100,000.
2. Have received an interest in a residential property.
This interest can be received in the following ways:
a. Purchase of a residential property;
b. A gift of a residential property;
c. A transfer of a residential property from a deceased estate; and
d. Certain leasing arrangements.
A residential property is defined as either (a) a building on a property designed and constructed primarily for residential purposes, or (b) a property which will have constructed a building designed primarily for residential purposes. In respect of commercial property, the additional duty does not apply unless it is primarily used as a residential property.
EXEMPTION AND CONCESSIONS
An additional duty will only be payable where a land transfer or land holder duty is payable. If an interest holder in residential property is not required to pay the land transfer duty, then by default, they will not be required to pay the additional duty regardless of whether they are a foreign purchaser or not. Foreign purchasers, however, are not entitled to any duty concessions or concession rates on any additional duty that is payable, even if they are eligible for duty concessions on the initial duty payable.
EXAMPLE 3
Leah, a foreign purchaser, has just purchased a residential property off-the-plan for $400,000 (existing land and building value at date of contract $100,000) which she intends to use as her principal place of residence (PPR). Leah is not eligible for the PPR as she is not an Australian citizen and is eligible for the off-the-plan concession on the land transfer duty payable.
However, even though Leah is eligible to these concession, she must still pay the normal stamp duty based on the value of $100,000 and additional duty of 3% of the dutiable value of $400,000 of the property under these provisions.
NOMINATIONS AND SUB-SALE EVENTS
Where a foreign purchasers is nominated by a title holder after 1 July 2015 and the nomination triggers a sub-sale, that foreign purchaser must pay the additional duty even if the original contract date was before 1 July 2015. This ‘nomination trigger’ will also apply where the transfer occurs under an off-the-plan contract.
If nominations do not trigger a sub-sale (i.e. the transaction involves no consideration passing between the parties and no land development), contracts entered into before 1 July 2015 will not attract the additional duty.
EXAMPLE 4
Kevin purchased a residential property in St Kilda for $500,000 off-the-plan; construction has commenced and the residence is due to be complete in March 2016. The contract was signed by Kevin on 20 February 2015. On 2 February 2016 Kevin nominated his new girlfriend Mary to take a transfer of the residential property for $200,000. Mary must now pay additional duty of 3% of the dutiable value of $200,000 on top of the initial transfer duty payable.
SUMMARY
The imposition of the additional duty payable by foreign purchasers means they may be liable for a total of 8.5% once the transfer of the residential property has occurred. The additional 3% is on the contract build value and may be overlooked by inexperienced conveyancers and can really hurt one financially when they do not expect it. Always ensure when purchasing property you have an experienced and reliable conveyancer who is aware of and keeps up to date with the law. There may be some strategies a purchaser planning should be obligated at the time of purchase that should also be discussed.
If you have any queries regarding any of the above, please contact Anthony Pointon or Laszlo Konya.
IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT: PURCHASER PURCHASING 2MILLION PLUS PROPERTY FROM FOREIGN VENDORS AFTER 1 JULY 2016 REQUIRED TO PAY 10% OF SALE PRICE TO A.T.O.
The Commonwealth Government have introduced new legislation that received Royal Assent on 25 February 2016 which provides that where a foreign resident disposes of property for over 2 million dollars, 10% of the purchase price is required to be withheld by the purchaser and paid directly to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO). Through a certificate clearance model, the onus will now fall on the purchaser to withhold this taxable amount and where they fail to do so, they will be liable to the ATO for a minimum amount of $200,000 in respect of residential property. This onus now forces purchasers to undertake a much higher degree of due diligence and ensure those that act on their behalf are not only competent but resourceful. This new withholding regime will apply to contracts entered into on or after 1 July 2016.
WHAT PROPERTY IS AFFECTED?
Where a foreign resident disposes of a taxable Australia property, the purchaser of that property will be required to withhold 10% of the purchase price and pay this amount to the ATO. A taxable Australia property is one of the following:
1. Real property in Australia- land, buildings, residential and commercial buildings;
2. Lease premiums paid for the grant of a lease over real property in Australia;
3. Mining, quarrying and prospecting rights;
4. Interests in Australian entities whose majority assets consist of the above types of property or interest (this is called an indirect interest); and
5. Options or rights to acquire the above types of property or interest.
There are a number of exclusions, however, including:
a. Where the real property is valued under $2 million;
b. Transactions on the approved stock exchange; and
c. If the foreign resident vendor is under external administration or in bankruptcy.
ENSURING ACCOUNTABILITY
In order to ensure that all parties comply with their obligations, this legislation has introduced a clearance certificate model. If a property’s purchase price is more than $2 million, vendors will now be required to apply for and obtain from the Commonwealth Government a clearance certificate. This certificate will state (if provided) that the withholding tax is not required to be withheld by the purchaser and will usually be provided within 1 – 14 days post application. The certificate must then be provided to the purchaser before or at settlement. If the clearance certificate is not produced, the purchaser must assume that 10% of the purchase price must be withheld and paid to the ATO at settlement. If the purchaser is not presented with the certificate and they fail to withhold the 10%, the purchaser will be imposed with a penalty to the amount that was supposed to be withheld.
EXAMPLE 1
Adam has entered into a contract with Leah for the purchase of Leah’s property for $3.5 million. Leah is a foreign person and is aware of the 10% tax required to be withheld by Adam. When Leah and Adam attend settlement, Leah does not present Adam with the clearance certificate and expects Adam to withhold the 10% tax, but Adam is unaware of the law and pays Leah the full amount. Leah takes advantage Adams naivety and obtains the full amount of the purchase price and returns to her home in Germany. The ATO has now issued Adam with a $350,000 penalty being the 10% tax he was supposed to withhold from Leah.
EXAMPLE 2
Greg is a foreign person and is selling his house to Irene for $2.8 million. When the pair attend settlement, Greg has failed to produce the clearance certificate. Irene informs Greg she must withhold 10% for payment to the ATO. Greg says that if she does that the sale is off. Irene, not wanting to lose the property and feeling pressured by Greg, pays the full amount to Greg in the hope no one will find out. Shortly after Greg has returned home to Italy, the ATO hands down a penalty of $280,000 to Irene for failing to comply with her obligations.
APPLICATIONS FOR VARIATION
If the foreign person (Vendor) is not eligible for a clearance certificate, yet believes that the 10% withholding tax is unreasonable, they may apply to the Commissioner of Taxation for a variation. A variation application will usually be assessed and provided within 28 days of receipt.
PROTECTING YOURSELF
The level of due diligence required of purchasers has substantially raised following this new legislation. In order to protect yourself against substantial penalties, it is fundamental that you conduct all the relevant searches into the property and when unable, engage the services of a diligent lawyer or conveyancer.
If you have any queries regarding any of the above, please contact Anthony Pointon or Laszlo Konya.
Proposed Changes To Foreign Investment
The Federal Government has recently released an ‘options paper’ setting out numerous proposed changes to the current Australian foreign investment review framework. One of the proposed changes, which has been met with strong criticism from property development industry groups, is a new fee structure for foreign investment in Australian residential real estate.
Proposed new fee structure
The proposed fees will be imposed by the Australian Tax Office (ATO) and will include a $5,000 application fee for property purchases which are valued at under $1 million. Applications to purchase a property equal to or greater than $1 million will be subject to a fee of up to $10,000. The fee will then increase in increments of up to $10,000 for each additional $1 million in the property value.
It is expected that the government will collect approximately $200 million each year.
Government Position
The Government believes there would be significant benefits in creating a new specialist compliance and enforcement area within the ATO, to improve data collection, compliance and enforcement activities around foreign investment in residential real estate.
The costs of administering this new function will therefore be offset through the introduction of these new fees and through increased penalties for breaches of the foreign investment rules. The fees also aim to assist Australian residents in securing property against foreign investors.
Whilst industry professionals support better compliance and data collection, the general consensus is that the proposed fees are excessive and well above what is needed to fund these activities.
Additionally, these fees are significantly higher than the $1,500 recommended by last year’s parliamentary inquiry into foreign investment.
Concerns and implications of proposed new fees
Despite the Government’s reasoning, industry experts believe the higher fees will in fact have a negative impact on the Australian property market.
It is argued that the fees will provide a strong disincentive for those looking to invest in Australia, which will in turn stifle the market.
Currently, foreign investors can only buy newly developed property under existing Foreign Investment Review Board rules and for every newly constructed home that a foreign investor purchases, up to four other homes are enabled to be built. Therefore, if foreign investment in new residential housing does decrease as a result of these fees, this would jeopardise housing supply, thereby worsening existing shortages and driving up house prices.
While other industry professionals believe that the fees will not achieve the desired outcome of maintaining affordable property prices and will most likely not prevent foreign investment, they do agree that it nevertheless sends a bad message to the world, particularly China, that Australia is not welcoming to foreign investors.
Other notable proposed changes outlined in ‘options paper’
(a) Advanced off-the-plan certificates
Currently, property developers can apply for an advanced off-the-plan certificate to sell new apartments in a development of 100 or more to foreign investors (the investor does not then need to obtain separate approval).
These certificates are granted on the condition that the apartments are marketed in Australia, as well as overseas. This is to ensure that domestic buyers have the same opportunity to purchase the apartments.
Although, there are currently no penalties for breaching this condition, the ‘options paper’ proposes to significantly increase the civil and criminal penalties for developers who fail to comply with their obligation to market their development to domestic buyers and not solely to foreign investors.
The new proposed penalties are:
- Civil — Individual 250 penalty units ($42,500)
- Criminal — 500 penalty units ($85,000), imprisonment of two years or both
Additionally, the Government is proposing to tighten the rules around the use of these advanced off-the-plan certificates by limiting the value of all apartments that can be bought by a single foreign investor to $3 million in any single development. Thus, in order to purchase apartments above this value, foreign investors would have to seek individual approval.
This new proposal may not however affect:
- Syndicate foreign investment (that is, multiple foreign investors acquiring Australian real estate)
- Local syndicated investment (that is, foreign investors who invest into local real property managed investment schemes. This gives investors access to the Significant Investor Visa which carries eligibility to apply for permanent residency after a minimum for 4 years)
- Multiple development investments ( as presumably, a foreign investor will still be able to invest more than $3 million across multiple developments)
(b) Foreign investment in rural land and agribusinesses
Under the current foreign investment framework, proposed investments by private investors in rural land and agribusinesses are subject to the same thresholds that apply to other foreign acquisitions of Australian companies or business assets. However, the Government is seeking to dramatically reduce these current thresholds.
This means foreign investors will need to obtain prior approval for a proposed acquisition of an interest in rural land where the cumulative value of the land owned by the foreign investor, including the proposed purchase, is $15 million or more.
The lowering of these thresholds may create possible opportunities for local developers in that they could acquire rural land or agribusinesses for the purpose of selling to foreign investors once the rural land has been rezoned and designated as urban land.
As there are no thresholds on foreign investors seeking to purchase urban land, local developers could sell this newly designated urban land at a premium to foreign investors.
If you have any queries regarding the above, please contact David Mazzeo on 03 9614 7707.
Overhaul of Section 32 of the Sale of Land Act 1962 (Vic)
Is Your Vendor’s Statement Compliant?
New laws came in to force on 1 October 2014, changing how and what vendors must disclose prior to the sale of property.
The requirement for the Vendor to make disclosures to prospective purchasers stems from section 32 of the Sale of Land Act 1962 (Vic), which was recently amended.
Vendor’s Statements that have been signed by prospective purchasers prior to 1 October 2014, do not need to be replaced, if the land remains for sale since 1 October 2014. Otherwise, Vendor’s Statements must comply with the new legislative provisions.
Here are some important changes, relevant to the preparation of Vendor’s Statements:
- A Consumer Affairs Due Diligence Checklist must be provided by the Vendor from the time the property is made available for sale.
- If a licenced Real Estate Agent is engaged, the obligation to provide the checklist becomes the Agent’s (some Agents are now providing a link to the checklist on their websites).
- Vendor’s Statements are to be given to purchasers prior to the signing of the Contract of Sale.
- If the Vendor’s Statement is not provided prior to the Contract of Sale:
(a) that does not invalidate the Contract of Sale;
(b) may result in a penalty to the Vendor; and
(c) the Purchaser’s usual rights to rescind the Contract of Sale for non-disclosures operate as usual.
- The Vendor’s Statement no longer needs to be attached to the Contract of Sale.
Provisions have modified how the following information is now disclosed in Vendor’s Statements: Owners Corporation information, Essential Services, Planning information, and Notices directly and indirectly affecting the land.
If you are engaged in, or are planning to undertake a property transaction, it is important that the form of Vendor’s Statement provided meets the legislative requirements.
Pointon Partners act in a wide variety of property transactions, ranging from standard conveyances through to large scale developments, assisting both vendors and purchasers.
If you need assistance with property transactions or related matters, please contact Ted Vlahos.