Pointon Partners

All downhill for ski resort in its attempts to control ‘THREDBO’

Thredbo Village

Thredbo is ski resort location in the Kosciusko National Park in NSW.  Kosciuszko Thredbo Pty Limited, in conjunction with its subsidiary Thredbo Resort Centre Pty Ltd (collectively referred to as KT) owns (by way of a 99 year lease granted over the land in 1957) and operates, the well-known Thredbo Village Ski Resort (the Village).

ThredboNet Marketing Pty Ltd (ThredboNet) provides an online booking service for accommodation at the Thredbo Village Ski Resort. Although ThredboNet sub-leases accommodation from KT and manages about 50 properties in the Village, the parties are not affiliated and ThredboNet has a disclaimer on its website to this effect.

KT takes action

In 2013, KT unsuccessfully sought to restrain ThredboNet from using the word THREDBO in various domain, company and business names and on its website. KT had argued ThredboNet had engaged in passing off and misleading and deceptive conduct in breach of s 18 and 29 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) in using the word THREDBO. Likening it to ‘Disney Land, KT alleged THREDBO (which was not a registered trade mark) had acquired a secondary meaning, aside from its geographic connotation, and was synonymous with and exclusive to KT in light of their control of the Village. KT also claimed ThredboNet had breached various sublease agreements, including a prohibition on them using the name ‘THREDBO.’

Decision of the Federal Court

Justice Cowdroy held decided that the word THREDBO had not acquired a secondary meaning sufficient to give KT an exclusive right to its use and that ThredboNet had not engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct (or passing off) in using the word throughout its website and Facebook page. In relation to the sub-lease agreement, the provision restraining ThredboNet from using the word ‘THREDBO’ in relation to ‘any business carried on by the sublessee’ was excessive and an unreasonable restraint of trade because it lacked reasonable connection to KT’s legitimate interests. It was therefore void at common law.

The fact KT had spent millions on the Village was immaterial.

On Appeal

KT appealed. On 21 July 2014, the Full Court of the Federal Court (Justice Siopis, Rares & Katzmann) upheld the decision of the Federal Court, rejecting KT’s claims to the word THREDBO.

The Full Court identified that the primary Judge had erred in finding that KT had to prove an exclusive right to use of the word THREDBO in order to establish it had a secondary meaning.  Instead, KT had to establish that an ordinary reasonable consumer likely to purchase the goods or services would be misled to believe they were dealing with KT when dealing with ThredboNet and that the services of both parties were affiliated. This could not be established in this case.

Factors influencing their decision were:

Conclusion

This case demonstrates the utility of disclaimers which clarify the relationship (i.e. lack of affiliation) between similar website operators in negating any suggestion that one operator is attempting to capitalise on the reputation or goodwill of another.

It also highlights difficulties that can be faced by businesses seeking to enforce rights to an unregistered trademark, particular when it takes the form of a geographic location as is often the case in the tourism industry. While extensive use of a brand name can assist in overcoming objections to registration of trade marks that are descriptive or have geographic indications, developing a stylised logo which incorporates the geographic name may also assist. Other measures to protect businesses include securing a variety of domain names (.com.au, com, net.au) and utilising search engine optimisation and other strategies to confine your brand name to your own business.

If you have any queries regarding Intellectual Property and the above, please do not hesitate to contact David Mazzeo for advice on 03 9614 7707.

Nappy Land, Nappyland, and nappyland.com.au A Dirty Mess for Trade Mark Law

CI JI Family Pty Limited v National Australian Nappies (NAN) Pty Limited [2014] FCA 79

In a recent Federal Court decision, it was found that having a registered trade mark, did not protect the trade mark owner from other legal action, when using its own registered mark.

In this case, the trade mark owner was found, despite owning the registered trade mark in the dispute, to have misled or deceived the general public, and passed off its goods as another company’s goods.
The judge awarded $25,000 in damages to the other party, and will issue Court orders to prevent the trade mark owner’s conduct from continuing.

This case highlights that simply owning a registered trade mark, does not eliminate the need for careful legal strategy, in avoiding compliance issues and costly legal disputes.

Facts of the Case

The case involved two opposing sides:
The ‘Plaintiff’: CI JI Family Pty Ltd and Luong Huynh Ngo
The ‘Trade Mark Owner’: National Australian Nappies Pty Ltd and Nhut Thang Ho
The Plaintiff and the Trade Mark Owner were originally in business together, as a partnership between Mr Ho and his company, and Mr Ngo.

  1. That partnership registered a New South Wales (NSW) business name Nappy Land in July 1997, and traded with the logo (the logo having no spaces):
  2. Mr Ho and Mr Ngo dissolved the partnership in 1999 and Mr Ngo took over the original trading company, trading under the original business name and logo.
  3. Meanwhile, in March 1997, Mr Ho registered a separate business, National Australian Nappies (NAN), and business names Nappy Land in Victoria, Queensland and South Australia, and registered the trade mark illustrated below (the logo having a space):
  4. When the partnership was dissolved in 1999, the Plaintiff and the Trade Mark Owner entered into a verbal agreement (‘1999 Agreement’), presumably, that the Plaintiff would trade in NSW, using the original business name and logo, and the Trade Mark Owner would trade outside of NSW as Nappyland with its registered trade mark. If the Trade Mark Owner started to trade in NSW it would not use a name or mark similar to the Plaintiff’s mark.
  5. From at least mid-2013, the Trade Mark Owner started to trade in NSW in essentially the same way it did in other States and Territories.
The Plaintiff’s Case against the Trade Mark Owner

The Plaintiff made three complaints against the Trade Mark Owner, namely that it:

(a)   Breached the 1999 Agreement that it would not trade in NSW in a way that would confuse the Plaintiff’s customer base;

(b)   Breached Section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law, and misled or deceived customers; and

(c)    Committed a tort of passing off, by causing a loss to the Plaintiff, when trading on its established reputation, and deceiving customers as to the origin of the goods.

Court Decision

The residing judge, Flick J, assessed the three complaints as follows:

For the Plaintiff’s claim, that the Trade Mark Owner breached the 1999 Agreement, to succeed, it had to prove:

(i)                 that the 1999 Agreement existed,

(ii)               that it satisfied the requirements of contract formation, and

(iii)             that it was breached.

Flick J was not satisfied, based on the evidence presented by both sides, what the agreed terms of the contract were, and that it met the requirements of contract formation.

The Court’s finding was primarily based on the 1999 Agreement not being acknowledged in writing.

When both sides presented evidence as to what was agreed, they provided terms that most favoured their own position. The English language difficulties of both parties meant, that in cross-examination in Court, they contradicted themselves.

The judge was not clearly satisfied that the parties agreed to exclusive territories, only that the Plaintiff would undoubtedly have wanted that.

The Plaintiff could not prove, to the satisfaction of the Court, the terms of the alleged agreement, and that the Trade Mark Owner’s trading in NSW had breached it.

The Registered Trade Mark as a Sword or a Shield

Ordinarily, trade mark registration operates as a shield.

The protection provided by the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), provides that the registered owner has the exclusive right to use its mark, or authorise others to use it (section 20(1)).

That right does not give a trade mark owner a licence to universally breach other laws, and confuse consumers, merely because it is the protected owner of its own mark. To do so, would be to wield trade mark registration as a sword.

The Trade Mark Owner submitted to the Court, that it having the registered trade mark in the dispute was a complete defence to the Plaintiff’s other legal claims. The Judge’s finding on this defence was [34, 38]:

‘The argument so broadly expressed is rejected. (…) The rights conferred upon the registered owner of a trade mark do not extend to a licence to engage in conduct which is misleading or deceptive or to engage in conduct which constitutes a passing off’

As such if the Plaintiff could satisfy the Court that other laws had been breached, it was up to the Trade Mark Owner to defend them.

Misleading or Deceptive Conduct and Passing Off

Ultimately, Flick J found that the Trade Mark Owner had breached the two other laws despite it having the registered trade mark.

To show that the Trade Mark Owner had breached section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law, the Plaintiff had to show that the conduct did not merely cause confusion as to the current state of affairs. Rather, that consumers in that particular market were, or would likely have been misled or deceived by the way trading occurred.

Flick J was satisfied, based on the evidence presented, that at least some customers were actually misled as to who was operating the business. Indeed some consumers asked the Trade Mark Owner if they were “the same business” as the Plaintiff.

While the interpretation of section 18 has many legal nuances, an objective assessment by the residing Judge also showed that any consumer in that market would likely be misled in having to distinguish “Nappy Land” from “Nappyland”, particularly when the business names were spoken.

To show that the Trade Mark Owner had committed the tort of passing off, the Plaintiff had to show that it suffered loss or damage to its goodwill, based on misrepresentations of the Trade Mark Owner. Flick J was satisfied that the way the Trade Mark Owner targeted customers, and represented itself, made it seem like they were aligned with the Plaintiff. That conduct caused the Plaintiff loss as to acquiring potential customers for its business.

Court Orders

Flick J noted the difficulty in coming up with appropriate orders based on the breaches, but stated that where the Plaintiff had suffered loss, there was an obligation to give a remedy. In an example of “judicial estimation” Flick J awarded damages of $25,000. Flick J will also provide consent to orders that limit the offending conduct in the future, when orders have been agreed between the parties.

Lessons from the Decision

The important points to draw from this case are:

  1. Agreements should always be put in writing, and drafted carefully to best reflect commercial imperatives;
  2. Intellectual property law is complicated, and careful legal and commercial planning should always be undertaken, to ensure compliance with all laws affecting transactions;
  3. Having a registered trade mark is not a defence to other related legal and intellectual property claims.

 
Pointon Partners have extensive experience in drafting agreements, and the registration and defence of trade mark and intellectual property claims. We incorporate our understanding of many areas of law in assisting in transactions, to give effect to commercial imperatives.

If you are planning operations or entering into a new transaction, with an Intellectual Property or Trade Mark component, please feel free to contact David Mazzeo on (03) 9614 7707.

Brand Protection Strategies

Your brand is a major defining part of your business and legal rights arise in respect of it.

You should understand the legal rights arising from your brand and why you should not only register appropriate trademarks but also consider key strategies involving them we detail here.

If you do this you will not only establish strong protection from your competitors, and a platform for business growth but also create value in your business for any eventual sale.

  1. Trademarks, Passing Off and Trademark Registration
    You have common law rights arising just out of the use of your brand name or mark  as soon as your brand name or mark  is put into use.

    This common law right is sometimes signified by the owner placing a small TM that appears after the brand when it is advertised or in other correspondence, but this is not necessarily so and a common law trademark in respect of the name or mark will exist regardless of this. This right is protected by the legal redress of passing off which refers to someone attempting to pass themselves off as your business in the market place and causing enough confusion so as to damage your profits.

    Legal actions requiring the offender to stop using the name and/or to pay damages, including an account for profits made for the period of the passing off usage can be taken.The common law rights arising out of the common law trade marks use can be restricted in respect of the area the business is conducted, often to a small area or a State where trading of the product has actually occurred.

    For example a small Tasmanian store which had conducted a general merchandise business in Tasmania for many years under the name Target, was able to confirm its rights to the name and restrict the rights of Target, now owned by Wesfarmers , in those areas in Tasmania where that store conducted and conducts business.

    There may be a dispute in respect of the trademarks existence by others who claim you have not established your business in their area of trade or that they have prior usage and therefore ownership in the areas where they are trading. The starting point for good brand protection is trademark registration and the good news is that it is not expensive generally to do this, even when it is done by an expert which is highly recommended.If it is put in the hands of someone not fully familiar with the law then the registration can be a slow tortuous failure. Many inexpert applications do not consider the correct form of the application, which leads:
    – to many queries from Intellectual Property Australia
    – unknown conflicts that need to be resolved,
    – do not claim the correct classes for the business should claim and therefore do not get the required protection,
    – end up with a frustrating failure to register.

    Registering a trademark gives additional strong legal statutory rights to the common law passing off right, that prohibits others from using a sign or mark that is the same or deceptively similar to the mark you use on goods that fall within the category that your trademark is registered, and there are 36 categories of registration, that are common amongst all countries.

    The trademark is in respect of the territory of the registration. In Australia the territory is the whole of Australia. You may wish to also register in other territories in which you trade or realistically intend to trade such as New Zealand. You may also use The Madrid Protocol (an international treaty), which allows you to register international trademarks from Australia in countries that you trade in or intend to trade in , that can give your brand protection in more than the 90 signatory jurisdictions.

    The scope of this article does not fully explore issues involving what can or cannot be registered or the process of registration.

    The good news is that where you have registered your trademark, the facts of the trademarks existence and extent of use are clearly on the public record which reduces any problems establishing the facts and in addition you have those additional statutory rights. This leads to you being able to send a clear and importantly, effective legal letter, claiming your legal rights and demanding a party to cease using the name. No messy litigation is normally required as the case is clear to all that you will win. If it is not resolved easily, your rights are very strong and the other party will generally be ordered to pay your legal costs as well as damages claimed.

    Note also that if your trademark is not registered in a particular jurisdiction or within a class of goods you use your trademark, then you are leaving yourself open to others applying for a mark similar to yours and this can cause significant legal problems involving you having to prove your usage, if they make claim to their rights.

    You should also for asset protection purposes, very seriously consider the owner of the trademark and whether it is owned by your trading entity or alternatively it is owned by another related party to you and correctly licenced to the trading entity. The licence needs to be both registered with both Intellectual Property Australia and also under the new Personal Properties Security Register legislation.

    In addition to your trademark registrations:
    – You should consider and implement domain name registrations of your names and its variations.
    – Constant monitoring of your trademark for breach should be undertaken
    – Conduct a regular scheduled internet search of your trademark
    – Word of mouth confusing from any customer or supplier should be carefully followed up.
    – Ensure that each registration is monitored in respect of its duration.  An expert should offer a service of monitoring for you in this regard and you should also know this yourself.
    – Send appropriate cease and desist letters from your lawyers as soon as any breach is brought to your attention

  2. Licensing and Distributorships

If you are thinking of  expanding into interstate markets or international markets, or if you have already done so, then you need to ensure that your licensing and distribution arrangements do not leave you exposed to the unintended application of your trademark or unwanted parallel importation.

Carefully draft licensing and distribution agreements
When appointing a licensee or distributor it is important that you:

– Clearly define the goods that the licensee can apply the goods to
– Clearly define the territories that the licensee or distributor is able to sell into.
– Place an obligation on a distributor or licensee not to sell to a person in the permitted territory if the distributor or licensee reasonably believes that the person may resell the goods in an unpermitted territory unless you intend that they should.
– Ensure that any advertised sale on the internet or elsewhere by the licencee must point out the above restrictions clearly.

Note that there are many examples of licensees in established markets selling to customers in their allowed territories and those customers resupplying those goods into territories that the licencee has no jurisdiction.

The effect is often that the trademark owner or its other legitimate licenced distributors is undercut causing distress or the trademark owner has a potential action against them from their legitimately appointed licensees.

This is known as parallel importation
Parallel importation

Where your trademark is applied to goods with your consent (for example under a licensing arrangement), then a person doesn’t infringe your trademark simply by importing the goods into a jurisdiction where your trademark is registered.

Expanding on the above example, if:

– you permit a licensee to apply your trademark to goods manufactured in China
– the licensee sells those goods to a person in the permitted territory (Reseller)
– the Reseller then resells them into the United Kingdom, where you have appointed an exclusive distributor
– and you have registered your trademark in the United Kingdom

then your UK trademark has not been infringed because you consented to the application of the mark on the goods in China and to the sale of the goods to the Reseller.

How do you mitigate the incidence of parallel importation? 

The most practical way to mitigate the incidence of parallel importation by the above contractual restrictions set out above. Note is would normally be obvious that a customer is buying for the purpose of reselling due to quantity and there would also be a large incentive on the seller to make that sale. This gives the trademark owner contractual rights against the breaching licencee, but not against the on seller (although  the licence may  give the licensor the  right to prosecute  on behalf of the breaching licencee), and also rights to the licencee to prosecute the breaching customer under contract, but not under trademark law. The contractual restrictions must be very carefully drafted as you are restricting the rights of a purchaser from on selling and there are some key legal problems to be addressed in respect of this.

Oddly under trademark law, the trademark owner could not prosecute the end purchaser as he has purchased from a legitimate licensee of the trademark  and also the licensee could not prosecute the on seller as he is not the owner of the trademark.

You could also mitigate the incidence of parallel importation by conditionally assigning registration of your trademarks to your exclusive distributors.

For example, you could assign your UK trademarks to your exclusive UK distributor.

To protect your interests, your distribution agreement  would unconditionally transfer the trademark back to you on termination of the agreement. This process does work in Australia and other jurisdictions, however it needs to be carefully considered.

The effect of this arrangement is that if the Reseller imported the goods into the UK, then it would infringe the trademark of your exclusive distributor in the UK (who registered the trademark in the UK) as your UK distributor did not consent to the application of the trademark to the goods in China.

You consented to the application, but your UK distributor did not.

Value of the Correct Strategy

This article should help you understand the key legal right rights arising from your brand and if you choose to implement the above strategies you will have established strong protection from your competitors passing off on your goodwill, have given your business a platform for growth and also created value in your business for any subsequent sale. We recommend you should seek advice from your advisors to help you implement these strategies and to discuss any other issues arsing from them that are relevant to you.

If you have any queries regarding Brand Protection Strategies, please contact Anthony Pointon or David Mazzeo of our office on 03 9614 7707.

Licences of Intellectual Property and the PPSA

Licences of Intellectual Property and the PPSA

This article considers the impact of the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (‘the Act’) on intellectual property (‘IP’) licences. Both lenders and owners of IP should be aware of the advantages and disadvantages of the Act when dealing with IP licences.

IP Licences

Security interests over IP Licences

Section 12(1) of the Act provides that “…a security interest means an interest in personal property provided for by a transaction that, in substance, secures payment or performance of an obligation (without regard to the form of the transaction or the identity of the person who has title to the property).” Therefore, the Act allows a third party lender separate from the licensor (for example, a bank) to take a security interest over an IP licence granted to the licensor as security for a loan.

However, an IP licence in and of itself does not constitute a security interest which, on its own, can be registered under the Act. Rather, the Act simply defines an IP licence as an authority or licence to exercise rights comprising IP. Indeed, section 12(5)(a) of the Act excludes licences from the definition of “security interest.”

Therefore, for example, if a person grants another person a licence to use their patent, that licence would not constitute a stand-alone security interest. In contrast, if a third party lender takes a security interest over the IP licence which has been granted – for example, as security for a loan – the security interest over the licence will be a security interest for the purposes of the Act and may be registered on the Personal Property Securities Register (‘PPSR’).

This diverges from an assignment of IP, which is sometimes used as an alternative to an IP licence and which falls within the definition of “security interest” in the Act.

Proceeds of a licence

A security interest over an IP licence may also extend to the proceeds of the licence, being identifiable or traceable personal property that is derived from dealings with the collateral. The definition of “proceeds” in section 31(1)(d) includes the right of a licensee of the IP to receive payments under any licence agreement relating to that collateral.

Therefore, if a third party lender takes a security interest over an IP licence, they may also obtain the proceeds of the licence – for example, any royalties which flow from the licence.

Disposing of IP – granting licences

If the third party lender or other secured party has taken an IP licence as collateral and decides to exercise their security interest, the lender may seek to dispose of the collateral under section 128(2)(c), which allows the lender to licence the IP to a third party. However, because the power to dispose of the collateral is subject to the pre-existing terms and conditions of the licence, this power is limited. For example, if the pre-existing licence is an exclusive licence, the lender will be unable to dispose of the IP by granting a further licence without breaching the terms and conditions of the licence.

Binding successive licensors

Further, section 106 of the PPSA provides that if a security interest is granted in an IP licence and the IP is subsequently transferred to a new licensor but the original licensee continues to hold the licence after the transfer, the security agreement will bind any successor in title to the original licensor.

While personal property may be acquired free of security interests in certain circumstances, this will not apply if the successor in title has constructive knowledge of the security interest. Therefore, even if a successor in title has no actual knowledge of the pre-existing security interest when dealing with the IP licence, they may be bound by the security interest nonetheless.

IP and goods

Some IP licences may apply to goods, allowing the licensor to use a trade mark or other intellectual property on those goods. For example, a fashion brand may licence their trade mark to a cosmetics manufacturer to use on cosmetics.

The Act specifies that, in the absence of an agreement to the contrary, any security interest over the IP will also be exercisable over the goods. This can lead to competing security interests where the goods are already subject to a security agreement, leading to a clash between the security interest over the goods and the deemed security interest stemming from the IP licence.

When an IP licence permits IP to be used on goods (for example, the licence allows branded goods), it may be appropriate for a licensor to request that licensees exclude IP rights from any subsequent security interest placed over the goods by a third party.

What should clients do next?

Points to consider for licensors:
 

 
Pointon Partners has extensive expertise and experience in drafting IP licences, security agreements and dealing with security interests on the PPSR more generally.

If you require further information about the Act and its impact on IP licences or you would like us to assist in reviewing your licencing or IP documents, please contact David Mazzeo of our office on 03 9614 7707.

IP Raising the Bar- Trade Mark Law

The Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act (‘the Act’) will introduce significant changes to intellectual property law. Most amendments introduced under the Act will come into effect on 15 April 2013.

Whilst the majority of the amendments in the Act amend the Patent Act 1990, it also reforms the Trade Marks Act 1995, Copyright Act 1968, Designs Act 2003 and Plant Breeder’s Rights Act 1994.

The purpose of the reforms is to improve processes, reduce delays and create consistency between Australia intellectual property law and other major intellectual property jurisdictions. The changes are intended to promote a more reliable intellectual property enforcement system, including increased penalties for infringement of intellectual property rights.

Amendments to Trade Mark Law

The main changes to the Trade Marks Act are summarised below:

Opposition Reform

In an attempt to reduce the delays associated with the opposition of trade mark applications and removal of trade marks for non-use, numerous changes have been made to the opposition process.

Amendments include:

Customs Regime

The Act will simplify the Customs seizure processes. Where a trade mark or copyright owner have a Notice of Objection in place with the Australian Customs Service, Customs may seize goods suspected of infringing intellectual property rights before they come into the Australian market.

Under the Act, where Customs seize allegedly infringing goods subject of a Notice of Objection, the Australian Customs Service may provide details about the imported goods and other relevant information about the Australian importer and foreign supplier.

The Act will allow Customs to permit a trade mark owner to inspect or remove multiple samples of the goods in order to allow the parties to make a more accurate determination of whether the consignment contains infringing goods.

The amendments shift the onus onto the importer to make a claim to Customs to release the seized goods. The claim must specify contact information which would enable a trade mark owner to enforce their rights and contact the designated owner. If a claim by the importer or designated owner is not made within the specified time, the goods subject of the seizure will be forfeited to the Commonwealth.

An equivalent provision will apply in respect of the Copyright Act seizure regime.

Presumption of Registrability

Where the Registrar of trade marks is equally uncertain about whether a mark is or is not capable of distinguishing the applicant’s good and services, the Registrar must resolve the doubt in favour of the applicant. This amendment may ultimately result in making it easier for applicant’s to have their application accepted by the Registrar unless there are grounds to reject it, however this is not certain given the Registrar must still determine whether a mark is inherently adapted to distinguish the applicant’s goods and/or services.

Increased Penalties and Damages

Trade Mark owners will have the opportunity under the Act to obtain additional (punitive) damages for trade mark infringement in certain circumstances, including where there is a flagrant infringement, the conduct of the infringer or where there may be a need to deter similar infringers.

Summary offences have been added to the Trade Marks Act, corresponding with the indictable offences. The introduction of these offences will provide a two-tiered system of offence provisions.

Penalties in respect of indictable and summary trade mark offences will also be increased under the Act. The maximum penalties for indictable trade mark offences have been increased to 5 years imprisonment or fines up to $60,500 for an individual or $60,500 for a corporation, or both.

Jurisdiction – Federal Magistrates Court

The Act will extend jurisdiction to allow the Federal Magistrates Court to hear and decide trade mark matters, including appeals against decisions made by the Registrar regarding rejection, amendment, removal for non-use and trade mark infringement proceedings. The Federal Court of Australia currently hears such appeals and proceedings. The expense of instituting these actions will be less costly in the Federal Magistrates Court and may also allow proceedings to be resolved sooner.

Conclusion

The amendments to Australian intellectual property laws will allow for a more simplified intellectual property system. Strengthened penalties and customs regime will provide additional protection for trade mark and copyright owners. In order to protect your trade mark and brand from the importation of counterfeit or pirated goods and trade mark infringement, you should consider availing yourself to the customs seizure regime, and trade mark registration.

If you would like to know more about the reforms coming into effect, or intellectual property generally then please contact David Mazzeo of our office on 03 9614 7707.

STRATEGIES TO PROTECT YOUR INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

Intellectual property (IP) is perhaps one of the most valuable business assets that your company owns. IP rights can provide your business with a competitive advantage. It is essential that alongside the money and time spent inventing, developing and marketing your IP, you take adequate measures to protect it. Some IP rights require a formal process of application, examination and registration while others come into force without the need for any formal registration.

Like any other asset, IP rights can be bought, owned, sold, licensed, transferred or bequeathed much like a physical piece of property. They offer protection and can act as a deterrent to would be infringers.

Some of the more common intellectual property rights, discussed in further detail below, include trade marks, designs, patents and copyright. Your intellectual property rights may fall into one or more of these categories, and our firm can provide further advice as to which category is most advantageous to your specific situation.

Types of IP rights

Type of IP Right What’s protected
Trade marks Letters, numbers, words, colours, a phrase, sound, smell, logo, shape, picture, aspect of packaging or any combination of these.
Designs The way a product looks or a design on a manufactured product
Patents Inventions
Copyright Art, literature, music, film, broadcasts and computer programs

 
Trade marks

A trade mark is a badge of origin that allows you to distinguish your goods and services from those of other traders. They are an important means of maintaining goodwill with your client and forms an integral part of the marketing strategies for your goods and services. Trade marks may take the form of a word, logo, phrase, number, letter, colour or any combination of these.

Whilst it is not necessary to register a trade mark, registration grants the owner the exclusive right to use, license or sell the mark for the goods and services for which it is registered. Registration also provides a trade mark owner with an easier and more cost efficient means to enforce the rights conferred by a trade mark. If a trade mark is registered, there is no need to prove the trade mark has a well known reputation in Australia in order to protect the mark. Trade mark registration gives an automatic right of action to stop other parties infringing registered marks. There is also no need to provide evidence that a substantial number of consumers have been misled or deceived by the use of the mark by the infringing party.

Trade mark registration can be obtained without the trade mark actually being in use, as long as there is a genuine intention to use the mark.

When seeking to register your trade mark, there are various steps involved and things to consider. A trade mark search should always be conducted prior to applying for registration to ensure your intended mark is unlikely to infringe a registered trade mark and to determine whether your trade mark is registrable in Australia in respect of the goods and services you wish to seek registration for. We suggest that a trade mark search be conducted as early as possible prior to substantial expenditure on the mark being made.

An application for the registration of a trade mark in Australia must be filed with IP Australia. You should be aware that once you submit your trade mark application you cannot substantially change the details of your trade mark or add classes of goods or services.

IP Australia will appoint a Trade Mark Examiner to review an application and to ensure the mark meets the requirements of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). Initial registration of a trade mark is for a period of ten years.

Designs

A design refers to the features of shape, configuration, pattern or ornamentation which gives a product a unique appearance, and must be new and distinctive. Designs law is governed by the Designs Act 2003 (Cth) and is exclusively concerned with the protection of the specific details of the appearance of functional or useful articles. A design should be registered if the look of your product gives your business a competitive edge.

As with a registered trade mark, once a design is examined and registered it allows an owner to create, license, sell, or use a product that embodies the design. The length of protection of a design is initially for five years from the date the application was filed. The design registration can be renewed for a further five years. If you do not renew your registration it will cease.

A design can be registered in Australia, on the provision that is both ‘new’, meaning it is not be identical to any design previously disclosed anywhere in the world, and it is ‘distinctive’, that is it must not be substantially similar in overall impression to any design previously published anywhere in the world.

Please be aware that you must apply for design registration before you sell or use your design. If you have already publicly disclosed your design, that is sold copies, reproduced it online or exhibited the design, you may not be able to register it as it may not be considered to be new and distinctive.

Prior to applying for a design it is prudent to conduct a search to ensure there are no similar designs in the marketplace which may affect the likelihood of your design being certified. Design applications can be made through IP Australia. You may request your design application to either be registered or published.

Published designs allow a design owner to establish their design as prior art. It will not give the owner the exclusive right to the design, but it prevents others from gaining exclusive rights to the design.

Registered designs are able to be examined. A design once it has been examined and certified, allows an owner to enforce their exclusive rights over the design. There is no set time in which to request your design be examined and it is an optional process. Design registration is certified once it meets all the requirements under the Designs Act 2003 (Cth). The certified registration is then published in the Official Journal of Designs. Once a design is certified and all associated fees are paid the design will be enforceable.

Patents

A patent is a right that is granted for any device, substance, method or process that is new, inventive, and useful. A granted patent gives you the exclusive right to commercially exploit your invention for the life of the patent. In Australia, there are two types of patent protection, namely standard patents and innovation patents. A standard patent will remain in force for up to twenty years. An innovative patent on the other hand, will remain in force for eight years.

In order to constitute a standard patent, patentable subject matter for an invention must be
novel and inventive, that is non-obvious, when compared to the existing prior art in the relevant area. In order to be suitable to be an innovation patent, an invention must be novel and possess an innovative step when compared to the prior art. An innovative step is the difference in comparison to the prior art which makes a substantial contribution to the working of the invention. The threshold for an innovative patent is somewhat lower than a standard patent.

As with designs, it is crucial that you do not demonstrate, sell or discuss your invention in public before you file for a patent. If you want to discuss it with employees or business partners, then it may be necessary to have them sign a confidentiality agreement. Applications for patents are also filed with IP Australia.

It is often necessary to engage the services of a patent attorney to prepare the specification required to accompany the patent application.

Copyright

Copyright in Australia is a free an automatic right that applies when material is created. Unlike many other intellectual property rights, there is no form of registration of copyright in Australia. In Australia, copyright law is set out in the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). In many instances other intellectual property rights including design will overlap with copyright.

Copyright protects ‘original’ literary, dramatic, musical or artistic works. To be original in terms of copyright means simply that the work isn’t a copy of something else. Copyright does not protect an idea or concept, title, slogan, title, technique or information.

There is no requirement for the copyright symbol © to be included on works for copyright protection to subsist. However the symbol does alert people that the work may be protected.

Generally, copyright protection lasts for the life of the creator plus seventy years. Copyright owners have a number of exclusive rights in respect of their works including the right to reproduce the work, make the work public, and communicate the work to people.

Permission must be sought from the copyright owner if a third party wishes to reproduce the work, even if someone only wishes to use part of a work.

As with other intellectual property rights, copyright can be assigned, sold or licensed. Copyright is an important asset of a business and should be treated accordingly.

If you would like further details of the application process or applicable government fees, or if you have any queries regarding these matters or protecting intellectual property rights generally then please contact David Mazzeo of our office on 03 9614 7707.