Tenant entitled to terminate commercial lease after landlord fails to investigate potential structural defects: Brotherhood of St Laurence v Sarina Investments Pty Ltd [2024] VSCA 46

Who should read this article?   Commercial landlords and tenants. The article will also be relevant to commercial property managers who are often the first port-of-call when these issues arise. In a nutshell: what do you need to know? Victoria’s highest Court has found that a landlord’s failure to investigate [...]

2024-04-16T12:20:09+10:00April 15th, 2024|Categories: Litigation, Property|Tags: |

VCAT decision provides clarity for retail landlords and tenants: Beware of mixed rent review clauses

VCAT’s recent decision in Q St Kilda Tenancy Pty Ltd v Kane (Building and Property) [2023] 75 provides helpful guidance for retail landlords and tenants concerning rent reviews and the operation of section 35(2) of the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) (RLA). This case concerned the lease of a serviced [...]

2023-04-20T11:07:24+10:00April 20th, 2023|Categories: Litigation, Property|Tags: , |

A DISCLAIMER SAVES THE DAY

A recent Queensland Court of Appeal decision shows the continuing utility of disclaimers on products despite legislative reforms narrowing the scope of their effectiveness. In Mallonland Pty Ltd & Anor v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd[1]  a class action was brought on behalf of commercial farmers against the manufacturer of sorghum seed. [...]

2023-03-14T10:39:11+11:00March 14th, 2023|Categories: Commercial, Litigation|Tags: , , |

Hands off my deposit… at least for now: creative special condition modifying the operation of statutory deposit release rules deemed void

Vendors in real estate transactions are motivated to have their deposits released as early as possible. This motivation is particularly strong in relation to sales of high-value development sites, which are often sold on terms where settlement may be scheduled many years into the future. A recent decision of the [...]

2023-01-19T11:45:33+11:00January 19th, 2023|Categories: Litigation, Property|Tags: , , |

An expensive lesson: prospective purchasers lose $168,000 deposit after failing to comply with subject to finance clause

Buying a property can be one of the biggest and most important transactions you make during your lifetime and it is important you seek professional advice to protect your interests.     A decision of the Victorian Supreme Court[1] handed down on 5 August 2021 demonstrates the potentially disastrous consequences when a subject [...]

2021-08-12T16:55:03+10:00August 12th, 2021|Categories: Litigation, Property|Tags: |

Living in a ‘material’ world: off-the-plan purchasers score convincing win over apartment developer in s 9AC(2) case

A decision of the Victorian Supreme Court[1] handed down on 9 August 2021 has highlighted the rights of off-the-plan purchasers to rescind contracts pursuant to s 9AC(2) of the Sale of Land Act 1962 (Act) when changes are made to the proposed plan of subdivision after the contract is signed and [...]

2021-08-12T11:27:16+10:00August 11th, 2021|Categories: Litigation, Property|Tags: |

The Financial Planning Industry – A Changing Landscape

In our Commercial Update of 14 August last year (Sale or purchase of financial planning practices) we commented on the significant volatility and turmoil which the financial planning industry had experienced in the preceding several years.  That included, amongst other things, the Royal Commission and the filing of a class [...]

2021-07-20T12:35:41+10:00July 20th, 2021|Categories: Commercial, Litigation|Tags: , |

Your builder gives you a quote, but no written building contract, and you agree to proceed. Where do you stand?

It’s surprisingly common for home owners to engage builders to undertake domestic building works without that arrangement being supported by a written building contract. Sometimes the only documentary support is a written quotation, which may not be compliant. Home owners may be tempted to agree to go ahead in such [...]

2021-03-04T19:59:05+11:00March 4th, 2021|Categories: Litigation, Property|Tags: , |

Heard it through the grapevine: Facebook defamation suit between congregation members leads to >$200,000 judgment

A string of recent, high profile defamation decisions, for example those involving actors Rebel Wilson and Geoffrey Rush, have shown that Courts are prepared to award significant damages to successful complainants. But it is important to remember that defamation disputes are not exclusively between celebrities and the print and television [...]

2020-12-11T13:46:16+11:00December 11th, 2020|Categories: Commercial, Litigation|Tags: |
Go to Top